10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
JAQ, thats what we are supposed to do to get the truth is it not? Why do you not answer?

Too inconvenient?

You still have nothing after all this time do you?

back to the OP, was there a 10 storey gash in the WTC7? Yes or no?
What i have uncovered after all this time is:

You have nothing.

There was no 10 story gouge 1/4 to 1/3 the width of WTC 7 as described on pg 18 of NIST Apx. L.

There was no
debris damage to or near the area of the initiating event.

There is no evidence of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

The fires in the area of the initiating event were insufficient to cause a column weighing over 4 tons per floor to fail.





 
Thank you for the info.
What so said about the risers makes sense.
I still think the valve bodies and 'T' housings were fixed solid to the building.
Absent further evidence, it cannot be assumed either way.

In any case, the chances of a double wall pipe breaking at the other end of the building are slim to remote.
There is no evidence to suggest the fuel pipe broke in the NE generator room.
On the other hand, it is likely that the pipe was severed in or near the SW generator room where the debris damage was.

Chris, is a strong pipe has a force applied to it that force can travel a great distance until it finds a weak point. Where would the weak point be?
 
Chris, is a strong pipe has a force applied to it that force can travel a great distance until it finds a weak point. Where would the weak point be?

Is it too much to ask that a post be coherent and grammatically correct?

I mean geez GT/CS do you bother to proofread your posts?

MM
 
Is it too much to ask that a post be coherent and grammatically correct?

I mean geez GT/CS do you bother to proofread your posts?

MM
At least his post is on topic and contains facts; when will you post a fact?

A fact, you know something to support your ideas on 9/11? When?

So when will Chris finally believe WTC7 fell due to fire? Steel fails in fire; and fires not fought destroy buildings. But it is harder to explain how the building fell, but not why. Fire.
 
Is it too much to ask that a post be coherent and grammatically correct?

I mean geez GT/CS do you bother to proofread your posts?

MM

You might want to actually deal with the serious logical and logistical problems of your beloved 'inside job' theory instead of scolding posters about their grammar.

I'm just saying.
 
Last edited:
Is it too much to ask that a post be coherent and grammatically correct?

I mean geez GT/CS do you bother to proofread your posts?

MM

MM, and the rest of the members who were appalled by my grammatically atrocious post, please accept my sincere apology for not proofreading the post before submitting it.

Thank you MM for civilly alerting me to the error.
 
Chris, if a strong pipe has a force applied to it that force can travel a great distance until it finds a weak point. Where would the weak point be?
You are assuming there is a weak point.

A double wall pipe is extremely strong.
Testimony of Dr. S. Shyam Sunder
"The pipe-in-pipe design used in WTC 7 is quite robust ....."

FEMA 5-28
The following is, therefore, a hypothesis based on potential rather than demonstrated fact.

There was no sign of fire in the NE generator room at any time.

This whole diesel fuel fire thing is a pipe dream with no basis and no evidence to support it.

Even if there was a fire in the NE generator room, it would not have had sufficient air flow to burn hot enough to be a factor in the collapse.
 
Last edited:
You are assuming there is a weak point.

A double wall pipe is extremely strong.
Testimony of Dr. S. Shyam Sunder
"The pipe-in-pipe design used in WTC 7 is quite robust ....."

FEMA 5-28
The following is, therefore, a hypothesis based on potential rather than demonstrated fact.

There was no sign of fire in the NE generator room at any time.

This whole diesel fuel fire thing is a pipe dream with no basis and no evidence to support it.

Even if there was a fire in the NE generator room, it would not have had sufficient air flow to burn hot enough to be a factor in the collapse.

Regarding pipe-in-pipe designs be robust. There would be 2 typical weak points in the pipe system. The 1st would be the hangers. They are designed to support the weight of the pipe, not impacts.

Do you know what happens when pipes try to hang in air without hangers? They fail at the 2nd weak points, the joints, usually elbows. A "robust" pipe can span a much longer distance than a flimsy pipe so it is nearly impossible to say where the pipes broke just by looking at impact points.
 
What i have uncovered after all this time is:

You have nothing.

Still more than you CD boy

C7 said:
There was no 10 story gouge 1/4 to 1/3 the width of WTC 7 as described on pg 18 of NIST Apx. L.

But there was a huge gash on the face of the building at least 10 stories high?


C7 said:
There was no debris damage to or near the area of the initiating event.

Possibly

There is no evidence of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

Possibly


The fires in the area of the initiating event were insufficient to cause a column weighing over 4 tons per floor to fail.

In your opinion and using your assumptions, hypocrisy again C7?
 
Regarding pipe-in-pipe designs be robust. There would be 2 typical weak points in the pipe system. The 1st would be the hangers. They are designed to support the weight of the pipe, not impacts.
Do you know what happens when pipes try to hang in air without hangers? They fail at the 2nd weak points, the joints, usually elbows. A "robust" pipe can span a much longer distance than a flimsy pipe so it is nearly impossible to say where the pipes broke just by looking at impact points.
Hangers are not a weak point.

It is conjecture to say the double wall pipe broke anywhere because of a shock wave.

It is quite possible that the SSB supply pipe was severed in or near the SW generator room by a falling debris.

This whole idea that the shock wave from the impacts caused a double wall pipe to break off at the other end of the building is a pipe dream.
 
Hangers are not a weak point.

It is conjecture to say the double wall pipe broke anywhere because of a shock wave.

It is quite possible that the SSB supply pipe was severed in or near the SW generator room by a falling debris.

This whole idea that the shock wave from the impacts caused a double wall pipe to break off at the other end of the building is a pipe dream.

Please explain how hangers are not a weak point. Have you seen pipe hangers and understand how they work?

Are you familiar with the concept of a moment arm? I'll give you some time to Google it if you need.
 
Fact vs. theory

This gets pretty ridiculous pretty fast.

The conspiracy theory has to had a major event- explosions - knock out the building at approximately the time it started to collapse. Nitpicking about NIST and FEMA language or minor unexplained issues, etc. does not addess the fundamental and undispouted facts:

1.The debris from the North Tower pulverized part of WTC7.

2. WTC7 did not fall "symetrically" oir "in its own footprint." It threw with the north wall on top and it fell across the street.

3. The fire department - before any event that could be part of a conspiracy- announced that the damage to the building was so extensive that it should be evacuated. There was no dissent among any of the NYFD supervisiors on the site about this conclusion. It was arrived at BEFORE any aleged "squibs" (faked in the photograph by Prof. Jones).

These known facts seem to be ignored by the CTs in favor of some petty dispute about column numbers, etc.

Some real questions in their explanations seem to also never by answred:

1. If it was a conspiracy, why would Silverstein admit to it on public broadcasting?

2. Why would all the fire department bosses lie, especially when dozens of their colleagues and fellow workers had been killed that day?

3. Why would such a clever conspiracy do make the building fall asymetrically or it a mater that was more convincing to them? i.e. symetrically collapse actually proves nothing, even if it occurred.

4. How could hundreds of charges be placed in WTC7 in secret over the weeks before 9-11? They would have had to be placed inside the walls and behind the interior surfaces, pretty ovious to anyone who worked there.

5. Devices to cut steel beams would have to be elaborate to get the thermite to cut horizonally. Elements of these in the hundreds of locations needed would have survived the fall, none were found.

6. All of this would have to be coordinated with the WTC Towers attack and with the willing participation of Al Qaeda, who has repeatedly now admitted the attacks. How likely is this theory?

So we have numerous known facts the contradict the CTs and major questions that suggest it is completely implausible and incredible to believe their allegations.

Randy
 
Please explain how hangers are not a weak point. Have you seen pipe hangers and understand how they work?
Yes, I have done work in commercial buildings. As jaydeehess noted, the hangers are usually threaded rod with a 2 piece clamp that wraps around the pipe. The rods are attached to a mounting bracket which is fixed solid to the building.
To allow an adequate safety margin, these rods and mounting brackets are capable of carrying many times their prescribed load.
In any case, the hangers near the impact would receive a greater shock than the hangers at the other end of the building.

Are you familiar with the concept of a moment arm? I'll give you some time to Google it if you need.
Moment means torque [twisting force].
This would not come into play until the pipe was severed and there was an arm that could rotate.
 
Nitpicking about NIST and FEMA language or minor unexplained issues, etc. does not addess the fundamental and undispouted facts:
On the contrary, what you call nitpicking is simply quoting facts in the FEMA and NIST reports concerning critical issues.

These facts do not support the DD/F hypothesis.

1.The debris from the North Tower pulverized part of WTC7.
The south west part. The collapse began in the east central part.

2. WTC7 did not fall "symetrically" oir "in its own footprint." It threw with the north wall on top and it fell across the street.
Wrong

FEMA 5-31 WTC 7 had a relatively small debris field because the façade came straight down, suggesting an internal collapse.
NIST L-33
The debris of WTC 7 was mostly contained within the original footprint of the building.

Part of the north wall buckled outward and damaged the building across the street.
The upper part of the north wall landed on top of the debris pile.

There was simply too much material to be entirely contained within the original footprint.

This implosion was done without permits and damage to the surrounding buildings was not a consideration.

3. The fire department - before any event that could be part of a conspiracy- announced that the damage to the building was so extensive that it should be evacuated. There was no dissent among any of the NYFD supervisiors on the site about this conclusion.
Wrong again.

Chiefs Nigro, Fellini and Hayden thought WTC 7 was going to collapse.
Chief Norman did not.
"I looked at 7 World Trade Center. There was smoke showing, but not a lot and I’m saying that isn’t going to fall."

"I never expected it to fall the way it did as quickly as it did, 7."

These known facts seem to be ignored by the CTs in favor of some petty dispute about column numbers, etc.
There is no dispute about column numbers.

You cannot dispute or accept the facts so you change the subject and ask the infinitely arguable questions.
Some real questions in their explanations seem to also never by answred:
1. If it was a conspiracy, why would Silverstein admit to it on public broadcasting?
2. Why would all the fire department bosses lie, especially when dozens of their colleagues and fellow workers had been killed that day?
3.etc.
Randy
These are the facts in the NIST report.

There is no evidence to support the DD/F hypothesis.
There were fires on several floors, at different times, in the area of the initiating event.
[the failure of core column 79, 80 and/or 81]

Fires in east half of WTC 7

NIST
11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.
Fire on floor 12, moved toward the east face
2:00 to 2:30 p.m.
Fires on east face Floors 11 and 12 at the southeast corner, progressing north

As of 3:00 p.m., there were fires on floors 11 and 12 in the area of the initiating event.

Some time later, fires on 8 and 13

For the NIST hypothesis to happen, a core column, weighing over 4 tons per floor, would have to be uniformly heated to about 1,000 F, and 2 or 3 floors would have to collapse all around that column, before it could break at 3 splice joints and buckle.

There is no evidence of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

There was no debris damage to or near the area of the initiating event.


That's the evidence.

Debris damage to the other end of the building,
and fires that a burned on a few floors, for a few hours, at different times, in the area where the implosion began.
 
There was observed fire on floors 7 and 8 with the one on 8 eventually moving along the north face all the way to the east face.
There was a two storey opening from the 5th floor slab through the 6th floor right at the area of the initiating event.

Some type of damage occured just west of the initiating event due to the collapse of WTC 1 which caused the elevator cars to be ejected out of their shafts at floor 8.

So, there is a major fire on 8 and structural damage quite possible at the 8th floor core area diaphragm.

Fire causes the floor span of floor 8 to sag all along the north face all the way to the east face creating a pull on the core columns towards the north and then , later in the day, also to the east. There was also a fire towards the center of the north face on the 7th floor which puts it in the vicinity of the elevator car that was ejected at the 8th floor.

The ceiling of the 5th floor is the floor of the 6th floor EXCEPT at the area of the initiating event where there is an opening. That would be a weak point in the 6th floor. If the 7th and 8th floor fires are both pulling the core columns, along the north side of the core, towards the north then there is less lateral bracing for columns 79,80,81 at the 2 storey opening just below that area.

IFa slow leak from a crack in the diesel pipe created a pool of fuel in the same area but on the 5th floor that pool would be evaporating into the 5th floor space, with, as Chris likes to point out, little ventilation and thus creating a fairly large fuel air mix. This need not occur in the NE generator room but rather just about anywhere along the north side of the 5th floor. That fuel cloud could eventually make its way to an ignition source on the still smoldering 7th floor (with fires on the 7,8,11,12th floors air would be moving up through the bottom floors of the building) which would create a blast event on the 5th floor pushing the columns 79,80,81 to the east and or north , the same direction they are already being pulled by the sagging 7th and 8th floors.

Columns 79,80,81 shift to the east pulling down on them, they are also suffering some creep at the 11/12th floor fires due to the heavy fires that were there. They are then already shortened at the 12th floor level when they are pulled down by the event on the 5-7th floor and while in isolation neither the fire damage at the 12th floor nor the insult at the 5-7th would be enough to cause the columns to fail, the combination of the two does fail them at the 12th floor.


The penthouse kink is created and the machinery in the penthouse falls through the floor along with flooring and other debris. This dense, heavy debris falls with little in the way to slow it until it reachs the transfer trusses at the 7th floor, impacting them and pulling them also to the east which pulls the next core columns out of line as well which in turn pull on the next causing a horizontal progression from east to west of column failures at the 7th floor which is evident from the outside as the rest of the roof structures start to sink into roof. Before the roof structures can completely fall into the building the failure of these core columns causes the cantilever trusses runing over the Con-ed building to have no support at their connection to the core and they push up on the north face. They north face end of the canitlever trusses cannot lift the north face though and the columns under them fail and the north wall starts down while being pulled southward by the already falling core.

The eastern portion of the building fails at the bottom at columns 79,80,81but has separted from the western 2/3rds of the building along that line of columns and thus has less force pulling the NE corner towards the core than does the western portion of the building since the horizontal progression of column failures went west from the initial failure. At least part of the NE corner falls away from the building and impacts the building accross Broadway while most of the rest of the building collapses inward.

This is all guess work on my part, based upon what we know of damage to the building, location of fires and the fact that diesel fuel went missing. As such it uses much more in the way of empirical evidence than does any contention of the use of explosives to knock out columns in WTC 7. the probability of this sequence of events may be low, that's for experts to decide, but aside from a fuel air explosion it uses only known events and empirical evidence. In this, the only difference needed between this senario and a CD senario would be the cause of the blast event. Given that diesel fuel was missing and had to have been burned off somehow whereas there is no evidence that any explosives actually were in the building at any time on 9/11/01 Occam's razor would argue that if the two senarios are to be considered against only each other, the one with a diesel fuel explosion would be that most likely.
 
Last edited:
Yes, I have done work in commercial buildings. As jaydeehess noted, the hangers are usually threaded rod with a 2 piece clamp that wraps around the pipe. The rods are attached to a mounting bracket which is fixed solid to the building.
To allow an adequate safety margin, these rods and mounting brackets are capable of carrying many times their prescribed load.
In any case, the hangers near the impact would receive a greater shock than the hangers at the other end of the building.

Moment means torque [twisting force].
This would not come into play until the pipe was severed and there was an arm that could rotate
.

Wow. Just wow. Now I understand. I'll have no more questions for you Chris.
 
There was observed fire on floors 7 and 8 with the one on 8 eventually moving along the north face all the way to the east face.
There was a two storey opening from the 5th floor slab through the 6th floor right at the area of the initiating event.

Some type of damage occured just west of the initiating event due to the collapse of WTC 1 which caused the elevator cars to be ejected out of their shafts at floor 8.
You are assuming the elevator cars were ejected by debris from WTC 1 and that this happened just west of the initiating event.

So, there is a major fire on 8 and structural damage quite possible at the 8th floor core area diaphragm.

Fire causes the floor span of floor 8 to sag all along the north face all the way to the east face creating a pull on the core columns towards the north and then , later in the day, also to the east.
Wrong.
The fire on floor 8 may have cause the beams on floor 9 to sag.

There was also a fire towards the center of the north face on the 7th floor which puts it in the vicinity of the elevator car that was ejected at the 8th floor.

The ceiling of the 5th floor is the floor of the 6th floor EXCEPT at the area of the initiating event where there is an opening. That would be a weak point in the 6th floor. If the 7th and 8th floor fires are both pulling the core columns, along the north side of the core, towards the north then there is less lateral bracing for columns 79,80,81 at the 2 storey opening just below that area.

IFa slow leak from a crack in the diesel pipe created a pool of fuel in the same area but on the 5th floor
A slow leak would be partially captured by the outer containment pipe, directed to the containment vessel and the pumps would be turned off.

that pool would be evaporating into the 5th floor space, with, as Chris likes to point out, little ventilation and thus creating a fairly large fuel air mix. This need not occur in the NE generator room but rather just about anywhere along the north side of the 5th floor. That fuel cloud could eventually make its way to an ignition source on the still smoldering 7th floor (with fires on the 7,8,11,12th floors air would be moving up through the bottom floors of the building) which would create a blast event on the 5th floor pushing the columns 79,80,81 to the east and or north , the same direction they are already being pulled by the sagging 7th and 8th floors.
A blast event would blow out thru the louvers as would the smoke from the ensuing fire.
This did not happen.

Columns 79,80,81 shift to the east pulling down on them, they are also suffering some creep at the 11/12th floor fires due to the heavy fires that were there. They are then already shortened at the 12th floor when they are pulled down by the event on the 5-7th floor level
Shortened? You are making this stuff up as you go along.
How did these massive columns get shorter?

and while in isolation neither the fire damage at the 12th floor nor the insult at the 5-7th would be enough to cause the columns to fail, the combination of the two does fail them at the 12th floor.
There is NO evidence of an 'insult' on the 5 floor near the initiating event.

Quite the contrary, there was NO sign of fire in that area at any time.

If there was a fire there, smoke would be pouring out of the ventilation louvers.

This did not happen.

There is NO reason to think there was a fire in the NE part of floor 5.
The evidence clearly demonstrates that there was
no fire there.

 
Last edited:
You are assuming the elevator cars were ejected by debris from WTC 1 and that this happened just west of the initiating event.

Just dealing with the known factor of elevator cars being ejected Chris and surmising one distinct possibility.

Wrong.
The fire on floor 8 may have cause the beams on floor 9 to sag.

Ok, make it floor 9, anything to help your understanding of this senario along Chris.

A slow leak would be partially captured by the outer containment pipe, directed to the containment vessel and the pumps would be turned off.


No, I am reffering to a crack that allowed a slow leak through both inner and outer pipe but which is not a complete severing of them.

A blast event would blow out thru the louvers as would the smoke from the ensuing fire.
This did not happen.

Its not IN the NE generator room Chris, its in the core area and occurs moments before the east penthouse sinks.

Shortened? You are making this stuff up as you go along.
How did these massive columns get shorter?

Do some research on how steel behaves in fires Chris. The steel heats and attempts to expand but is under axial load so it cannot and instead sags (bunchs up near the ceiling usually, I am sure you have seen the pictures of the fire that occured in the WTC towers years ago in which a column(s?) did exactly this or those in the Cardington tests that did it) under the combination of this load and the more plastic state it is in due to the heat. This is usually not enough to cause failure. When the fire moves on the steel starts to cool and as it does so it contracts which it can do under axial load. what it cannot do it return to the same length it had before sagging and thus is now shorter than it was before being heated.

There is NO evidence of an 'insult' on the 5 floor near the initiating event.

Quite the contrary, there was NO sign of fire in that area at any time.

If there was a fire there, smoke would be pouring out of the ventilation louvers.

Again this occurs just before the collapse occurs Chris.


There is NO reason to think there was a fire in the NE part of floor 5.
The evidence clearly demonstrates that there was no fire there.

No fire Chris, an explosion that occurs just before collapse. No one saw the smoke because this was not an overly powerful explosion but enough to tip the balance and besides you have stated that no one need have seen the explosives you believe in going off either. It does not require that fire be the initiating event, something you state it could not be. Instead it is an extrodinary event that simply would not occur in most steel structure fires.

Hey, I thought you'd be pleased since this senario even includes a source of a "thunderclap" while using info that is well docuemented.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom