10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
I was just looking at that
The author is LYING !
"The original 7 World Trade Center collapsed at 5:20 p.m. on September 11 due to the combined effect of structural and fire damage."

NIST said it "appears possible"

I note your lack of use of the Implosion word in this instance? The author at least got that correct.
 
funk de fino said:
Is it possible to have a controlled demolition without explosives
and purposely not landing the building in its own footprint?
Are you too scared to answer? You dont know do you? I do.
Your question was funny.
[answer: no and no]

I also know the US army did not invent CD, you are incorrect in a large way.
Care to admit your mistake?
I could be wrong on that one.
The Army started with bridges in WWII and continued to develop the art.
Do you know of anything that predates that?


BTW
WTC 7 collapsed in on itself and landed mostly in it's own footprint.

It is extremely difficult to get a building to fall in on itself and land mostly in it's own footprint.

Only a few companies can do it.

It cannot happen by chance.
 
Your question was funny.
[answer: no and no]

No and No to what? The first question or just the second?

I'll repeat. A straight No will do?

Funk said:
Is it possible to have a controlled demolition without explosives
and purposely not landing the building in its own footprint?



C7 said:
I could be wrong on that one.
The Army started with bridges in WWII and continued to develop the art.
Do you know of anything that predates that?

Controlled demolition has been ongoing for years prior to that and you should know it before making grand claims. I suspect you are being one dimensional in your CD thinking.

BTW
WTC 7 collapsed in on itself and landed mostly in it's own footprint.

It is extremely difficult to get a building to fall in on itself and land mostly in it's own footprint.

Only a few companies can do it.

It cannot happen by chance.

BTW if it hadnt landed mostly in its own footprint would it still be a CD?

If its really that difficult especially with one of the biggest and tallest ever jobs, who could have done it? Not the Army, they do not have the experience. Therefore it leaves you one option. It must have been one of the top three or so companies in the US. So which one?
 
The only reason given for the supposed implosion was to avoid too much damage to non-WTC buildings.

So what I am getting here is that if TPTB could make the building drop anywhere they wanted to then the most logical thing to have done would have been to drop it towards the south. That would not only have it moving in the direction of the most debris damage but also make sure that it only impacts WTC 5(or is it 6?) accross the street, a building that would already be damaged beyond any hope of repair.

Surely the supposed planners do not give a ding about any further loss of life. After all they just killed thousands in the towers.
 
The only reason given for the supposed implosion was to avoid too much damage to non-WTC buildings.

So what I am getting here is that if TPTB could make the building drop anywhere they wanted to then the most logical thing to have done would have been to drop it towards the south. That would not only have it moving in the direction of the most debris damage but also make sure that it only impacts WTC 5(or is it 6?) accross the street, a building that would already be damaged beyond any hope of repair.

Surely the supposed planners do not give a ding about any further loss of life. After all they just killed thousands in the towers.
Reverse logic

I can't figure out how they did it, therefore it couldn't be a CD.

I can't figure out why they did it, therefore it couldn't be a CD.

I can't figure out why they made it fall straight down instead of over, therefore it couldn't be a CD.
 
No and No to what? The first question or just the second?

I'll repeat. A straight No will do?
No

Controlled demolition has been ongoing for years prior to that
Source?

BTW if it hadnt landed mostly in its own footprint would it still be a CD?
Yes

If its really that difficult especially with one of the biggest and tallest ever jobs, who could have done it? Not the Army, they do not have the experience.
What makes you think they don't?

Therefore it leaves you one option. It must have been one of the top three or so companies in the US. So which one?
I don't know.
 

Fred Dibnah, no explosives, outside the footprint, on purpose

C7 said:
Wheres yours for the fact the Army invented it?

The history page at Implosion world is my source but I think you already knew that (you did point me there before)

C7 said:

So if it has similarities to a CD it is a CD and if it has things different from a CD it is still a CD. I guess you have all bases covered there eh?

C7 said:
What makes you think they don't?

Why dont you ask them? I think you know the answer though.

C7 said:
I don't know.

You're nothing if not predictable
 
Reverse logic

I can't figure out how they did it, therefore it couldn't be a CD.

I can't figure out why they did it, therefore it couldn't be a CD.

I can't figure out why they made it fall straight down instead of over, therefore it couldn't be a CD.

I can't figure out how the fire made the columns fail, therefore it must be a CD.

I can't figure out why the collapse started in the eastern half of the building, therefore it must be a CD.

I can't figure out why the building fell straight down instead of falling over, therefore it must be a CD.

Any of that look familiar?

Dave
 
I can't figure out how the fire made the columns fail, therefore it must be a CD.

I can't figure out why the collapse started in the eastern half of the building, therefore it must be a CD.

I can't figure out why the building fell straight down instead of falling over, therefore it must be a CD.

Any of that look familiar?

Dave


Dave is quite correct Christopher, you cannot simply apply that logic only to one side of the arguement.

Now the first two subjects are engineering based and given enough information such matters could, in theory, be figured out.

The last one though does not require an engineering analysis. It is a strictly logic based arguement. If one assumes a giant conspiracy of extreme sabotage and treason one must also expect an extreme amount of planning that would include, as one of its basic items, a course of action that would preclude suspicion that this was a highly treasonous act.

Such a plan would not have any condition concerning the limiting of causualties. It would be highly illogical to expect that the planners were prepared to kill thousands in the towers but only the towers (as far as the actions in Manhattan are concerned) while desiring to limit them anywhere outside of the WTC complex.

While it is also illogical to expect that the planners would desire to limit collateral damage outside the WTC complex this has been given as the reason for the implosion of WTC 7 largely into its own footprint. It is barely within the realm of possibility that this was indeed a consideration.

However, now one has to wonder why the building would be brought down into itself rather than to the south and onto the wreckage of the previously destroyed buildings. Certainly dropping the building to the south would be more likely to ensure less collateral damage to surrounding buildings other than those already damaged beyond repair..

Secondly it would also add to the supposed cover-up by having the building fall towards the original impact damaged side.

So it defies logic to assume that the planners deliberatly dropped the building into itself as it would be counter productive to the 'plan'.
 
Last edited:
I don't want to let this thread end! I have been a conspiracy buff for a long time, and I have been reading about 9/11 for the past year, but I just discovered the JREF about 3 weeks ago.

I have used my available leisure time over the past couple of weeks to read virtually all 4000+ posts in this thread. Given the ‘progress’ that has been made, I’m unsure as to whether I should be proud of myself for that or embarrassed about it. Regardless, I have enjoyed the thought-provoking and mostly-civil debate that is often difficult to find elsewhere on the web.

I just wanted to comment that I believe Chris7 is an intelligent skilled debater, staying, for the most part, on the original thread points, choosing words carefully, making a fairly convincing argument. (Except for the ‘fake NIST photo’ debacle.) I think you would make a fine criminal defense lawyer, in that, to be successful, one would not be required to prove anything definitively in the defendant's favor, but rather only to cast enough reasonable doubt of the evidence to get the defendant set free.

Your three primary points from your original post (paraphrasing): there is no 10 story gouge in the south face, no evidence of debris damage in the area of the initiating event and no evidence of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event (AIE) are completely accurate and cannot be disputed. It is an indisputable fact that there are conflicting descriptions of the dimensions of the south face damage. It is an indisputable fact that there is no known direct evidence of structural damage to the AIE. It is an indisputable fact that there is no known direct evidence of a diesel fire in the AIE. You’ve won the debate on these three points. Congratulations.

However, the conclusions you have chosen to draw from these statements (debris damage and fuel fires did not contribute to the collapse) are not sufficiently supported. The additional assumptions that must be made are too great. Evidence, with respect to damage and fires, is either that which has been observed and reported by witnesses or that which has been documented in photos and videos. To make the leap from “no evidence of debris damage or fire in AIE” to “definitively no debris damage or fire in AIE” you must assume that ALL of the debris damage and fire is KNOWN and that NONE of it is UNKNOWN. You must assume that ALL of the debris damage and fire progression was observed, reported and documented and that NO DAMAGE OR FIRE went undetected by the witnesses and cameras. A 110 story building falling onto a 47 story building is not an event that would produce predictable results. It is a random and chaotic event. Your assumption that the entirety of the damage and fire progression is observed and known is an unreasonable assumption. I accept your analysis that NIST does not/will not have sufficient evidence to irrefutably prove the DD/F hypothesis, but I reject your conclusions based on your unreasonable assumptions. While the evidence for DD/F is admittedly somewhat hampered by unknowns, there is no evidence at all for CD.

Looking forward to continuing this and other debate topics.
 
welcome GStan and a nice post. However I would dispute some of your points.(would you expect otherwise;) )

Your three primary points from your original post (paraphrasing): there is no 10 story gouge in the south face, no evidence of debris damage in the area of the initiating event and no evidence of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event (AIE) are completely accurate and cannot be disputed.

Actually the non-existance of the 10 storey hole can be disputed.

It is an indisputable fact that there are conflicting descriptions of the dimensions of the south face damage.

,,, and that is one reason why it can.

It is an indisputable fact that there is no known direct evidence of structural damage to the AIE.

Except that the elevator cars were ejected and could very well be relatively close to the (as you put it) AIE and be indicative of impact damge to the core of the building. That makes it less than "indisputable".

It is an indisputable fact that there is no known direct evidence of a diesel fire in the AIE.

Once again we know that there were several thousand gallons of liquid fuel missing and that fuel had a path to the AIE which makes the no diesel fire contention at the very least, slightly less than "indisputable".
 
JDH
Thank you for the reply. I have read through this entire thread and I have found you to be one of the most coherent and logically grounded thinkers in the forum. With that in mind, I can't believe that in only my second post ever, I am going to disagree with you in support of Christopher.

The point I was trying to make, which I sure was not lost on you, was that agreement with Christopher's three primary issues identified in the NIST report need not be necessarily in conflict with the DD/F hypothesis. It is merely an acknowlegement of a lack of verified/verifiable evidence in certain areas.

I don't know how to put previous post quotes in yet, so I'll just restate. With respect to the debris damage, you and I are in agreement that the ejected elevator cars could very well have damaged or be an indication of damage to the core columns in the AIE, however, their is no report that someone actually observed column damage. This is consistent with Christopher's analysis of the NIST report, yet not necessarily inconsistent with a DD/F hypothesis. It may be just splitting hairs, but a careless reader could easily see "no evidence of core column damage" and misconstrue it as "evidence that there was no core column damage." There is simply no evidence in either direction.

As for the fuel fires, I think Chris's "no evidence of AIE diesel fires" is technically 100% correct. You and I agree that a diesel line runs through the AIE and could have fractured in that area. But no one actually observed that to be the case. Again, hairsplitting, but you'll come to find that I can be bit anal about details from time to time.

As far as the gouge goes, I am conceding to Chris that the dimensions from the NIST report that he pointed out as inaccurate, are probably inaccurate, based on conflicting descriptions. Again, you and I agree that there was still a biga$$ hole somewhere near the center of the south face.

Thanks again for the welcome.

Do JREF newbies get formally hazed/initiated?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom