10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
There is no reason to think the double wall supply pipe severed completely at the other end of the building while remaining intact where the damage was.

As I understand it there is only one place where the pipe is solidly fixed to the building.
Otherwise the pipe connects via hangers, to the building. That means that only at one point would the pipe be vulnerable to seismic damage.

To my knowledge this has not been thoroughly investigated has it Chris?


,,,,, wait for it
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,louvers
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,smoke
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,all fires known
 
They did not investigate the possibility of diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room, they just included it in the summary saying:
"The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5."

This is misleading.

I don't see how.
It apparently did not mislead you, or me.
It would be something that would be investigated in more detail in a more extensive report

The debris impact to the south face indicates the possibility of fires to the SW part of WTC 7,
NOT THE NORTH EAST GENERATOR ROOM!

The next statement starts with:
"The initiating event may have included a number of structural components"

This is misleading.
.


Really? I don't see how. It did not mislead you or me.
Should they have put a few empty lines between the two? Actually the next line begins with a number does it not? You know , such as is used in demarking the separation between two technical points.

You certainly are looking for ghosts in the minutia.

Maybe there is a way to rearange the letters in "Shyram Sunder of NIST" to get it to spell something sinister too Chris.:boggled::rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Reported for quote mining my post, sad that you cannot even quote the whole post and reply, as usual with truthers it is cherry picked. Conveniently leaving out the explosives again C7? Why is that?
This thread is about DD/F, not CD. OK?

If someone who was involved in the NIST investigation was not happy with the report they can remove their name from it. I dont see anyone who has, so why is this? If your name goes against the report you are saying you are happy with its conclusions and everything contained in it.
If you say so.

NIST L-51
"The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5."
A statement about the diesel cannot be misleading if it does not state categorically but says there was a possibility
I disagree.
Including diesel fuel fires as a possible contributing factor to the collapse is misleading for two reasons.
1) There is NO EVIDENCE of fire in or near the NE generator room and no reason to think there was a fire there.
2) The fires indicatedwould have been in the other end of the building.

And why does the next statement make it misleading?
Because it leads the reader to think the possible diesel fuel fires in the SW corner contributed to the initiating event.


You make great assumnptions make bold claims yet castigate NIST or any other poster here for the same
You are a [childish insult deleted]
Why can you make assumptions like this C7 surely you can see this is misleading by your own standards?
Your understanding of the word 'assumption ' is incorrect.
In the sentence,
"Falling debris may have severed pipes in the SW corner of WTC 7, where the SSB, OEM and Silverstein generator rooms were.",
'may have' does not assume, it suggests a possibility.
 
"Falling debris may have severed pipes in the SW corner of WTC 7, where the SSB, OEM and Silverstein generator rooms were.",
'may have' does not assume, it suggests a possibility.



NIST L-51
"The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5[/B]."

......Including diesel fuel fires as a possible contributing factor to the collapse is misleading


Oooh the irony, oooh the hypocrisy!!!!!!!!

Stundie nominated
 
Last edited:
As I understand it there is only one place where the pipe is solidly fixed to the building.
Otherwise the pipe connects via hangers, to the building. That means that only at one point would the pipe be vulnerable to seismic damage.
Only the horizontal piping on the 5th floor was a double-wall pipe within a pipe.

The SSB fuel oil risers [supply and return pipes] were single-wall pipes in a utility shaft in the west end of the building.
The risers would be fixed to the side of the shaft and to the single-to-double pipe fitting which would be fixed to the building.

There had to be a special fitting at the 'T' for the SW and NW generators to 'T' off the inner pipe while keeping the outer pipe continuous.
This fitting would be fixed to the building.


It is simply not possible for the double wall pipe at the other end of the building to completely break off and these single wall connections, close to the debris damage, to remain intact.
 
This thread is about DD/F, not CD. OK?

So, you have not mentioned CD in this thread? You do not believe it was CD?

If you say so.

You know so, you would not put your name to a report that had aspects you were not happy with would you?

NIST L-51
"The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5."
I disagree.
Including diesel fuel fires as a possible contributing factor to the collapse is misleading for two reasons.
1) There is NO EVIDENCE of fire in or near the NE generator room and no reason to think there was a fire there.
2) The fires indicatedwould have been in the other end of the building.

Waffle, there is no evidence of a lot of things you believe in this situation so I guess you will be dismissing them?

Because it leads the reader to think the possible diesel fuel fires in the SW corner contributed to the initiating event.

It leads you due to your bias, it does not lead me anywhere. How are the statements seperated?

Your understanding of the word 'assumption ' is incorrect.
In the sentence,
"Falling debris may have severed pipes in the SW corner of WTC 7, where the SSB, OEM and Silverstein generator rooms were.",
'may have' does not assume, it suggests a possibility.

You can say "may have" "it is safe to assume" "it is a possibility" but no-one else can? Hypocrisy C7 and you know it
 
I think you meant "may have been".
No, i meant to say "would have been".

NIST L-51
1. Fires were observed .......... Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows*.The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5.

2. The initiating event may have included a number of structural components .........


The fires indicated would have been in the other end of the building in the 5th floor generator room in the SW corner of the building.

Debris damage to the south west part of the building does NOT indicate a fire in the north east generator room in the area of the initiating event as the summary implies.


*this statement ignores the tell tale sign of diesel fuel fires, a lot of thick black smoke.
 
Only the horizontal piping on the 5th floor was a double-wall pipe within a pipe.

The SSB fuel oil risers [supply and return pipes] were single-wall pipes in a utility shaft in the west end of the building.
The risers would be fixed to the side of the shaft and to the single-to-double pipe fitting which would be fixed to the building.

There had to be a special fitting at the 'T' for the SW and NW generators to 'T' off the inner pipe while keeping the outer pipe continuous.
This fitting would be fixed to the building.


It is simply not possible for the double wall pipe at the other end of the building to completely break off and these single wall connections, close to the debris damage, to remain intact.


,, and you know this for a fact because its reported where please?
 
Would it be asking too much for you to address the issue?

JAQ, thats what we are supposed to do to get the truth is it not? Why do you not answer?

Too inconvenient?

You still have nothing after all this time do you?

back to the OP, was there a 10 storey gash in the WTC7? Yes or no?
 
C7 said:
It is simply not possible for the double wall pipe at the other end of the building to completely break off and these single wall connections, close to the debris damage, to remain intact.

,, and you know this for a fact because its reported where please?
and you can't figure this out for yourself?

Do you really think a double wall pipe broke off in the NE generator room and the single wall pipes in the SW generator room did not?
 
and you can't figure this out for yourself?

Do you really think a double wall pipe broke off in the NE generator room and the single wall pipes in the SW generator room did not?


If the single wall pipe was mounted with hangers and the only place where the pipe was affixed solidly to the structure was at the valve box then that would be the most likely place for a seismically caused fracture Chris. I asked you what method was used to hold the pipes. You stated an assumption it seems. If you don't know because it has not been stated in the reports to date then that would certainly suggest another item to be explored in an investigation into where the diesel fuel went missing.

Not that long ago I was in our local recreation center(ice rink, training rooms, two pools) and noticed that ALL of the piping ran through hangers and in vertical runs was held by hangers that fixed to the vertical wall by threaded rods. (I was doing a wiring job so I was in the crawl spaces and utility shafts) This building is a steel and concrete construction. It was quite obvious that these were to allow for expansion and contraction of the piping.
 
Last edited:
If the single wall pipe was mounted with hangers and the only place where the pipe was affixed solidly to the structure was at the valve box then that would be the most likely place for a seismically caused fracture Chris. I asked you what method was used to hold the pipes. You stated an assumption it seems. If you don't know because it has not been stated in the reports to date then that would certainly suggest another item to be explored in an investigation into where the diesel fuel went missing.

Not that long ago I was in our local recreation center(ice rink, training rooms, two pools) and noticed that ALL of the piping ran through hangers and in vertical runs was held by hangers that fixed to the vertical wall by threaded rods. (I was doing a wiring job so I was in the crawl spaces and utility shafts) This building is a steel and concrete construction. It was quite obvious that these were to allow for expansion and contraction of the piping.
Point well taken.

Did you see the starting and termination points?

Did the pipes connect to valve bodies and if so, were those affixed solid to the building?

Was the pipe 2 1/2 " ?

The SSB system required a 'T' and valve at the SW and NW generator rooms.
 
Point well taken.

Did you see the starting and termination points?

For some of the systems, yes. Not attached to the concrete or steel frame of the building.

Did the pipes connect to valve bodies and if so, were those affixed solid to the building?

The ones I saw, some did and no, there were hangers on either side of the valves.

Was the pipe 2 1/2 " ?

about 4" outer diameter for the heating system.
About 2" for the natural gas.
and IIRC about 2" for the ice rink coolant but these were embedded in the concrete starting about 4 feet from the refrigeration unit
 
For some of the systems, yes. Not attached to the concrete or steel frame of the building.
The ones I saw, some did and no, there were hangers on either side of the valves.
Just to be clear, were the valves or any part of the heating pipe system affixed solid to the building?

about 4" outer diameter for the heating system.
About 2" for the natural gas.
and IIRC about 2" for the ice rink coolant but these were embedded in the concrete starting about 4 feet from the refrigeration unit
 
Just to be clear, were the valves or any part of the heating pipe system affixed solid to the building?

At least one was not affixed to the concrete. I recall this one in particular because I hit my head on the dang thing. where the pipes went through the concrete walls they were in a steel sleeve and not affixed to the concrete(ie. they could move)

Where they went up through the concrete they were fixed to it. I do not know what was on the other side of the concrete in this case. The distance from horizontal run to the concrete ceiling of the crawl space was only a few feet at most. the horizontal run of the longest pipe would have been approx 300 feet.

I tell ya what Chris, if the company ever needs me to go back there and point out exactly where I ran my cables I'll take pictures and post them here. Not likely to happen though as I do not have the same job anymore and there was another guy with me who also knows where the cables run for the most part
 
Last edited:
At least one was not affixed to the concrete. I recall this one in particular because I hit my head on the dang thing. where the pipes went through the concrete walls they were in a steel sleeve and not affixed to the concrete(ie. they could move)

Where they went up through the concrete they were fixed to it. I do not know what was on the other side of the concrete in this case. The distance from horizontal run to the concrete ceiling of the crawl space was only a few feet at most. the horizontal run of the longest pipe would have been approx 300 feet.

I tell ya what Chris, if the company ever needs me to go back there and point out exactly where I ran my cables I'll take pictures and post them here. Not likely to happen though as I do not have the same job anymore and there was another guy with me who also knows where the cables run for the most part
Thank you for the info.
What so said about the risers makes sense.
I still think the valve bodies and 'T' housings were fixed solid to the building.
Absent further evidence, it cannot be assumed either way.

In any case, the chances of a double wall pipe breaking at the other end of the building are slim to remote.
There is no evidence to suggest the fuel pipe broke in the NE generator room.
On the other hand, it is likely that the pipe was severed in or near the SW generator room where the debris damage was.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom