10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why didn't FEMA put as much emphasis on structural damage from falling debris as NIST now apparently is?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/7_World_Trade_Center

NIST has released a video and still-photo analysis of 7 World Trade Center before its collapse that appears to indicate a greater degree of structural damage from falling debris than originally assumed by FEMA. Specifically, NIST's interim report on 7 World Trade Center displays photographs of the southwest façade of the building that show it to have significant damage. The report also highlights a 10-story gash in the center of the south façade, toward the bottom, extending approximately a quarter of the way into the interior.
That photo is part of the composite i posted.
It was well above the 5th floor and had nothing to do with the diesel fuel fire.
 
What did NIST have access to that Fema didn't?

It's not that FEMA didn't have access to it, more information just came out with time. What are you trying to suggest by asking these questions?

All of the data wasn't collected during FEMA's brief investigation, this is even said in their report.
"Additional data should be collected to confirm the extent of the damage to the south face of the building caused by falling debris."
http://www.fema.gov/pdf/library/fema403_ch5.pdf
 
It's not that FEMA didn't have access to it, more information just came out with time. What are you trying to suggest by asking these questions?

All of the data wasn't collected during FEMA's brief investigation, this is even said in their report.
"Additional data should be collected to confirm the extent of the damage to the south face of the building caused by falling debris."
http://www.fema.gov/pdf/library/fema403_ch5.pdf

Its clear what he is trying to suggest, but as usual he has no facts to back up anything at all.
 
It's not that FEMA didn't have access to it, more information just came out with time. What are you trying to suggest by asking these questions?

All of the data wasn't collected during FEMA's brief investigation, this is even said in their report.
"Additional data should be collected to confirm the extent of the damage to the south face of the building caused by falling debris."
http://www.fema.gov/pdf/library/fema403_ch5.pdf
FEMA researched the diesel fuel fire possibility and determined that there was a low probability of that happening.
NIST had photos, videos and firefighter accounts to WTC 7 to determine when and where the fires occurred.
There was NO fire reported in or near the NE generator room.
Recently released photos have shown more damage to the south west part of WTC 7.

It's possible that debris damage caused a diesel fuel fire in the SSB south west generator room.

There is no reason to think that a double wall pipe fractured in or near the north east generator room at the opposite corner of the building.
 
Originally Posted by jaydeehess
I know there will be a bending stress on the column, basic physics says there would be. I know that if a column is bent then the load will no longer be directed through the column properly and therfore it will no longer function as designed.

Originally Posted by Christopher7
Bent how much?
This is a theory that has not been tested.

What's a theory ? That bent columns do not perform as designed ?

Originally Posted by Christopher7
http://www.fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire07/PDF/f07021.pdf

page 45 [57 on pg counter]
As illustrated in Figure 17, non-uniform heating can be full height, but incomplete fire exposure of entire column section contour or a partial height exposure of some or all the section contour. Loaded column tests with non-uniform heating are expected to show asymmetric structural response and failure mechanisms that are not obviated from the currently unloaded, uniformly-critical E 119 temperature tests with their idealized conditions.
page 46
Provision for investigating loaded column and wall response under non-uniform fire exposure should be studied, as this may be a more severe condition than uniform heating.

I noticed you didn't answer my question, Chris...
I did.
The theory that uneven heating could cause the failure of core column has not been studied.

This did not happen in the Meridian Plaza and other major fires in high rise buildings.

[FONT=&quot]http://www.interfire.org/res_file/pdf/Tr-049.pdf
pg 19 [24 on pg counter]
After the fire, there was evident significant structural damage to horizontal steel members and floor sections on most of the fire damaged floors. Beams and girders sagged and twisted -- some as much as three feet -- under severe fire exposures, and fissures developed in the reinforced concrete floor assemblies in many places.
[/FONT]

Despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.

The columns in the Meridian Plaza continued to "function as designed".

There is no reason to suspect that the columns in WTC 7 behaved differently.
 
Back from a weeks vacation. Did I miss you all. naaahhhh, but now that I am back home.........

Originally Posted by jaydeehess
I know there will be a bending stress on the column, basic physics says there would be. I know that if a column is bent then the load will no longer be directed through the column properly and therfore it will no longer function as designed.

Originally Posted by Christopher7
Bent how much?
This is a theory that has not been tested.

Shall we list the theories that were not tested before they were accepted?
Tell me Chris7, do you believe that Einstein's General Theory of Relativity, a theory much more ethereal than bending steel by differential heating, is on the right track? Why? Many aspects have never been tested but some that have illustrate that he was indeed correct when he first postulated it.



Originally Posted by Christopher7
http://www.fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire07/PDF/f07021.pdf

page 45 [57 on pg counter]
As illustrated in Figure 17, non-uniform heating can be full height, but incomplete fire exposure of entire column section contour or a partial height exposure of some or all the section contour. Loaded column tests with non-uniform heating are expected to show asymmetric structural response and failure mechanisms that are not obviated from the currently unloaded, uniformly-critical E 119 temperature tests with their idealized conditions.
page 46
Provision for investigating loaded column and wall response under non-uniform fire exposure should be studied, as this may be a more severe condition than uniform heating.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, we know Chris. seems to me that I read this somewhere before(again and again and again)
That deals with strict uniform heating strength loss.



This did not happen in the Meridian Plaza and other major fires in high rise buildings.

[FONT=&quot]http://www.interfire.org/res_file/pdf/Tr-049.pdf
pg 19 [24 on pg counter]
After the fire, there was evident significant structural damage to horizontal steel members and floor sections on most of the fire damaged floors. Beams and girders sagged and twisted -- some as much as three feet -- under severe fire exposures, and fissures developed in the reinforced concrete floor assemblies in many places.
[/FONT]

Despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.

The columns in the Meridian Plaza continued to "function as designed".

There is no reason to suspect that the columns in WTC 7 behaved differently.

So given that it did not cause a collapse in the Meridian Plaza you assume that it could not cause a collapse in a structure that had undergone significant structural damage prior to the fires attacking it for several hours. Your reasoning, that differential heating structural loss of heavy columns under load has not been tested.

From there you will automatically assume explosives were used.
 
The columns in the Meridian Plaza continued to "function as designed".

There is no reason to suspect that the columns in WTC 7 behaved differently.

EXCEPT for the fact that TONS of debris rained down on WTC7 prior to the fires.

Could that have made a difference? Hmmm? Perhaps?? Maybe?? Whatcha' think? Tons of debris! Not, just a couple of pounds. TONS. That's over 2000 pounds per ton. WOW WEE, that's a lot of STUFF.

Geeze o' Petes a lot of STUFF hit WTC7. Think that might have made a difference?

Did the Meridian Plaza get hit by TONS (Not just ounces.) of debris BEFORE the fires started?

Think that could have made a difference? Maybe?

(How was that for annoying?)
 
That photo is part of the composite i posted.
It was well above the 5th floor and had nothing to do with the diesel fuel fire.

As you are so fond of mentioning at times Chris7, this thread started as a discussion about the debris damage to the building. That your particular concern , at this time, is the possible diesel fire, is irrellevent to Zens brining up the gash itself.

not that I don't understand that Zens is about to claim that the gash never happened, that any image in which it appears is fake and perhaps that WTC 7 actually jumped out of the way of any heavy debris that came at it only to be brought down later in the day by explosives/thermobaric bombs/thermite/mini-nukes/space beams.
 
Last edited:
Detonations were heard over an extended period of time before the collapse. Some of the witnesses were still in the building when they heard the explosions.

Please watch this 10-minute video and explain:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dzUNvEfYDEQ

It has about two dozen witnesses relating the explosions they heard. You can also hear several explosions yourself, for instance at 4:30-4:45. There is also a witness telling how he overheard the WTC 7 countdown over a radio, at the 6:26 mark. At 6:10 a witness tells how an explosion "blew us back onto the 8th floor." See also a group of firemen describing the detonations at the 4 minute mark. There is also network news footage of people on the scene, reporters, fire department spokesmen, talking about secondary explosions.

"Secondary" to what? a "primary" explosion?
A loud banging sound or a serries of luad banging sounds while the interior of the building collapsed, while the witness can not see the interior nor the other side of the building. Yeah, quite convincing of explosive use:rolleyes:

In ANY office or home fire one is also going to hear "explosions". Some will be actual explosions. They can be anything from aerosol cans to televisions or CRT computer displays cooking off. Some are simply going to be structural failures or sudden shifts of the building's load.

The only witnesses in the building who report an explosion are the two who were in the stairwell AT THE TIME that the towers fell. Gee, one wonders what that would sound and feel like.
 
To list it as the second item in the summary is to suggest diesel fuel fires had something to do with the initiating event.

FEMA said there was a low probability and there is no evidence of fire on floor 5 at any time.

Horse pucks!

The diesel fuel represented a large possible fuel load. It simply had to be addressed and deserved consideration. NIST did not, in its prelim report, do an in depth investigation of any possible contributing factor in the collapse. That's why its called a prelim report. The diesel fuel warrented mention so all you have to go on is the fact that it figured prominently, in your opinion, in the report summary. Item 2 in the summary addresses the fires. The fires most certainly warrant being listed prominently and the possiblity of the diesel fuel being involved would HAVE TO go with the item that deals with the fires.
Item 1 - a summary of debris damage
Item 2 - a summary of fires
Item 3 - probable initiating event
Item 4 - initial vertical collapse
Item 5 - probable conditions that led to the interior horizontal collapse
Item 6 - perimeter and global collapse

In this list then Chris, where would you have put the possibility of involvement of the diesel fuel? It certainly does not belong in any item after #2 and is of no relevence to Item #1 either. The other alternatives would be to not mention it at all, or to list it at the end as another less probable contributing factor. Not mentioning it would be rather derilict as it represents a very large possible fire effect. Adding it on as an afterthought at the end of the summary is a torured way of including it.
Seems its right where it belongs.
 
Shall we list the theories that were not tested before they were accepted?
Let's not and say we did.

Tell me Chris7, do you believe that Einstein's General Theory of Relativity, a theory much more ethereal than bending steel by differential heating, is on the right track? Why? Many aspects have never been tested but some that have illustrate that he was indeed correct when he first postulated it.
The theory that uneven heating might cause a column to fail cannot be compared to Einstein's theory.

***********************************
Originally Posted by Christopher7
http://www.fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire07/PDF/f07021.pdf

page 45 [57 on pg counter]
As illustrated in Figure 17, non-uniform heating can be full height, but incomplete fire exposure of entire column section contour or a partial height exposure of some or all the section contour. Loaded column tests with non-uniform heating are expected to show asymmetric structural response and failure mechanisms that are not obviated from the currently unloaded, uniformly-critical E 119 temperature tests with their idealized conditions.
page 46
Provision for investigating loaded column and wall response under non-uniform fire exposure should be studied, as this may be a more severe condition than uniform heating.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, we know Chris. seems to me that I read this somewhere before(again and again and again)
That deals with strict uniform heating strength loss.
*********************************
So given that it did not cause a collapse in the Meridian Plaza you assume that it could not cause a collapse in a structure that had undergone significant structural damage prior to the fires attacking it for several hours.
There was no structural damage to or near the area where the collapse began.

Your reasoning, that differential heating structural loss of heavy columns under load has not been tested.
No, my reasoning is:
There were fires on many contiguous floors that burned much longer in the Meridian Plaza and the investigation found that
despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.

From there you will automatically assume explosives were used.
Wrong
From there i can state that columns in longer lasting and more extensive fires have not failed.

The columns in WTC 7 were larger and would take longer to heat up.
 
EXCEPT for the fact that TONS of debris rained down on WTC7 prior to the fires.
Could that have made a difference? Hmmm? Perhaps?? Maybe?? Whatcha' think? Tons of debris! Not, just a couple of pounds. TONS. That's over 2000 pounds per ton. WOW WEE, that's a lot of STUFF.
Geeze o' Petes a lot of STUFF hit WTC7. Think that might have made a difference?
Gee golly wizz buckeroo, all that stuff hit the south west part of that building and the collapse started in the east central part.
The lower floors of a 47 story building must have a great deal of shear strength. This shear strength would have taken up any lateral stress.

Did the Meridian Plaza get hit by TONS (Not just ounces.) of debris BEFORE the fires started?

Think that could have made a difference? Maybe?

(How was that for annoying?)
Exceptional!
 
The diesel fuel represented a large possible fuel load. It simply had to be addressed and deserved consideration. NIST did not, in its prelim report, do an in depth investigation of any possible contributing factor in the collapse.
FEMA did a in depth study and determined that there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.
NIST did an in depth study of the fire time line an location of the fires.
There was no sign of fire in the NE generator room at any time.

That's why its called a prelim report. The diesel fuel warrented mention so all you have to go on is the fact that it figured prominently,
Thank you for making my point.

There is no reason to think it figured prominently.

Yet, because of this erroneous entry, you and others think it did.

in your opinion, in the report summary. Item 2 in the summary addresses the fires. The fires most certainly warrant being listed prominently and the possiblity of the diesel fuel being involved would HAVE TO go with the item that deals with the fires.
Not if the evidence points the other way.

Item 1 - a summary of debris damage
Item 2 - a summary of fires
Item 3 - probable initiating event
Item 4 - initial vertical collapse
Item 5 - probable conditions that led to the interior horizontal collapse
Item 6 - perimeter and global collapse

In this list then Chris, where would you have put the possibility of involvement of the diesel fuel?
It should not have been included.

It certainly does not belong in any item after #2 and is of no relevence to Item #1 either. The other alternatives would be to not mention it at all, or to list it at the end as another less probable contributing factor. Not mentioning it would be rather derilict as it represents a very large possible fire effect.
deritlic?
It was misleading to include possible diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event as a possible cause when there is NO evidence to support that hypothesis.

There was no smoke coming from the east generator room.

If the louvers were open, smoke would be pouring out.

If the louvers were closed, a fire would have no air supply and could not have burned hot enough to be a factor.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom