10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't know Chris, I just know that it will cause a bending stress and loss of function in the column.
You don't know that.
No one knows that because it has never happened.
It's just a theory that hasn't been tested yet.

How's about that time it would take to heat up the column, got that yet?
Not yet.

If you read up on this you will see that he first thing to go in such a column would be the welds which would reduce the stability of the column. You know, that part you <snip> in your post.
NIST L-40
Welds reach yield strength at 600 deg C

uniform steel temperatures of approximately 570 ºC would result in column failure.
 
You don't know that.
No one knows that because it has never happened.
It's just a theory that hasn't been tested yet.
I know there will be a bending stress on the column, basic physics says there would be. I know that if a column is bent then the load will no longer be directed through the column properly and therfore it will no longer function as designed.



NIST L-40
Welds reach yield strength at 600 deg C

uniform steel temperatures of approximately 570 ºC would result in column failure.

NIST, from the part you wish to ignore:
Quote:
Analysis of a one-story segment of interior column 79 indicates that the cover plate weld would begin to yield at a mean temperature of 490 °C with a 200 °C gradient across the section,

The reason the welds fail before 600o is that there is a lateral stress accompanying the loss of strength due to heating. The reason the column would fail at a lower temp than in uniform heating is that in uniform heating there would be no accompanying lateral stress due to bending that would occur during a non-uniform heating.

If the weld fails then more heat can attack the inner portion of the column thus increasing the heat transfer to the central "I" of the column.

You are correct that fire tests , under load , of a non-uniform heating of columns such as the one that made up column 79 of WTC 7 have not been conducted. However, NIST would have used basic physical laws in their computer analysis. If you wish to doubt their analysis then post a rebuttal of it. I know you will say you are not qualified to do so but surely, given that this is included in the WTC 7 interim report, someone has done so in the CT world. After all, you get so bent out of shape (pun not intended until I realised I had made one) about the inclusion of the possibility of diesel fires, and that is roundly pooh-poohed by the CT community, so I am sure someone has noticed this comment about temp gradients and the effect on columns.
 
Last edited:
As I said:
Part of a fire investigation is getting a handle on fuel loads. The fuel load in office space is well known within a certain range.
There was another fuel source in the building. NIST would have to, as a proper matter of course in a fire inestigation, look into the deisel fuel as a source of fuel in the building's fires. To do this they would not, should not simply say that there was deisel in the building and therefore it was on fire and contributing to the heat. In FACT they did not do that. They did what was proper and prudent and determined what would have to occur in order for that deisel fuel to be involved. Only then can one determine how likely it was that the deisel fuel was indeed involved in the fires. Some evidence suggests that it may have been(missing fuel) while others suggest it was not involved.
You are getting the reports mixed up.

FEMA investigated the possibility of diesel fuel fires in the NE generator room, on the 5th floor, and concluded:
Although the total diesel fuel on the premises contained massive potential energy, the best hypothesis has only a low probability of occurrence.

Tell me again that this is misleading and how so?
The FEMA statement is not misleading.

The NIST statement is misleading.

NIST knew from the FEMA report that there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in the NE generator room.

The fire time line in NIST L established the absence of fire on floor 5.

From 11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.:
• No diesel smells reported from the exterior, stairwells, or lobby areas
• No signs of fire or smoke were reported below the 6th Floor from the exterior, stairwells or lobby areas


Despite the fact that there was a low probability, and no evidence of diesel fuel fires in the NE generator room.

The reason for including:
"The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5."

in the summary is:
"Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows."

The NE generator room had vent louvers which would be open if the generators were running.

How likely did NIST say it was that the deisel was involved?
Well in the interim report all they say is

2. Fires were observed after the collapse of WTC 1. Fires were observed after 2 pm on Floors 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, and 13. Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows. The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5.

Certainly not a rousing indication of support for the idea.
Then it should not have been included in the summary.

This has led many people to think that diesel fuel fires contributed to the implosion of WTC 7.
 
You are getting the reports mixed up.
Apparently so. My slip.



The NIST statement is misleading.

NIST knew from the FEMA report that there was a low probability of diesel fuel fires in the NE generator room.

The fire time line in NIST L established the absence of fire on floor 5.

From 11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.:
• No diesel smells reported from the exterior, stairwells, or lobby areas
• No signs of fire or smoke were reported below the 6th Floor from the exterior, stairwells or lobby areas


Despite the fact that there was a low probability, and no evidence of diesel fuel fires in the NE generator room.

The reason for including:
"The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5."

in the summary is:
"Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows."

The NE generator room had vent louvers which would be open if the generators were running.

Then it should not have been included in the summary.

This has led many people to think that diesel fuel fires contributed to the implosion of WTC 7

You are telling me that two sentences, in a 50 page report, in which NIST mentions the existance of diesel fuel and the possibility that maybe it was on fire but unseen is your evidence that NIST was being deliberativly deceptive and out to convince people that there was a very real possibility of a diesel fule fire. That about sum it up Chris7?
 
The generators did not have to be running for the make-up system to detect a pressure drop and start pumping. That part of the system was independent and had a battery system.

Which introduces another interesting senario.
The pumps detect a loss of pressure and start pumping which then creates a pool of fuel at the area of the crack in the pipe, possibly in the generator room. That fuel remains there, the door is closed and no one smells diesel fuel especially in the smoky, dusty enviroment surrounding the WTC complex. Several hours later and after continuing mass shifts in the building due to the fires and debris damage, a crack occurs in the walls of the generator room and the fumes find an ignition source, it explodes and further damages the coulmns next to the generator room. This is the last straw for these columns and they collapse starting at the 12th floor where they are already weakened by the fires, the vibration and shift at the generator level causing the column to give out at the 12th floor.

Now Chris is going to shout "impossible" and piss and moan about this, but of course saying it is "impossible" would simply be hyperbole from Mr.7 Unlikely perhaps, improbable maybe, but within the realm of possibility. What separates it from the possibility of CD is that we know for a fact that diesel fuel existed in the building. That is something we do not know in regards to explosives.

We know also that some fuel cannot be accounted for. It is possible that the fuel line cracked further west either at the impact of the debris or later due to shifting loads as a result of the fires and continuing pieces of WTC 7 structure that was falling off. This in turn causing a fire there right away, or pooling and igniting later, in either case it would lead to a further weakening of the structure and a pull to the west on the core.

Chris7 just wants to write off the diesel fuel as not in any way being involved. Of course he does though, he has to ignore any and all senarios in which the building could have collapsed without explosives.
 
I know there will be a bending stress on the column, basic physics says there would be. I know that if a column is bent then the load will no longer be directed through the column properly and therfore it will no longer function as designed.
Bent how much?

This is a theory that has not been tested.

There will be some distortion with uneven heating .

You have no idea how much that would be or what effect it would have.

NIST, from the part you wish to ignore:
Analysis of a one-story segment of interior column 79 indicates that the cover plate weld would begin to yield at a mean temperature of 490 °C with a 200 °C gradient across the section, as shown in Fig. L–38.

The 200ºC gradient goes from 400ºC to 600ºC.
The cover plate weld on the 600ºC side will begin to fail.

The reason the welds fail before 600o is that there is a lateral stress accompanying the loss of strength due to heating. The reason the column would fail at a lower temp than in uniform heating is that in uniform heating there would be no accompanying lateral stress due to bending that would occur during a non-uniform heating.
Good point

You are correct that fire tests , under load , of a non-uniform heating of columns such as the one that made up column 79 of WTC 7 have not been conducted. However, NIST would have used basic physical laws in their computer analysis.
And they concluded that the splice welds would fail at approximately 600ºC.
 
What's a theory ? That bent columns do not perform as designed ?
http://www.fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire07/PDF/f07021.pdf

page 45 [57 on pg counter]
As illustrated in Figure 17, non-uniform heating can be full height, but incomplete fire exposure of entire column section contour or a partial height exposure of some or all the section contour. Loaded column tests with non-uniform heating are expected to show asymmetric structural response and failure mechanisms that are not obviated from the currently unloaded, uniformly-critical E 119 temperature tests with their idealized conditions.
page 46
Provision for investigating loaded column and wall response under non-uniform fire exposure should be studied, as this may be a more severe condition than uniform heating.
 
OH! Miragememories. You're a sight for sore eyes.

Oh, look. He's trying to sound like a lawyer. How cute.

And he's doing a very, very poor job of it. It appears that he spends too much of his time watching crappy courtroom drama television shows. He's Canadian, and no real trial lawyer in Canada would ever in a thousand years say, "I move to strike that question..."

Pfft.

But then what more can one expect from a guy who can't tell the difference between a 6 storey building and an 18 storey building, and who thinks that both the 6 storey building and the 18 storey building are actually 22 storey buildings?
 
You are telling me that two sentences, in a 50 page report, in which NIST mentions the existance of diesel fuel and the possibility that maybe it was on fire but unseen is your evidence that NIST was being deliberativly deceptive and out to convince people that there was a very real possibility of a diesel fule fire. That about sum it up Chris7?
To list it as the second item in the summary is to suggest diesel fuel fires had something to do with the initiating event.

FEMA said there was a low probability and there is no evidence of fire on floor 5 at any time.
 
http://www.fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire07/PDF/f07021.pdf

page 45 [57 on pg counter]
As illustrated in Figure 17, non-uniform heating can be full height, but incomplete fire exposure of entire column section contour or a partial height exposure of some or all the section contour. Loaded column tests with non-uniform heating are expected to show asymmetric structural response and failure mechanisms that are not obviated from the currently unloaded, uniformly-critical E 119 temperature tests with their idealized conditions.
page 46
Provision for investigating loaded column and wall response under non-uniform fire exposure should be studied, as this may be a more severe condition than uniform heating.

I noticed you didn't answer my question, Chris...
 
[FONT=&quot]
The generators did not have to be running for the make-up system to detect a pressure drop and start pumping. That part of the system was independent and had a battery system.
You are right.*

FEMA 5-15
The pump then operated in response to the pressure difference between the supply and return, and the pump would circulate oil as long as such a difference existed.

However, this system would have to fail.
5-13
The volume between the inner and outer pipes was designed to contain a leak from the inner pressurized pipe and direct that fuel oil to a containment vessel. Upon detection of fuel oil in the containment vessel, the fuel oil pumps automatically de-energized.

*I have made the necessary correction to my summary. Thank you.


[/FONT]
 
The containment vessel was in all probability not large enough to contain the whole volume of fuel. Such containment systems do not expect a severed pipe but a leak or crack as might form when the building moves over a period of years due to diurnal heating and wind load.
 
Explosions and explosion witnesses on Youtube

A few witnesses state that they heard explosions during the collapse. One could expect loud banging and booming noises from any collapse.
The countdown story is unconfirmed at best and frankly , laughable.

Detonations were heard over an extended period of time before the collapse. Some of the witnesses were still in the building when they heard the explosions.

Please watch this 10-minute video and explain:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dzUNvEfYDEQ

It has about two dozen witnesses relating the explosions they heard. You can also hear several explosions yourself, for instance at 4:30-4:45. There is also a witness telling how he overheard the WTC 7 countdown over a radio, at the 6:26 mark. At 6:10 a witness tells how an explosion "blew us back onto the 8th floor." See also a group of firemen describing the detonations at the 4 minute mark. There is also network news footage of people on the scene, reporters, fire department spokesmen, talking about secondary explosions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom