10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
FEMA did a in depth study and determined that there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.
NIST did an in depth study of the fire time line an location of the fires.

yes, one was FEMA, the other NIST. You conflating them?

There was no sign of fire in the NE generator room at any time.

Which does not completely exclude a diesel fire.

Thank you for making my point.

There is no reason to think it figured prominently.

It only does so when you truncate my sentence.

Yet, because of this erroneous entry, you and others think it did.

No, I believe that the probability of it having occured is fairly low yet I cannot dismiss it out of hand as you do.

Not if the evidence points the other way.

Beside the point. The point is that it was a possible very significant fire/heat source.

It should not have been included.
It was misleading to include possible diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event as a possible cause when there is NO evidence to support that hypothesis.

Yes it should be included because it represents an extraordinary fuel source within the building.

deritlic?

My bad
derelict:failing in what duty requires; "derelict (or delinquent) in his duty"
 
yes, one was FEMA, the other NIST. You conflating them?
You were saying the diesel fuel had to be addressed and deserved consideration.
It was addressed, researched and considered.

FEMA determined that there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event based on what they knew about the location of the tanks, pumps, generators and supply pipes.
NIST determined the location and progression of the fires and there was no fire reported in or near the NE generator room at any time.


With a low probability of occurrence, and no sign of fire in or near the NE generator room, there was no reason to believe that there were fires there and no reason to include it in the summary as a possible contributing factor in the collapse.


Which does not completely exclude a diesel fire.
There was no smoke coming from the east generator room at any time.

If there was a fire and the louvers were open, smoke would be pouring out.

If the louvers were closed, a fire would have no air supply and could not have burned hot enough to be a factor.

The same is true for the area west of the NE generator room.


That eliminates diesel fuel fire as a contributing factor in the collapse.
 
It only does so when you truncate my sentence.
My bad.
You were trying to say that diesel fuel fires did not figure "prominently".
Item 2 is prominent.
jdh said:
The diesel fuel warrented mention so all you have to go on is the fact that it figured prominently, in your opinion, in the report summary. Item 2 in the summary addresses the fires. The fires most certainly warrant being listed prominently and the possiblity of the diesel fuel being involved would HAVE TO go with the item that deals with the fires.
The fires warrant being listed prominently because they existed.
That does not mean diesel fuel fires should be mentioned when there is NO evidence of their existence.

C7 said:
Not if the evidence points the other way.
Beside the point. The point is that it was a possible very significant fire/heat source.
So you ignore the evidence and say it's "beside the point".

C7 said:
It should not have been included.
It was misleading to include possible diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event as a possible cause when there is NO evidence to support that hypothesis.
Yes it should be included because it represents an extraordinary fuel source within the building.
So what?
There was no reason to suspect diesel fuel fires in the opposite end of the building from where the damage was.
They were just searching for ways to explain how fires caused the implosion of WTC 7.
They found NO EVIDENCE to support this hypothesis.
On the contrary, the evidence points the other way.

It is clear beyond a reasonable doubt that there was NO FIRE in the NE generator room! [louvers]

copyofe5asn4.png


Suggesting that there was is misleading.

In fact, the entire statement is misleading double talk.

NIST L-51
2. Fires were observed after the collapse of WTC 1. Fires were observed after 2 pm on Floors 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, and 13. Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows. The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5.

This indicates fires may have been present in the south west generator room, not the north east generator room.
The next statement starts with:
3. The initiating event .................
 
Is this standard "chris" stuff to run a thread for thousands of post with no real point?

Major damage, no fire fighting; building falls. No RDX, no thermite, no CD. What is the point. Experienced firemen knew the building could fail; what is your point? What is the meaning of bsing for thousands of posts if you have no goal? What is your goal with your OP and posting off topic? Who cares if you are wrong about 9/11? But what is your potion and how does it relate to 9/11 and your OP?

I forgot your position on the OP. You failed to take a position in the OP. What a waste.
 
There was no smoke coming from the east generator room at any time.

If there was a fire and the louvers were open, smoke would be pouring out.
NO, no, no, no. It does not mean there was no fire, and the smoke does not have to come out the louvers! The louvers on my fire place rarely emit smoke! Sorry, you failed to make a point and even get close to relating it to the OP.
Some of your posts are research and knowledge deficient. Beside so far from the OP as to disregard reality.
The thread with no goal. Is going strong. Carry on.
 
Is this standard "chris" stuff to run a thread for thousands of post with no real point?
I have made several points using the data from the various govt. reports that people here have so graciously provided as evidence for DD/F.

The
[FONT=&quot]"middle 1/4 to 1/3 width of the south face was gouged out from floor 10 to the ground" [NIST L-18]
[/FONT]was a misinterpretation of other damage further west.

There were no diesel fuel fires in the east half of WTC 7.

The fires in the area of the initiating event were not sufficient to cause a column, weighing over 4 tons per floor, to fail.

Major damage,
To the other end of the building

no fire fighting;
Fires in the Meridian plaza and the Caracas Tower burned out of control and lasted much longer.

Experienced firemen knew the building could fail;
The only experience those firefighters had with high rise collapses was the 2 buildings that had just collapsed.
They did not consult a structural engineer as was done at the Meridian Plaza fire.

Chief Norman did not think WTC 7 would collapse.
Battalion Chief John Norman
I looked at 7 World Trade Center. There was smoke showing, but not a lot and I’m saying that isn’t going to fall.

I never expected it to fall the way it did as quickly as it did, 7.

I forgot your position on the OP. You failed to take a position in the OP.
How could you forget something you never heard because i didn't say it yet?
OP?
 
You were saying the diesel fuel had to be addressed and deserved consideration.
It was addressed, researched and considered.

FEMA determined that there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event based on what they knew about the location of the tanks, pumps, generators and supply pipes.

That was the FEMA report not the NIST report.

NIST determined the location and progression of the fires and there was no fire reported in or near the NE generator room at any time.

That was the NIST report, which did not go into an analysis of the probability of the diesel fire. That is the report in question. Why bring up what was contained in the FEMA report when we are speaking to what was in the NIST report?


With a low probability of occurrence, and no sign of fire in or near the NE generator room, there was no reason to believe that there were fires there and no reason to include it in the summary as a possible contributing factor in the collapse.

NIST did NOT state that they "believed" there was a diesel fire. They only include the possibility of one. If it is simply not listed at all in the prelim report it could not be in a final report later. It represents a large fuel load and therefore should be included.


There was no smoke coming from the east generator room at any time.

If there was a fire and the louvers were open, smoke would be pouring out.

If the louvers were closed, a fire would have no air supply and could not have burned hot enough to be a factor.

The same is true for the area west of the NE generator room.


That eliminates diesel fuel fire as a contributing factor in the collapse.

Thank you Mr. Sunder
 
Fires in the Meridian plaza and the Caracas Tower burned out of control and lasted much longer.

They did not consult a structural engineer as was done at the Meridian Plaza fire.
Meridian Plaza fire was fought, until the firemen feared failure! Then the 30 floor fire system put the fire out. The systems in the WTC did not work, and WTC7 systems also failed; they were destroyed at impact! Meridian Plaza was too weak to keep, it is totaled by fire, as was the WTC complex! Fire destroys steel structures. Fact. WTC7 was on fire all day long, it failed in due to fire and damage from the WTC complex. Facts.

The other fires you speak of were fought! End of story. WTC7 was not, nor was WTC1 and 2. Some of the WTC structures were fought and total collapse was averted.

Seems like building failure is inversely proportional to the amount of firefighting and fire systems working. But people who are unable to understand reality can not understand this.

Oh good; you have no position on your own OP; just asking questions. What a waste. No facts, no understanding, cherry picked statements, and ignoring the out of control NOT fought fires of WTC7; comparing the un-fought fires of WTC7 to the fought fires of the other buildings! And ignoring the Madrid building and Meridian buildings no longer standing because they were destroyed by fire; just like WTC complex. Destroyed by fire but too challenged to even take a position on your own OP; is this the definition of trolling?

Does this mean you have no idea what happen on 9/11 like the entire 9/11 truth movement?
 
Last edited:
My bad.
You were trying to say that diesel fuel fires did not figure "prominently".
Item 2 is prominent.

No, I was illustrating that it was included right where it should be, with the item refering to the fires and that it fit no where else in the summary.

The fires warrant being listed prominently because they existed.
That does not mean diesel fuel fires should be mentioned when there is NO evidence of their existence.

They are quite clear that it is only a possibility, whereas the other fires are stated as fact. What part of this do you have trouble comprehending?


So you ignore the evidence and say it's "beside the point".

It is beside the point in terms of a PRELIMINARY report! The possibility of a diesel fuel fire simply MUSt be included.


So what?
There was no reason to suspect diesel fuel fires in the opposite end of the building from where the damage was.
They were just searching for ways to explain how fires caused the implosion of WTC 7.They found NO EVIDENCE to support this hypothesis.

They state that it is only a possibility that diesel fuel was on fire and that diesel fuel lines were present in the area of collapse initiation. At no place do I read that disel fuel fires caused the implosion of WTC 7.


On the contrary, the evidence points the other way.

It is clear beyond a reasonable doubt that there was NO FIRE in the NE generator room! [louvers]

Actually I'd say it is extremly suggestive that there was no fire in the NE generator room, as far as the evidence listed in the preliminary report goes.

Suggesting that there was is misleading.

In fact, the entire statement is misleading double talk.

No, its just you casting about for ghosts.

NIST L-51
2. Fires were observed after the collapse of WTC 1. Fires were observed after 2 pm on Floors 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, and 13. Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows. The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5.

Nary a mention of the NE generator room in that statement Chris7.

This indicates fires may have been present in the south west generator room, not the north east generator room.

They said nothing about the NE generator room Chris. That's you going on about the NE generator room isn't it?

The next statement starts with:
3. The initiating event .................

Yes, new paragraph, new subject.
Looking for ghosts again Chris7, looking for ghosts.
 
Is this standard "chris" stuff to run a thread for thousands of post with no real point?

I can't tell.
I can state that he simply goes round and round, his paranoia causing him to read nefarious intent wording in reports, and making definitive statements based on his own interpretation of what "must be".

I forgot your position on the OP. You failed to take a position in the OP. What a waste.

Chris7, Beachnut is being sarcastic with the first sentence and making a statement with the second.
Does that help your comprehension?
 
That was the NIST report, which did not go into an analysis of the probability of the diesel fire. That is the report in question. Why bring up what was contained in the FEMA report when we are speaking to what was in the NIST report?
FEMA had already done an analysis of the probability of a diesel fuel fire in the the NE part of WTC 7 and determined there was a low probability.
There was no need for NIST to do that part again.
NIST investigated debris damage, fire locations and progression.
There were no signs of fire in or near the NE generator room at any time and there is no reason to think there were fires in that area.

NIST did NOT state that they "believed" there was a diesel fire. They only include the possibility of one.
It falls into the "any thing's possible" group.
There is nothing to support the diesel fuel fire hypothesis.

If it is simply not listed at all in the prelim report it could not be in a final report later.
If they found anything to support the diesel fuel fire in the NE generator room hypothesis, they could include it.

It represents a large fuel load and therefore should be included.
The fuel was at the other end of the building.

Pipes would have broken in the SW generator room, where the damage was, not the NE generator room.

Saying there was a low probability was an overstatement.

There is no demonstrable probability of a fuel leak or a fire in or near the NE generator room.

Including it in the summary as possibly contributing to the collapse is misleading.
 
C7 said:
There was no smoke coming from the east generator room at any time.

If there was a fire and the louvers were open, smoke would be pouring out.

If the louvers were closed, a fire would have no air supply and could not have burned hot enough to be a factor.

The same is true for the area west of the NE generator room.


That eliminates diesel fuel fire as a contributing factor in the collapse.

Thank you Mr. Sunder
You're quite welcome Mr. Bush
 
FEMA had already done an analysis of the probability of a diesel fuel fire in the the NE part of WTC 7 and determined there was a low probability.
There was no need for NIST to do that part again.
NIST investigated debris damage, fire locations and progression.

Two SEPARATE reports Chris. IF NIST decided to examine the diesel fuel possibility itself that's their perogative, or do you consider FEMA the last word on such things?
There were no signs of fire in or near the NE generator room at any time and there is no reason to think there were fires in that area.

Why just in the generator room Chris?

It falls into the "any thing's possible" group.
There is nothing to support the diesel fuel fire hypothesis.

NIST has not done any investigation into diesel fuel fire, so they include it as a possibility in THEIR prelim report.

If they found anything to support the diesel fuel fire in the NE generator room hypothesis, they could include it.

You are the one harping on about the NE enerato room Chris. Does NIST even mention it?

The fuel was at the other end of the building.

For the most part, yes.

Pipes would have broken in the SW generator room, where the damage was, not the NE generator room.

In your humble opinion, that is the only place they could have broken.

Saying there was a low probability was an overstatement.

FEMA said that. NIST didn't. NIST did not assign probability.

Including it in the summary as possibly contributing to the collapse is misleading.

In your humble opinion
 
Two SEPARATE reports Chris. IF NIST decided to examine the diesel fuel possibility itself that's their perogative, or do you consider FEMA the last word on such things?
What's to examine?
FEMA researched the location of the fuel tanks, pumps, pipes and generators. That is the last word on that.
They said there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room.

NIST did examine the evidence.
They researched the location of the debris damage and the fires.
There was no sign of fire in that area.
There is no reason to think there were fires in that area.

They found nothing to support the diesel fuel fire hypothesis.
In fact, the evidence points the other way.

NIST has not done any investigation into diesel fuel fire, so they include it as a possibility in THEIR prelim report.
They did investigate the location of the fires.
They knew about the presence of diesel fuel from the FEMA investigation.
They knew FEMA had said there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room.


You are the one harping on about the NE enerato room Chris. Does NIST even mention it?
The NE generator room and the area next to it is the only place where there could have been a diesel fuel fire in the area where the implosion began.

In your humble opinion, that is the only place they could have broken.
It is not possible for the pipes to fracture at the other end of the building and remain intact where the debris damage was. IMHO


FEMA said that. NIST didn't. NIST did not assign probability.
Are you saying NIST should ignore the FEMA report?

In your humble opinion
Including diesel fires as a possible contributing factor in the collapse when the evidence points the other way, is misleading.
 
What's to examine?
FEMA researched the location of the fuel tanks, pumps, pipes and generators. That is the last word on that.
NIST is a separate organization tasked with a job. In their preliminary report they did not get into details about any of the fires and therefore in THEIR report they do not assign probability to any fire aspects.

They said there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room.

Again, FEMA did go into this in detail, NIST did not. In the preliminary report it would be odd to go into detail on ONE aspect of the fires.

NIST did examine the evidence.
They researched the location of the debris damage and the fires.

Yes, a preliminary investigation into the debris damage and the fires. The full report should go into the fuel oads in the area of the fires , the temp and heat output of those fires and how that would affect the steel. Gee, looky there, more work to do, and you thought NIST was finished by publishing appendix L.

There was no sign of fire in that area.
There is no reason to think there were fires in that area.

A thorough investigation has not been published yet and yet you make sich definitive statements.

They found nothing to support the diesel fuel fire hypothesis.
In fact, the evidence points the other way.

NIST did not go into it at all. That is different than saying they found nothing.

They did investigate the location of the fires.

In a preliminary fashion, yes. they did not go into detail about the fires.

They knew about the presence of diesel fuel from the FEMA investigation.
They knew FEMA had said there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room.

Again, DEMA did say that but that was FEMA's report, not NIST's. NIST would have to examine FEMA's report before actually accepting it verbatim. That was not within the pervue of a preliminary report.


The NE generator room and the area next to it is the only place where there could have been a diesel fuel fire in the area where the implosion began.

Whether or not the diesel fuel was burning near the initiating event NIST would want to investigate the possibility of it burning anywhere in the building regardless of wheteher or not it would directly affect the initial failure.

It is not possible for the pipes to fracture at the other end of the building and remain intact where the debris damage was. IMHO

Well, well, Chris throws in an "IMHO".


Are you saying NIST should ignore the FEMA report?
Answered above
 
NIST is a separate organization tasked with a job. In their preliminary report they did not get into details about any of the fires and therefore in THEIR report they do not assign probability to any fire aspects.
Double talk.
A low probability of diesel fuel fires in that area had already been assigned by FEMA based on the location of the tanks, pipes and generator rooms.

Again, FEMA did go into this in detail, NIST did not. In the preliminary report it would be odd to go into detail on ONE aspect of the fires.
NIST did not need to go into that part of it because FEMA already had.
NIST investigated the extent of the debris damage and fires.

Yes, a preliminary investigation into the debris damage and the fires. The full report should go into the fuel oads in the area of the fires , the temp and heat output of those fires and how that would affect the steel.
Yes, fuel loads in the area, that does not include diesel fuel.

C7 said:
There was no sign of fire in that area.
There is no reason to think there were fires in that area.
A thorough investigation has not been published yet and yet you make sich definitive statements.
A through investigation of where the fires were has been done and published.

A through investigation of where the diesel fuel tanks, pipes and generators were, has been done and published.

Based on those published reports it can be said, beyond a reasonable doubt, that there were no diesel fuel fires in or near the area where the implosion began.


C7 said:
They found nothing to support the diesel fuel fire hypothesis.
In fact, the evidence points the other way.
NIST did not go into it at all. That is different than saying they found nothing.
NIST did go into it.
They researched the debris damage and fires.
They found that there was NO debris damage or fires in or near the NE generator room.
i.e. they found nothing to support the diesel fuel fire hypothesis.

So what's left to investigate on this hypothesis, ..... nothing.
 
Last edited:
Of course there is the theory that the fires on 11 and 12 alone could have initiated the collapse.
Chris has said (over and over again) that the building was designed such that if a tenant wanted it, some floors could be removed. The columns could take the added unbraced length.

Of course in order to do that they would first brace the underside and support the floor span to be removed, THEN cut it away and take it out. This would mean that at no time would there be any lateral forces on the columns.

Chris also points out that the columns are very large and would take a long time to fail simply due to loss of strength by heating. However that also assumes that the lateral forces of a sagging floor span be the same as for a short span floor as in other examples such as the Cardington tests. WTC 7 used relativly long spans.

Here Arthur Scheuerman describes how fire alone could have doomed WTC 7.

Of interest as far as Chis' latest bugaboo is this quote
The 5th floors to
7th floors were transition floors. There was speculation about the fire’s being on
these floors and fed from oil-fired generators supplied from tanks on the lower
floors, but I have seen no hard evidence of fire from this source.

You will note that he does not state, as Chris does, that it is simply impossible for there to have been an oil fire on those floors. All he says is that he has not seen any hard evidence of such fires.

Funk de Fino points out that there is circumstantial evidence, that of the missing fuel, that there was a diesel fuel fire somewhere in the bldg.
Scheuerman, is stating that he is NOT considering a diesel fuel fire in his theory. Not because he believes it is impossible, but because he has not enough evidence to believe there was. It is this type of nuance that completely escapes people like Chris 7

Chris will undoubtably read into what I say as my backing the notion that a fuel oil fire definatly contributed to the initial collapse. It ain't so Chris. Too bad you cannot fathom that.
 
Last edited:
Double talk.
A low probability of diesel fuel fires in that area had already been assigned by FEMA based on the location of the tanks, pipes and generator rooms.

NIST did not need to go into that part of it because FEMA already had.

In fact NIST would decide what NIST would do as far as the fuel sources of the fires in the building and investigate the possibility of fires in areas with no windows. THAT WAS NOT DONE IN THE PRELIM REPORT. It would be the pervue of a more in depth report.

NIST investigated the extent of the debris damage and fires.

NIST listed the obvious areas that had been damaged and the obvious fire locations. That is all they did in the preliminary report.

Yes, fuel loads in the area, that does not include diesel fuel.

NIST would also be concerned whether or not there was a diesel fire anywhere in the bldg. Just review what the letters in NIST stand for to understand why.


A through investigation of where the fires were has been done and published.

Really? You know where I can find a detailed description of fuel loads, fire progression, fire temps etc? It isn't in the FEMA report or NIST WTC appendix L.

A through investigation of where the diesel fuel tanks, pipes and generators were, has been done and published.

Based on those published reports it can be said, beyond a reasonable doubt, that there were no diesel fuel fires in or near the area where the implosion began.

Which may well be used in the final report.


NIST did go into it.
They researched the debris damage and fires.
They found that there was NO debris damage or fires in or near the NE generator room.
i.e. they found nothing to support the diesel fuel fire hypothesis.

So what's left to investigate on this hypothesis, ..... nothing.

yeah, and everything that can be invented has been. Might as well close the patent office down.
It is quite obvious that there is much more to be investigated. Too bad you can't see that. then again given your low burden of investigation to show that CD was the cause of the collapse, I am not surprised.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom