10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's what i thought at first after reading that.

This is another very misleading statement.

Fire codes would never allow such a design.

On pg 3 of that same report is this:
The 5th floor base system generator room appears to have been constructed of 8 inch thick concrete block. The other generator room enclosures were constructed using gypsum board.

It's easy to miss because it's buried in a paragraph about sprinklers.

The intake fans were in the north end of the east wall.
The exhaust louvers were on the north wall.


There are other indications that my understanding of the 5th floor generator layout could be right. The FEMA report contains the following quote on page 5-29 regarding the possible consequences of fuel leak on floor 5:
Depending on ventilation sources for air, this is sufficient to flashover the space along the north wall on this floor.
............
The hot gases generated would be blocked from impacting Trusses 1 and 2 by the masonry wall separating the generation area from the mechanical equipment room, assuming that this wall was still intact after the collapse of the tower and there were no other significant penetration of walls.
My bolding

The second paragraph on page 5-30 could also indicate a continues generator room on floor 5 along the north and the west wall.

On page 5-14 and 5-15 about the fuel pipe for the SSB generators:
The pipe traversed most of the length of the 5th floor immediately north of a concrete masonry wall running most of the length of the floor in an east-west direction


It looks as an established fact that all the generators on the 5th floor were contained behind a concrete masonry wall separating them from the rest of the floor. The SSB generator system was added in 1990 before the other modifications to the original base system. That masonry wall could very well be a original part of the building. If I remember correctly, WTC 7 was built to be easily modified according to the needs of future tenants. Therefore it would be plausible that additional generator space was originally allocated on floor 5, to accommodate future generators in addition to the two original base system generators on that floor. It is also likely that the SSB system used up all the available generator space allocated for future needs on floor 5. As a consequence of this the later generators added to the base system had to be located in areas not originally intended for generators elsewhere in the building, these rooms were constructed using gypsum boards as stated by NIST. Therefore I can not see anything misleading in the NIST statement you quoted Christopher7.

As I have said earlier there are a lot of unknowns here. We do not have all the information available to NIST. We are both making a lot assumptions based on limited information from an ongoing investigation. Based on the available information we can not rule out the possibility of a diesel fire on floor 5 playing a significant role in the initiating event.
 
FEMA 5-30
Evaluation of fires on the 3rd to 6th floors is complicated by the fact that these floors were windowless with louvers, generally in a plenum space separating any direct line of sight between the open floor space and the louvers

According to the FEMA report (page 5-22) there were air plenums on floor 5 and 6 along the east and west walls and partially along the north wall.

To get an indication of how wide that plenum space were we can take a look at the figure below from NIST:


The figure shows the openings in the slab of floor 6 to make space for the two-story mechanical spaces including plenum space. In the opening for the east mechanical room there is a dashed line possible indicating a wall.

My understanding of the quote you made from the FEMA report, Christopher7, is that behind the louvers there were a new wall separating the air plenum space from the floor space behind. That wall would contain openings for things like ventilation systems, cooling fans and exhaust. The louvers keep snow and rain away from the openings, while they at the same time hides all the openings in an architectural aesthetic manner.

Therefore I can very well understand the statements by FEMA and NIST saying that it is difficult to evaluate the presence of fire on floor 5 and 6.

During the afternoon the fires on the south side of WTC 7 had made their way to some of the floors on the north side. An interesting photo is Figure L-24b in the NIST report, that shows fires on floor 7 and 12 on the north face of WTC 7. Notice that even though fires are clearly visible on floor 7 very little smoke is coming out of the windows. A possible fire on floor 5 would in addition be hidden behind the louvers and the next wall behind the louvers. Wether or not smoke would come out on the north side on floor 5, depends on the nature of the openings in the wall behind the louvers, and in which direction the smoke would ventilate. I can envision scenarios where fresh air is sucked in by the fire through openings on the north side and the smoke goes out on the south side.

But yet again we have very limited information about the layout of floor 5 and 6 and the systems present on those floors.
 
Christopher7, as I have pointed out in my last posts we are making a lot of assumptions based on limited information about the detailed layout and construction of rooms and systems on floor 5 and 6 in the WTC 7. In addition to this you are continuously accusing NIST of being misleading or dishonest based on those assumptions. Actually this is symptomatic for the whole thread.

Neither the FEMA report or the various reports issued by NIST so far regarding WTC 7 can be viewed as the final word on the collapse of WTC 7. FEMA stated clearly that further studies were needed to understand the collapse of WTC 7. The NIST reports must be regarded as progress reports outlining the status of the research and the working hypothesis. This is what NIST said about the content of the final report in december last year:

Dr. Sunder noted that the end product of the WTC 7 investigation will be three reports. One will be a companion to the original summary report for the towers (NCSTAR 1). It will be written in a narrative format so that it is accessible to a large audience. The second will be a detailed technical report, written by NIST staff, along the lines of the previous technical reports, with all of the details and assumptions used in the analysis. The report will cover all aspects of the investigation of WTC 7. Appendices will include the seismic analysis and the review of the Consolidated Edison Substation, preliminary structural response analysis, and the hypothetical blast scenarios. The third report will be written by ARA on the modeling work they and their subcontractors have performed in support of the investigation.

We have to expect that even the reports regarding WTC 7 issued as final reports together with the WTC 1 and WTC 2 reports could be issued in revised form. And instead of an interim report of 56 pages we can expect thousands of pages of detailed information. I am therefore certain that we eventually can continue this discussion based upon far better information, in a new thread, if you still are unhappy with the conclusions in the final report Christopher7. And based upon your views in this thread and the information provided so far by NIST I am very certain that you will be unhappy.

Why you are unhappy with NIST's continued investigation of the role of diesel fuel is beyond me. Especially when NIST have felt it necessary to include hypothetical blast scenarios and thermite as a part of the study. While the diesel fuel scenario is plausible, the CD scenarios are completely unlikely lacking both logic and evidence. But certainly included in a vain attempt by NIST to make a final rebuttal of all the CD myths floating around regarding the collapse of the WTC buildings. Hopefully the hypothetical blast scenarios could be helpful in designing more blast proof buildings.

We could continue this thread endlessly discussing various fire scenarios on floor 5 based upon assumptions made on incomplete and limited information from preliminary reports. But at this stage diesel fuel can not be ruled out or in as a significant factor in the initiating event. And regardless of that, the role of diesel fuel in sustaining and spreading the fires should be a part of the study with the aim of designing more fire safe fuel systems. Thats a fact wether you agree or not Christopher7.

With this I am going to leave this thread permanently, while I notice that I can make claim to the dubious honor of advancing this thread to page 100.:o And I am going to restrain myself from the dubious temptation of making post number 4000.:D
 
There are other indications that my understanding of the 5th floor generator layout could be right. The FEMA report contains the following quote on page 5-29 regarding the possible consequences of fuel leak on floor 5:
On page 5-14 and 5-15 about the fuel pipe for the SSB generators:
The second paragraph on page 5-30 could also indicate a continues generator room on floor 5 along the north and the west wall.
First of all, i appreciate your debating this issue using data and giving your take on that data in a straightforward respectful manner.

5-29
"Depending on ventilation sources for air, this is sufficient to flashover the space along the north wall of this floor."

"... the masonry wall separating the generation area from the mechanical equipment room, .... "
These statements suggest an open 'generator area'.

5-14
"...... concrete masonry wall running most of the length of the floor in an east-west direction"
This one, not so much.

5-30
"such a fire would have more severely exposed Truss 3."
This 'indicates' there may have been an open area between the SW corner and Truss 3.


This statement clearly says there were generator rooms as would be expected.

The 5th floor base system generator room appears to have been constructed of 8 inch thick concrete block. The other generator room enclosures were constructed using gypsum board.

It looks as an established fact that all the generators on the 5th floor were contained behind a concrete masonry wall separating them from the rest of the floor.
No
Only the NE generator room.
The wall, ran most of the length, east to west.
Since it went all the way to the east end to separate the east mechanical room from the NE generator room, it did not go all the way to the west end.
The wall probably stopped at the end of the core.
There is no mention of a masonry wall running south to north in the west end.

As a consequence of this the later generators added to the base system had to be located in areas not originally intended for generators elsewhere in the building, these rooms were constructed using gypsum boards as stated by NIST. Therefore I can not see anything misleading in the NIST statement you quoted Christopher7.
You previously said:
"There are other indications that my understanding of the 5th floor generator layout could be right."

Based on NIST Chapter 12 and supported by the FEMA report, you thought the generators were not in rooms but in an open area and the fans blew the smoke from the NE generator room out thru the louvers at the SW corner.

As you now seem to realize, such is not the case.

You were mislead into thinking the generators were not in enclosed rooms and that explained the lack of smoke from the exhaust louvers on the north side of the NE generator room.

As I have said earlier there are a lot of unknowns here. We do not have all the information available to NIST. We are both making a lot assumptions based on limited information from an ongoing investigation.
Speak for yourself.

Based on the available information we can not rule out the possibility of a diesel fire on floor 5 playing a significant role in the initiating event.
On the contrary, the information in the FEMA and NIST reports is sufficient to conclude, beyond a reasonable doubt, that diesel fuel fires did NOT play a significant role in the initiating event.
 
Last edited:
I do have question that probably was answered but i am to lazy to search/read about right now....

Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
That just doesnt quite add up to me and would a truthers best argument in my eyes.
 
I do have question that probably was answered but i am to lazy to search/read about right now....

Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
That just doesnt quite add up to me and would a truthers best argument in my eyes.
Lazy will not hack it.

Fire destroys steel, it fails. Learn about steel and fire.
 
I do have question that probably was answered but i am to lazy to search/read about right now....

Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
That just doesnt quite add up to me and would a truthers best argument in my eyes.

Because one or more of three columns (79,80.81) under the penthouse mechanical room failed first pulling the penthouse in as well as the heavy equipment located in the penthouse. The senario is that this(these) columns failed somewhere lower down in the building, the 12th floor being a prime level for this to have occured. There is also an outside possibility that it failed at th 5th floor due to heating by a diesel fuel fire, which is the subject of this debate at the moment. Chris7 argues that it is not a possibility, others argue that, with the info available, one cannot completely dismiss it out of hand.

I do not understand just how the fact that the penthouse went first could be a truther's best arguement. Perhaps you'd like to expand on that just a bit.
 
Lazy will not hack it.

Fire destroys steel, it fails. Learn about steel and fire.

I have removed your insult. Please remember remain both civil and polite, and remember to attack argument not other members
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: brodski

I guess the LC forums werent the only place for stupid people, they are everywhere and in abundance!
I have researched fire melting steel and know the whole scenario on 9/11. I asked about why the Penthouse went first not how steel was melted that day. I figured you guys would have a reasonable explanation for my question and didnt want to have to read through 51 pages of crap post from people like you to find one intellectual among the group who made a post with the answer to my question in it!
Its funny you say learn about steel and fire for i am an NYC Ironworker and thats what i deal with all day everyday. To bad thats not what i was asking.

To jaydeehess
Thank you for answering my post and understanding that reading through all of this topic wasnt going to be done at 6 in the morning while a little drunk...lolz
To respond to you all i have until i can find the topics it was discussed in is that i have heard truthers make some good points about why the penthouse falling first was some sort of evidence for a CD. I cant exactly post it because i wouldnt want to screw up the details of there argument until i know exactly what they were stating, but i will say that there explanantion has holes and the one you posted above is much more plausible!
Thank You
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have removed your insult. Please remember remain both civil and polite, and remember to attack argument not other members
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: brodski

I guess the LC forums werent the only place for stupid people, ...
Was I suppose to say, lazy does hack it, and do not learn about steel and fire.

I think I will stick to the "lazy does not hack it", and learn about things. I use it everyday with my grandkids and they, in turn, use it with me. But as you see some people have the answer ready to go; I have to look them up.

This thread could go on for a long time. People in the truth movement ignore physical reality and make up stories about 9/11. If you do not understand how fire does make steel fail, you should research it. jaydeehess did a great job answering your question and summarizing the thread. Saving you and I over 700 posts of reading.
 
No you were supposed to not respond if you had no clue as to what i was asking or could not answer it yourself. Again i will state that i wasnt asking about how fire affects steel!!!

Why do you keep making that the point of your argument with me?

Clearly i asked why was it the penthouse fell first in the collapse sequence of WTC7.
It is hard to not personally insult those who are making blatant attacks on me just to try and push me over the forum edge.

Lazy? Not the case, i just see no point in reinventing the wheel when i know the answer is more then willing to be spewed out by any decent forum member at any given moment!
Again read what i posted, and understand what my original question was....

Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?

And your answer was....
Research what fire does to steel.
Great POST and topic to research now how does that answer "Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?"

Now i realize it might not have worded correct due to how late it was when i posted it, but im pretty sure any intelligent member of the forum was able to decipher my hieroglyphics. If needed by anyone else i will correct it now....

It should read "Why was it the pent house that collapsed DID SO a few seconds before the rest of the building?"

Again your answer to me was research what fire does to steel. Thank for your help and await for the next time your help will be required.
 
No you were supposed to not respond if you had no clue as to what i was asking or could not answer it yourself. Again i will state that i wasnt asking about how fire affects steel!!!

Why do you keep making that the point of your argument with me?

Clearly i asked why was it the penthouse fell first in the collapse sequence of WTC7.
It is hard to not personally insult those who are making blatant attacks on me just to try and push me over the forum edge.

Lazy? Not the case, i just see no point in reinventing the wheel when i know the answer is more then willing to be spewed out by any decent forum member at any given moment!
Again read what i posted, and understand what my original question was....

Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?
Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?

And your answer was....
Research what fire does to steel.
Great POST and topic to research now how does that answer "Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?"

Now i realize it might not have worded correct due to how late it was when i posted it, but im pretty sure any intelligent member of the forum was able to decipher my hieroglyphics. If needed by anyone else i will correct it now....

It should read "Why was it the pent house that collapsed DID SO a few seconds before the rest of the building?"

Again your answer to me was research what fire does to steel. Thank for your help and await for the next time your help will be required.
Glad to give you great advice. Have fun studying. Thanks for the veiled "calling me stupid" again.

jaydeehess answer was good!
 
My understanding of the quote you made from the FEMA report, Christopher7, is that behind the louvers there were a new wall separating the air plenum space from the floor space behind. That wall would contain openings for things like ventilation systems, cooling fans and exhaust. The louvers keep snow and rain away from the openings, while they at the same time hides all the openings in an architectural aesthetic manner.

Therefore I can very well understand the statements by FEMA and NIST saying that it is difficult to evaluate the presence of fire on floor 5 and 6.
Diesel fuel fires create a lot of heavy black smoke.

The expanding gases from a large diesel fuel fire would expel large amounts of smoke out thru the ventilation louvers.

But yet again we have very limited information about the layout of floor 5 and 6 and the systems present on those floors.
On the contrary.

From the FEMA and NIST reports:

We have the information on where the tanks, pumps, pipes and generator rooms were.

All the tanks, pumps, risers were in the west half of WTC 7.

The fans come on and the louvers open when the generators come on.

The fans force 320,000 cfm of air into and thru the NE generator room.

The hypothesis requires the fans to be on.
"Given open louvers and other sources for entry of air, it is, therefore, probable that a fuel oil spill fire would have found sufficient air for combustion."

There was no smoke coming from the air exhaust louvers in the NE Generator room at any time.

Based on this information it is clear that:

If there was a fire in the NE generator room, the louvers were closed and it would not have sufficient air for sustained high temperature combustion.
 
C7, do you concur that most of the diesel fuel must have burned regardless of the location of the fire? It dissappeared so it must have burned?
 
C7, do you concur that most of the diesel fuel must have burned regardless of the location of the fire? It dissappeared so it must have burned?
That would be a reasonable assumption.

Given the damage to the SW corner, it is reasonable to assume that it burned there.

There in no indication that any of it burned in the NE part of WTC 7.
 
Deleted - my post was in error.
 
Last edited:
Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?

This has been discussed in a lot of detail here, and probably will be again. It's covered in the interim NIST report on WTC7. The clear implication of the prior collapse of the penthouse is that core columns 79, 80 and/or 81 failed in advance of the remainder of the structure and were unable to support the weight of the penthouse. The penthouse therefore fell into the building, doing damage to the remaining structure as it did so, and this damage together with the existing debris and fire damage resulted in the collapse of the remainder of the building. The details of why these specific columns failed are as yet uncertain, and speculation about the cause of this collapse in advance of NIST's presentation of the evidence is the subject of this thread at the moment.

One of the commonly articulated arguments of the truth movement is that WTC7 collapsed perfectly symmetrically, and that this could not possibly have occurred unless all the support columns failed simultaneously. This is taken to imply that the columns were severed by explosive charges. The collapse of the penthouse, however, is undeniable physical evidence that three of the core columns failed about 6 seconds before the remainder of the structure. The observable characteristics of the collapse of WTC7 therefore conclusively disprove the assertion that the collapse required simultaneous failure of the columns; in fact, the collapse observed absolutely requires a sequence of column failures separated by several seconds. The prior collapse of the penthouse is therefore a clear refutation of one of the major pro-CD arguments.

Dave
 
That would be a reasonable assumption.

Given the damage to the SW corner, it is reasonable to assume that it burned there.

There in no indication that any of it burned in the NE part of WTC 7.

Is it correct then that if this diesel burned, regardless of where it burned, then it should have been or should be mentioned somewhere in the NIST report?

Why are you allowed to "assume" but people that are against your position are not?
 
On the contrary, the information in the FEMA and NIST reports is sufficient to conclude, beyond a reasonable doubt, that diesel fuel fires did NOT play a significant role in the initiating event.

What ? That old canard, again ? I thought we had been through this!!

I guess it serves to show that some people, yourself included, are incapable od changing their minds based on evidence.
 
Again read what i posted, and understand what my original question was....

Why was it the pent house that collapsed a few seconds before the rest of the building?

A possible explanation is that whatever caused the collapsed occured right below the penthouse and pulled it down, and the rest of the building with it.

Now, wasn't that easy ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom