jaydeehess
Penultimate Amazing
.Originally Posted by jaydeehess
The Cardington and other tests were used to develop the model which gives us that a uniform heating to 570oC would result in column failure
On the contrary,
the Cardington tests show the 570º C (1,058º F) is far to low.
Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."
I was addressing Your number, 570oC which you quoted. Use any number you feel is correct then Chris.
Source?Quote:
In the real world some parts of that column could be heated to 700oC while others parts were at 300oC a condition that would stress the column more than a uniform heating to 570oCeven though uniform heating to that temp would result in failure due to loss of strength due to plastic deformation.
Undergraduate physics course and hanging around with undergrad engineering students
Really? Source?Quote:
Uniform heating would cause vertical creep. Non-uniform heating would cause twisting/bending.
ditto above
Steel is known for it's ability to transfer heat rapidly.Quote:
Fire develops heating a column at one level and quite possibly one less than all 4 sides causing the hotter portions to expand and putting a bending strain on the column.
Any bending strain would be minimal.
Source?
Hell I have cookie sheets that twist and bend in the oven at only 350oF that illustrate this.
.In the real world [WTC 7] there were fires on floors 8, 11, 12 and 13.Quote:
The flooring fails above and or below this area spreading the fire to the next level portion of the coulmn and possibly also to other faces of the column on the original and/or the new fire floors.
The fire on floor 12 burned out more than 1/2 hour before the building imploded
Thank you for illustrating the temperature differentials.
NoQuote:
Now you have a column that is bending,
Yes
it would be hard to argue otherwise.YesQuote:
has less lateral support
.Quote:
and is also losing strength due to plastic deformation in some parts of the coulmn
No
yes
,Quote:
Add to this a lateral pull due to damaged columns in other parts of the structure
Framework between the damage to the south west part of WTC 7 and columns 79 - 81, would take up any lateral stress.
that stress just does not disappear into the ether Chris.
NIST said that point is about 570º C.Quote:
and a situation in which there is less load-to-capacity headroom on this particular column than there is on adjacent columns and at some point it results in the failure of this column.
Cardington tests put it much higher.
I was referring to the design strength and normal loading on the building before 9/11. These columns may have held more load than the other nearby columns. Not that in normal circumstances this would be a problem and would still be well within design specs but when other factors start increasing the loads (vertical and lateral) and reducing the strength of the columns it will be the ones with the greatest original load that will fail first.
Brilliant, my dear Watson.Quote:
Complicated? Yes, its the real world and it will be more complicated than ideal conditions testing steel columns in test ovens and more complex than the Cardington tests as well.
Thank you Moriarity
.Quote:
In the Cardington structure for instance each column in a fire area had the same load
Tests are very specific and detailed. Designed to test a particular piece of framework or section.
Something that had seemed to escape you....
The results can then be used to set standards.
They can also be used to analyize events in the real world
yes, and that is how the standards are set but they cannot cover all circumstances and all designs.
You throw around terms like plastic deformation, twisting/bending, bending strain, lateral pull and the cool sounding, but irrelevant 'load-to-capacity headroom'.Quote:
Am I saying that this IS what occured? No, but it does conform to what could happen in a real world fire.
It would be good if you understood them too.
In the real world, none of these things you have mentioned has caused a column in a high rise building to fail!
....
... In the real world, columns do not fail.
In the real world the situation for the buildings in the WTC complex had never occured previously. That includes the situation in WTC 7 in which major structural damage had been done by impacts of large, dense and fast objects and then suffered unfought major fires for half a day.