10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
jdh said:
That fuel cloud could eventually make its way to an ignition source on the still smoldering 7th floor .... which would create a blast event on the 5th floor pushing the columns 79,80,81 to the east and or north

C7 said:
A blast event would blow out thru the louvers as would the smoke from the ensuing fire.
This did not happen.

Its not IN the NE generator room Chris, its in the core area and occurs moments before the east penthouse sinks.
Please

Diesel fumes igniting would not have the explosive force to effect the core columns.
 
Please

Diesel fumes igniting would not have the explosive force to effect the core columns.
Not directly, but it would exert great force on walls and floors, attached to the core columns. Gas (and fume) explosions have been known to knock down buildings before.

Hans
 
I wonder if this thread could remain on the front page for a whole year... I mean, I don't want it to, but I wonder if it will.
 
Last edited:
Not directly, but it would exert great force on walls and floors, attached to the core columns. Gas (and fume) explosions have been known to knock down buildings before.

Hans
Great force?

Natural gas and gasoline fumes are far more volatile than diesel fuel fumes.

If a diesel fuel tank is exposed to fire it could explode.

Diesel fuel fumes in open air will flash over.

Can you site a case of a diesel fuel fume [in open air] explosion?


Jaydehess' hypothesis requires the double wall pipe to fracture in such a way as to spill a large amount of diesel without any being caught by the containment pipe. This is very unlikely.

It is extremely unlikely that both pipes would fracture in the NE generator room and not in the SW generator room.

Someone would have to leave the door open between the NE generator room and the mechanical room. This is also extremely unlikely.
 
Great force?

Natural gas and gasoline fumes are far more volatile than diesel fuel fumes.

If a diesel fuel tank is exposed to fire it could explode.

Diesel fuel fumes in open air will flash over.

Can you site a case of a diesel fuel fume [in open air] explosion?


Jaydehess' hypothesis requires the double wall pipe to fracture in such a way as to spill a large amount of diesel without any being caught by the containment pipe. This is very unlikely.
It is extremely unlikely that both pipes would fracture in the NE generator room and not in the SW generator room.

Someone would have to leave the door open between the NE generator room and the mechanical room. This is also extremely unlikely.

What does your hypothesis require C7?

Something more likely than JDH?

Out with it, you could even start a new thread.
 
What does your hypothesis require C7?

Something more likely than JDH?

Out with it, you could even start a new thread.
When left without a leg to stand on, OTers subject shift to "My dog is still bigger than your dog."

Example:
Originally Posted by Christopher7
What i have uncovered after all this time is:
You have nothing.

Response by Belz:
You have nothing.

If that is true, then you're left with a negative amount of evidence.


This thread is about the "10 story gouge 1/4 to 1/3 the width of WTC7" and other false or misleading claims.

If you want to deny the evidence for CD, you may do so here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2902751#post2902751
 
When left without a leg to stand on, OTers subject shift to "My dog is still bigger than your dog."

Example:
Originally Posted by Christopher7
What i have uncovered after all this time is:
You have nothing.

Response by Belz:
You have nothing.

If that is true, then you're left with a negative amount of evidence.


This thread is about the "10 story gouge 1/4 to 1/3 the width of WTC7" and other false or misleading claims.

If you want to deny the evidence for CD, you may do so here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2902751#post2902751



Should that be a column to stand on? Unfortunately for you C7, your dog does not exist.

You admit you are too scared to admit what your theory for the collapse is and if it is more plausible than the one JDH put forward in his post?

The thread you quoted was a joke and you got the smackdown there as well, no evidence again.

back to the OP

Was there a gouge 10 stories high in the face of the WTC7 building? yes or no?

Could this gouge have been reported incorrectly as being further west than it was? yes or no?

Is there any other actual evidence for anything other than DD/F as having caused the collapse of the building? yes or no?

Is it a more plausible hypothesis than the one put forward by JDH. yes or no?
 
Should that be a column to stand on? Unfortunately for you C7, your dog does not exist.
Only to those in denial

You admit you are too scared to admit what your theory for the collapse is and if it is more plausible than the one JDH put forward in his post?
Wrong
I created a thread to discuss that issue separately

The thread you quoted was a joke and you got the smackdown there as well, no evidence again.
Wrong again.
All evidence of CD is simply denied and dismissed.

back to the OP

Was there a gouge 10 stories high in the face of the WTC7 building? yes or no?
You are a superb sophist.
You intentionally left out the 1/4 to 1/3 the width of WTC 7 and ignored the FACT that this graphic shows the 10 story gouge described on pg 18 as being in the middle of the south side.

11qd1.jpg


Was there a 10 story gouge 1/4 to 1/3 the width of WTC 7 as described on pg 18 and depicted in this graphic?

NO

There was a 20+ story gouge but it is NOT the one described on pg 18 and shown in this graphic as "Approximate region of Impact Damage by WTC 1 debris". You know that.
The 20+ story gouge is in line with the "Roof and Upper Level Debris Damage".

Could this gouge have been reported incorrectly as being further west than it was? yes or no?
It was reported incorrectly as being further EAST than it was.

Is there any other actual evidence for anything other than DD/F as having caused the collapse of the building? yes or no?
Yes, but deniers simply deny that evidence and then claim "There is no evidence".

Is it a more plausible hypothesis than the one put forward by JDH. yes or no?
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3154908#post3154908
 
Only to those in denial

Pot-kettle-black

C7 said:
Wrong
I created a thread to discuss that issue separately

explosives? show me the video and sound of these explosives, i do not see them in the other thread

C7 said:
Wrong again.
All evidence of CD is simply denied and dismissed

replace dismissed with non-existant

You are a superb sophist.
You intentionally left out the 1/4 to 1/3 the width of WTC 7 and ignored the FACT that this graphic shows the 10 story gouge described on pg 18 as being in the middle of the south side.

[qimg]http://img292.imageshack.us/img292/3375/11qd1.jpg[/qimg]

Was there a 10 story gouge 1/4 to 1/3 the width of WTC 7 as described on pg 18 and depicted in this graphic?

NO

NIST said:
While the accounts are mostly consistent, there are some conflicting descriptions: − middle one-fourth to one-third width of the south face was gouged out from Floor 10 to

So. It is not stated as a fact, is it stating there were conflicting descriptions and this may be one of the conflictions?

I intentionally left nothing out, I was asking a question

C7 said:
There was a 20+ story gouge but it is NOT the one described on pg 18 and shown in this graphic as "Approximate region of Impact Damage by WTC 1 debris". You know that.
The 20+ story gouge is in line with the "Roof and Upper Level Debris Damage

So because this mentions roof and upper level this means that this is the huge gouge we see in the face in photos from top to nearly bottom?

Can it be this is another confliction?

C7 said:
It was reported incorrectly as being further EAST than it was.

Which I meant to say of course, I stand corrected


C7 said:
Yes, but deniers simply deny that evidence and then claim "There is no evidence".

Thats a no then

There is no evidence, you know what would happen if there was dont you?
 
explosives? show me the video and sound of these explosives, i do not see them in the other thread
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3156769#post3156769

So. It is not stated as a fact, is it stating there were conflicting descriptions and this may be one of the conflictions?
Yes
The problem is, they used the 10 story gouge statement in their graphic and ignored two other statements in direct conflict with that statement.

Shyam Sunder, a Bush appointee, is the one who quoted that statement and failed to mention the other two statements in his interview for FM.

That's dishonest.

Many people have come to believe there was a huge gouge in the middle of WTC 7 after reading that interview because he withheld the other conflicting statements. Had he included them, people would have known the issue was in question.

It is known that the Bush administration systematically distorts scientific documents.

NIST Apx. L is no exception.


So because this mentions roof and upper level this means that this is the huge gouge we see in the face in photos from top to nearly bottom?
It means it is not in the middle of WTC 7, floor 10 to the ground.

Which I meant to say of course, I stand corrected
No worries mate, Been there, done that.
 
Great force?

Gas explosions usually make houses collapse. The reason is that although the expansion speed is low compared to a HE, the expansion volume is great.

Natural gas and gasoline fumes are far more volatile than diesel fuel fumes.

That is only a question of temperature. And how volatile they are has no direct bearing on their explosivity, only on the conditions where an explosive situation could arise.

If a diesel fuel tank is exposed to fire it could explode.

Quite possibly, yes. Especially if it is partly empty.

Diesel fuel fumes in open air will flash over.

Can you site a case of a diesel fuel fume [in open air] explosion?

Aerosol bombs. However, since we are discussing a possible explosion inside a building that is irrelevant.

Jaydehess' hypothesis requires the double wall pipe to fracture in such a way as to spill a large amount of diesel without any being caught by the containment pipe. This is very unlikely.

Why is that unlikely? We have a situation where a building is hit by flying debris and takes considerable damage. Why can't pipes suffer multiple breaks, and posibly be displaced?

It is extremely unlikely that both pipes would fracture in the NE generator room and not in the SW generator room.

Why is there to be any connection between what happens in the two rooms?

Someone would have to leave the door open between the NE generator room and the mechanical room. This is also extremely unlikely.

Why? And why could the violent events (debris hitting the building, possible mionor explosions due to fires, etc.) not cause the door to open?

Hans
 

not even close

Yes
The problem is, they used the 10 story gouge statement in their graphic and ignored two other statements in direct conflict with that statement.

I cannot see anywhere on that graphic where it says 10 story gouge. All it says is "possible region". The other statements could also fit that description? Unless you can show me different

C7 said:
Shyam Sunder, a Bush appointee, is the one who quoted that statement and failed to mention the other two statements in his interview for FM.

That's dishonest.

Many people have come to believe there was a huge gouge in the middle of WTC 7 after reading that interview because he withheld the other conflicting statements. Had he included them, people would have known the issue was in question.

They could also wait and read the report and see for themselves, there was a huge gouge in it though so not really misleading or dishonest. Not anymore dishonest than truthers who say there was no damage to WTC7 from the collapse of the towers


C7 said:
It is known that the Bush administration systematically distorts scientific documents.
NIST Apx. L is no exception.

really, so where are the scientists who are shouting about these distortions? are the scientists who did the investigations happy with the distortions?


C7 said:
It means it is not in the middle of WTC 7, floor 10 to the ground.

Not what you claimed. Does this mean this is the gouge we have seen in photos even though it only mentions the roof and upper level?

No worries mate, Been there, done that.

Not when it matters though

one thing C7, please quote me all the times that NIST use "implode" compared to "collapse". Please do not fly back to FEMA again it is very dishonest and dare I say it cherrypicking
 
That is only a question of temperature. And how volatile they are has no direct bearing on their explosivity, only on the conditions where an explosive situation could arise.
Volatile: a substance that evaporates at a relatively low temperature
Gasoline evaporates faster, burns faster and is therefore, more explosive.

C7 said:
Jaydehess' hypothesis requires the double wall pipe to fracture in such a way as to spill a large amount of diesel without any being caught by the containment pipe. This is very unlikely.
Why is that unlikely? We have a situation where a building is hit by flying debris and takes considerable damage. Why can't pipes suffer multiple breaks, and posibly be displaced?
They might have, in the SW generator room, but that's not what i was saying.
Read the statement again.
The fuel was under 50 lbs. of pressure and a break at a welded joint would be somewhat jagged.
The odds that none of the fuel would be caught by the containment pipe are remote.
The odds that the pipe would fracture in the NE generator room at the other end of the building and not in the SW generator room, where the damage was, are remote.

Why? And why could the violent events (debris hitting the building, possible mionor explosions due to fires, etc.) not cause the door to open?
Hans
Once again, the odds of that door, at the other end of the building, popping open, are remote.
Do you think every door in the building popped open or just that one?

The hypothesis is a series of extremely unlikely events.
 
I cannot see anywhere on that graphic where it says 10 story gouge. All it says is "possible region". The other statements could also fit that description? Unless you can show me different
The inner area is 1/4 the width of WTC 7 and the outer area is 1/3 the width.
The depth is consistent with what Shyam Sunder told FM.
On page 23 it is labeled "Possible region" and on pages 31 and 32 it's labeled as "Approximate Region".
In the summary, it lists the damage attributed to this 10 story gouge
as:
"Possible components that may have led to the failure of columns 79, 80, and/or 81 include interior columns 69, 72, 75,78, and 78A"

Given the two statements in direct conflict with the '10 story gouge' statement, including the damage attributed to the '10 story gouge' in the summary is fraudulent.

C7 said:
Many people have come to believe there was a huge gouge in the middle of WTC 7 after reading that interview because he withheld the other conflicting statements. Had he included them, people would have known the issue was in question.
They could also wait and read the report and see for themselves, there was a huge gouge in it though so not really misleading or dishonest.
Wait 2 years to learn about the two conflicting statements?

Most people will not look up and carefully read the NIST report as i did.
No one here noticed the conflict until i pointed it out.

Not anymore dishonest than truthers who say there was no damage to WTC7 from the collapse of the towers
Is that your justification for Shyam Sunder's misleading the public?
Some anonymous person said something equally incorrect.
Good God, that's like saying it's OK to lie about reasons for going to war in the State of the Union speech as long as you keep in under 20 words.

really, so where are the scientists who are shouting about these distortions? are the scientists who did the investigations happy with the distortions?
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?sec=technology&res=9A00E2DD133DF93AA25751C0A9629C8B63

Scientists Say Administration Distorts Facts

By JAMES GLANZ
Published: February 19, 2004
More than 60 influential scientists, including 20 Nobel laureates, issued a statement yesterday asserting that the Bush administration had systematically distorted scientific fact in the service of policy goals on the environment, health, biomedical research and nuclear weaponry at home and abroad.


one thing C7, please quote me all the times that NIST use "implode" compared to "collapse". Please do not fly back to FEMA again it is very dishonest and dare I say it cherrypicking
FEMA acknowledged that WTC 7 imploded.
You say my quoting FEMA is dishonest.
Please

When making a point, one uses the statements to support that point.
You call it 'cherry picking'. This just an excuse to ignore the facts.
 
FEMA 5-14
The SSB system had two 6,000 gal. tanks.
[The Silverstein system had two 12,000 gal. tanks: OEM one 6,000 gal tank]

Falling debris may have severed pipes in the SW corner of WTC 7, where the SSB, OEM and Silverstein generator rooms were.

There is no reason to think the double wall supply pipe severed completely at the other end of the building while remaining intact where the damage was.

Then, Einstein, it is up to you to tell me where that 40,000+ gallons of fuel went.

I assert that the battery-backed pumps detected a pressure drop in the day tank system and pumped ALL that fuel onto the floor on 5. This needs to be looked into in the design of future fuel systems in high rise towers. (Personally, I think that NG is a more suitable fuel for such uses, for many obvious reasons.)

And I don't think you can prove otherwise - but even if you could, you cannot otherwise account for 40,000 gallons of fuel. And your argument stands or falls on that one point.
 
The inner area is 1/4 the width of WTC 7 and the outer area is 1/3 the width.
The depth is consistent with what Shyam Sunder told FM.
On page 23 it is labeled "Possible region" and on pages 31 and 32 it's labeled as "Approximate Region".
In the summary, it lists the damage attributed to this 10 story gouge
as:
"Possible components that may have led to the failure of columns 79, 80, and/or 81 include interior columns 69, 72, 75,78, and 78A"

Given the two statements in direct conflict with the '10 story gouge' statement, including the damage attributed to the '10 story gouge' in the summary is fraudulent.

C7 said:
The problem is, they used the 10 story gouge statement in their graphic and ignored two other statements in direct conflict with that statement.

No, you claimed the graphic showed the 10 storey gouge and was misleading. The graphic shows possible or approximate damage and has no height or amount of floors, only width and depth. These width and depth could be supported by the conflicting statements. You have not tied the 10 storey gouge to the graphic and it is not fraudulent. The other two descriptions can be used with the graphic also.

This is what the summary states

NIST said:
The initiating event may have included a number of structural components, though the relative role of impact damage and fire need further investigation. Possible components that may have led to the failure of columns 79, 80, and/or 81 include interior columns 69, 72, 75,
78, and 78A, the east transfer girder (which supports column 78A and frames into transfer truss #2), and adjacent framing and floor systems.

This does not mention a 10 storey gouge as being this initiating event cause

Above it however it states this

NIST said:
The damaged floors are less certain, but reports indicatethey occurred between the ground and up to Floors 15 or 20. The extent of damage, bothstructural and to fireproofing, of core framing is not known,

Wait 2 years to learn about the two conflicting statements?

Why not?

C7 said:
Most people will not look up and carefully read the NIST report as i did.
No one here noticed the conflict until i pointed it out.

They wont read it with the total bias you have showed either.

C7 said:
Is that your justification for Shyam Sunder's misleading the public?
Some anonymous person said something equally incorrect.
Good God, that's like saying it's OK to lie about reasons for going to war in the State of the Union speech as long as you keep in under 20 words.

I dont have to justify anything he says, you howver have to justify calling people criminals without evidence


C& said:
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?sec=technology&res=9A00E2DD133DF93AA25751C0A9629C8B63

Scientists Say Administration Distorts Facts

By JAMES GLANZ
Published: February 19, 2004
More than 60 influential scientists, including 20 Nobel laureates, issued a statement yesterday asserting that the Bush administration had systematically distorted scientific fact in the service of policy goals on the environment, health, biomedical research and nuclear weaponry at home and abroad.

Derail, this is about WTC7, you are quick enough to jump on anyone else for this. Show us where Bush and his administration have distirted the NIST preliminary report into WTC7. Still no proof that the investigators are shouting to the rooftops about Bush distorting the report?


C& said:
FEMA acknowledged that WTC 7 imploded.
You say my quoting FEMA is dishonest.
Please

NIST do not at any time say it imploded, this in itself is evidence that it could not have been a CD. These are your standards C7 not mine.

C7 said:
When making a point, one uses the statements to support that point.
You call it 'cherry picking'. This just an excuse to ignore the facts

The fact is NIST do not call it an implosion, they call it a collapse, you knew this but did not quote NIST and only FEMA. Why is that?
 
Scientists Say Administration Distorts Facts

By JAMES GLANZ
Published: February 19, 2004
More than 60 influential scientists, including 20 Nobel laureates, issued a statement yesterday asserting that the Bush administration had systematically distorted scientific fact in the service of policy goals on the environment, health, biomedical research and nuclear weaponry at home and abroad.

And yet we scientists are all scared to speak out against the Bush administration about 9-11 for fear of losing our jobs. Right.

Dave
 
Then, Einstein, it is up to you to tell me where that 40,000+ gallons of fuel went.
The SSB system had two 6,000 gallon tanks. The fate of the rest of the 40,000 gallons is irrelevant.
It is likely that the fuel pipes for the SSB system were severed or fractured in or near the SW generator room where the debris damage was.

I assert that the battery-backed pumps detected a pressure drop in the day tank system and pumped ALL that fuel onto the floor on 5.
In the SW generator room.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom