10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
I noticed in reading this thread that that term has been used a few times by Christopher. My personal belief is that DD/F is what actually doomed the building, but as a critical thinker and debater I want to hold myself to the same standards of logic/assumptions/evidence/burden of proof/etc. that I am going to hold Chris or any other CT to. Thus, I just think it's prudent for now to call it a hypothesis.
It is also factually correct.
NIST L-50
L.3.5 Summary of Working Collapse Hypothesis
The working collapse hypothesis has been developed around four phases of the collapse that were
observed in photographic and videographic records: the initiating event, a vertical progression at the east
side of the building, and a horizontal progression from the east to west side of the building, leading to
global collapse.

From an analysis of the observed collapse sequence, the following general sequence of events
appears possible:


I think there was probably more debris damage to the building than could be observed by those on the scene and that the overall structural integrity was sufficiently weakened and compromised that it was doomed by fire,
That is speculation based on an assumption that there was more damage and that damage weakened the overall structure.

diesel or no diesel, simply because the fires were not fought at all.
I've heard this one a lot.
A fire burning out of control burns just as hot as one that not being fought.

The fires in the AIE were as follows:

NIST L 22–26
11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.:
fire on floor 22 on south side
fire on floor 12 burned west to east across the south side
[NIST did not publish any photos of the SE face]
[there were no other fires reported in the east half of the south side]

2:00 to 2:30 p.m.: fires on floors 11 and 12 at SE corner, progressing north
http://img262.imageshack.us/img262/7555/e40rv.jpg

About 3:00 p.m., fires on floors 7 and 12 near the center of the north face
The fire on floor 12 spread in both directions, eventually reaching the NE corner
http://img54.imageshack.us/img54/346/11kp0.jpg
http://img410.imageshack.us/img410/3849/copyofnorthfacekj6.png

Sometime later, fires on floors 8 and 13
Fire on floor 8 eventually burned to NE corner and moved to east face
http://img165.imageshack.us/img165/337/copyof3kt0.jpg

Around 4:45 p.m., a photograph showed fires floors 7, 8, 9 and 11 near the middle of the north face.
The fire on floor 12 had burned out by this time
[NIST did not publish this photo]


The south west corner had fires on nearly every floor.
The smoke [screen] obscures the south face.

These fires had nothing to do with the implosion that began at the other end of the building.
http://img404.imageshack.us/img404/6830/wtc7southwest4vc6.jpg
 
Last edited:
Evidently you have been misled by "Gravy's list" as so many have.

Of the 60 quotes in Gravy's list, only a few said they thought WTC 7 was going to fall.
The rest heard it thru the grapevine.

Mislead? Do you have a more comprehensive list of firefighter quotes? Some said they thought it would fall and others, even if they were only told it would fall, expressed no objections or otherwised questioned that assessment. Only one, out of all those firefighters, expressed any sentiment that it wasn't in danger of collapse.

Chiefs Fellini and Hayden thought WTC 7 was going to fall.
Chief Nigro based his opinion on what Fellini and Hayden had told him.

Gravy failed to mention Chief Norman:
"I looked at 7 World Trade Center. There was smoke showing, but not a lot and I’m saying that isn’t going to fall."

Does he now think there was foul play involved?
 
Thank you for your kind words.

It impossible to prove a negative so that argument doesn't hold up.

I am in agreement with you that no one observed definitive damage to the core columns or any hard evidence of a diesel line break in the AIE. You just can't make the leap from no one observing it to definitively stating that those conditions were impossible, even if they were improbable. I would even concede that based on the visible damage to the exterior of the south face that it was an unlikely probability. However, based on the absence of hard evidence, you can only speculate that it did not happen, which fits your collapse hypothesis, but stating it definitively does not hold up.

NIST interviewed over 100 witnesses and they have photos of the south east side of WTC 7.
If there was significant damage there, they would have published the photos.
The fact that they published photos of every other side and angle except the south east side, is evidence of a cover up. [to anyone not in denial]

I think I remember from earlier in this thread that you have been in touch with NIST. (Sorry if I'm not recalling correctly) Did you ask them why they have not released those photos?

There is no reason to think there was a diesel fuel fire in the NE generator room or mechanical room.
There is clear evidence that there was not.
The 5th & 6th floors had ventilation louvers. These would only be closed in a blizzard, if then.

Diesel fuel fires produce a lot of heavy black smoke.
There was no sign of smoke in or near the NE generator room or mechanical room at any time.

I'm sure you've seen the photos of the south face that show what looks like black smoke coming out of the entire face of the building. Something happened to the missing diesel fuel, most likely it burned. There were plenty of holes in the building, and even a fire in the AIE, however unlikely, does not have to send smoke out of those louvers. It could have been coming out of any of those holes near the initiating event.
 
Mislead? Do you have a more comprehensive list of firefighter quotes? Some said they thought it would fall and others, even if they were only told it would fall, expressed no objections or otherwised questioned that assessment. Only one, out of all those firefighters, expressed any sentiment that it wasn't in danger of collapse.
The firefighters did not consult a structural engineer.
Their only experience with high rise collapses was the Trade Towers.
It is therefore, not surprising that some thought WTC 7 might fall.


Does he now think there was foul play involved?
I don't know
 
The firefighters did not consult a structural engineer.
Their only experience with high rise collapses was the Trade Towers.

It is FDNY policy for senior on-scene firefighters to consult a structural engineer during a fire? Are you implying that they should? Firefighters are trained to assess building damage and make an educated guess as to the structural integrity of the building. They are trained to do so to protect the lives of the men serving under them.

It is therefore, not surprising that some thought WTC 7 might fall.

A 110 story building significantly damaged WTC7 at multiple visible locations on the south face. They were not able to fight the ensuing fires. The building was reported by those on site to be creaking, groaning, bulging, leaning, dropping debris, and fires were reported on nearly every floor. It is therefore, not surprising that some thought WTC 7 might fall.
 
Last edited:
There is no reason to think there was a diesel fuel fire in the NE generator room or mechanical room.
There is clear evidence that there was not.
The 5th & 6th floors had ventilation louvers. These would only be closed in a blizzard, if then.

Diesel fuel fires produce a lot of heavy black smoke.
There was no sign of smoke in or near the NE generator room or mechanical room at any time.

This presumes that the smoke will definitely exit in precisely the area of the fire. That is not necessarily the case. Here is a photo favorite among the truth movement (sorry, just a couple more posts, then I can URL):

hxxp://img223.imageshack.us/img223/4300/copyof3zn0.jpg

There are clearly fires burning near the open windows. Where is all the smoke going? The picture is a bit hazy, as there may be a small amount of smoke exiting the building through the broken windows. But nowhere near the amount coming from the other side of the building. Nowhere near the amount that would be expected IMO if that were the only path for the smoke to exit the building. The bulk of the smoke from these fires is coming out of the building somewhere else. A fire, diesel or no diesel, does not have to send smoke out the NE gen room louvres. A lack of smoke coming through the louvres does not rule out the possibility of a diesel fed fire in the AIE.
 

Attachments

  • wtc7fires.jpg
    wtc7fires.jpg
    18.7 KB · Views: 5
Last edited:
chris sarns said:
They have been most helpful in providing websites containing data that proves, beyond a reasonable doubt, WTC 7 did NOT collapse due to DD/F.

C7, is this you at LCF?

Please show me this (bolded part) as I cannot see it on here?

Showing off to the morons over there? I thought better of you to be honest. Not much action on your posts though considering they are probably the biggest most active nest of CT numpties? 12 replies to 5 threads in the last 30 days?

That movement is in its death throes
 
The firefighters did not consult a structural engineer.

How do you know?

It is FDNY policy for senior on-scene firefighters to consult a structural engineer during a fire?

I am sure that it is not FDNY policy to consult with structural engineers during every fire event, but the events of 9/11 were, of course, no ordinary fire event, and there were consultations with engineers from the Department of Buildings that day.

As I understand it, a number of city agencies sent representatives to 7WTC to convene at the OEM but 7WTC was being evacuated, so they convened in the lobby. This included engineers from the Dept. of Buildings, and it was one of those engineers who issued the warning that the structural damage to the twin towers was immense, that the stability of both buildings was compromised, and that they were in danger of imminent collapse. An EMT named Richard Zarillo was tasked with making his way over to the FDNY command center on West Street to pass that warning on to Chief Ganci. The warning was delivered to Chief Ganci by Mr. Zarillo mere moments before the south tower collapsed.

Therefore, I think it is reasonable to assume (in the absence of evidence to the contrary) that the Building Dept. engineers would continue to do the job that they were there to do - i.e. assess the structural integrity of the buildings that were damaged and on fire.

Firefighters are trained to assess building damage and make an educated guess as to the structural integrity of the building. They are trained to do so to protect the lives of the men serving under them.

Yes, they receive extensive, ongoing training to assess damage and structural integrity, and they take it very, very seriously because their lives and the lives of others depend on it.


P.S. Welcome to the sub-forum, GStan. ::w2:
 
It is FDNY policy for senior on-scene firefighters to consult a structural engineer during a fire? Are you implying that they should? Firefighters are trained to assess building damage and make an educated guess as to the structural integrity of the building. They are trained to do so to protect the lives of the men serving under them.
Firefighters consulted a structural engineer at the Meridian Plaza before ordering a withdrawal of firefighters because of a possible collapse.
No high rise building, other than the Trade Towers had ever collapsed due to fire. That was their only frame of reference and their decision to pull the firefighters was reasonable and prudent.
However, they were NOT qualified to make a structural assessment and their belief that WTC 7 would collapse is not evidence that debris damage and fire actually caused the collapse.

A 110 story building significantly damaged WTC7 at multiple visible locations on the south face. They were not able to fight the ensuing fires. The building was reported by those on site to be creaking, groaning, bulging, leaning, dropping debris, and fires were reported on nearly every floor. It is therefore, not surprising that some thought WTC 7 might fall.
Agreed
 
Firefighters consulted a structural engineer at the Meridian Plaza before ordering a withdrawal of firefighters because of a possible collapse.
No high rise building, other than the Trade Towers had ever collapsed due to fire.

Dare I ask if this is an acknowledgement on your part that the Towers were brought down by damage and fire? Or are you simply stating that that would have been the firefighters' interpretation of it?

That was their only frame of reference and their decision to pull the firefighters was reasonable and prudent.

Agreed that it was reasonable and prudent. But I disagree that they had no other frame of reference. They have experience/training fighting fires where the structural integrity of the building may be in doubt. I concede that their experience assessing structural integrity would not have been on structures anywhere near the size of WTC7.

However, they were NOT qualified to make a structural assessment and their belief that WTC 7 would collapse is not evidence that debris damage and fire actually caused the collapse.

They are qualified to make such an assessment. They are trained to make such assessments to keep their men out of harm's way. Their assessments may not be as informed as a structural engineer's, but they do have at least the basic training to give an educated guess.

Forgive my ignorance here, but do we know for a fact that an SE was not consulted on WTC7? Or is there simply no report that this occured? Please share if you already have this info, otherwise I'll go do some research on it.

I also agree with you that their belief is not hard evidence that DD/F actually caused the collapse. However, the fact there was enough damage and fire to give firefighters the impression that it could collapse is circumstantial evidence that supports the DD/F hypothesis. If it is discovered that one of the senior firefighters did communicate with an SE on WTC7, would you agree that that would constitute more than just circumstantial evidence for the DD/F hypothesis?
 
This presumes that the smoke will definitely exit in precisely the area of the fire. That is not necessarily the case.
Fire = expanding gases. Smoke would definitely be coming out of the louvers if there was a fire in the NE generator room or the mechanical room.

copyofe5asn4.png



There are clearly fires burning near the open windows. Where is all the smoke going? The picture is a bit hazy, as there may be a small amount of smoke exiting the building through the broken windows.
Those were fairly clean burning office fires. Fire does not go one way and smoke another.

But nowhere near the amount coming from the other side of the building.
The smoke at the other end of the building is highly suspicious. The fires progressed vertically and produced a lot of smoke while the other fires progressed horizontally and produced very little smoke.
Fire is random and that smoke screen is too perfect.

Nowhere near the amount that would be expected IMO if that were the only path for the smoke to exit the building. The bulk of the smoke from these fires is coming out of the building somewhere else.
A fire, diesel or no diesel, does not have to send smoke out the NE gen room louvres. A lack of smoke coming through the louvres does not rule out the possibility of a diesel fed fire in the AIE.
Diesel fuel fires make a lot of heavy black smoke and there is no way some it wouldn't be coming out of the louvers. There was no damage to that area so the only other possible place for the smoke to go would be out the mechanical room door and it is unlikely that it would have been left open. Even if it was, some smoke would be coming out of the louvers.
 
Ahem, Chris7, please address post #4130. You claimed that the firefighters did not consult structural engineers on 9/11 and then skated past my post questioning that assertion on your part.

Chris7 said:
The firefighters did not consult a structural engineer.

me said:
How do you know?

GStan said:
It is FDNY policy for senior on-scene firefighters to consult a structural engineer during a fire?

me said:
I am sure that it is not FDNY policy to consult with structural engineers during every fire event, but the events of 9/11 were, of course, no ordinary fire event, and there were consultations with engineers from the Department of Buildings that day.

As I understand it, a number of city agencies sent representatives to 7WTC to convene at the OEM but 7WTC was being evacuated, so they convened in the lobby. This included engineers from the Dept. of Buildings, and it was one of those engineers who issued the warning that the structural damage to the twin towers was immense, that the stability of both buildings was compromised, and that they were in danger of imminent collapse. An EMT named Richard Zarillo was tasked with making his way over to the FDNY command center on West Street to pass that warning on to Chief Ganci. The warning was delivered to Chief Ganci by Mr. Zarillo mere moments before the south tower collapsed.

Therefore, I think it is reasonable to assume (in the absence of evidence to the contrary) that the Building Dept. engineers would continue to do the job that they were there to do - i.e. assess the structural integrity of the buildings that were damaged and on fire.
 
Last edited:
Dare I ask if this is an acknowledgement on your part that the Towers were brought down by damage and fire?
No
Or are you simply stating that that would have been the firefighters' interpretation of it?
Right

Agreed that it was reasonable and prudent. But I disagree that they had no other frame of reference. They have experience/training fighting fires where the structural integrity of the building may be in doubt. I concede that their experience assessing structural integrity would not have been on structures anywhere near the size of WTC7.
They are qualified to make such an assessment. They are trained to make such assessments to keep their men out of harm's way. Their assessments may not be as informed as a structural engineer's, but they do have at least the basic training to give an educated guess.
An educated guess by an unqualified person does not = evidence.

Forgive my ignorance here, but do we know for a fact that an SE was not consulted on WTC7? Or is there simply no report that this occured? Please share if you already have this info, otherwise I'll go do some research on it.
There is no mention of anyone consulting a structural engineer in any of the firefighters testimony.

I also agree with you that their belief is not hard evidence that DD/F actually caused the collapse. However, the fact there was enough damage and fire to give firefighters the impression that it could collapse is circumstantial evidence that supports the DD/F hypothesis.
No

If it is discovered that one of the senior firefighters did communicate with an SE on WTC7, would you agree that that would constitute more than just circumstantial evidence for the DD/F hypothesis?
No, the damage was to the SW side and the collapse began in the east central part.
They cleared everybody back 600' because they thought it might fall over, not straight down.
 
How do you know?
I am sure that it is not FDNY policy to consult with structural engineers during every fire event, but the events of 9/11 were, of course, no ordinary fire event, and there were consultations with engineers from the Department of Buildings that day.

As I understand it, a number of city agencies sent representatives to 7WTC to convene at the OEM but 7WTC was being evacuated, so they convened in the lobby. This included engineers from the Dept. of Buildings, and it was one of those engineers who issued the warning that the structural damage to the twin towers was immense, that the stability of both buildings was compromised, and that they were in danger of imminent collapse. An EMT named Richard Zarillo was tasked with making his way over to the FDNY command center on West Street to pass that warning on to Chief Ganci. The warning was delivered to Chief Ganci by Mr. Zarillo mere moments before the south tower collapsed.

Therefore, I think it is reasonable to assume (in the absence of evidence to the contrary) that the Building Dept. engineers would continue to do the job that they were there to do - i.e. assess the structural integrity of the buildings that were damaged and on fire.
P.S. Welcome to the sub-forum, GStan. ::w2:
Good point

The decision to pull everyone back was made around 1:00 p.m.
At that time, there were no fires on the east and north sides and only at the south corner of the west side.
A structural engineer might consider the possibility of a partial collapse but since there was no apparent damage to the core except for where the elevator cars were ejected, it isn't even reasonable to assume WTC 7 would fall over, much less straight down.
Chief Norman:
I looked at 7 World Trade Center. There was smoke showing, but not a lot and I’m saying that isn’t going to fall.

I never expected it to fall the way it did as quickly as it did, 7.
 
Last edited:
Good point... [followed by evasion and obfuscation that does not even remotely respond adequately to the questions and points raised that directly refute your assertions]

Nice attempted evasion, Chris.

Now, how about answering my questions and points directly instead of trying to skate all around them in hopes that nobody notices? Start with the first question, which you have avoided entirely:

Chris7 said:
The firefighters did not consult a structural engineer.
me said:
How do you know?

Once you answer that, we can move on to the next point.
 
Last edited:
An educated guess by an unqualified person does not = evidence.

:i:


ETA: And an uneducated guess by an unqualified person, such as yourself, most certainly does not = evidence.
 
Last edited:
Nice attempted evasion, Chris.

Now, how about answering my questions and points directly instead of trying to skate all around them in hopes that nobody notices? Start with the first question, which you have avoided entirely:
Once you answer that, we can move on to the next point.
What part of "good point" don't you understand?
I acknowledged that there may have been structural engineers present even though Chief Nigro did not mention them.
 
What part of "good point" don't you understand?
I acknowledged that there may have been structural engineers present even though Chief Nigro did not mention them.

No, Chris. You don't get off the hook that easily.

You previously stated categorically (in your post #4125) that the firefighters did not consult with any structural engineers. Now, in light of my subsequent posts, it appears that you are admitting that you were wrong about that but you haven't yet said so directly.

If you are conceding that firefighters did, in fact, consult with structural engineers, please say so directly rather than circumspectly so that the record is clear.

Are you conceding that the firefighters did consult with structural engineers and are you conceding that your previous assertion to the contrary was wrong, or aren't you?

It is important for the record to be clear (and free of the tap dancing that you appear to be doing).
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom