10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, you claimed the graphic showed the 10 storey gouge and was misleading. The graphic shows possible or approximate damage and has no height or amount of floors, only width and depth. These width and depth could be supported by the conflicting statements. You have not tied the 10 storey gouge to the graphic and it is not fraudulent.
Wrong
Read my post again.
The inner area is 1/4 the width and the outer area is 1/3 the width.
This is consistent with the '10 story gouge' statement.
The depth is consistent with what Shyam Sunder told FM when he described to '10 story gouge'.
There are NO other accounts of damage 30 to 40 feet deep.

This is what the summary states

This does not mention a 10 storey gouge as being this initiating event cause
Correct
It does list the possible damage to columns 69, 72, 75 78 and 78A, depicted in the graphic of the '10 story gouge' as "Possible components that may have led to the failure of columns 79, 80, and/or 81"

I dont have to justify anything he says,
There is no justification for Shyam Sunder to mislead the public by failing to mention the conflicting statements.

Derail, this is about WTC7, you are quick enough to jump on anyone else for this. Show us where Bush and his administration have distirted the NIST preliminary report into WTC7.
I just did.
NIST included the damage attributed to the '10 story gouge' in the summary and ignored the two statements in direct conflict with the '10 story gouge'.
Bush appointee Shyam Sunder mislead the public by failing to mention the statements that were in conflict with the '10 story gouge' in his interview with FM.

NIST do not at any time say it imploded, this in itself is evidence that it could not have been a CD.
Hogwash.
What they did not say is not evidence.
You continue to ignore the video evidence and the clear statement by FEMA

The fact is NIST do not call it an implosion, they call it a collapse, you knew this but did not quote NIST and only FEMA. Why is that?
FEMA was more specific.
Although NIST did not use the word 'implosion'. this statement on pg L-33 describes what happens in a building implosion.
"The debris of WTC 7 was mostly contained within the original footprint of the building. From aerial photos, the debris visible on top of the pile is mostly façade structure. This failure sequence suggests that the interior of the building collapsed before the exterior."

The timeline states the interior collapsed before the exterior, ................... or does it?
NIST L-27
7.0 - West penthouse and screen wall begin to move downward into building
.... - Movement of entire north face of WTC7 (visible above Floor 21)
7.2 - West end of roof starts to move
7.7 - East end of roof starts to move

The video shows the screenwall and west penthouse collapse about 1/2 second BEFORE the north face.

Who proof reads this stuff?

NIST Final 4-5-05
7.0 North side of west penthouse moves
.... Movement of entire north face of WTC7 (visible above floor 21)

Still missing that 1/2 second.



Implosion means "collapsed in on itself"
This is what WTC 7 did.
 
Implosion means "collapsed in on itself"
This is what WTC 7 did.

Stick to NIST C7, you have been happy enough to until it does not suit you?

NIST do not say implode they say collapse therefore by your standards this is proof that it is not CD

Look up implode and collapse in a selection of dictionary and then come back and tell me the very important diference in most definitions when they are applied to buildings. It is very important and distinct.

I will come back monday and see how you do and we will look at your 10 storey lie again
 
Last edited:
The SSB system had two 6,000 gallon tanks. The fate of the rest of the 40,000 gallons is irrelevant.
It is likely that the fuel pipes for the SSB system were severed or fractured in or near the SW generator room where the debris damage was.

Fool.

46,000 gallons on a flat floor with hallways.

Where do you suppose it's going to go?

Obviously it will stay right where you spilled it, forming walls of fuel at the doorways of that room like some sort of alien living fluid.

That fuel was pumped.

That fuel was pumped into the building.

That fuel Most likely burned and weakened Column 79.

Unless you have some other means of accounting for 46000 gallons of fuel that defies modern physics?
 
The SSB system had two 6,000 gallon tanks. The fate of the rest of the 40,000 gallons is irrelevant.
It is likely that the fuel pipes for the SSB system were severed or fractured in or near the SW generator room where the debris damage was.

In the SW generator room.

First of all you have no evidence with which to state such a thing unequivocally. It may or may not be more likely that a fracture would occur at the SW end. It is also possible that such a fracture occured at more than one point(which would preclude any trouble with fuel in the outer pipe).

Gee, Chris, it seems that some more in depth investigation of this should be done if at all possible. It is after all quite relevent where that 40,000 gallons of fuel went, if not juts for the determination of how WTC 7's fate came about but in order to make determinations about future construction.

As for a fuel-air explosion. If the fuel was spilled into the open area of the 5th floor then that area is in essence the same as an almost empty fuel tanl. That is the most explosive condition available.

You contend that a fuel cloud would 'flash over'. If that were true diesel fuel would be more useful in heating a steam engine rather than in driving a piston downward. In fact diesel contains more explosive energy than does gasoline which is one reason it is used to power engines on bigger vehicles.
 
You see in other people what you are yourself.

46,000 gallons on a flat floor with hallways.

Where do you suppose it's going to go?
Probably on the first floor seein' is how that where the tanks were.

Obviously it will stay right where you spilled it, forming walls of fuel at the doorways of that room like some sort of alien living fluid.
Judy Woods has that one covered.

That fuel was pumped.

That fuel was pumped into the building.
Correct
That fuel Most likely burned and weakened Column 79.
Incorrect
The fuel spill was most likely in the SW generator room, where the debris damage was, not in the opposite corner of the building.
It is extremely unlikely that the diesel fuel spilled in the NE generator room.
There is no evidence to support that hypothesis.
There was no evidence of a fire in that area and no reason to believe there was one.
 
Stick to NIST C7, you have been happy enough to until it does not suit you?
Although i have come to know and love that insipid piece of misleading dribble [NIST L] for the little hypothesis busting pearls of fact it contains, i still quote the half baked farce [FEMA 5] and other documents as they also contain valuable data.
Broaden your horizons Funk. Think outside the NIST.

NIST do not say implode they say collapse therefore by your standards this is proof that it is not CD
No

Look up implode and collapse in a selection of dictionary and then come back and tell me the very important diference in most definitions when they are applied to buildings. It is very important and distinct.
Words have more than one meaning sometimes.
Implosion has become the vernacular for a controlled demolition that causes a building to collapse mostly within it's original footprint.
NOVA: A common misconception is that you blow buildings up. That's not really the case, is it?
Stacy Loizeaux: No. The term "implosion" was coined by my grandmother back in, I guess, the '60s. It's a more descriptive way to explain what we do.

Implode, when used to describe a building collapse, means a controlled demolition because every high rise building that has ever imploded was a controlled demolition.
 
Although i have come to know and love that insipid piece of misleading dribble [NIST L] for the little hypothesis busting pearls of fact it contains, i still quote the half baked farce [FEMA 5] and other documents as they also contain valuable data.
Broaden your horizons Funk. Think outside the NIST.

NIST does not support your implosion so you ignore. Cherrypicking, pure and simple.

C7 said:

Yes, exactly the reasoning you have used earlier. It says collapse and does not say implode.

C7 said:
Words have more than one meaning sometimes.
Implosion has become the vernacular for a controlled demolition that causes a building to collapse mostly within it's original footprint.
NOVA: A common misconception is that you blow buildings up. That's not really the case, is it?
Stacy Loizeaux: No. The term "implosion" was coined by my grandmother back in, I guess, the '60s. It's a more descriptive way to explain what we do.

Implode, when used to describe a building collapse, means a controlled demolition because every high rise building that has ever imploded was a controlled demolition.

Dictionary definitions please, dont make me go and get them you should be able to tell me the difference between collapse and implode when it comes to buildings. I know why you are avoiding it.
 
NIST does not support your implosion so you ignore.
MY implosion?
You cannot assume NIST does not support FEMA's conclusion just because they don't use the word implosion.

NIST L-33
The debris of WTC 7 was mostly contained within the original footprint of the building. From aerial photos, the debris visible on top of the pile is mostly façade structure. This failure sequence suggests that the interior of the building collapsed before the exterior.

The videos clearly show the interior falling before the exterior.
When the interior collapses first, the building falls in on itself.

This is a description of a building implosion.

Yes, exactly the reasoning you have used earlier. It says collapse and does not say implode.
Are you saying WTC 7 did not implode?

Dictionary definitions please, dont make me go and get them you should be able to tell me the difference between collapse and implode when it comes to buildings. I know why you are avoiding it.
Are you calling Stacy Loizeaux a liar?:mad:

Seriously, Sophie

All building implosions are collapses but
not all collapses are implosions.


Again, are you saying WTC 7 did not implode?
 
MY implosion?
You cannot assume NIST does not support FEMA's conclusion just because they don't use the word implosion.

NIST L-33
The debris of WTC 7 was mostly contained within the original footprint of the building. From aerial photos, the debris visible on top of the pile is mostly façade structure. This failure sequence suggests that the interior of the building collapsed before the exterior.

The videos clearly show the interior falling before the exterior.
When the interior collapses first, the building falls in on itself.

This is a description of a building implosion.

But NIST describe it as a collapse, this is their conclusion, or are you putting words in their mouth?

C7 said:
Are you saying WTC 7 did not implode?

online dictionary said:
im·plode (m-pld)
v. im·plod·ed, im·plod·ing, im·plodes
v.intr.
To collapse inward violently.
v.tr.
1. To cause to collapse inward violently.
2. To demolish (a building) by causing to collapse inward

online dictionary said:
col·lapse (k-lps)
v. col·lapsed, col·laps·ing, col·laps·es
v.intr.
1. To fall down or inward suddenly; cave in.
2. To break down suddenly in strength or health and thereby cease to function: a monarchy that collapsed.
3. To fold compactly: chairs that collapse for storage.
v.tr.
To cause to fold, break down, or fall down or inward.
n.
1. The act of falling down or inward, as from loss of supports.
2. An abrupt failure of function, strength, or health; a breakdown.
3. An abrupt loss of perceived value or of effect: the collapse of popular respect for the integrity of world leaders

As you can see these descriptions are interchangable in general. Collapse and implode both mean to fall down and can both be used. However implode is generally used in CD and you have no proof of CD therefore collapse is the correct term. Note the use of demolish in implode definition that it not used in collapse.

By all means use implode if it tickles you but unless you find evidence of CD you could also use collapse.

C7 said:
Are you calling Stacy Loizeaux a liar?:mad:

Seriously, Sophie

Show me where I did this. Did Stacy say WTC7 was a CD?

C7 said:
All building implosions are collapses but
not all collapses are implosions.

See above definition, the WTC7 was a collapse inward.

C7 said:
Again, are you saying WTC 7 did not implode?

Are you saying it did not collapse? I say it collapsed and so do NIST.
 
Implode, when used to describe a building collapse, means a controlled demolition because every high rise building that has ever imploded was a controlled demolition.

We've seen a lot of Creationist arguments and techniques adopted by the truth movement, so I suppose it was only a matter of time before someone resorted to the ontological argument.

Dave
 
But NIST describe it as a collapse,
An implosion IS a collapse of a particular kind.
this is their conclusion, or are you putting words in their mouth?
Are you removing the word implosion from FEMA's mouth?

As you can see these descriptions are interchangable in general. Collapse and implode both mean to fall down and can both be used. However implode is generally used in CD
Exactly
No high rise building has ever imploded that was not a CD.

and you have no proof of CD therefore collapse is the correct term.
Implode means 'fall in on itself' and that's what WTC 7 did.
It fell in on itself and mostly straight down, leaving a debris pile mostly within the original footprint of the building.
This can only happen by design.
It is a fine art.
It cannot happen by chance.

Millions of people consider this to be proof.
At very least, it is clear evidence of a controlled demolition.



By all means use implode if it tickles you but unless you find evidence of CD you could also use collapse.
Which ever word you use, WTC 7 fell in on it self a manner and speed consistent with a professional building implosion.

Show me where I did this.
That was satire mate ;)
Did Stacy say WTC7 was a CD?
Possibly, i don't know. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
An implosion IS a collapse of a particular kind.
Yes, a particular kind and you have no proof it was this type of implosion

I note you completely ignore the definitons I gave you. Collapse is the correct definition to use unless you have direct proof it was CD.

C7 said:
Are you removing the word implosion from FEMA's mouth?

No, I am using the experts own words, you seem to dislike using them and revert to cherrypicking again. Why are NIST investigating this collapse?

C7 said:
Exactly
No high rise building has ever imploded that was not a CD.

Poor reasoning C7, just because something has not happened before it is impossible? I have seen CD that do not use explosives and do not bring down the building into its own footprint, in fact, very far from its own footprint. By your reasoning this could not be CD?

Implode means 'fall in on itself' and that's what WTC 7 did.
It fell in on itself and mostly straight down, leaving a debris pile mostly within the original footprint of the building.
This can only happen by design.
It is a fine art.
It cannot happen by chance.

The building did not collapse that day by chance unless you say it was chance that it was hit and damaged by debris and then became involved with fire that was not fought. You are making grand claims again about only with design and have nothing to prove it.

C7 said:
Millions of people consider this to be proof.
At very least, it is clear evidence of a controlled demolition

Oh, really, millions? Where are they? Were they at GZ this year? Only a few thousand deluded fools with no ability to use reasoning and logic believe this.

The only evidence is that the building collapsed inward and downward.


C7 said:
Which ever word you use, WTC 7 fell in on it self a manner and speed consistent with a professional building implosion.

What professional company would have carried out this world record demolition then C7? (Using silent explosives remember)

There are surely only 2 or 3 people who could have taken on a task of this magnitude?


C7 said:
That was satire mate ;)
Possibly, i don't know. :rolleyes:

Loizeaux say its CD or not? If so, who do they think could have done it?
 
I just viewed a conspiracy video about bombs also being planted at the WTC.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZekosYOmXc&feature=related

With all the eyewitness reports, wrong information and general panic of the days events (the video is totally made up of the news from that day) were these interesting bits of information.

Audio of a reporter with firefighters saying that they were staring at a burning building.
They then talk about the WTC building that has had the front of it removed, rumbling then a chunk lands in the street.

A reporter talking about explosions and being at west broadway...

They have videos of reporters who were in a WTC that heard explosions and were told to remove due to threat it would collapse (at around 1030 am)

These all sounds like news reports of WTC 7 damage.
 
Yes, a particular kind and you have no proof it was this type of implosion.

I note you completely ignore the definitons I gave you. Collapse is the correct definition to use unless you have direct proof it was CD.

No, I am using the experts own words, you seem to dislike using them and revert to cherrypicking again.
You argue endlessly about definitions of words.
A rose by any other name would smell as sweet.

WTC 7 collapsed in on itself and landed mostly in it's own footprint.
It is extremely difficult to get a building to fall in on itself and land mostly in it's own footprint.
Only a few companies can do it.
It cannot happen by chance.

The building did not collapse that day by chance unless you say it was chance that it was hit and damaged by debris and then became involved with fire that was not fought.
The debris damage was to the south west face and would not cause the building to fall in on itself starting at the east end.

The only evidence is that the building collapsed inward and downward.
at a speed and manner consistent with a professional building implosion.

What professional company would have carried out this world record demolition then C7?
I don't know.

I do know that the US military invented controlled demolition and no doubt has state of the art equipment.
 
I do know that the US military invented controlled demolition and no doubt has state of the art equipment.

Where do you get this? What I have found is that it predates the US military and has little/nothing to do with military in general. Why would those responsible for bringing down huge buildings (like demo companies), which the US military does not do with CDs, not have state of the art. JMarshall should be able to answer better, but the US military would have equipment capable of doing the job and nothing more. Try serving and tell me everything is state of the art.
 
It is extremely difficult to get a building to fall in on itself and land mostly in it's own footprint.

No, it's not. What's difficult is doing that without damaging surrounding buildings, which is not what happened on 9/11. All of the surrounding buildings were heavily damaged.
 
I do know that the US military invented controlled demolition and no doubt has state of the art equipment.

Complete rubbish

So now members of the US army are responsible for this collapse? They are now the world record holders in building demolition?

i have snipped the rest because i am fed up with you snipping out questions that are inconvenient to you so will only look at this one huge mistake you have made

Is it possible to have a controlled demolition without explosives and purposely not landing the building in its own footprint?

and did the US army invent this?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom