10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by Christopher
Why don't you take your own advise (sic) and stop claiming that WTC 7 collapsed because of DD/F until NIST can explain how it happened.
They have only a hypothesis [a set of assumptions
that they admit, may not hold up.

"This hypothesis may be supported or modified, or new hypotheses may be developed, through the course of the continuing investigation."

No
I have known this for a long time and i have been asking you all to stop claiming that WTC 7 collapsed due to DD/F for a long time.
This does not mean we should ignore the evidence contained in the NIST and other reports.
NIST is stalling because they cannot demonstrate how the fires could have caused the collapse.
You would like to have us all ignore the facts and wait for another snow job from an administration that systematically distorts scientific documents.

Whoa!!!

It has been stated many times by many here that the evidence for DD/F having caused the collapse far outweighs the evidence for CD. This is not a definitive statement, it is saying thatthere is chance that something else caused or contributed to the collapse, albeit a small one.

It is you who has made the definitive statements concerning what could or could not have occured in WTC 7 due to fires and debris damage. How many times have I complained about your definitive statements in this thread Chris? Given the number of times it has occured I would have to believe that you recall my having called you on it.

I too am a Bush hater. I hate the global temp change data fudgeing, the stem cell research obstacles etc. I have stated many times in JREF forums that I hate GWB and that I feel that he will go down in history as the worst POTUS to date. Yet somehow I cannot allow my own feelings about the man and his administration to affect critical thinking. I certainly am not allowing my own political views and feelings concerning the administration to drive my assessment of the events of 9/11, that much is obvious. Can you say the same?

Now you claim inside knowledge of the workings of NIST, specifically you accuse NIST of working towards a pre-determined conclusion, of distortion and obfuscation. Do I detect an 'out' for you when/if NIST's final report does indeed have a good model of DD/F resulting in the collapse and very little evidence of CD?
In other words it will matter not what conclusions are drawn and what tech/science is employed, you will stick to YOUR predetermined conclusion.
 
Last edited:
Both structures fully intact at the outset, both structures not nearly as tall as WTC 7 , both structures of a less complex structural design.
Meridian Plaza was 37 stories tall.
The Cardington tests were to examine how different framework members react in extreme fire conditions.
That data could be used in a computer model of WTC 7.

C7 said:
How much could that difference be in a column of the size and shape of the columns 79, 80 and 81, given steel's ability do disperse heat rapidly?
How much bend could occur in 12 feet?
Gradient would be greater the bigger the column Chris. Its 1st year thermodynamics, take a course in it. The cookie sheet would dissapate heat faster than a thick column. Steel has a finite rate of conduction, it is greater than concrete but less than copper or aluminum.
You did not answer the question because you don't know what the actual effect would be.
Your theory means nothing unless you can apply it to the case at hand.

C7 said:
The core columns at the east end of the building failed first.
NIST L-49 and 50 show Trusses 1 and 2 collapsing to the east, the opposite direction of the lateral pull you say contributed to the collapse.
Which only indicates where something let go. If this were a spring then it failed at the anchor point.
So now it's the 'spring effect' ..... please
I suppose you have a URL for this phonynomanon.

Each fire was as hot as the Meridian fire.
You are right, the fires were similar, except the fires in the Meridian Plaza were on contiguous floors.
WTC 7 was designed better and had far less vertical expansion of fires.
[except for the SW corner]


meridianplazacbg5.jpg


e7yn8.jpg


copyof3zn0.jpg



In all other fires the entire building was intact at the outset of the fire.
So what?
The area where the collapse began was not damaged by debris or weakened by the damage.
You have shown no data to back up your claim that the debris damage had a significant structural effect on the east end of the building.

Like all your so called evidence for DD/F, it's just inference and innuendo.

C7 said:
The columns were much heavier and would take longer to heat up
,,, and the fires in WTC 7 were moe extensive.
Wrong
See photos above.
 
Last edited:
You state, as a fact, that NIST is stalling because they cannot demonstrate how the fires could have caused the collapse. If you state this as a fact, and you have no idea whether this is true why should we listen to any of your other facts?
If they were able to show how the fires caused the collapse of WTC 7, they would have released the report.
You are looking for an excuse to ignore the facts contained in the NIST and other reports.
These facts are not 'my facts', they are simply 'the facts'.

Again, you are making up facts, just like you have for the past few months.
Wrong

I have listed facts from the FEMA and NIST reports, as well as data from the Tr-049 report, the Cardington tests and others.
 
Meridian Plaza was 37 stories tall.
The Cardington tests were to examine how different framework members react in extreme fire conditions.
That data could be used in a computer model of WTC 7.
,,a nd may well be used in the NIST report. Gee, maybe we could wait for it.


You did not answer the question because you don't know what the actual effect would be.
Your theory means nothing unless you can apply it to the case at hand
.

So you now at least admit that steel does not conduct heat as well as you wish it could and that a temp gradient will result in bending? All you dispute is the degree?


So now it's the 'spring effect' ..... please
I suppose you have a URL for this phonynomanon.

Look back. I used your description of what was taking place.

You are right, the fires were similar, except the fires in the Meridian Plaza were on contiguous floors.
WTC 7 was designed better and had far less vertical expansion of fires.
[except for the SW corner]

Yeah, go figure, all buildings don't react exactly alike.
How do you quantify "WTC 7 was designed better"?

So what?
The area where the collapse began was not damaged by debris or weakened by the damage.
You have shown no data to back up your claim that the debris damage had a significant structural effect on the east end of the building.

Like all your so called evidence for DD/F, it's just inference and innuendo.

At least it is infered by the existance of debris and fire damage, unlike the inference that CD caused the collapse which is pure fantasy

Wrong
See photos above.

My bad, I thought you were reffering to the Cardington structure there.
How much longer Chris?
 
So you now at least admit that steel does not conduct heat as well as you wish it could and that a temp gradient will result in bending? All you dispute is the degree?



Steel conducts heat approx 60 times better than concrete.
 
It has been stated many times by many here that the evidence for DD/F having caused the collapse far outweighs the evidence for CD. This is not a definitive statement,
You got that part right.

It's just a "My dog is bigger than your dog" statement.

You refuse to acknowledge the evidence for CD and then and claim inference and innuendo is better than nothing.

it is saying that there is chance that something else caused or contributed to the collapse,
Something else?
Something other than a CD?

albeit a small one.
A small one indeed.



I hate GWB and that I feel that he will go down in history as the worst POTUS to date. ......... am not allowing my own political views and feelings concerning the administration to drive my assessment of the events of 9/11, that much is obvious. Can you say the same?
Yes

We agree that GWB is the worst President ever but unlike you, i don't hate Bush, i despise and fear him.
Yet my first reaction to the video of WTC 7 was denial.
I told myself "That's not really WTC 7"
When i saw it again on the History Channel, it finally hit home.

Now you claim inside knowledge of the workings of NIST
No

specifically you accuse NIST of working towards a pre-determined conclusion, of distortion and obfuscation.
Yes

Do I detect an 'out' for you when/if NIST's final report does indeed have a good model of DD/F resulting in the collapse and very little evidence of CD?
In other words it will matter not what conclusions are drawn and what tech/science is employed, you will stick to YOUR predetermined conclusion.
Given that the Bush administration systematically distorts scientific documents, i would need independent review and verification of the data to believe it.

The facts do not support the DD/F hypothesis.
On the contrary, they show that vertical support columns do not fail in tests or the real world.*

What makes you think NIST will find some data that contradicts the data in the Tr-049 report, the Lessons Learned report, and the Cardington tests?


*The Windsor Tower had light weight exterior box columns [18 pounds per lineal foot] on the upper 10 floors.
These cannot be compared to the columns in the Meridian Plaza or the 730 lb per lin. ft. columns in WTC 7.
 
You got that part right.

It's just a "My dog is bigger than your dog" statement.

As I said before, two dogs in the yard and a 2 foot wide by 1 foot deep hole with paw prints indicating it was dug by a dog. One dog is a Pomeranian and the other a German Shepard. What are the odds that the Pomeranian did the deed? the Shepard? a third dog that was not seen by anyone?
(OK maybe I used different breeds before, the comparison stands.)

You are saying that because the evidence for DD/F is more compelling than CD, that CD is the more likely to have been the cause? Sorry Chris lack of evidence is not evidence.

You refuse to acknowledge the evidence for CD and then and claim inference and innuendo is better than nothing

The 7 supposed hallmarks of CD? You are kidding right? 7 items drummed up by people out to prove a predetermined conclusion who leave out any characteristic of CD that just happens to not bolster that predetermined conclusion.
The supposed cut columns that oddly enough all seem to have occured at splices?
The loud booming or banging sounds that all occur AS the building is collapseing? Yes, of course falling debris should make whistleing, or soft rustleing noises.

Something else?
Something other than a CD?

No, I was including CD, your fav, but also leaving it open space based beam weapons, mini-nukes, and UFO's, the favs of some others in the CT camp.

A small one indeed.
Hmm, sarcasm or agreement?,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,




Well it is patently obvious that my political dislike of GWB isn't colouring my stance. Its not so obvious in your case.

We agree that GWB is the worst President ever but unlike you, i don't hate Bush, i despise and fear him.

OK I don't actually hate the man, I disagree with him and look forward to someone else taking over from him.

Yet my first reaction to the video of WTC 7 was denial.I told myself "That's not really WTC 7"

Denial that it was WTC 7?
Please don't make yourself sound like the no-planers.

When i saw it again on the History Channel, it finally hit home.

That it was indeed WTC 7.


Sure you do. you claim that you know for a fact that NIST will create data soley to support a predetermined conclusion. That means you have some inside knowledge on the inner workings of NIST.

Given that the Bush administration systematically distorts scientific documents, i would need independent review and verification of the data to believe it.

It would require that you can show that the science was manipulated IN THIS CASE.

The facts do not support the DD/F hypothesis.

The debris and fire damage are they only facts in evidence that point to a cause.

On the contrary, they show that vertical support columns do not fail in tests or the real world.*

Yes, in fact columns do fail. This is another case of a definitive sentence of yours that is simply incorrect. Buildings have collapsed due to fire and in those cases the vertical columns failed. They did so in buildings not the size of WTC 7 but those buildings were intact before the fires.

What makes you think NIST will find some data that contradicts the data in the Tr-049 report, the Lessons Learned report, and the Cardington tests?

Contradict? Neither of those state that columns are immune to fire damage failure.

I asked you how much longer the columns of WTC 7 would take to heat up than for instance, those of the Meridian Plaza. Let's assume equal heat input which only requires that one compartment be on fire in each case.
 
http://www.fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire07/PDF/f07021.pdf

page 45-46 (actual page #)

As illustrated in Figure 17, non-uniform heating can be full height, but incomplete fire exposure of entire column section contour or a partial height exposure of some or all the section contour. Loaded column tests with non-uniform heating are expected to show asymmetric structural response and failure mechanisms that are not obviated from the currently unloaded,uniformly-critical E 119 temperature tests with their idealized conditions.
<<snip>>
Provision for investigating loaded column and wall response under non-uniform fire exposure should be studied, as this may be a more severe condition than uniform heating.
 
You are saying that because the evidence for DD/F is more compelling than CD, that CD is the more likely to have been the cause?
No
First of all, that sentence doesn't make sense.
I believe you meant "the evidence for DD/F is less compelling ....."
I have stated that the lack of evidence for DD/F does not prove CD [or vise versa].

Hmm, sarcasm or agreement?,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Both

specifically you accuse NIST of working towards a pre-determined conclusion, of distortion and obfuscation.
C7 said:
you claim that you know for a fact that NIST will create data soley to support a predetermined conclusion. That means you have some inside knowledge on the inner workings of NIST.
No
I can see that they made misleading statements in the preliminary report.
There is no evidence of diesel fuel fires or reason to believe they existed in the area of the initiating event.
There were no fires reported on floor 5.
There is no smoke coming from the louvers in the north east generator room. [floor 5]
Pipes would fracture in the SW generator room where the debris damage was, not in the NE generator room at the opposite end of the building.

C7 said:
Given that the Bush administration systematically distorts scientific documents, i would need independent review and verification of the data to believe it.
It would require that you can show that the science was manipulated IN THIS CASE.
It would require qualified independent persons to verify or refute the data.

The debris and fire damage are they only facts in evidence that point to a cause.
IYO

Yes, in fact columns do fail. This is another case of a definitive sentence of yours that is simply incorrect. Buildings have collapsed due to fire and in those cases the vertical columns failed.
To satisfy this bit of sophistry, i use the term 'high rise building' instead of 'steel framed building'.

C7 said:
What makes you think NIST will find some data that contradicts the data in the Tr-049 report, the Lessons Learned report, and the Cardington tests?
Contradict? Neither of those state that columns are immune to fire damage failure.
Large columns in high rise buildings are not immune to fire but in tests and real world events, they do not fail.

I asked you how much longer the columns of WTC 7 would take to heat up than for instance, those of the Meridian Plaza. Let's assume equal heat input which only requires that one compartment be on fire in each case.
I can only say that the heavier the column, the longer it will take to heat it up.

I have not yet found any data on how hot and how long office fires burn or how long it takes structural steel to heat up at those temperatures.
Do you know of any data on that?
 
Last edited:
There will be a couple of other factors to consider, mainly the conservation of momentum from the fact that the falling mass had to accelerate the lower floors up to its falling speed. However, for WTC7 this is a much smaller term than the twin towers, because the main collapse started low down and hence the mass of the upper block was a much greater proportion of the whole. Overall, 6.5 seconds or so looks like a very sensible time for a gravity-driven collapse.

While I suspect I may be talking to myself here because respublicus found the trauma of actually getting an answer a little too much to cope with:

I put conservation of momentum into the spreadsheet by assuming a constant mass per floor, collapse initiation at the 7th floor, and two alternative scenarios - crush down / crush up, and alternate crush up/down until the falling mass impacts the ground. I assumed for the first scenario that the velocity of the falling mass was reduced by a factor 40/41 at the first impact, 41/42 at the second, and so on; for the second I assumed that the reduction in velocity occurred every second floor by the same amount.

The two scenarios gave me 6.43 and 6.45 seconds respectively, both of which are in excellent agreement with the observed 6.5 second collapse time. I can run through the calculations in more detail if anyone's interested.

Dave
 
No
First of all, that sentence doesn't make sense.
I believe you meant "the evidence for DD/F is less compelling ....."
Remember this all goes back to your big/little dog statements.
I was paraphrasing what seems to be your position, and yes, it makes no sense. The evidence that debris and fire damage caused the collapse is more compelling than the evidence that explosives were used to collapse the building. Yet it seems that you claim that because of this we should believe that CD was used.

I have stated that the lack of evidence for DD/F does not prove CD [or vise versa].

I must have missed that sorry.


No
I can see that they made misleading statements in the preliminary report.
There is no evidence of diesel fuel fires or reason to believe they existed in the area of the initiating event.
There were no fires reported on floor 5.
There is no smoke coming from the louvers in the north east generator room. [floor 5]
Pipes would fracture in the SW generator room where the debris damage was, not in the NE generator room at the opposite end of the building.

They listed possibilities. It is to be determined in the final report what probability should be attached to each. At the strident urging of the CT community they also are including the possibility of blast events in the final report, a matter that likely has had something to do with the delay in its completion.


It would require qualified independent persons to verify or refute the data
.

Then by all means quote it.


I've seen nothing otherwise that is compelling in the least.

To satisfy this bit of sophistry, i use the term 'high rise building' instead of 'steel framed building'.

So? 9/11 was the first time that any high rise was hit by an aircraft or by large dense and fast debris.


Large columns in high rise buildings are not immune to fire but in tests and real world events, they do not fail.

See my last sentence.

I can only say that the heavier the column, the longer it will take to heat it up.
I have not yet found any data on how hot and how long office fires burn or how long it takes structural steel to heat up at those temperatures.
Do you know of any data on that?

I agree but you have stated that this column could not have heated up enough to cause a problem. Therefore I thought you had some quantification of that contention you could share.

[/QUOTE]
 
C7 said:
I can see that they made misleading statements in the preliminary report.
There is no evidence of diesel fuel fires or reason to believe they existed in the area of the initiating event.
There were no fires reported on floor 5.
There is no smoke coming from the louvers in the north east generator room. [floor 5]
Pipes would fracture in the SW generator room where the debris damage was, not in the NE generator room at the opposite end of the building.

They listed possibilities. It is to be determined in the final report what probability should be attached to each.
There is no evidence of diesel fuel fires or reason to believe they existed in the area of the initiating event.

Including diesel fuel fire as a possibility has mislead many people into thinking it was a factor in the collapse.

Then by all means quote it.
If the final report presents data to explain how DD/F brought down WTC 7, i will review it and the independent assessment.

In the mean time, the list of qualified persons refuting the NIST report and calling for an independent investigation is long and growing.

C7 said:
I can only say that the heavier the column, the longer it will take to heat it up.
I agree but you have stated that this column could not have heated up enough to cause a problem. Therefore I thought you had some quantification of that contention you could share.
There were fires on floors 8, 11, 12 and 13 in the area where the implosion began.

There were similar fires in the Meridian plaza on 8 contiguous floors.
Despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.

The columns in WTC 7 were heavier and would take longer to heat up.
 
I see life in the sandbox has changed little.

There is a very effective way to prove that a 47-story concrete and steel building could perform a total, high speed, symmetrical (after the penthouse falls) near footprint collapse due to natural causes, because of a bit of debris damage (the infamous gouge and corner) and and a few waste cans on fire (ya ya the firefighters said it was fully involved..I saw all the smoke..ya guess they were right.)

One of the clever people here just has to make an animation illustrating how the building was fired up like a forge from hell, showing WTC 1 had all but ripped the sucker to shreds from debris fall at 10:28 a.m. and that the only unusual aspect to the collapse was that it didn't happen at an odder time like say 5:15 p.m on Dec 3rd, 2078.

I mean what's with these natural collapses happening at scheduled-like times. 09:58 a.m., 10:28 a.m. and then 5:20 p.m...damn coincidences.

You've got to admire the engineering that went into WTC 7. It's not easy to design a building with known vulnerabilties and still have it collapse like that.

Yeah they built it over a electrical substation. What fools they were. Any idiot knows no amount of engineering is going to stop a total, high speed, symmetrical collapse once those horizontal trusses fail from all the ignited butane lighters folks dropped while abandoning the building. Yeah I know, there was lots and lots of diesel fuel, enough no doubt to power the whole U.S. of A. for a couple of weeks. Too bad we have no proof that it actually burned.

What I want to see in this animation..or is cartoon a better description? Simpsons comes to mind..whatever, is all the firefighters pointing at those, what was it 8 maybe 9 windows with billowing flames and concluding "that building is coming down!". "Hear that creaking?..That building is coming down!..What was that? The chief said "that building is coming down!"

Well that building did come down by jove.

Don't get me wrong, I have the deepest respect for the NYFD 'rank 'n file' members. Their management people?..well don't get me going.

I am hoping this JREF animation will show how all the supporting columns gave way at the same time? Gravy would be a good guy to direct this. He could convince anyone that a naked lady was dressed to the nines.

I'm really curious about how all those columns so slickly failed in agreement, cuz geez that sucker was level when she dropped. You woulda thought some of the columns away from the inferno might have held on for a few seconds longer. Enough to maybe make the building fall a bit more messy-like..don't ya think? Heck I watch all these WWII documentaries where they bomb the be jezus out of whole cities and the damn buildings just don't want to come down all at once. That WTC7 I tell ya was mighty cooperative. Looked nice and neat on TV. I'll bet the demolition companies are worried, maybe have to lower their rates now that folks know how easy their job really is.

Yup, I look forward to seeing those animations, drawings, whatever that you good JREF skeptics will provide that once and for all will put the nail in the coffin for this thread.

You's good people keeping the dream alive the way ya do.

MM
 
Last edited:
bla bla bla


MM

And we'll be waiting for you to actually present evidence.

Please do not alter other people's words. If you use the quote function, keep the wording the poster used.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LibraryLady
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I see life in the sandbox has changed little.

There is a very effective way to prove that a 47-story concrete and steel building could perform a total, high speed, symmetrical (after the penthouse falls) near footprint collapse due to natural causes, because of a bit of debris damage (the infamous gouge and corner) and and a few waste cans on fire (ya ya the firefighters said it was fully involved..I saw all the smoke..ya guess they were right.)

One of the clever people here just has to make an animation illustrating how the building was fired up like a forge from hell, showing WTC 1 had all but ripped the sucker to shreds from debris fall at 10:28 a.m. and that the only unusual aspect to the collapse was that it didn't happen at an odder time like say 5:15 p.m on Dec 3rd, 2078.

I mean what's with these natural collapses happening at scheduled-like times. 09:58 a.m., 10:28 a.m. and then 5:20 p.m...damn coincidences.

You've got to admire the engineering that went into WTC 7. It's not easy to design a building with known vulnerabilties and still have it collapse like that.

Yeah they built it over a electrical substation. What fools they were. Any idiot knows no amount of engineering is going to stop a total, high speed, symmetrical collapse once those horizontal trusses fail from all the ignited butane lighters folks dropped while abandoning the building. Yeah I know, there was lots and lots of diesel fuel, enough no doubt to power the whole U.S. of A. for a couple of weeks. Too bad we have no proof that it actually burned.

What I want to see in this animation..or is cartoon a better description? Simpsons comes to mind..whatever, is all the firefighters pointing at those, what was it 8 maybe 9 windows with billowing flames and concluding "that building is coming down!". "Hear that creaking?..That building is coming down!..What was that? The chief said "that building is coming down!"

Well that building did come down by jove.

Don't get me wrong, I have the deepest respect for the NYFD 'rank 'n file' members. Their management people?..well don't get me going.

I am hoping this JREF animation will show how all the supporting columns gave way at the same time? Gravy would be a good guy to direct this. He could convince anyone that a naked lady was dressed to the nines.

I'm really curious about how all those columns so slickly failed in agreement, cuz geez that sucker was level when she dropped. You woulda thought some of the columns away from the inferno might have held on for a few seconds longer. Enough to maybe make the building fall a bit more messy-like..don't ya think? Heck I watch all these WWII documentaries where they bomb the be jezus out of whole cities and the damn buildings just don't want to come down all at once. That WTC7 I tell ya was mighty cooperative. Looked nice and neat on TV. I'll bet the demolition companies are worried, maybe have to lower their rates now that folks know how easy their job really is.

Yup, I look forward to seeing those animations, drawings, whatever that you good JREF skeptics will provide that once and for all will put the nail in the coffin for this thread.

You's good people keeping the dream alive the way ya do.

MM

Well, that was certainly a coherent post. Friday night happy hour?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom