10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
What's up with your post occurring exactly at 11:12 am in my time zone?

Coincidence? I think not.

I'll be anywhere in the world it would still end in '12'!

Another coincidence? I think not.

I confess. I pushed all 3 plungers!

There. Ya got your confession and we got our proof of an inside job!

MM
 
Originally Posted by Miragememories
I mean what's with these natural collapses happening at scheduled-like times. 09:58 a.m., 10:28 a.m. and then 5:20 p.m...damn coincidences.

Reminds me of the time I was told that the Imperial measurement system made much more sense since, for instance, the speed of light is 186000 miles per second whereas in metric it is 299 792 458 m / s and that is such an odd number.

So the first two nominally occured 30 minutes apart and the collapse of WTC 7 occured 6 hours and 52 minutes (if my quick calc is right) later. What makes these schedule-like times especially given the odd amount of time between impacts and collapses of the towers? I thought it was supposed to be suspect that WTC 2 collapsed first?

You make this up as you go along don't you MM? Dosen't really matter if what you state makes any sense at all, right?
 
Jaydeehess are you suggesting that MM makes things up as he goes along?

NOOOOOO! Say it isn't so!!!
 
There is no evidence of diesel fuel fires or reason to believe they existed in the area of the initiating event.

Including diesel fuel fire as a possibility has mislead many people into thinking it was a factor in the collapse.

The diesel fuel existed and represented a large possible fuel load. To ignore it would be derilict and taking it into account would require investigating some method by which it would get employed in the fire. To not do so would be derilict.
Seems to me that NIST says that the probability of the senario they came up being true, is low. What more did you want them to do. Print in bold red letters that the probability was , at the time of the initial reports, low?

If the final report presents data to explain how DD/F brought down WTC 7, i will review it and the independent assessment.

Who do you have in mind? I trust its not Judy Woods.

In the mean time, the list of qualified persons refuting the NIST report and calling for an independent investigation is long and growing.

Are you speaking specifically of the WTC 7 interim report?
There are persons who have points of contention with aspects of various NIST reports concerning the destruction on 9/11/01 AND who do not believe in CD in any building nor believe that anything other than hijacked aircraft commandeered by Islamic extremists caused the destruction.

There were fires on floors 8, 11, 12 and 13 in the area where the implosion began.

Yeah, I got that.

There were similar fires in the Meridian plaza on 8 contiguous floors.
Despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.

A building that was more conventional in design and which had suffered not other physical damage prior to the fire.

Although you repeatedly quote that idea that heating uniformly would require big fires and high temps in order to cause a collapse of a column and although I gave you a chance to mention that temp gradients could have an effect you refuse to acknowledge it.
From the WTC 7 interim report:

I4.5 Temperature Gradients: Fire effects may have caused the failure of columns and other components through the forces induced by temperature gradients through their cross section. Bending and shear forces may be induced that are sufficient to
yield either the column splice or reinforcing plate welds. Analysis of a one-story segment of interior column 79 indicates that the cover plate weld would begin to yield at a mean temperature of 490 °C with a 200 °C gradient across the section, as shown in Fig. L–38. Other mean temperature and gradient combinations may also cause this type of failure
 
The diesel fuel existed and represented a large possible fuel load. To ignore it would be derilict and taking it into account would require investigating some method by which it would get employed in the fire. To not do so would be derilict.
There was no reason to think there were diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room.
Pipes would have broken where the damage was, not the other end of the building.
FEMA Figure 5-19 shows there is no smoke coming from the NE generator room.

Seems to me that NIST says that the probability of the senario they came up being true, is low. What more did you want them to do. Print in bold red letters that the probability was , at the time of the initial reports, low?
FEMA 5-29
[FONT=&quot]The following is, therefore, a hypothesis based on potential rather than demonstrated fact.[/FONT]

FEMA 5-31
"Although the total diesel fuel on the premises contained massive potential energy, the best hypothesis has only a low probability of occurrence."

In addition to that, NIST knew there were no fires in that area.


NIST L-22
From 11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.:
• No diesel smells reported from the exterior, stairwells, or lobby areas
• No signs of fire or smoke were reported below the 6th Floor from the exterior, stairwells or lobby areas

NIST L-26 [sometime after 3]
• The fire on Floor 8 continued to move east on the north face, eventually reaching the northeast corner and moving to the east face.
[no fire on floor 5 reported]

Yet they list it in their summary.


NIST L-51
2. Fires were observed after the collapse of WTC 1. Fires were observed after 2 pm on Floors 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, and 13. Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows. The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5.


The possibility of diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room had been investigated and there is no evidence to support this hypothesis.

The evidence points the other way.

There was NO probability of diesel fuel fires in that area.

Common sense tells us that the pipes would have fractured in or near the SW generator room where the damage was, not at the other end of the building.
 
A building that was more conventional in design
So what?
WTC 7 had fewer columns carrying a greater load and they were sized accordingly, much stronger and heavier.
The greater the mass, the longer it takes to heat it up.

and which had suffered not other physical damage prior to the fire.
Forsooth, the area of the initiating event suffered not other physical damage prior to the pyre.
 
So what?
WTC 7 had fewer columns carrying a greater load and they were sized accordingly, much stronger and heavier.
The greater the mass, the longer it takes to heat it up.

Forsooth, the area of the initiating event suffered not other physical damage prior to the pyre.

Chris, sorry if you've already answered the following question but after nearly 4000 posts I tend to lose track of such details. Do you have any experience or training in structural engineering? If so, what is the extent of that experience or training?
 
Chris, sorry if you've already answered the following question but after nearly 4000 posts I tend to lose track of such details. Do you have any experience or training in structural engineering? If so, what is the extent of that experience or training?

I move to strike that question as it is irrelevant and immaterial.

The Rules of the JREF Forums require that you challenge content and not the person presenting the content.

If you can find errors in Chris's factual presentation I such that is what you focus on.

MM
 
… you repeatedly quote that idea that heating uniformly would require big fires and high temps in order to cause a collapse of a column …...

From the WTC 7 interim report:
I4.5 Temperature Gradients: Fire effects may have caused the failure of columns and other components through the forces induced by temperature gradients through their cross section. Bending and shear forces may be induced that are sufficient to
yield either the column splice or reinforcing plate welds. Analysis of a one-story segment of interior column 79 indicates that the cover plate weld would begin to yield at a mean temperature of 490 °C with a 200 °C gradient across the section, as shown in Fig. L–38. Other mean temperature and gradient combinations may also cause this type of failure
http://www.fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire07/PDF/f07021.pdf

page 45-46 (actual page #)
As illustrated in Figure 17, non-uniform heating can be full height, but incomplete fire exposure of entire column section contour or a partial height exposure of some or all the section contour. Loaded column tests with non-uniform heating are expected to show asymmetric structural response and failure mechanisms that are not obviated from the currently unloaded, uniformly-critical E 119 temperature tests with their idealized conditions.
<<snip>>
Provision for investigating loaded column and wall response under non-uniform fire exposure should be studied, as this may be a more severe condition than uniform heating.

It is reasonable to expect an asymmetrical response to asymmetrical fires.
The question remains:

How much would that be in a column of the size and shape of columns 79, 80 and 81?
How much bend could occur in 12 feet?
 
Fig L-22b seems to show quite well the ragged edge and missing parts of the building which would seem to me leads us to the conclusion that the Zafar photo is the one with seeming anomolies?

This could be due to the different view angle as has already been mentioned

either that or Nist have faked another photo?

What is your take on Fig L-22b C7?
I don't think the different angle could explain the difference in damage.

L-22a nd L-22b appear to agree with each other.


l22al22bzafarvv0.png


However

There are the fires on floors 22 and 30

74830165qh3.png

4th window from corner on floor 30 is intact

2cropvd7.png

4th window from corner on floor 30 still intact
1/2 of first window on floor 22 is broken and smoke is coming out

55446298pw4.jpg

4th window from corner on floor has 30 burned out
First 2 windows on floor 22 have burned out

69703016yj4.jpg

Floor 22 is on fire again on the west face

63908760hz6.jpg

Floor 22 is still on fire on the west face

timegraphicmj1.jpg
 
Last edited:
I see life in the sandbox has changed little.

There is a very effective way to prove that a 47-story concrete and steel building could perform a total, high speed, symmetrical (after the penthouse falls) near footprint collapse due to natural causes, because of a bit of debris damage (the infamous gouge and corner) and and a few waste cans on fire (ya ya the firefighters said it was fully involved..I saw all the smoke..ya guess they were right.)

One of the clever people here just has to make an animation illustrating how the building was fired up like a forge from hell, showing WTC 1 had all but ripped the sucker to shreds from debris fall at 10:28 a.m. and that the only unusual aspect to the collapse was that it didn't happen at an odder time like say 5:15 p.m on Dec 3rd, 2078.

I mean what's with these natural collapses happening at scheduled-like times. 09:58 a.m., 10:28 a.m. and then 5:20 p.m...damn coincidences.

You've got to admire the engineering that went into WTC 7. It's not easy to design a building with known vulnerabilties and still have it collapse like that.

Yeah they built it over a electrical substation. What fools they were. Any idiot knows no amount of engineering is going to stop a total, high speed, symmetrical collapse once those horizontal trusses fail from all the ignited butane lighters folks dropped while abandoning the building. Yeah I know, there was lots and lots of diesel fuel, enough no doubt to power the whole U.S. of A. for a couple of weeks. Too bad we have no proof that it actually burned.

What I want to see in this animation..or is cartoon a better description? Simpsons comes to mind..whatever, is all the firefighters pointing at those, what was it 8 maybe 9 windows with billowing flames and concluding "that building is coming down!". "Hear that creaking?..That building is coming down!..What was that? The chief said "that building is coming down!"

Well that building did come down by jove.

Don't get me wrong, I have the deepest respect for the NYFD 'rank 'n file' members. Their management people?..well don't get me going.

I am hoping this JREF animation will show how all the supporting columns gave way at the same time? Gravy would be a good guy to direct this. He could convince anyone that a naked lady was dressed to the nines.

I'm really curious about how all those columns so slickly failed in agreement, cuz geez that sucker was level when she dropped. You woulda thought some of the columns away from the inferno might have held on for a few seconds longer. Enough to maybe make the building fall a bit more messy-like..don't ya think? Heck I watch all these WWII documentaries where they bomb the be jezus out of whole cities and the damn buildings just don't want to come down all at once. That WTC7 I tell ya was mighty cooperative. Looked nice and neat on TV. I'll bet the demolition companies are worried, maybe have to lower their rates now that folks know how easy their job really is.

Yup, I look forward to seeing those animations, drawings, whatever that you good JREF skeptics will provide that once and for all will put the nail in the coffin for this thread.

You's good people keeping the dream alive the way ya do.

MM

OH! Miragememories. You're a sight for sore eyes.

And you're back with stundie-worthy posts, too!

I move to strike that question as it is irrelevant and immaterial.

The Rules of the JREF Forums require that you challenge content and not the person presenting the content.

If you can find errors in Chris's factual presentation I such that is what you focus on.

MM

Oh, look. He's trying to sound like a lawyer. How cute.
 
Last edited:
http://www.fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire07/PDF/f07021.pdf

page 45-46 (actual page #)
As illustrated in Figure 17, non-uniform heating can be full height, but incomplete fire exposure of entire column section contour or a partial height exposure of some or all the section contour. Loaded column tests with non-uniform heating are expected to show asymmetric structural response and failure mechanisms that are not obviated from the currently unloaded, uniformly-critical E 119 temperature tests with their idealized conditions.
<<snip>>
Provision for investigating loaded column and wall response under non-uniform fire exposure should be studied, as this may be a more severe condition than uniform heating.

It is reasonable to expect an asymmetrical response to asymmetrical fires.
The question remains:

How much would that be in a column of the size and shape of columns 79, 80 and 81?
How much bend could occur in 12 feet?

I don't know Chris, I just know that it will cause a bending stress and loss of function in the column. How's about that time it would take to heat up the column, got that yet?

If you read up on this you will see that he first thing to go in such a column would be the welds which would reduce the stability of the column. You know, that part you <snip> in your post.
Analysis of a one-story segment of interior column 79 indicates that the cover plate weld would begin to yield at a mean temperature of 490 °C with a 200 °C gradient across the section,

There was no reason to think there were diesel fuel fires in or near the NE generator room.
Pipes would have broken where the damage was, not the other end of the building.
FEMA Figure 5-19 shows there is no smoke coming from the NE generator room.

They listed possibilities. It is to be determined in the final report what probability should be attached to each. At the strident urging of the CT community they also are including the possibility of blast events in the final report, a matter that likely has had something to do with the delay in its completion.

The diesel fuel existed and represented a large possible fuel load. To ignore it would be derilict and taking it into account would require investigating some method by which it would get employed in the fire. To not do so would be derilict.

Seems that all you think NIST should have investigated is the possibility that explosives wee used.:boggled:
 
As I said:
Quote:
They listed possibilities. It is to be determined in the final report what probability should be attached to each. At the strident urging of the CT community they also are including the possibility of blast events in the final report, a matter that likely has had something to do with the delay in its completion.
Quote:
The diesel fuel existed and represented a large possible fuel load. To ignore it would be derilict and taking it into account would require investigating some method by which it would get employed in the fire. To not do so would be derilict.

Part of a fire investigation is getting a handle on fuel loads. The fuel load in office space is well known within a certain range.

There was another fuel source in the building. NIST would have to, as a proper matter of course in a fire inestigation, look into the deisel fuel as a source of fuel in the building's fires. To do this they would not, should not simply say that there was deisel in the building and therefore it was on fire and contributing to the heat. In FACT they did not do that. They did what was proper and prudent and determined what would have to occur in order for that deisel fuel to be involved. Only then can one determine how likely it was that the deisel fuel was indeed involved in the fires. Some evidence suggests that it may have been(missing fuel) while others suggest it was not involved.
How likely did NIST say it was that the deisel was involved?

Well in the interim report all they say is
2. Fires were observed after the collapse of WTC 1. Fires were observed after 2 pm on Floors 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, and 13. Fires were not observed on Floor 5, but this may be due to the lack of windows. The presence of a fuel distribution system and the possibility of damage at the south face from WTC 1 debris impact, indicates that fires may have been present on Floor 5.

Certainly not a rousing indication of support for the idea.

What did FEMA say?
Although the total diesel fuel on the premises contained massive poitential energy, the best hypothesis has only a low probability of occurance.

Tell me again that this is misleading and how so?
 
Well, the fuel DID go somewhere. The storage tank was found to be empty during site clearing, and the earth around the tank was not saturated with fuel.

Yes, and that is one piece of evidence to suggest that there was a diesel fuel fire. The reason a diesel fuel fire is put at a low probability is that several things had to occur that were seen as having a low probability of happening in order to have a diesel fuel fire. The missing fuel is a bit of empirical evidence that a diesel fuel fire of some manner did occur. It is not known where the fuel burned or if there was another manner by which it was not in the tank.

This is a wild goose strawman chase for Chris though. He uses it to try and throw suspicion of obfuscation at NIST/FEMA. He says that they state or imply or mislead people to believe that a diesel fuel fire was occuring near the initial failure point when in fact they do not say that and are very clear that they do not consider it, at the time of the writing of those reports, to be of a high probability, which is exactly what Chris is saying about a diesel fuel fire. Chris7 apparently is one of those people who has difficulty in taking 'yes' for an answer without looking under the bed for an ulterior motive.
 
Logically, the tank wasn't going to empty itself, and so the fuel would have had to be pumped out by the pumps that react to a pressure drop and refill the day tanks. And this does mean the fuel reached the fifth floor.

But yes we cannot PROVE that there was a fuel fire.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom