Just what did NIST quote FEMA as having investigated in the WTC appendix L report? I am not concerned with simple building specs or photographs. I am asking what NIST used in the way of conclusions that FEMA had already made.
The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5.
You see Chris if an agency is to do a report then the people who commissioned that report expect that the agency will actually do their own report or if the do borrow the conclusions of another agency , that they show that they have actually investigated that agency's work and come to the same conclusion. That is what they paid to do.
You are saying one government agency should ignore the findings of another government agency investigating the same event and re-investigate their findings.
That is not what NIST is paid to do, nor is that what they did.
FEMA researched and established the location of the tanks, pipes and generator rooms.
What's left to investigate?
C7 said:
Any scientific investigation builds on the established body of knowledge.
Yes, but in the case of something as unigue as the collapse of a building each investigation will first have to satisfy itself that the previous work is valid and determine if they would add or modify the other group's conclusions based on the same or additional evidence. THAT would not be done in a preliminary report. THAT would be the scope of a more in depth, final report.
IYO
To include the possibility of diesel fuel fires as a possible contributing factor to the initiating event in the summary without investigating that possibility, is wrong and misleading.
C7 said:
NIST also ignored the evidence it had established about the location of the fires by saying:
"Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows."
What part of that ignores the evidence Chris? It simply states that there is a possibility that there were fires that could not be seen from the outside and which had not been observed when the FF's went through early on in the day.
The 5th and 6th floors had ventilation louvers.
If there was a fire on these floors, smoke would be pouring out of the louvers.
There was no debris damage to this area and no reason to believe there was a fire in this area.
This is something that the investigators at NIST would have to look at. Do they agree 100% with the FEMA investigators or would they, for instance, change "Given open louvers and" to "Given open louvers or?
You are speculating on what NIST 'might say' if they investigated.
The facts are:
FEMA said there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room.
NIST did not re-investigate that possibility.
There was no sign of fire in or near the NE generator room.
There is no reason to think there was a fire in that area.
There was no reason to include it in the summary.
So they would blow fumes into adjoining rooms if the door was open but smoke would have to exit via the louvers and the generator has to be running. Hmmm.
The fans would blow fumes or smoke out every opening.
The door would normally be shut. Quite correct. But this building had just been hot by a large amount of debris, it had been shaken by the seismic activity of two 110 storey buildings collapsing next door so it is quite possible that the normally closed door was sprung open,
Quite possible?
Try remotely possible and extremely unlikely.
You are really grasping at straws with that one.
it is also somewhat possible that the door was left open.
You are dwelling in the infinite world of unlikely possibilities.
In your world the fact that these are only possibilities and less probable than the door being shut means that it simply and certainly did not happen.
Wrong
In the real world, there is no reason to think the door was open.
Could air enter via the louvers and smoke go out the door?
No
The louvers opened when the fans came on.
The fans forced 320,000 cfm of air into the generator room.
That would force air out thru every opening.
Does the generator have to be running when the (alleged) pool of fuel is on fire?
No
The pumps were governed by a pressure switch.
The pumps would come on if there were a break or fracture in the supply pipe and the pressure dropped.
However, the supply pipe would have to be completely severed somewhere to stop the oil in the containment pipe from reaching the containment vessel and shut off the pumps.
If the pipe was severed, there would be little or no pressure in the line.
Have you ever had a broken water pipe?
If so, how much water came out when you turned a faucet on?
There were the same pipes and connections in the SW and NW generator rooms.
For the hypothesis to work, the double wall pipe would have to break completely in the NE generator room and remain intact in the generator rooms closer to the debris damage.