10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
NIST listed the obvious areas that had been damaged and the obvious fire locations. That is all they did in the preliminary report.
NIST did a through investigation of the fire locations and progression.

They interviewed over 100 witnesses and studied all the photos and videos.

From 11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.:
• No diesel smells reported from the exterior, stairwells, or lobby areas
• No signs of fire or smoke were reported below the 6th Floor from the exterior, stairwells or lobby areas

After that there was no one in the building.

You use the word 'obvious' as if there is some faint hope NIST will somehow find out about more fires six years after the event.
From who?

C7 said:
A through investigation of where the fires were has been done and published.
Really? You know where I can find a detailed description of fuel loads, fire progression, fire temps etc? It isn't in the FEMA report or NIST WTC appendix L.
You can find a detailed description of the location and progression of the fires on pages L-22 thru L-26.
FEMA listed the location and fuel loads of the diesel tanks on page 5-14.

Other fuel loads and potential temperatures will be discussed in the final report.

C7 said:
A through investigation of where the diesel fuel tanks, pipes and generators were, has been done and published.

Based on those published reports it can be said, beyond a reasonable doubt, that there were no diesel fuel fires in or near the area where the implosion began.
Which may well be used in the final report.
Indeed

C7 said:
NIST did go into it.
They researched the debris damage and fires.
They found that there was NO debris damage or fires in or near the NE generator room.
i.e. they found nothing to support the diesel fuel fire hypothesis.

So what's left to investigate on this hypothesis, ..... nothing.
yeah, and everything that can be invented has been.
It is quite obvious that there is much more to be investigated. Too bad you can't see that.
The possibility of diesel fuel fires in the area where the implosion began has been throughly investigated.
To bad you can't see that.
Again, what's left to investigate concerning diesel fuel fires in that area?
 
It is not known where the diesel fuel went but there's a high probability that there was a diesel fuel fire in the SW corner where the debris damage was.

Thank you, and do you not believe that NIST would be interested in the details of how such a fire would have developed, progressed and affected the building during the day.

Please note that I am NOT saying that such a diesel fire would have been THE cause of the collapse nor that it has a high probability of having greatly affected the area of columns 79,80,81 on that floor. It certainly could have some affect in increasing the lateral forces on the floor slab as a whole.

You say that the mention of the diesel is item #2 of the prelim report summary makes it prominent. Have you noticed that the items in the summary are basically in chronilogical order; debris damage, fire, collapse initiating event, interior vertical collapse, interior horizontal collapse, perimeter and global collapse?

Now if the diesel is included in this list it belongs only in the section dealing with the fires which would make it a part of the second item. No nefarious deliberate act choosing to put it in the second item. So does it belong at all in the summary. I say yes. The diesel fuel represents an extrodinary possible fuel load so it deserves to be there. If/when it is addressed in the final eport I expect taht they will quote the FEMA work and possibly add some investigation of their own and conclude that there is a low probability that a diesel fuel fire initiated collapse by weakening the columns proximate to the generator.

They may find that fuel piping systems in high rise buildings should be built more robust and with more failsafe shut offs if they conclude that there were diesel fuel fires anywhere in wTC 7.
 
FEMA listed the location and fuel loads of the diesel tanks on page 5-14.
Again with conflating the two reports by two separate agencies.

Other fuel loads and potential temperatures will be discussed in the final report
.

Yes, they will and I expect a report with similar detail as in the report on the fires in the towers. That is not what we find in the preliminary report.


The possibility of diesel fuel fires in the area where the implosion began has been throughly investigated.
To bad you can't see that.
Again, what's left to investigate concerning diesel fuel fires in that area?

It was investigated by FEMA. NIST has to create its final report and they will have to address the liquid fuel as well. They were unwilling to simply write if off and include a statement that the investigators at FEMA do so and that's all there is to say about it.

Christ Chris, you guys complain bitterly that explosives were not included but now you complain that the diesel fuel was. Biased much?
 
C7 said:
It is not known where the diesel fuel went but there's a high probability that there was a diesel fuel fire in the SW corner where the debris damage was.
Thank you, and do you not believe that NIST would be interested in the details of how such a fire would have developed, progressed and affected the building during the day.
NIST would be so interested but that's not what we are talking about.
NIST mentioned the diesel fuel fires as a possible contributing factor in the initiating event.

Please note that I am NOT saying that such a diesel fire would have been THE cause of the collapse nor that it has a high probability of having greatly affected the area of columns 79,80,81 on that floor. It certainly could have some affect in increasing the lateral forces on the floor slab as a whole.
Source?

"The floor slab"?
There were 46 floor slabs.

You say that the mention of the diesel is item #2 of the prelim report summary makes it prominent. Have you noticed that the items in the summary are basically in chronilogical order; debris damage, fire, collapse initiating event, interior vertical collapse, interior horizontal collapse, perimeter and global collapse?
You can argue the definition of prominent if you like but the fact remains, it is just a hypothesis without basis or evidence to support it.
Diesel fuel fires should not have been included in the summary as a possible contributing factor in the initiating event.

F-28
The following is, therefore, a hypothesis based on potential rather than demonstrated fact.
Assume that the distribution piping system was severed and discharged up to 75 gpm onto
the 5th floor in the vicinity of Truss 1."

F-29

Although there is no physical evidence available, this hypothesis assumes that it is possible that both the inner and outer pipes were severed


 
Last edited:
JDH said:
Christ Chris, you guys complain bitterly that explosives were not included but now you complain that the diesel fuel was. Biased much?

Just about sums this whole thing up, its quite pathetic to watch actually especially when C7 then states this

C7 said:
You can argue the definition of prominent if you like but the fact remains, it is just a hypothesis without basis or evidence to support it.

I am stunned
 
NIST would be so interested but that's not what we are talking about.
We were speaking about whether or not it should be included in the report.

"The floor slab"?
There were 46 floor slabs.

The floor where this fire might occur. That much was pretty obvious wasn't it?

You can argue the definition of prominent if you like but the fact remains, it is just a hypothesis without basis or evidence to support it.
Diesel fuel fires should not have been included in the summary as a possible contributing factor in the initiating event.

You were the one to state it was "prominent". I take exception to the inference that NIS was deliberaly attempting to sway people into believeing that diesel fuel fires caused the collapse. If you wish to drop the "prominent" bit, I'm all for it.

F-28
The following is, therefore, a hypothesis based on potential rather than demonstrated fact.
Assume that the distribution piping system was severed and discharged up to 75 gpm onto
the 5th floor in the vicinity of Truss 1."

F-29

Although there is no physical evidence available, this hypothesis assumes that it is possible that both the inner and outer pipes were severed



On what page of appendix L do these appear?

It amazes me how you can claim bad intent on the part of NIST by quoting FEMA. especialy given that I believe that I can safely assume you hold no more love of FEMA than you do for NIST.
 
It amazes me how you can claim bad intent on the part of NIST by quoting FEMA. especialy given that I believe that I can safely assume you hold no more love of FEMA than you do for NIST.
FEMA established the facts about the location of the diesel fuel tanks, and pipes.
They concluded that there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

You think that it's OK for NIST quote some facts in the FEMA report while ignoring other facts and the conclusion.

Any scientific investigation builds on the established body of knowledge.

NIST also ignored the evidence it had established about the location of the fires by saying:
"Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows."

This is ridiculous because there would either be smoke pouring out of the louvers or a fire would not have sufficient airflow to burn hot enough to be a factor in the collapse.

FEMA 5-29
Although there is no physical evidence available, this hypothesis assumes that it is possible that both the inner and outer pipes were severed

The air required for combustion of 75-gpm (160 MW potential) diesel fuel is approximately 100,000 cubic feet per minute (cfm).
If less air is available for combustion, the burning rate will decrease proportionally
. As the engine generator sets come on line, automatic louvers open and 80,000 cfm are provided for each of the nine SSB engines.
Given open louvers and other sources for entry of air
*, it is, therefore, probable that
a fuel oil spill
fire would have found sufficient air for combustion.


*The generator room would have to be relatively air tight because of the potential for fire.
Otherwise, when the fans came on they would create elevated air pressure and blow fumes from the engines or a potential fire into adjoining rooms.
 
NIST also ignored the evidence it had established about the location of the fires by saying:
"Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows."

This is ridiculous because there would either be smoke pouring out of the louvers or a fire would not have sufficient airflow to burn hot enough to be a factor in the collapse.

.

Chris are you sure that the louvers could be the only source of oxygen for the fires? If the doors to the mechanical room were open would there not be a floor-full (or more) of oxygen for the fires to use?
 
Chris are you sure that the louvers could be the only source of oxygen for the fires? If the doors to the mechanical room were open would there not be a floor-full (or more) of oxygen for the fires to use?
Due to the presence of diesel fuel and the inherent possibility of fire, the doors to the generator room would be kept shut.
This would be especially necessary when the generators were running because the fans would be blowing 320,000 cubic feet per minute (cfm) of air into the generator room.

There is no reason to think the doors were open.
 
Due to the presence of diesel fuel and the inherent possibility of fire, the doors to the generator room would be kept shut.
This would be especially necessary when the generators were running because the fans would be blowing 320,000 cubic feet per minute (cfm) of air into the generator room.

There is no reason to think the doors were open.

Chris you have no idea whether the doors were open or shut. You can claim that it may be possible that they were supposed to be shut but you cannot say that they were so please stop stating assumptions as facts.
 
FEMA established the facts about the location of the diesel fuel tanks, and pipes.
They concluded that there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

You think that it's OK for NIST quote some facts in the FEMA report while ignoring other facts and the conclusion.

Just what did NIST quote FEMA as having investigated in the WTC appendix L report? I am not concerned with simple building specs or photographs. I am asking what NIST used in the way of conclusions that FEMA had already made.

You see Chris if an agency is to do a report then the people who commissioned that report expect that the agency will actually do their own report or if the do borrow the conclusions of another agency , that they show that they have actually investigated that agency's work and come to the same conclusion. That is what they paid to do.


Any scientific investigation builds on the established body of knowledge.

Yes, but in the case of something as unigue as the collapse of a building each investigation will first have to satisfy itself that the previous work is valid and determine if they would add or modify the other group's conclusions based on the same or additional evidence. THAT would not be done in a preliminary report. THAT would be the scope of a more in depth, final report.

NIST also ignored the evidence it had established about the location of the fires by saying:
"Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows."

What part of that ignores the evidence Chris? It simply states that there is a possibility that there were fires that could not be seen from the outside and which had not been observed when the FF's went through early on in the day.


This is ridiculous because there would either be smoke pouring out of the louvers or a fire would not have sufficient airflow to burn hot enough to be a factor in the collapse.

The air required for combustion of 75-gpm (160 MW potential) diesel fuel is approximately 100,000 cubic feet per minute (cfm).

If less air is available for combustion, the burning rate will decrease proportionally

As the engine generator sets come on line, automatic louvers open and 80,000 cfm are provided for each of the nine SSB engines.

Given open louvers and other sources for entry of air, it is, therefore, probable that a fuel oil spill fire would have found sufficient air for combustion.

This is something that the investigators at NIST would have to look at. Do they agree 100% with the FEMA investigators or would they, for instance, change "Given open louvers and" to "Given open louvers or?


*The generator room would have to be relatively air tight because of the potential for fire.
Otherwise, when the fans came on they would create elevated air pressure and blow fumes from the engines or a potential fire into adjoining rooms.


So they would blow fumes into adjoining rooms if the door was open but smoke would have to exit via the louvers and the generator has to be running. Hmmm.

The door would normally be shut. Quite correct. But this building had just been hot by a large amount of debris, it had been shaken by the seismic activity of two 110 storey buildings collapsing next door so it is quite possible that the normally closed door was sprung open, it is also somewhat possible that the door was left open. In your world the fact that these are only possibilities and less probable than the door being shut means that it simply and certainly did not happen.

Could air enter via the louvers and smoke go out the door?

Does the generator have to be running when the (alleged) pool of fuel is on fire? Could it have been running early on but stopped before the fuel ignited?
 
Chris you have no idea whether the doors were open or shut. You can claim that it may be possible that they were supposed to be shut but you cannot say that they were so please stop stating assumptions as facts.
A room with diesel engines would have fire doors and they would be kept closed.

That's a no brainer, not an assumption.

For the sake of argument, let's assume that they were open.

FEMA 5-30
Evaluation of fires on the 3rd to 6th floors is complicated by the fact that these floors were windowless with louvers, generally in a plenum space separating any direct line of sight between the open floor space and the louvers

A fire would have the air in the 2 story mechanical room.

Smoke would be pouring out the ventilation louvers in the mechanical room.

The hypothesis assumes the louvers in the generator room were open and the fans were on because it would take a great deal of air flow to sustain a fire hot enough to cause the failure of Truss 1 which was in the mechanical room.

Given open louvers and other sources for entry of air, it is, therefore, probable that a fuel oil spill fire would have found sufficient air for combustion.
 
I can not see that this testimony by Shyam Sunder from NIST has been brought up so far in the discussion regarding the fuel system in WTC 7. The testimony was given before New York City Council Joint Meeting, Committees on Lower Manhattan Redevelopment; Fire & Criminal Justice Services on september 8th 2006.

The testimony contains as appendix 1 NCSTAR 1-1, Chapter 12, “WTC 7 Fuel System” where NIST elaborates on the fuel system and the possible role it could have played in initiating the collapse of WTC 7.

This what NIST says about the layout of the SSB emergency generator system:
The system also included cooling fan units (each consisting of four fans) with three units (rated
30,000 cfm per fan, 12 fans) installed in the northeast corner of the 5th floor near generators 1 through 4,
six units (rated 38,000 cfm per fan, 24 fans) in the northwest corner near generators 8 and 9, and exhaust
louvers in the southwest corner near generators 5 through 7. The fans were powered from the generators
and ran whenever the generators were running. They brought outside air into the building and across the
generators.

My understanding, after reading what both NIST and FEMA writes about the system, is that the SSB generators on floor 5 where located within the same room on that floor. The room was compartmentalized from the rest of floor 5 by a masonry concrete wall running east - west on the north side of the floor. The cooling fan units would generate a flow of air that would go from the northeast corner and the northwest corner towards the southwest corner, where it would leave the building through the exhaust louvers. Consequently any smoke within the generator room on floor 5 would be blown out of the southwest corner exhaust louvers, while the fans where working.

Regarding the fuel system NIST is focusing on column 79 in Chapter 12, not Truss 1 or 2 as FEMA did:
At the end of the pipe run, where the fuel supply pipe
ended and the fuel return pipe began, there was a valve box containing a backpressure regulator, gauges,
and a by-pass line. This liquid tight valve box was mounted to the underside of the floor slab for the
6th floor near generator #1.
A working hypothesis is that the impact sustained by WTC 7 from the collapse of WTC 1 resulted in
fractures in the fuel piping system (both the fuel pipe and the containment pipe) especially at the point
where the pipes entered the valve box, which was rigidly mounted to the underside of the floor slab. With
the base system and all of the modifications thereto, such a fracture would result in a small leak of
residual fuel in the pipes at the point of the fracture. A fracture of the pipe at the valve box would release
fuel under pressure that, if ignited, could produce a spray fire and/or a pool fire very near column 79.

This could have sustained a limited fire within the generator room, heating up column 79, but not visible since smoke were blown out the southwest corner exhaust louvers on the south side of the building.

But there is a lot of unknown details here since we do not have detailed drawings of the floors, etc. That is something Christopher 7 should keep in mind when he attempts to rule out the possibility that the fuel system could have played a significant role in the collapse.
 
Last edited:
Just what did NIST quote FEMA as having investigated in the WTC appendix L report? I am not concerned with simple building specs or photographs. I am asking what NIST used in the way of conclusions that FEMA had already made.
The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5.

You see Chris if an agency is to do a report then the people who commissioned that report expect that the agency will actually do their own report or if the do borrow the conclusions of another agency , that they show that they have actually investigated that agency's work and come to the same conclusion. That is what they paid to do.
You are saying one government agency should ignore the findings of another government agency investigating the same event and re-investigate their findings.

That is not what NIST is paid to do, nor is that what they did.

FEMA researched and established the location of the tanks, pipes and generator rooms.
What's left to investigate?

C7 said:
Any scientific investigation builds on the established body of knowledge.
Yes, but in the case of something as unigue as the collapse of a building each investigation will first have to satisfy itself that the previous work is valid and determine if they would add or modify the other group's conclusions based on the same or additional evidence. THAT would not be done in a preliminary report. THAT would be the scope of a more in depth, final report.
IYO

To include the possibility of diesel fuel fires as a possible contributing factor to the initiating event in the summary without investigating that possibility, is wrong and misleading.

C7 said:
NIST also ignored the evidence it had established about the location of the fires by saying:
"Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows."
What part of that ignores the evidence Chris? It simply states that there is a possibility that there were fires that could not be seen from the outside and which had not been observed when the FF's went through early on in the day.
The 5th and 6th floors had ventilation louvers.
If there was a fire on these floors, smoke would be pouring out of the louvers.

There was no debris damage to this area and no reason to believe there was a fire in this area.

This is something that the investigators at NIST would have to look at. Do they agree 100% with the FEMA investigators or would they, for instance, change "Given open louvers and" to "Given open louvers or?
You are speculating on what NIST 'might say' if they investigated.

The facts are:
FEMA said there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room.

NIST did not re-investigate that possibility.

There was no sign of fire in or near the NE generator room.

There is no reason to think there was a fire in that area.

There was no reason to include it in the summary.

So they would blow fumes into adjoining rooms if the door was open but smoke would have to exit via the louvers and the generator has to be running. Hmmm.
The fans would blow fumes or smoke out every opening.

The door would normally be shut. Quite correct. But this building had just been hot by a large amount of debris, it had been shaken by the seismic activity of two 110 storey buildings collapsing next door so it is quite possible that the normally closed door was sprung open,
Quite possible?

Try remotely possible and extremely unlikely.

You are really grasping at straws with that one.

it is also somewhat possible that the door was left open.
You are dwelling in the infinite world of unlikely possibilities.

In your world the fact that these are only possibilities and less probable than the door being shut means that it simply and certainly did not happen.
Wrong
In the real world, there is no reason to think the door was open.

Could air enter via the louvers and smoke go out the door?
No
The louvers opened when the fans came on.
The fans forced 320,000 cfm of air into the generator room.
That would force air out thru every opening.

Does the generator have to be running when the (alleged) pool of fuel is on fire?
No
The pumps were governed by a pressure switch.
The pumps would come on if there were a break or fracture in the supply pipe and the pressure dropped.

However, the supply pipe would have to be completely severed somewhere to stop the oil in the containment pipe from reaching the containment vessel and shut off the pumps.

If the pipe was severed, there would be little or no pressure in the line.

Have you ever had a broken water pipe?
If so, how much water came out when you turned a faucet on?

There were the same pipes and connections in the SW and NW generator rooms.

For the hypothesis to work, the double wall pipe would have to break completely in the NE generator room and remain intact in the generator rooms closer to the debris damage.
 
FEMA researched and established the location of the tanks, pipes and generator rooms.
What's left to investigate?


A lot of things according to FEMA:
5.8 Recomendations
Certain issues should be explored before final conclusions are reached and additional studies of the performance of WTC 7, and related building performance issues should be conducted. These include the following:
  • Determination of the specific fuel loads, espcially at the lower levels, is important identify possible fuel suplied to sustain fire the fires for substantial duration. Areas of intrest include storage rooms, file rooms, spaces with high-density combustible matrials, and location of fuel lines. The control and operation of the emergency power system, including generators and storage tanks, needs to be throughly understood. Specifically, the ability of the disel fuel pumps to continue to operate and send fuel to upper floors after a fuel line is severed should be confirmed.
Source: FEMA WTC 7. My bolding.

FEMA said there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room.

NIST did not re-investigate that possibility.


The first claim is correct, but FEMA also said as a part of that statement in its WTC 7 report:
Further research, investigation, and analyses are needed to resolve this issue


The last claim is wrong, NIST is reinvestigating the role of the fuel system:
In summary, NIST has presented a working hypothesis for the collapse of WTC 7 and
fully documented the fuel systems present in the building on September 11, 2001.
NIST’s investigation of the collapse of WTC 7 is continuing with a focus on identifying
the factors that contributed to the collapse of the building. NIST has not reached a final
determination on the role of the diesel fuel in sustaining the fires that burned in WTC 7
and is continuing to study its role in contributing to the collapse of the building.
Source: Testimony of Dr. S. Shyam Sunder. My bolding.

It is way too early to close the book on the role of the fuel system in the initiating event.
 
A lot of things according to FEMA:
Certain issues should be explored before final conclusions are reached ....... These include the following:
  • location of fuel lines. The control and operation of the emergency power system, including generators and storage tanks, needs to be throughly understood. Specifically, the ability of the disel fuel pumps to continue to operate and send fuel to upper floors after a fuel line is severed should be confirmed.
The location of the fuel lines in the NE part of WTC 7 is known.

FEMA 5-14
The pipe traversed most of the length of the 5th floor immediately north of a concrete masonry wall running most of the length of the floor in an east-west direction. At the east end of the 5th floor and to the south of the wall was a 1- to 2-story mechanical equipment room. Transfer Trusses 1 and 2 were located in this room.


The control and operation of the emergency power system is known insofar as the NE generator room is concerned.

FEMA 5-15
The pump then operated in response to the pressure difference between the supply and return, and the pump would circulate oil as long as such a difference existed. Upon sensing a power interruption, the system would automatically switch to emergency mode.


All the storage tanks are in the west half of the building.
See the chart on FEMA 5-14

The last claim is wrong, NIST is reinvestigating the role of the fuel system:

"In summary, NIST has presented a working hypothesis for the collapse of WTC 7 and fully documented the fuel systems present in the building on September 11, 2001.
NIST’s investigation of the collapse of WTC 7 is continuing with a focus on identifying the factors that contributed to the collapse of the building. NIST has not reached a final determination on the role of the diesel fuel in sustaining the fires that burned in WTC 7 and is continuing to study its role in contributing to the collapse of the building."
Source: Testimony of Dr. S. Shyam Sunder. My bolding.
Your claim that my claim is wrong, is wrong.

Seriously, Shyam Sunder testified in Sept 2006
NCSTAR 1-1, Chapter 12 and NCSTAR1-1J were published in September 2005

NIST had not re investigated the possibility of diesel fires in June 2004 when they included it in the summary.

It is way too early to close the book on the role of the fuel system in the initiating event.
1)
FEMA 5-29
"Although there is no physical evidence available, this hypothesis assumes that it is possible that both the inner and outer pipes were severed"

The double and single wall pipes would have to remain intact in the SW corner, where the debris damage was, and a double wall pipe would have to break off completely near the opposite corner of the building.

This is extremely unlikely. To say the least.

2)
FEMA 5-29
"The temperature of the fire gases would be governed to a large extent by the availability of air for combustion."

"If less air is available for combustion, the burning rate will decrease proportionally."

"Given open louvers and other sources for entry of air, it is, therefore, probable that a fuel oil spill fire would have found sufficient air for combustion."

The hypothesis assumes the louvers in the generator room were open and the fans were on because it would take a great deal of air flow to sustain a fire hot enough to cause the failure of Truss 1

If the louvers were open, the fans would be blowing the smoke out thru them.

This did not happen.

FEMA 5-29
3) "The hot gases generated would be blocked from impacting Trusses 1 and 2 by the masonry wall separating the generation area from the mechanical equipment room"

"If the door was of superior construction (as with a fire door), it is unlikely that the fire would have reached the trusses in the mechanical equipment room until such time that the door failed."

It is also unlikely that someone left the door open.

It is time to close the book on this fairy tale.
 
I can not see that this testimony by Shyam Sunder from NIST has been brought up so far in the discussion regarding the fuel system in WTC 7. The testimony was given before New York City Council Joint Meeting, Committees on Lower Manhattan Redevelopment; Fire & Criminal Justice Services on september 8th 2006.

The testimony contains as appendix 1 NCSTAR 1-1, Chapter 12, “WTC 7 Fuel System” where NIST elaborates on the fuel system and the possible role it could have played in initiating the collapse of WTC 7.

This what NIST says about the layout of the SSB emergency generator system:
[see paragraph below photo of NE corner]
My understanding, after reading what both NIST and FEMA writes about the system, is that the SSB generators on floor 5 where located within the same room on that floor. The room was compartmentalized from the rest of floor 5 by a masonry concrete wall running east - west on the north side of the floor. The cooling fan units would generate a flow of air that would go from the northeast corner and the northwest corner towards the southwest corner, where it would leave the building through the exhaust louvers. Consequently any smoke within the generator room on floor 5 would be blown out of the southwest corner exhaust louvers, while the fans where working.
That's what i thought at first after reading that.

This is another very misleading statement.

Fire codes would never allow such a design.

On pg 3 of that same report is this:
The 5th floor base system generator room appears to have been constructed of 8 inch thick concrete block. The other generator room enclosures were constructed using gypsum board.

It's easy to miss because it's buried in a paragraph about sprinklers.

The intake fans were in the north end of the east wall.
The exhaust louvers were on the north wall.

copyofe5asn4.png


These two paragraphs are separated by two paragraphs about pumps.

The system utilized nine generators on the 5th floor with a combined capacity of 1,750 kW. Seven cooling fan sets (four fans per set) were installed to provide cooling and combustion air to the generators.
Three fan setswere installed on the north end of the east wall and four fan sets on the north end of the west wall. There were exhaust louvers on the south end of the west wall. These fans were arranged to come on when the generators were running.

The system also included cooling fan units (each consisting of four fans) with three units (rated 30,000 cfm per fan, 12 fans) installed in the northeast corner of the 5th floor near generators 1 through 4, six units (rated 38,000 cfm per fan, 24 fans) in the northwest corner near generators 8 and 9, and exhaust louvers in the southwest corner near generators 5 through 7. The fans were powered from the generators and ran whenever the generators were running. They brought outside air into the building and across the generators.

This is blatant obfuscation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom