10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, Chris. You don't get off the hook that easily.

You previously stated categorically (in your post #4125) that the firefighters did not consult with any structural engineers. Now, in light of my subsequent posts, it appears that you are admitting that you were wrong about that but you haven't yet said so directly.
Fire Chief Daniel Nigro explains their decision-making process, saying, “A number of fire officers and companies assessed the damage to the building. The appraisals indicated that the building’s integrity was in serious doubt. I issued the orders to pull back the firefighters and define the collapse zone.” [Fire Engineering, 9/2002]

If you are conceding that firefighters did, in fact, consult with structural engineers, please say so directly rather than circumspectly so that the record is clear.
If Chief Nigro had consulted with structural engineers, he would have said so.
Although your point was well taken, there is nothing to support your conclusion.

Like all the other arguments to support DD/F, it's just inference and innuendo., nothing solid.
 
Last edited:
Fire = expanding gases. Smoke would definitely be coming out of the louvers if there was a fire in the NE generator room or the mechanical room.

By your own standards of evidence, you are not qualified to make this educated guess.

Those were fairly clean burning office fires. Fire does not go one way and smoke another.

By your own standards of evidence, you are not qualified to make this educated guess.

The smoke at the other end of the building is highly suspicious. The fires progressed vertically and produced a lot of smoke while the other fires progressed horizontally and produced very little smoke.
Fire is random and that smoke screen is too perfect.

By your own standards of evidence, you are not qualified to make this educated guess.

Diesel fuel fires make a lot of heavy black smoke and there is no way some it wouldn't be coming out of the louvers.

You have no idea if smoke came out of those louvres. You have a few snapshots that show a few points in time when smoke was not observed exiting the louvres. The building burned for 7 hours. Is there a 7 hour video of the louvres that I am not aware of that prove they were free of smoke for the duration? After 1PM, the area was cleared to a radius of 600 feet. So there is probably almost no video or direct observation by witnesses of the louvres after that time. You do not have enough evidence to state definitively that those louvres were free of smoke for the duration of the day.

There was no damage to that area

Again, you don't know this definitively. A lack of evidence of damage does not equal no damage.

so the only other possible place for the smoke to go would be out the mechanical room door and it is unlikely that it would have been left open. Even if it was, some smoke would be coming out of the louvers.

By your own standards of evidence, you are not qualified to make this educated guess. And again, you have snapshots that show the louvres for about 3 seconds in time out of a 7 hour fire. While it is convenient for your theory to conclude that that 3 seconds is representative of the entire 7 hours, it does not make it so.
 
Last edited:
Come on C7, is that you over on LC showing off to the kiddies?

If so please show me where you have demonstrated the below on this forum

Chris Sarns said:
proves, beyond a reasonable doubt, WTC 7 did NOT collapse due to DD/F.
 
<snip>

An educated guess by an unqualified person does not = evidence.

Will you be applying this standard of evidence to all of the witnesses or just the ones who don't support your theory? I agree that an educated guess by an unqualified person does not equal evidence. But we may just have to agree to disagree about the firefighters. They are qualified to assess the structural integrity of buildings to protect their men. Your dispute of that point is willfully obtuse. Do you realize that not all of the evidence is going to point in one direction for any of these theories and that it is ok to concede a point when evidence points in another direction without disproving your theory? The fact that firefighters on site thought the building could collapse is evidence of the DD/F, but its not proof. Its just one piece of evidence that falls in line with that theory. If you want to conduct an open-minded pursuit of truth, you'll acknowledge that. Sticking your fingers in your ears and stating that firefighters are not qualified to assess building damage makes you look ignorant and discredits other points of your argument which may have merit. From what I have seen, there is very little evidence to support a 9/11 conspiracy that extends beyond Al Qeida. Is this why so many truthers never, ever concede a debate point? Is it because there is such precious little concrete evidence upon which the theories rest, that any point conceded seems like a major defeat? Your approach to most of this thread gave me the impression that you were more intelligent than the average truther, yet you are doing your best to prove me wrong.

<snip> No, the damage was to the SW side and the collapse began in the east central part.

There was damage to the center of the south face. It is visibly verified, in stills posted on this very thread, from the roof extending down at least 25 floors, possibly more, but not documented in photo or video. There was also damage, verified and reported by firefighters to the center of south face near the ground floors. The reports varied as to the extent of that damage, but all accounts put it at roughly the center of the south face, fairly close to the initiating event. To disregard the damage as being only to the SW is simply wrong, and you have read and seen enough to know it is wrong.

They cleared everybody back 600' because they thought it might fall over, not straight down.

They pulled them back that far because it was prudent to keep men out of harm's way. They did not know how it would fall, only that it was structurally vulnerable to possible collapse. They sensibly prepared for a damage area with a radius somewhat beyond the height of the building.
 
Last edited:
They pulled them back that far because it was prudent to keep men out of harm's way. They did not know how it would fall, only that it was structurally in vulnerable to collapse. They sensibly prepared for a damage area with a radius somewhat beyond the height of the building.

IIRC they simply used a standard formula - when a structure is expected to collapse, set up a collapse perimeter distant by 1.5 times the height of the structure. If they'd expected it to fall symmetrically into its own footprint they might have decided to stay a bit closer ;).

Dave
 
You have no idea if smoke came out of those louvres. You have a few snapshots that show a few points in time when smoke was not observed exiting the louvres. The building burned for 7 hours. Is there a 7 hour video of the louvres that I am not aware of that prove they were free of smoke for the duration? After 1PM, the area was cleared to a radius of 600 feet. So there is probably almost no video or direct observation by witnesses of the louvres after that time. You do not have enough evidence to state definitively that those louvres were free of smoke for the duration of the day.

By your own standards of evidence, you are not qualified to make this educated guess. And again, you have snapshots that show the louvres for about 3 seconds in time out of a 7 hour fire. While it is convenient for your theory to conclude that that 3 seconds is representative of the entire 7 hours, it does not make it so.

I have no idea which individual louver serves which purpose in the photos posted, but consider this:

Different louvers have different purposes.

They may be for exhaust, fresh air intake, combustion air intake, they may be attached to ductwork or ventilate a space.

They may include motorized dampers to adjust airflow, those dampers may be normally open or normally closed, meaning they assume a default position in the event of power loss.

Louvers may also include fire dampers which slam shut when a fusible link rated to a setpoint temperature fails.

Presence or absence of smoke at any one time will be affected by these factors, as well as fire conditions.
 
Good point

The decision to pull everyone back was made around 1:00 p.m.
At that time, there were no fires on the east and north sides and only at the south corner of the west side.
A structural engineer might consider the possibility of a partial collapse but since there was no apparent damage to the core except for where the elevator cars were ejected, it isn't even reasonable to assume WTC 7 would fall over, much less straight down.
Chief Norman:
I looked at 7 World Trade Center. There was smoke showing, but not a lot and I’m saying that isn’t going to fall.

I never expected it to fall the way it did as quickly as it did, 7.

Wow, that quote by Chief Norman is quite damning to the DD/F hypothesis. Too bad it cannot be used as evidence since, by your own standards, an educated guess by an unqualified person does NOT equal evidence. Or does that standard not apply to unqualified guesses that might refute DD/F or support CD? Are you willing to retract your assertion that firefighters are not qualified to make an assessment of a building's structural integrity?
 
By your own standards of evidence, you are not qualified to make this educated guess.
There's a big difference between predicting a building will fall and saying smoke would be coming out of the louvers or the smoke would not go in a different direction than the fire or the SW corner fires were very suspicious.

You have no idea if smoke came out of those louvres. You have a few snapshots that show a few points in time when smoke was not observed exiting the louvres. The building burned for 7 hours. Is there a 7 hour video of the louvres that I am not aware of that prove they were free of smoke for the duration? After 1PM, the area was cleared to a radius of 600 feet. So there is probably almost no video or direct observation by witnesses of the louvres after that time. You do not have enough evidence to state definitively that those louvres were free of smoke for the duration of the day.
Yes i do.
The fire time line in NIST L covers 11:30 a.m. to 4:45 p.m.
There were NO reports of fire on the 5th or 6th floor in the east half of WTC 7 at any time.


Again, you don't know this definitively. A lack of evidence of damage does not equal no damage.
Yes it does.
 
I agree that an educated guess by an unqualified person does not equal evidence. But we may just have to agree to disagree about the firefighters. They are qualified to assess the structural integrity of buildings to protect their men.
Firefighters are not structural engineers. They are not qualified to say a steel framed high rise building is building in danger of collapse. At the Meridian Plaza a structural engineer thought there was a possibility of collapse but the building did not collapse.
In both cases, someone thinking that a building may collapse is not evidence of anything.

There was damage to the center of the south face. It is visibly verified, in stills posted on this very thread, from the roof extending down at least 25 floors, possibly more, but not documented in photo or video.
That damage was west of center between columns 5 and 6 [W. Smith#]

There was also damage, verified and reported by firefighters to the center of south face near the ground floors. The reports varied as to the extent of that damage, but all accounts put it at roughly the center of the south face, fairly close to the initiating event.
NIST L-18
debris damage across one-fourth width of the south face, starting several floors above the atrium (extended from the ground to 5th floor), noted that the atrium glass was still intact
[damage starting above the 4th floor. No mention of a gouge or hole]

NIST L-36
I3.1 Perimeter Moment Frame Arrests Failure Progression: Analysis of the global
structure indicates that the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged
areas. A progression of column failure to adjacent columns would have been arrested by
the vierendeel action of the perimeter moment frame, which could span across a sizeable
opening due to the strength and stiffness of the frame.

They pulled them back that far because it was prudent to keep men out of harm's way. They did not know how it would fall, only that it was structurally vulnerable to possible collapse.
They did not KNOW that, they were just being prudent.
 
Last edited:
I have no idea which individual louver serves which purpose in the photos posted, but consider this:
Different louvers have different purposes.
They may be for exhaust, fresh air intake, combustion air intake, they may be attached to ductwork or ventilate a space.
They may include motorized dampers to adjust airflow, those dampers may be normally open or normally closed, meaning they assume a default position in the event of power loss.
Louvers may also include fire dampers which slam shut when a fusible link rated to a setpoint temperature fails.
Presence or absence of smoke at any one time will be affected by these factors, as well as fire conditions.
Good point
However
If all the louvers were closed, a diesel fuel fire would not have sufficient air flow to burn hot enough to weaken a column weighing over 4 tons per floor.
FEMA 5-29
Given open louvers and other sources for entry of air, it is, therefore, probable that a fuel oil spill fire would have found sufficient air for combustion.

There is NO evidence of fire at any time in the NE generator or mechanical rooms and NO reason to think there was a fire there.

Your insistence that there 'could have been' a fire there is just wishful thinking based on NOTHING.
 
Wow, that quote by Chief Norman is quite damning to the DD/F hypothesis. Too bad it cannot be used as evidence since, by your own standards, an educated guess by an unqualified person does NOT equal evidence. Or does that standard not apply to unqualified guesses that might refute DD/F or support CD? Are you willing to retract your assertion that firefighters are not qualified to make an assessment of a building's structural integrity?
No
Chief Norman's opinion only demonstrates that not all the fire chiefs thought WTC 7 would collapse.
 
There's a big difference between predicting a building will fall and saying smoke would be coming out of the louvers or the smoke would not go in a different direction than the fire or the SW corner fires were very suspicious.

Yes, but they are all things firefighters are trained to pay attention to. None of the firefighters found anything suspicious in the fires, the smoke or the decision to pull back because the building's integrity was in doubt. If they had noticed something suspicious, they would have mentioned it, as you like to say.

Yes i do.
The fire time line in NIST L covers 11:30 a.m. to 4:45 p.m.
There were NO reports of fire on the 5th or 6th floor in the east half of WTC 7 at any time.

The operative words there being NO REPORTS. That does not mean definitively that there were no fires. I'm not saying there were fires there or debris damage there. It just means that there is a lack of evidence. You can't definitively state that the area remained free from fire or damage because there is not enough evidence to make that definitive statement. There are a couple of photos of the area and the firefighter observations which have proven to be somewhat varied about both the fires and the damage.

Yes it does.

No it does not. And no matter how many times you repeat it, it will still not be true.
 
Fire Chief Daniel Nigro explains their decision-making process, saying, “A number of fire officers and companies assessed the damage to the building. The appraisals indicated that the building’s integrity was in serious doubt. I issued the orders to pull back the firefighters and define the collapse zone.” [Fire Engineering, 9/2002]


So, are you now willing to accept Chief Nigro as a reliable source and are you now willing to accept what he says as accurate? Please, let's be very clear on this. Are you accepting Chief Nigro, and the people with whom he spoke, as legitimate and credible sources of information or aren't you?

Please answer that question specifically and directly.

If Chief Nigro had consulted with structural engineers, he would have said so.

Upon what basis do you make that claim? The same basis upon which you earlier stated categorically that "the firefighters did not consult a structural engineer", which you have now resiled from? Or some other basis?

Although your point was well taken, there is nothing to support your conclusion.

There is, actually, but let's leave that aside for the moment. What you really mean is that you are not personally aware of structural engineers having discussions with members of the FDNY about the status of the building(s), isn't that so?

Like all the other arguments to support DD/F, it's just inference and innuendo., nothing solid.

That is, quite frankly, nonsense, but let's not let that detract us from the current discussion for the moment.
 
Last edited:
Yes, but they are all things firefighters are trained to pay attention to. None of the firefighters found anything suspicious in the fires, the smoke or the decision to pull back because the building's integrity was in doubt. If they had noticed something suspicious, they would have mentioned it, as you like to say.
Good point.
With all due respect to the firefighters, i find the fires at the south west corner suspicious.
These fires burned in the same place for over 3 hours.
The other fires moved horizontally as they consumed all the available fuel and moved on.
The fire on floor 12 appeared near the center of north face at about 3:00 p.m., progressed to the NE corner and burned itself out by 4:45 p.m.

C7 said:
The fire time line in NIST L covers 11:30 a.m. to 4:45 p.m.
There were NO reports of fire on the 5th or 6th floor in the east half of WTC 7 at any time.
The operative words there being NO REPORTS. That does not mean definitively that there were no fires. I'm not saying there were fires there or debris damage there. It just means that there is a lack of evidence. You can't definitively state that the area remained free from fire or damage because there is not enough evidence to make that definitive statement. There are a couple of photos of the area and the firefighter observations which have proven to be somewhat varied about both the fires and the damage.
FEMA, and then NIST, had two years to establish the fire time line and progression.
The time line and progression of the fires is documented with observations and photos.
The times are approximate but the fact remains:
There were NO reports of smoke or fire in or near the NE generator room.
It is impossible to prove a negative, however:
It can be said, beyond a reasonable doubt, that there were no fires in the NE generator or mechanical rooms.
 
So, are you now willing to accept Chief Nigro as a reliable source and are you now willing to accept what he says as accurate? Please, let's be very clear on this. Are you accepting Chief Nigro, and the people with whom he spoke, as legitimate and credible sources of information or aren't you?

Please answer that question specifically and directly.



Upon what basis do you make that claim? The same basis upon which you earlier stated categorically that "the firefighters did not consult a structural engineer", which you have now resiled from? Or some other basis?



There is, actually, but let's leave that aside for the moment. What you really mean is that you are not personally aware of structural engineers having discussions with members of the FDNY about the status of the building(s), isn't that so?



That is, quite frankly, nonsense, but let's not let that detract us from the current discussion for the moment.

"Your honor I object!"

"The lawyer for the Official Conspiracy Theory is badgering the witness and going off topic as well."

"Her question has been answered."

MM
 
So, are you now willing to accept Chief Nigro as a reliable source and are you now willing to accept what he says as accurate? Please, let's be very clear on this. Are you accepting Chief Nigro, and the people with whom he spoke, as legitimate and credible sources of information or aren't you?
Please answer that question specifically and directly.
Chief Nigro and the firefighters he consulted are credible sources of information, but their assessment does not qualify as evidence of anything.
Their only frame of reference was the collapse of the Trade Towers in which they had lost hundreds of their brothers.
They were acting with an abundance of caution.

C7 said:
If Chief Nigro had consulted with structural engineers, he would have said so.
Upon what basis do you make that claim? The same basis upon which you earlier stated categorically that "the firefighters did not consult a structural engineer", which you have now resiled from? Or some other basis?
My statement stands as is. It is a reasonable, logical conclusion.

C7 said:
Although your point was well taken, there is nothing to support your conclusion.
There is, actually, but let's leave that aside for the moment.
What you really mean is that you are not personally aware of structural engineers having discussions with members of the FDNY about the status of the building(s), isn't that so?
Chief Nigro's statement about the decision to pull everyone back is clear and unambiguous. He consulted with firefighters and not structural engineers.
You have only your personal incredulity and the fact that it is impossible to prove a negative.

At the Meridian Plaza, they did consult with a structural engineer and he said the building might collapse. It did not collapse. Even when a structural engineer says a building might collapse, it is NOT EVIDENCE of anything, only an opinion based on limited information.

When firefighters die, Chiefs act with an abundance of caution to prevent further loss of life.
Chief Hayden summed it up rather eloquently:
""**** 'em all. Let 'em burn. Just tell the guys to keep looking for guys. Just keep looking for the brothers."

C7 said:
Like all the other arguments to support DD/F, it's just inference and innuendo., nothing solid.
That is, quite frankly, nonsense,
On the contrary, the fire chief's assessment, like all the other reasons for believing WTC 7 collapsed due to DD/F, is supposition.

but let's not let that detract us from the current discussion for the moment.
The current discussion is about the fire chief's assessment.

At about 1:00 p.m., when the decision was made to pull back, there were NO FIRES on the east, north and west sides except for a couple fires at the SW corner.
There was NO reason to think WTC 7 would fall to the west, north or east.
There was NO reason to think WTC 7 would fall to the south due to the damage to the perimeter frame, as the structural engineers at NIST have determined.
NIST L-36
Analysis of the global structure indicates that the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged areas. A progression of column failure to adjacent columns would have been arrested by the vierendeel action of the perimeter moment frame, which could span across a sizable opening due to the strength and stiffness of the frame.
 
Come on C7, is that you over on LC showing off to the kiddies?

I repeat again C7, for the 3rd time.

Why do you dodge this question?

Please show me where you have proved beyond all reasonable doubt that DD/F did not bring down the building. Its a pretty big claim.

If it not you just let me know so I do not keep badgering you OK?
 
Good point.
With all due respect to the firefighters, i find the fires at the south west corner suspicious.
These fires burned in the same place for over 3 hours.
The other fires moved horizontally as they consumed all the available fuel and moved on.
The fire on floor 12 appeared near the center of north face at about 3:00 p.m., progressed to the NE corner and burned itself out by 4:45 p.m.


FEMA, and then NIST, had two years to establish the fire time line and progression.
The time line and progression of the fires is documented with observations and photos.
The times are approximate but the fact remains:
There were NO reports of smoke or fire in or near the NE generator room.
It is impossible to prove a negative, however:
It can be said, beyond a reasonable doubt, that there were no fires in the NE generator or mechanical rooms.

How did the fires start in WTC 7?
 
Take an axe and tear through your walls without shutting of the gas or electricity and you might get a clue.

Using you "axe theory", do you think this happened in one location or multiple locations? What does the photographic evidence and eyewitnesses have to say? Where and when did the fires start?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom