10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is it correct then that if this diesel burned, regardless of where it burned, then it should have been or should be mentioned somewhere in the NIST report?
Mentioned perhaps, but not in the summary as a possible contributing factor to the initiating event.

The evidence shows that diesel fuel fires were not a factor in the initiating event.

The fans come on and the louvers open when the generators come on. FEMA 5-29

The fans blow 320,000 cfm of air into the generator room. FEMA 5-29

The hypothesis requires the fans to be on.
"Given open louvers and other sources for entry of air, it is, therefore, probable that
a fuel oil spill fire would have found sufficient air for combustion." FEMA 5-29

There was no smoke coming from the air exhaust louvers in the NE Generator room at any time.

There is no reason to think there was a fire in the NE generator room.

Even if there was a fire in the NE generator room, the louvers would have to be closed and the fire would not have sufficient air for sustained high temperature combustion.
 
Last edited:
Mentioned perhaps, but not in the summary as a possible contributing factor to the initiating event.

The evidence shows that diesel fuel fires were not a factor in the initiating event.

The fans come on and the louvers open when the generators come on. FEMA 5-29

The fans blow 320,000 cfm of air into the generator room. FEMA 5-29

The hypothesis requires the fans to be on.
"Given open louvers and other sources for entry of air, it is, therefore, probable that
a fuel oil spill fire would have found sufficient air for combustion." FEMA 5-29

There was no smoke coming from the air exhaust louvers in the NE Generator room at any time.

There is no reason to think there was a fire in the NE generator room.

Even if there was a fire in the NE generator room, the louvers would have to be closed and the fire would not have sufficient air for sustained high temperature combustion.

Listen mate, stop quoting FEMA at me, I am talking about NIST. Do you think they should not investigate anything FEMA has done already or should they carry out their own investigations? It is the NIST report they are putting their names to not the FEMA one.

Where should NIST have mentioned the diesel fuel and possible fires that consumed it?
 
:deadhorse
Where should NIST have mentioned the diesel fuel and possible fires that consumed it?

oh, oh , I know this one. NIST, in its interim report summary, should have listed this in the section that dealt with the fires in the building.

deja vu , I could swear that I have already stated that somewhere.,,,,,
 
Listen mate, stop quoting FEMA at me, I am talking about NIST. Do you think they should not investigate anything FEMA has done already or should they carry out their own investigations?
It was not necessary to re-investigate where the tanks, pumps, pipes and generator rooms were, nor should this data be ignored as you seem to suggest.

FEMA also established that the louvers opened and the fans came on when the generators were running.
Do you think NIST should re-investigate or ignore that too?

NIST continued the investigation and determined where the fires were and the time line of those fires.

It is the NIST report they are putting their names to not the FEMA one.
There are no names listed in the NIST Apx. L report.
Those who contributed endorse their contribution but not necessarily the report.
Do you know who actually 'signed off' on the NIST Apx. L report?

Where should NIST have mentioned the diesel fuel and possible fires that consumed it?
The evidence shows that diesel fuel fires did not contribute to the initiating event that led to the implosion of WTC 7

Since the NIST investigation is to determine what caused the collapse of WTC 7, diesel fuel fires should not have been included anywhere.


NIST determined that there was no sign of fire in or near the NE generator room at any time.

If the louvers were open and the fans on, smoke from a fire would be pouring out of the louvers.

If the louvers were closed, a fire would not have sufficient air to burn hot enough to be a factor in the initiating event that led to the implosion of WTC 7.

NIST knew these facts.

Do you dispute any of these facts?
If so, which one and why?
 
The evidence shows that diesel fuel fires did not contribute to the initiating event that led to the implosion of WTC 7

Since the NIST investigation is to determine what caused the collapse of WTC 7, diesel fuel fires should not have been included anywhere.

NIST also made mention of fires and debris damage that occured no where near the initiating event. There is even a picture of the damage to the roof parapet. Should they have ignored that as well Chris? Why mention the damage to the SW corner Chris? After all , according to you the only thing NIST was supposed to do is investiagte the collapse and nothing else.

They also mentioned that FF's had been in the building including in areas no where near the initiating event and we all know that no one was in the building at the time of the collapse so why bother mentioning that either?
 
NIST also made mention of fires and debris damage that occured no where near the initiating event. There is even a picture of the damage to the roof parapet. Should they have ignored that as well Chris? Why mention the damage to the SW corner Chris? After all , according to you the only thing NIST was supposed to do is investiagte the collapse and nothing else.
There was photographic evidence and firefighter statements to verify the debris damage and fires.

These should have been, and were included.

There was NO evidence to support the diesel fuel hypothesis.

There was no reason to think there were diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

Therefore, diesel fuel fires should not have been included as a possible contributing factor in the initiating event.

They also mentioned that FF's had been in the building including in areas no where near the initiating event and we all know that no one was in the building at the time of the collapse so why bother mentioning that either?
They mentioned the damage and fires that the firefighters reported.

There was NO reports of fires in the NE part of floor 5, and NO reason to think there was a fire there.
 
When the final verion is published can we just recycle all these posts or do we need to go through the mind-numbing task of generating 4000 new posts?
 
When the final verion is published can we just recycle all these posts or do we need to go through the mind-numbing task of generating 4000 new posts?
It's time to stop hiding behind the words 'preliminary' or 'interim' as if the known facts are going to change in the 'final' report.

The location of the NE generator room and the supply pipe running to it are not going to change.

There is virtually no chance the supply pipe severed completely at the other end of the building while remaining completely intact in the area where the damage was.

The location and progression of the fires is not going to change.

The fact that there was no sign of fire in the NE generator room at any time is not going to change.

Even if there was a fire there, with the louvers closed it would not have sufficient air flow to burn hot enough to be a factor in the initiating event.

These are known facts from the data in the reports OTers put fourth as their reason for believing that WTC 7 collapsed due to DD/F.
 
Last edited:
When the final verion is published can we just recycle all these posts or do we need to go through the mind-numbing task of generating 4000 new posts?


Cristopher 7 writes;
It's time to stop hiding behind the words 'preliminary' or 'interim' as if the known facts are going to change in the 'final' report....

....These are known facts from the data in the reports OTers put fourth as their reason for believing that WTC 7 collapsed due to DD/F.

Seems that Chris feels that the final report isn't even required. Everything that needs to be known is already known.

I predict that once the final report does come out that there will indeed be another 4000 or more posts in which Chris will continue to post the same old tired story again and again in an attempt to make NIST's report look like it has some small holes in it. These small holes he believes are/will be, big enough to drive a truck full of explosives and thermate(ite) through.
 
It was not necessary to re-investigate where the tanks, pumps, pipes and generator rooms were, nor should this data be ignored as you seem to suggest.

FEMA also established that the louvers opened and the fans came on when the generators were running.
Do you think NIST should re-investigate or ignore that too?

They should not ignore anything but they have a duty to investigate things they put their name against.

Look at it like a police investigation, do they never go back and look at leads or evidence thay have previously looked at before. If a new OIC comes onboard do you think he never goes back and looks at the work carried out by other officers to see if there is anything they have missed and needs to be looked at again?

In you world evreything is done correctly first time and never needs looked at again? If that is the case then after the full report is realeased you will have to put up and shut up cause it has been done and dusted.


NIST continued the investigation and determined where the fires were and the time line of those fires.

There are no names listed in the NIST Apx. L report.
Those who contributed endorse their contribution but not necessarily the report.
Do you know who actually 'signed off' on the NIST Apx. L report?

Anyone involved in the investigation is putting their name to the report.

The evidence shows that diesel fuel fires did not contribute to the initiating event that led to the implosion of WTC 7

Since the NIST investigation is to determine what caused the collapse of WTC 7, diesel fuel fires should not have been included anywhere.

Then they should not have mentioned any fires or damage that were nowhere near the initiating event at all either?

NIST determined that there was no sign of fire in or near the NE generator room at any time.

If the louvers were open and the fans on, smoke from a fire would be pouring out of the louvers.

If the louvers were closed, a fire would not have sufficient air to burn hot enough to be a factor in the initiating event that led to the implosion of WTC 7.

NIST knew these facts.

So they had to mention them, if there was stash of High Explosives in the building, not near the initiating event and they did not mention them or investigate them, the truthers would be up in arms and all over it.

Do you dispute any of these facts?
If so, which one and why?

No, I dispute your whole position. There is more evidence of diesel fuel fire in the building than there is of explosives so if they should not look at or mention diesel fuel then they should not mention or look at explosives.

Your witness statements are suspect, you have no video or sound of explosives, you avoid the silent explosive questions, you expect NIST to ignore things while you think they should investigate things there is not a shred of evidence for, you expect them to take FEMA word for everything they investigated even though in the case of the twin towers they went against the FEMA theory, your shadow analysis was suspect and flawed, your accusations of photo fakery were false and without evidence, you make wild assumptions yet berate anyone else who does the same, you use FEMA when people are discussing NIST.

Your arguments are flawed, contradictory and hypocritical.
 
Seems that Chris feels that the final report isn't even required.
Wrong

Everything that needs to be known is already known.
Everything that needs to be known about the location of the NE generator room, the supply pipe, the fans, the louvers and the location and progression of the fires, is already known.
 
Last edited:
Wrong

Everything that needs to be known about the location of the NE generator room, the supply pipe, the fans, the louvers and the location and progression of the fires, is already known.

How can you justify making an arrogant statement like that if you are not part of the NIST team?

How do you know that everything is known? And since you know everything that is known about the diesel fires please tell us exactly where in the building the fuel burned.

Go ahead and tell us so we can end this thread and investigate invisible bigfoots.
 
Last edited:
I do have question that probably was answered but i am to lazy to search/read about right now....

Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
That just doesnt quite add up to me and would a truthers best argument in my eyes.

According to what I understand, it appears that one of the key columns (#79?) on the East side of the building, one of several that supported "large floor areas" had given way. Ignore for now the cause of this "initiating event". It supported one end of the East equipment penthouse.

With the column failed, the resulting structural failure progressed upward to the top of the structure, it would not be unreasonable to expect that the now unsupported end of the East equipment penthouse would also fail and would collapse down into the building. Since the progression involved internal failures, the exterior probably showed less obvious signs of the structural failure than might have been expected.

The issue of what caused the column to fail is what has been contentious. On the one hand there is the controlled demo idea. On the other hand there is the raging, possibly diesel fed fires, idea. Another theory could be that the office fires on relatively low levels, inadequate or non-existent fire protection, and lack of fire fighting caused floors to buckle or deform which might pull the column out of alignment and maybe induce a buckling situation and failure.
 
According to what I understand, it appears that one of the key columns (#79?) on the East side of the building, one of several that supported "large floor areas" had given way. Ignore for now the cause of this "initiating event". It supported one end of the East equipment penthouse.

With the column failed, the resulting structural failure progressed upward to the top of the structure, it would not be unreasonable to expect that the now unsupported end of the East equipment penthouse would also fail and would collapse down into the building. Since the progression involved internal failures, the exterior probably showed less obvious signs of the structural failure than might have been expected.

The issue of what caused the column to fail is what has been contentious. On the one hand there is the controlled demo idea. On the other hand there is the raging, possibly diesel fed fires, idea. Another theory could be that the office fires on relatively low levels, inadequate or non-existent fire protection, and lack of fire fighting caused floors to buckle or deform which might pull the column out of alignment and maybe induce a buckling situation and failure.

It might also have been an inadequate design to begin with.
 
They should not ignore anything but they have a duty to investigate things they put their name against.
Excellent point.
They did not investigate the possibility of diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room, they just included it in the summary saying:
"The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5."

This is misleading.

The debris impact to the south face indicates the possibility of fires to the SW part of WTC 7,
NOT THE NORTH EAST GENERATOR ROOM!

The next statement starts with:
"The initiating event may have included a number of structural components"

This is misleading.

C7 said:
There are no names listed in the NIST Apx. L report.
Those who contributed endorse their contribution but not necessarily the report.
Do you know who actually 'signed off' on the NIST Apx. L report?
Anyone involved in the investigation is putting their name to the report.
So you don't know who 'signed off' on Apx. L.
'Putting their names to the report' by contributing is NOT endorsing the report.

C7 said:
Since the NIST investigation is to determine what caused the collapse of WTC 7, diesel fuel fires should not have been included anywhere.
Then they should not have mentioned any fires or damage that were nowhere near the initiating event at all either?
MY bad.
The possible diesel fuel fires near the SW corner could be mentioned somewhere in the report but not in the summary as a possible contributing factor in the collapse.

They correctly mentioned the fires and damage that was reported.
There was NO fire reported in or near the NE generator room, NO reason to think there was a fire there and NO reason to imply that there was a fire there in the summary.

C7 said:
NIST determined that there was no sign of fire in or near the NE generator room at any time.

If the louvers were open and the fans on, smoke from a fire would be pouring out of the louvers.

If the louvers were closed, a fire would not have sufficient air to burn hot enough to be a factor in the initiating event that led to the implosion of WTC 7.

NIST knew these facts.
So they had to mention them
NIST detailed the location and progression of the fires.

They did NOT mention the the fact that if the louvers were closed, a fire would not have sufficient air to burn hot enough to be a factor in the initiating event that led to the implosion of WTC 7.
C7 said:
Do you dispute any of these facts?
If so, which one and why?
Thank you.


Subject shift.
I dispute your whole position. There is more evidence of diesel fuel fire in the building than there is of explosives so if they should not look at or mention diesel fuel then they should not mention or look at explosives.
 
The fires absolutely were fuel-fed. 40,000 gallons of it that had been in an UNDAMAGED underground tank was gone when that tank was pumped out. The clay around the tank was not saturated with fuel, hence the only thing that could have happened to it is that the battery-backed up pumps ran to attempt to fill a Day Tank system that was clearly just spilling it on the floor. There is no third option.

Since the fuel could not leave the tank without the pumps, it HAD to have been spilled somewhere after the pumps.
 
Last edited:
The fires absolutely were fuel-fed. 40,000 gallons of it that had been in an UNDAMAGED underground tank was gone when that tank was pumped out. The clay around the tank was not saturated with fuel, hence the only thing that could have happened to it is that the battery-backed up pumps ran to attempt to fill a Day Tank system that was clearly just spilling it on the floor. There is no third option.

Since the fuel could not leave the tank without the pumps, it HAD to have been spilled somewhere after the pumps.
FEMA 5-14
The SSB system had two 6,000 gal. tanks.
[The Silverstein system had two 12,000 gal. tanks: OEM one 6,000 gal tank]

Falling debris may have severed pipes in the SW corner of WTC 7, where the SSB, OEM and Silverstein generator rooms were.

There is no reason to think the double wall supply pipe severed completely at the other end of the building while remaining intact where the damage was.
 
Excellent point.
They did not investigate the possibility of diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room, they just included it in the summary saying:
"The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5."

This is misleading.

The debris impact to the south face indicates the possibility of fires to the SW part of WTC 7,
NOT THE NORTH EAST GENERATOR ROOM!

The next statement starts with:
"The initiating event may have included a number of structural components"

This is misleading.


So you don't know who 'signed off' on Apx. L.
'Putting their names to the report' by contributing is NOT endorsing the report.


MY bad.
The possible diesel fuel fires near the SW corner could be mentioned somewhere in the report but not in the summary as a possible contributing factor in the collapse.

They correctly mentioned the fires and damage that was reported.
There was NO fire reported in or near the NE generator room, NO reason to think there was a fire there and NO reason to imply that there was a fire there in the summary.


NIST detailed the location and progression of the fires.

They did NOT mention the the fact that if the louvers were closed, a fire would not have sufficient air to burn hot enough to be a factor in the initiating event that led to the implosion of WTC 7.

Thank you.


Subject shift.

Reported for quote mining my post, sad that you cannot even quote the whole post and reply, as usual with truthers it is cherry picked. Conveniently leaving out the explosives again C7? Why is that?

If someone who was involved in the NIST investigation was not happy with the report they can remove their name from it. I dont see anyone who has, so why is this? If your name goes against the report you are saying you are happy with its conclusions and everything contained in it.

A statement about the diesel cannot be misleading if it does not state categorically but says there was a possibility, again you are reading with bias. And why does the next statement make it misleading?

You make great assumnptions make bold claims yet castigate NIST or any other poster here for the same

You are a hypocrite and are not even man enough to confront the lack of evidence you have for your theory while dancing around the NIST and FEMA report

C7 said:
Falling debris may have severed pipes in the SW corner of WTC 7, where the SSB, OEM and Silverstein generator rooms were

Why can you make assumptions like this C7 surely you can see this is misleading by your own standards?

WTC7 was the thing that brought me to 911 truth because some truthers on a music board were getting the smack down with there wild claims and falsehoods about planes, thermite, hijacker being alive etc etc, you know the usual crap bunk. They then showed me the WTC7 video with no sound and no penthouse collapse and I was taken aback and had to go look for myself and research. Well guess what, I went to trutrher boards and debunker boards and then came here. Outcome - this was just as much bunk as the rest.

You have nothing and never will, what a waste of an obviously reasonable intelligence C7.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom