So, are you now willing to accept Chief Nigro as a reliable source and are you now willing to accept what he says as accurate? Please, let's be very clear on this. Are you accepting Chief Nigro, and the people with whom he spoke, as legitimate and credible sources of information or aren't you?
Please answer that question specifically and directly.
Chief Nigro and the firefighters he consulted are credible sources of
information, but their
assessment does not qualify as evidence of anything.
Their only frame of reference was the collapse of the Trade Towers in which they had lost hundreds of their brothers.
They were acting with an abundance of caution.
C7 said:
If Chief Nigro had consulted with structural engineers, he would have said so.
Upon what basis do you make that claim? The same basis upon which you earlier stated categorically that "the firefighters did not consult a structural engineer", which you have now resiled from? Or some other basis?
My statement stands as is. It is a reasonable, logical conclusion.
C7 said:
Although your point was well taken, there is nothing to support your conclusion.
There is, actually, but let's leave that aside for the moment.
What you really mean is that you are not personally aware of structural engineers having discussions with members of the FDNY about the status of the building(s), isn't that so?
Chief Nigro's statement about the decision to pull everyone back is clear and unambiguous. He consulted with firefighters and not structural engineers.
You have only your personal incredulity and the fact that it is impossible to prove a negative.
At the Meridian Plaza, they did consult with a structural engineer and he said the building might collapse. It did not collapse. Even when a structural engineer says a building might collapse, it is NOT EVIDENCE of anything, only an opinion based on limited information.
When firefighters die, Chiefs act with an abundance of caution to prevent further loss of life.
Chief Hayden summed it up rather eloquently:
""**** 'em all. Let 'em burn. Just tell the guys to keep looking for guys. Just keep looking for the brothers."
C7 said:
Like all the other arguments to support DD/F, it's just inference and innuendo., nothing solid.
That is, quite frankly, nonsense,
On the contrary, the fire chief's
assessment, like all the other reasons for believing WTC 7 collapsed due to DD/F, is supposition.
but let's not let that detract us from the current discussion for the moment.
The current discussion is about the fire chief's
assessment.
At about 1:00 p.m., when the decision was made to pull back, there were NO FIRES on the east, north and west sides except for a couple fires at the SW corner.
There was NO reason to think WTC 7 would fall to the west, north or east.
There was NO reason to think WTC 7 would fall to the south due to the damage to the perimeter frame, as the
structural engineers at NIST have determined.
NIST L-36
Analysis of the global structure indicates that the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged areas. A progression of column failure to adjacent columns would have been arrested by the vierendeel action of the perimeter moment frame, which could span across a sizable opening due to the strength and stiffness of the frame.