10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
If we had a society free of indoctrination and intimidation, the speed of fall alone would be enough to convince everyone it was a CD, and to indict a lot of suspects, too.

Um, no. The length of time it took for the building to fall is not even suspicious, let alone enough to convince any rational person that it was a controlled demolition, and most certainly not even remotely close to being enough to indict anyone. Spouting nonsense on subjects about which you have no knowledge does not promote your cause in a positive fashion.

Never mind all this other verbiage. It doesn't cut one piece of steel.

What you call "all this other verbiage", rational people call facts and evidence.

Just answer this one killer question. While keeping the rules of physics intact too, of course.

What "killer question" is that? I don't see one.

And, while I'm here, I will reiterate this prior post to which you did not respond:

t looks like you deliberately missed my point. In fact, it looks like you just chose the nearest sentence to quote, without bothering to read the post, so that you could then jump in head first with the standard cut and paste twoofer CD nonsense that has been completely refuted here numerous times before.

All of the items on your list have been discussed here before. You could easily do a search for threads on those subjects, were you interested in learning rather than just cutting and pasting from the usual twoofer sites/suspects.

Should you conduct that search, in addition to learning about the very topics you raised in your post, you will likely also find some useful explanations of how to avoid the logical fallacies that you have employed, and you will, without a doubt, be exposed to the scientific method, critical thinking, and analytical thinking in action, all of which you could benefit from immensely, should you choose to try your hand at them.

Please do consider it, and good luck.
 
Please tell us, while keeping your dogma of the 911 big lie intact, how the buildings could come down at the speed of a fall through air?

Never mind all this other verbiage. It doesn't cut one piece of steel. Just answer this one killer question. While keeping the rules of physics intact too, of course.

OK, let's look at the rules of physics. I posted this with some errors on another thread, but newtons bit was kind enough to point out the amount of energy expended in inelastic deformation, so I think it's about right now.

Suppose a building starts to fall, for whatever reason. Let's not get hung up on the reason for collapse initiation, because that has nothing to do with your question. A complete floor's worth of support columns has, for some reason, broken, and the building falls till the next floor up hits either the next floor down or the ground. What are the forces on the falling building?

For a fall through one storey height, the force is -mg, where positive force is defined as upwards. Net acceleration is -g.

When the building hits the next floor, the columns of that floor can exert an upwards force. This force causes the columns to shorten elastically up to about 0.2% of their original length, at which point they start to buckle. Hooke's law tells us that the force exerted by an elastically compressed body is directly proportional to its compression, so the force exerted upwards by the columns increases linearly from zero to the failure load over this 0.2% compression. If we assume a safety factor of three (i.e. each column is able to support three times the weight of the building above it), then the average upward force over this stage is half the force (3mg) at the point of failure, giving 1.5mg. We also have gravitational force of -mg, so the net force is +0.5mg and the net acceleration is +0.5g. This will slow the falling block, therefore, by about 0.1% of the speed with which it hit the lower floor.

Next, the columns buckle inelastically. Newtons bit tells me that this dissipates about ten times the energy of the elastic shortening phase and continues until the column is shortened by about 3%, at which point it fractures and can no longer exert any upward force. During the inelastic shortening phase, the average upward force exerted is therefore (10 x 1.5 x 0.002) / 0.03 = mg (ratio of energy expended x average force in the elastic phase / ratio of distances travelled in the two phases). The gravitational force is still -mg, so the average net force on the falling block in this phase is zero; the falling block continues to fall at the same speed. [1]

After the columns fracture, the only force on the falling block is -mg, so it then accelerates at -g for the remaining 97% of the fall until the point the next floor hits the ground.

So we have a net force on the falling block over 0.2% of the distance of +0.5g, over another 3% of zero, and over the remaining 96.8% of -g. The average acceleration is therefore g x (-0.968 + 0.5 x 0.002) = 0.967g.

WTC7 was 186m tall. With g=9.81ms-2, we have a fall time in freefall of sqrt ( 2 x h / g ), which gives 6.16 seconds. Allowing for the resistance of the columns, we have t = sqrt (2 x h / 0.967g ), which gives 6.26 seconds. The resistance of the columns alone is expected to add about 0.1 second to the collapse time. That's not a difference you could measure from any of the collapse videos, so it looks like it fell in the same time as freefall.

I've answered your killer question while keeping the laws of physics intact. Are you happy now?

Dave

[1] This explains, of course, why the building continued to fall. The force exerted by the columns on a falling mass is nowhere near enough or exerted for long enough to bring it to a halt. If it doesn't get stopped by the first impact, it's travelling even faster at the second, and so on down.
 
Why do people say the event defied the laws of physics when it most certainly does not? Except for a few either dubiously biased or dubiously credentialed scientists, the vast majority of physicists don't think so; why would somebody discount their opinions to parrot a few kooks?
 
Why do people say the event defied the laws of physics when it most certainly does not? Except for a few either dubiously biased or dubiously credentialed scientists, the vast majority of physicists don't think so; why would somebody discount their opinions to parrot a few kooks?

Because, apart from Steven E. Jones and what's-his-face that tried to suggest that the top of WTC2 could have fallen a whole storey without bending most of the support columns, all the physicists in the world are terrified of being quietly murdered by the CIA for outing the conspiracy, so none of us have the guts to stand up and state what we know to be true. For a profession that includes Andrei Sakharov, I find that a bit of a stretch.

Dave
 
Because, apart from Steven E. Jones and what's-his-face that tried to suggest that the top of WTC2 could have fallen a whole storey without bending most of the support columns, all the physicists in the world are terrified of being quietly murdered by the CIA for outing the conspiracy, so none of us have the guts to stand up and state what we know to be true. For a profession that includes Andrei Sakharov, I find that a bit of a stretch.

Well it IS true that the vast majority of relevant experts in the world care more about their jobs and tenure than exposing mass murder of thousands of innocent people.

I guess that explains it. ;)
 
The corner column is clearly there on floors 17 and 16 in the screen cap i posted. The broken off edge of the wall, as you call it, is the corner column. If the corner column was gone, it would have taken part of the south wall with it and there would be a ragged edge, not the straight edge that we see.

The photo you posted is not as clear as the one i posted. That might be the corner column on [about] floor 12 but it's hard to say.
The NIST photos shows the corner and the first windows are gone on floors 11, 12 and 13.

Fig L-22b seems to show quite well the ragged edge and missing parts of the building which would seem to me leads us to the conclusion that the Zafr photo is the one with seeming anomolies?

This could be due to the different view angle as has already been mentioned

either that or Nist have faked another photo?

What is your take on Fig L-22b C7?
 
If we had a society free of indoctrination and intimidation, the speed of fall alone would be enough to convince everyone it was a CD, and to indict a lot of suspects, too.

Really? Who would be indicted by this supposed evidence republicus? Names please.

It has been pointed outto you on several occasions that the rate of fall ("speed" of fall is bad science since the speed was not constant) is not out of line with a collapse. Why do you continue to harp away that it is?
 
If we had a society free of indoctrination and intimidation, the speed of fall alone would be enough to convince everyone it was a CD, and to indict a lot of suspects, too.

We obviously do not have such a free-thinking forum.

Speaking of free thinking, why did you reply with such an oft-used tactic ? Accusing others of being close-minded instead of answering their points.

That speed of fall was only possible if the doors were opened, if the support columns were instantaneously severed.

You don't know much about physics, do you ?

No 911 Big Liar yet has come up with an alternative explanation - for the simple reason there isn't one. It's the only way to do it.

Come on 911 liars. We truthers are open minded. Please tell us, while keeping your dogma of the 911 big lie intact, how the buildings could come down at the speed of a fall through air?

Maybe because they were falling through air.

Oh, no, wait. They DIDN'T fall at that speed, so your question is irrelevant.
 
WTC7 was 186m tall. With g=9.81ms-2, we have a fall time in freefall of sqrt ( 2 x h / g ), which gives 6.16 seconds. Allowing for the resistance of the columns, we have t = sqrt (2 x h / 0.967g ), which gives 6.26 seconds. The resistance of the columns alone is expected to add about 0.1 second to the collapse time.

Just as an update: The above is averaged over distance, not time. I wanted to average it over time but the numbers got a bit, well, numerous, so I ended up putting the whole thing into a spreadsheet. From that, I got a rather more refined collapse time of 6.24 seconds counting column resistance alone. This is a simplified model, in that the only assumption it makes about weight and column strength is that the demand-to-capacity ratio of the support columns is constant for every floor; in practice it would be expected to vary, as the column thickness is not tapered continuously for higher floors but instead uses a limited number of sections of reducing cross-sectional area, but I think it's not a bad first approximation.

In a spreadsheet, of course, it's easy to vary specific parameters, so I took a quick look at how the collapse time varies with the factor of safety. A factor of ten still gives a collapse time less than the commonly quoted 6.5 seconds, so unless WTC7 was able to support more than ten times its own weight, there's nothing at all surprising about the collapse time.

There will be a couple of other factors to consider, mainly the conservation of momentum from the fact that the falling mass had to accelerate the lower floors up to its falling speed. However, for WTC7 this is a much smaller term than the twin towers, because the main collapse started low down and hence the mass of the upper block was a much greater proportion of the whole. Overall, 6.5 seconds or so looks like a very sensible time for a gravity-driven collapse.

Dave
 
Basically what occurs when a CT speaks about the collapse time is that they calculate the time of fall of a dense object (which would be very very close to the fall in a vaccum) and then compare that to the estimated time of collapse of the perimeter of WTC 7.

The two numbers are close and therefore this tweaks personal incredulity in people like our own republicus here. They then ignore any explanation that involves actual calculatons that show that the two number would indeed be close and that the free fall time always can be shown to be less than the collapse time. From there they advance to something akin to, " it could not be a natural collapse, therefore something aided collapse and therefore it must have been explosives". Of course the biggest problem with this is that they start from a position of personal incredulity that they will not shake even when shown their error.
 
Basically what occurs when a CT speaks about the collapse time is that they calculate the time of fall of a dense object (which would be very very close to the fall in a vaccum) and then compare that to the estimated time of collapse of the perimeter of WTC 7.

The two numbers are close and therefore this tweaks personal incredulity in people like our own republicus here. They then ignore any explanation that involves actual calculatons that show that the two number would indeed be close and that the free fall time always can be shown to be less than the collapse time. From there they advance to something akin to, " it could not be a natural collapse, therefore something aided collapse and therefore it must have been explosives". Of course the biggest problem with this is that they start from a position of personal incredulity that they will not shake even when shown their error.

And don't forget clunkity clunk.
 
Do you deny that even 570oC would severly compromise the strength of a column?
Meridian Plaza fire analysis:
Despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.

Cardington tests:

Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."


Read the last few paragraphs of the interim report again Chris. The part about further calculations.
Why don't you take your own advise and stop claiming that WTC 7 collapsed because of DD/F until NIST can explain how it happened.
They have only a hypothesis [a set of assumptions] that they admit, may not hold up.
"This hypothesis may be supported or modified, or new hypotheses may be developed, through the course of the continuing investigation."

The temp gradient across a thin cookie sheet would be minimal, accross a thick column it would be much greater.
How much could that difference be in a column of the size and shape of the columns 79, 80 and 81, given steel's ability do disperse heat rapidly?
How much bend could occur in 12 feet?

C7 said:
Any lateral stress to core columns in the west half of WTC 7 would be pulling primarily to the south.
jdh said:
South and west, the core failed and the progression was east to west.
The core columns at the east end of the building failed first.
NIST L-49 and 50 show Trusses 1 and 2 collapsing to the east, the opposite direction of the lateral pull you say contributed to the collapse.

each one of those 'limited fires' would have been considered a major fre by themselves.
They were not as extensive as the ones in the Meridian Plaza.

Now that was a limited fire and it occured in a pure post and beam structure that was completely intact at the outset of the fire.
It was a much bigger fire than the ones in WTC 7.
The area of the initiating event was completely intact.
The columns were much heavier and would take longer to heat up.
 
Christopher7;3047594 Why don't you take your own advise (sic) and stop claiming that WTC 7 collapsed because of DD/F until NIST can explain how it happened. They have only a hypothesis [a set of assumptions said:
that they admit, may not hold up.
"This hypothesis may be supported or modified, or new hypotheses may be developed, through the course of the continuing investigation."

Chris you never cease to amaze me with the things you write. We've been trying to tell you that for, what, 8000 posts? Now that you agree may we put this to rest until the report comes out?
 
Last edited:
Meridian Plaza fire analysis:
Despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.

Cardington tests:

Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."

Both structures fully intact at the outset, both structures not nearly as tall as WTC 7 , both structures of a less complex structural design.

Why don't you take your own advise and stop claiming that WTC 7 collapsed because of DD/F until NIST can explain how it happened.
They have only a hypothesis [a set of assumptions] that they admit, may not hold up.
"This hypothesis may be supported or modified, or new hypotheses may be developed, through the course of the continuing investigation."

As pointed out Chris we have wanted you to do just that for some time now. It is you who makes all the definitive statements about what DID bring down the building, about what could and could not occur.

How much could that difference be in a column of the size and shape of the columns 79, 80 and 81, given steel's ability do disperse heat rapidly?
How much bend could occur in 12 feet?

Gradient would be greater the bigger the column Chris. Its 1st year thermodynamics, take a course in it. The cookie sheet would dissapate heat faster than a thick column. Steel has a finite rate of conduction, it is greater than concrete but less than copper or aluminum.


The core columns at the east end of the building failed first.
NIST L-49 and 50 show Trusses 1 and 2 collapsing to the east, the opposite direction of the lateral pull you say contributed to the collapse.

Which only indicates where something let go. If this were a spring then it failed at the anchor point.

They were not as extensive as the ones in the Meridian Plaza.It was a much bigger fire than the ones in WTC 7.

Each fire was as hot as the Meridian fire.


The area of the initiating event was completely intact..

In all other fires the entire building was intact at the outset of the fire.

The columns were much heavier and would take longer to heat up

,,, and the fires in WTC 7 were moe extensive.
 
You might also notice that the thermal conductivity of steel is actually very low for a metal. "Steel's ability to disperse heat rapidly" is as much of a myth as anything else the truth movement has to say.

Dave

inaddition to iron and steel getting worse as the temp rises , as compared to the other metals listed over the three temps shown in the table. 13% less conductivity at a temp of 225C than it has at 25C.

Just by looking at the first few paragraphs of that web page it becomes obvious why heat sinks are made of copper or aluminum and why structural steel must have passive fire protection .

It was only one of many pages that came up with a google search for "heat transfer" + steel. Witha little more searching one could find steel's heat conductivity at temp of 500/600/700C but I know it will be even less than at 225C.
this illustrates that there is a point at which heat input will easily be greater than heat dissipation via conduction through the steel itself. Further adding to this is that in compartments that are on fire the insulation will degrade over the first hour whereas the compartments above and below the fire will still be well insulated. Thus the heat that is conducted to cooler areas, those compartments that are not on fire, the heat cannot easily be dissipated through radiation or convection from the steel to the air in the cooler compartments.

The CT bugaboo about the conductivity of steel is a non-starter.
 
Last edited:
People who live in Texas know that the best way to cook meat is to expose to very low temperatures for a long time. Can steel in a building fire "cook" the same way or does it lose its heat faster than it absorbs it?
 
Originally Posted by Christopher
Why don't you take your own advise (sic) and stop claiming that WTC 7 collapsed because of DD/F until NIST can explain how it happened.
They have only a hypothesis [a set of assumptions
that they admit, may not hold up.

"This hypothesis may be supported or modified, or new hypotheses may be developed, through the course of the continuing investigation."

Chris you never cease to amaze me with the things you write. We've been trying to tell you that for, what, 8000 posts? Now that you agree may we put this to rest until the report comes out?
No
I have known this for a long time and i have been asking you all to stop claiming that WTC 7 collapsed due to DD/F for a long time.
This does not mean we should ignore the evidence contained in the NIST and other reports.
NIST is stalling because they cannot demonstrate how the fires could have caused the collapse.
You would like to have us all ignore the facts and wait for another snow job from an administration that systematically distorts scientific documents.
 
Originally Posted by Christopher
Why don't you take your own advise (sic) and stop claiming that WTC 7 collapsed because of DD/F until NIST can explain how it happened.
They have only a hypothesis [a set of assumptions
that they admit, may not hold up.

"This hypothesis may be supported or modified, or new hypotheses may be developed, through the course of the continuing investigation."

No
I have known this for a long time and i have been asking you all to stop claiming that WTC 7 collapsed due to DD/F for a long time.
This does not mean we should ignore the evidence contained in the NIST and other reports.
NIST is stalling because they cannot demonstrate how the fires could have caused the collapse.
You would like to have us all ignore the facts and wait for another snow job from an administration that systematically distorts scientific documents.

Chris you just exposed yourself for what you really are.

You state, as a fact, that NIST is stalling because they cannot demonstrate how the fires could have caused the collapse. If you state this as a fact, and you have no idea whether this is true why should we listen to any of your other facts?

You also tell me that I would like to us you all ignore the facts and wait for another snow job.........

How can you be so arrogant as to tell me what I would like? Again, you are making up facts, just like you have for the past few months. Have I not told you that I am a Bush-hater, and that I'd love to nail him and his goons with a conspiracy? In light of that your statement is nonsense. In fact, it just proves that you cannot process data like a mature adult. You can only look for things that support your belief, and you ignore everything else.

Give it a rest and wait for the report to come out, then tear it apart if you want.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom