10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by jaydeehess
The Cardington and other tests were used to develop the model which gives us that a uniform heating to 570oC would result in column failure
.
On the contrary,
the Cardington tests show the 570º C (1,058º F) is far to low.

Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."

I was addressing Your number, 570oC which you quoted. Use any number you feel is correct then Chris.

Quote:
In the real world some parts of that column could be heated to 700oC while others parts were at 300oC a condition that would stress the column more than a uniform heating to 570oCeven though uniform heating to that temp would result in failure due to loss of strength due to plastic deformation.
Source?

Undergraduate physics course and hanging around with undergrad engineering students

Quote:
Uniform heating would cause vertical creep. Non-uniform heating would cause twisting/bending.
Really? Source?

ditto above

Quote:
Fire develops heating a column at one level and quite possibly one less than all 4 sides causing the hotter portions to expand and putting a bending strain on the column.
Steel is known for it's ability to transfer heat rapidly.
Any bending strain would be minimal.

Source?
Hell I have cookie sheets that twist and bend in the oven at only 350oF that illustrate this.

Quote:
The flooring fails above and or below this area spreading the fire to the next level portion of the coulmn and possibly also to other faces of the column on the original and/or the new fire floors.
In the real world [WTC 7] there were fires on floors 8, 11, 12 and 13.
The fire on floor 12 burned out more than 1/2 hour before the building imploded
.

Thank you for illustrating the temperature differentials.

Quote:
Now you have a column that is bending,
No

Yes

Quote:
has less lateral support
Yes
it would be hard to argue otherwise.

Quote:
and is also losing strength due to plastic deformation in some parts of the coulmn
.
No

yes

Quote:
Add to this a lateral pull due to damaged columns in other parts of the structure
,
Framework between the damage to the south west part of WTC 7 and columns 79 - 81, would take up any lateral stress.

that stress just does not disappear into the ether Chris.

Quote:
and a situation in which there is less load-to-capacity headroom on this particular column than there is on adjacent columns and at some point it results in the failure of this column.
NIST said that point is about 570º C.
Cardington tests put it much higher.

I was referring to the design strength and normal loading on the building before 9/11. These columns may have held more load than the other nearby columns. Not that in normal circumstances this would be a problem and would still be well within design specs but when other factors start increasing the loads (vertical and lateral) and reducing the strength of the columns it will be the ones with the greatest original load that will fail first.


Quote:
Complicated? Yes, its the real world and it will be more complicated than ideal conditions testing steel columns in test ovens and more complex than the Cardington tests as well.
Brilliant, my dear Watson.

Thank you Moriarity


Quote:
In the Cardington structure for instance each column in a fire area had the same load
.
Tests are very specific and detailed. Designed to test a particular piece of framework or section.

Something that had seemed to escape you....

The results can then be used to set standards.
They can also be used to analyize events in the real world

yes, and that is how the standards are set but they cannot cover all circumstances and all designs.


Quote:
Am I saying that this IS what occured? No, but it does conform to what could happen in a real world fire.
You throw around terms like plastic deformation, twisting/bending, bending strain, lateral pull and the cool sounding, but irrelevant 'load-to-capacity headroom'.

It would be good if you understood them too.

In the real world, none of these things you have mentioned has caused a column in a high rise building to fail!
....
... In the real world, columns do not fail.

In the real world the situation for the buildings in the WTC complex had never occured previously. That includes the situation in WTC 7 in which major structural damage had been done by impacts of large, dense and fast objects and then suffered unfought major fires for half a day.
 
http://fseg.gre.ac.uk/fire/structural_response_of_steel.html

http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi-bin/abstract/101019598/ABSTRACT?CRETRY=1&SRETRY=0
differential heating across the stud section causes the. stud to bend

http://www.civil.canterbury.ac.nz/fire/pdfreports/CWastney_02.pdf
Stresses within the beams did however change with heating, particularly in the earlier stages of the fire. These stresses arise from thermal bowing of the beam; this is the result of differential heating, and hence differential rates of expansion through the cross-section.

Most refer to the effect of differential heating in beams. Beams are usually much thinner than columns and the thicker a steel member the greater the thermal gradient. Beams tend however, to be more subject to heating on one side than do columns since in a normal post and beam construction the columns are most likely to experience fire on all sides at once and the differential would in that case be along the vertical axis not laterally through the column. But if the column is part of a firewall and is heated only on one side then it does indeed suffer differential heating which does indeed cause differential expansion(bending stress/strain). Since columns are under load and therefore constrained from expanding vertically, this stress contributes to both the vertical load on the column and the lateral stresses it is experiencing.
 
Your statement of "columns 79, 80 and 81 would have to be uniformly heated to 1,000 F over 4 stories before they would fail." is not an accurate interpretation of the above. There are other ways for the column to fail. NIST is just saying that if the column was heated to that temp it would fail.

You seem to not be able to distinguish between theoretical (perfect world) and actual (real world).

Basically, NIST is implying that WTC 7 was a controlled demolition, since they have implied that it is scientifically impossible to explain its collapse from office fires and/or structural damage.
 
Basically, NIST is implying that WTC 7 was a controlled demolition, since they have implied that it is scientifically impossible to explain its collapse from office fires and/or structural damage.

Basically your reading comprehension sux
 
Basically, NIST is implying that WTC 7 was a controlled demolition, since they have implied that it is scientifically impossible to explain its collapse from office fires and/or structural damage.

Now, that's an interesting interpretation.

Chris you seem to have signed in as Galileo, again. Having 2 identities is a real pain isn't it?
 
Galileo is C7? If this is true then Chris just went down a notch in my estimation.

Gawd, I hate it when people do that. (not that I know that it has in this case)
Its public maturbation., people who have to create a false persona to have it look like someone else is agreeing with them or putting out statements that they won't put out themselves (self stroking). creepy!!
 
Can't say for sure; just a hunch based on a response by Galileo a few dozen posts back. 3599, 3600, 3603
 
Last edited:
GT/CS: Galileo is a different person.
JREF decorum:
Attack the message, not the messenger.

I was addressing Your number, 570oC which you quoted. Use any number you feel is correct then Chris.
I was quoting the NIST number which is far too low according to the Cardington tests.

jdh said:
In the real world some parts of that column could be heated to 700oC while others parts were at 300oC a condition that would stress the column more than a uniform heating to 570o C even though uniform heating to that temp would result in failure due to loss of strength due to plastic deformation.
C7 said:
jdh said:
Undergraduate physics course and hanging around with undergrad engineering students
NIST did not mention plastic deformation.
They said the unbraced column would not be able to carry the load if uniformly heated to 570o C

NIST l-40
I4.6 Uniform High Temperatures: If initiating event components were sufficiently exposed to fire effects to be uniformly heated to elevated temperatures, the steel strength would be reduced below that required to support the load. Figure L–39 shows that for interior columns subject to service loads (shown as approximately 20 ksi of compressive stress), uniform steel temperatures of approximately 570 ºC would result in column failure.

C7 said:
Steel is known for it's ability to transfer heat rapidly.
Any bending strain would be minimal.
jdh said:
Hell I have cookie sheets that twist and bend in the oven at only 350oF that illustrate this.
You're comparing a cookie sheet to a column weighing 730 pounds per lineal foot?

C7 said:
In the real world [WTC 7] there were fires on floors 8, 11, 12 and 13.
The fire on floor 12 burned out more than 1/2 hour before the building imploded
Thank you for illustrating the temperature differentials.
The differential is between floors, not one side of the column to the other.

C7 said:
Framework between the damage to the south west part of WTC 7 and columns 79 - 81, would take up any lateral stress.
jdh said:
that stress just does not disappear into the ether Chris.
Any lateral stress to core columns in the west half of WTC 7 would be pulling primarily to the south.
The stress would be the greatest to adjacent columns and less to columns further away as the stiffness [shear strength] of the framework would 'take up' the lateral stress.

C7 said:
NIST said that point is about 570º C.
Cardington tests put it much higher.

I was referring to the design strength and normal loading on the building before 9/11. These columns may have held more load than the other nearby columns. Not that in normal circumstances this would be a problem and would still be well within design specs but when other factors start increasing the loads (vertical and lateral) and reducing the strength of the columns it will be the ones with the greatest original load that will fail first.
The columns with the greatest load would be the largest and therefore take longer to heat up.
Since the loads are proportionate, the column with the greatest original load would be proportionately stronger so the failure temperature would be roughly the same.

The failure of column 79, 80 or 81 would put additional vertical and lateral loads on adjacent columns.
This includes exterior columns and core columns 76, 77 and 78.
Though exposed to the same fires, these columns did not fail until about 7 seconds after the collapse sequence began.

In the real world the situation for the buildings in the WTC complex had never occured previously. That includes the situation in WTC 7 in which major structural damage had been done by impacts of large, dense and fast objects
You keep implying that the debris damage to the west half of the south side had a significant effect on core columns in the east end of the building.
It did not.

and then suffered unfought major fires for half a day.
OTers keep using the praise 'unfought fires' as if it meant something.
The Meridian Plaza burned out of control for 19 hours. Firefighting was ineffective because of low water pressure. The fires burned on many contiguous floors and were therefore more intense than the limited fires in the east half of WTC 7.

http://www.interfire.org/res_file/pdf/Tr-049.pdf
pg 19 [24 on pg counter]
After the fire, there was evident significant structural damage to horizontal steel members and floor sections on most of the fire damaged floors. Beams and girders sagged and twisted -- some as much as three feet -- under severe fire exposures, and fissures developed in the reinforced concrete floor assemblies in many places. Despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.

 
Remind me, what 110 storey tall building crashed into the Meridian Plaza?
And remind me, wasn't the source of that fire some linseed oil soaked rags in a single office on a single floor?
And remind me, wasn't that fire ultimately extinguished by working sprinkler systems?
And remind me, wasn't it the case that there was no structural damage to the building prior to the fire?

:rolleyes:

ETA: Oh, and remind me, did the fire department not consult with structural engineers who determined that there was a risk of collapse?

And, remind me, was it not the case that the Philadelphia fire department was confronted with an "essentially impossible situation" even though the Meridian Plaza had not been smashed into and damaged by any 110 storey tall skyscrapers, and even though the fire had originated from a single source in a single office, and even though the building wasn't built atop a Con-Ed station, and even though there had not been hundreds of firefighters, dozens of police officers, and thousands of civilians already killed in neighbouring buildings that day?
 
Last edited:
Remind me, what 110 storey tall building crashed into the Meridian Plaza?

None did. The first paragraph of the FEMA report cited above on the Meridian Plaza fire says that 20 months after the fire the building was still standing. What is your point here?

A few posts back someone here was saying Chris hasn't given a single shred of evidence of CD and that the burden of proof was on him.

The true situation is entirely the contrary. So much so that it doesn't really matter if there was a 10 story gash or not. Since we know it was a CD, if there was a gash, then it was probably created the same way as the CD was.

One poster kept being sarcastic about silent explosives as if this were the last word. But many witnesses heard explosions, some even heard the countdown for the CD.

The burden of proof is entirely on the OCT' ers, the defenders of the big lie, or 911liars.

Just go to ae911truth.org, the website of the 192 degreed Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth, and see where the truth is and where the burden of proof is:

As your own eyes witness — WTC Building #7 (a 47 story high-rise not hit by an airplane) exhibits all the characteristics of a classic controlled demolition with explosives:
1. Rapid onset of “collapse”
2. Sounds of explosions at ground floor - a full second prior to collapse (heard by hundreds of firemen and media reporters)
3. Symmetrical “collapse” – through the path of greatest resistance – at free-fall speed — the columns gave no resistance
4. Squibs, or “mistimed” explosions, at the upper 7 floors seen in the network videos
5. “Collapses” into its own footprint – with the steel skeleton broken up for shipment
6. Massive volume of expanding pyroclastic dust clouds
7. Tons of molten Metal found by CDI (Demolition Contractor) in basement (no other possible source than an incendiary cutting charge such as Thermate)
8. Chemical signature of Thermate (high tech incendiary) found in slag, solidified molten metal, and dust samples by Physics professor Steven Jones, PhD.
9. FEMA finds rapid oxidation and intergranular melting on structural steel samples
10. Expert corroboration from the top European Controlled Demolition professional
11. Fore-knowledge of “collapse” by media, NYPD, FDNY
And exhibited none of the characteristics of destruction by fire, i.e.
1. Slow onset with large visible deformations
2. Asymmetrical collapse which follows the path of least resistance (laws of conservation of momentum would cause a falling, to the side most damaged by the fires)
3. Evidence of fire temperatures capable of softening steel
4. High-rise buildings with much larger, hotter, and longer lasting fires have never “collapsed”.

This is an absolutely crushing burden of evidence.
 
Dr Jones? Thermate? What junk; old truth junk

None did. The first paragraph of the FEMA report cited above on the Meridian Plaza fire says that 20 months after the fire the building was still standing. What is your point here?

A few posts back someone here was saying Chris hasn't given a single shred of evidence of CD and that the burden of proof was on him.

The true situation is entirely the contrary. So much so that it doesn't really matter if there was a 10 story gash or not. Since we know it was a CD, if there was a gash, then it was probably created the same way as the CD was.

One poster kept being sarcastic about silent explosives as if this were the last word. But many witnesses heard explosions, some even heard the countdown for the CD.

The burden of proof is entirely on the OCT' ers, the defenders of the big lie, or 911liars.

Just go to ae911truth.org, the website of the 192 degreed Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth, and see where the truth is and where the burden of proof is:

As your own eyes witness — WTC Building #7 (a 47 story high-rise not hit by an airplane) exhibits all the characteristics of a classic controlled demolition with explosives:
1. Rapid onset of “collapse”
2. Sounds of explosions at ground floor - a full second prior to collapse (heard by hundreds of firemen and media reporters)
3. Symmetrical “collapse” – through the path of greatest resistance – at free-fall speed — the columns gave no resistance
4. Squibs, or “mistimed” explosions, at the upper 7 floors seen in the network videos
5. “Collapses” into its own footprint – with the steel skeleton broken up for shipment
6. Massive volume of expanding pyroclastic dust clouds
7. Tons of molten Metal found by CDI (Demolition Contractor) in basement (no other possible source than an incendiary cutting charge such as Thermate)
8. Chemical signature of Thermate (high tech incendiary) found in slag, solidified molten metal, and dust samples by Physics professor Steven Jones, PhD.
9. FEMA finds rapid oxidation and intergranular melting on structural steel samples
10. Expert corroboration from the top European Controlled Demolition professional
11. Fore-knowledge of “collapse” by media, NYPD, FDNY
And exhibited none of the characteristics of destruction by fire, i.e.
1. Slow onset with large visible deformations
2. Asymmetrical collapse which follows the path of least resistance (laws of conservation of momentum would cause a falling, to the side most damaged by the fires)
3. Evidence of fire temperatures capable of softening steel
4. High-rise buildings with much larger, hotter, and longer lasting fires have never “collapsed”.

This is an absolutely crushing burden of evidence.
Dr Jones? He is nuts, he made up thermite 4 years after 9/11. Total nut case on 9/11 topics, he has no clue, and repeating his junk makes you a poor researcher.

Meridian Plaza was torn down, the fire destroyed the strength of the steel if the the fire control systems and the fire department had not fought the fire and worked, the upper sections of the building may of collapsed and destroyed other things in the city of Betsy
Ross. Do some work here and stop telling lies of 9/11 truth.

Show me tons of molten metal. Have not seen any.

The building in Spain was torn down, it was destroyed by fire. Oops, fires destroy the strength of steel. Oops, better go back to school on this one. You are just repeating junk from 9/11 truth, old debunked junk.

dust evidence, right, you know how many iron spheres are in my back yard; go get a magnet and find your own; Wow, your house has evidence of thermate! Better get Dr THermite Jones! Who you going to call, Thermite Jones? He was fired for being an biased political liar.
 
None did. The first paragraph of the FEMA report cited above on the Meridian Plaza fire says that 20 months after the fire the building was still standing. What is your point here?

Point was made that the engineers consulted warned of the possibility of collapse. That it still stood at the time the fire was out does not invalidate their warning. The fact that once it managed to stay upright after the fire and for several months afterward simply means that it suffered no further insult. It was also shored up after the fire to help make sure that it did not collapse before it could be taken down deliberatly.

A few posts back someone here was saying Chris hasn't given a single shred of evidence of CD and that the burden of proof was on him.

,,, and he hasn't

The true situation is entirely the contrary. So much so that it doesn't really matter if there was a 10 story gash or not. Since we know it was a CD, if there was a gash, then it was probably created the same way as the CD was.

ROFLMAO

So as long as you can simply declare it a CD that's all there is to it,,, yes, I see.:rolleyes:

One poster kept being sarcastic about silent explosives as if this were the last word. But many witnesses heard explosions, some even heard the countdown for the CD.

A few witnesses state that they heard explosions during the collapse. One could expect loud banging and booming noises from any collapse.
The countdown story is unconfirmed at best and frankly , laughable.


The burden of proof is entirely on the OCT' ers, the defenders of the big lie, or 911liars.

The contention of CD is an extrodinary claim and therefore requires extrodinary evidence. This has not materialised. FACT is that the building had suffered major debris damage and then suffered fire damage over several hours in many areas of the building, each fire would have been considered a major fire by itself and there was no fire fighting effort made or possible.


As your own eyes witness — WTC Building #7 (a 47 story high-rise not hit by an airplane) exhibits all the characteristics of a classic controlled demolition with explosives:
1. Rapid onset of “collapse”

Not a unigue indicator of CD

2. Sounds of explosions at ground floor - a full second prior to collapse (heard by hundreds of firemen and media reporters)

People at the ground level could not know that there was an internal collapse taking place. The setting of this sound as coming 1 second before any collapse occurs simply cannot be said to be correct. In fact it is likely that the sounds heard are the result of the collapse starting in the interior of the building.
3. Symmetrical “collapse” – through the path of greatest resistance – at free-fall speed — the columns gave no resistance

Absolutely not. The collapse began in the interior of the building which accounts for the caving inwards. The supposed 'free fall" ignores the several seconds during which the interior of the building collapsed and applies only to the outer walls and even then is inaccurate given that it is 10-20% longer time of collapse than free fall drop which means that the acelleration was 20-40% less than g.
4. Squibs, or “mistimed” explosions, at the upper 7 floors seen in the network videos

Windows breaking as the building collapsed. these 'squibs' only go off as the building has already started its collapse. In fact they don't go off until the outer wall begins to come down.
5. “Collapses” into its own footprint – with the steel skeleton broken up for shipment

Given that the collapse started in the interior of the building this is as expected. The debris had to be cut up to be transported away.

In real CD's the dust cloud appears even though all interior walls, glass, carpets, furniture,,,,, has been removed. In WTC 7 all these items remained in the building and were crushed during the collapse creating a hell of a lot more dust than one would ever get in a true controlled demolition.
7.
Tons of molten Metal found by CDI (Demolition Contractor) in basement (no other possible source than an incendiary cutting charge such as Thermate)

Really? Source?
8. Chemical signature of Thermate (high tech incendiary) found in slag, solidified molten metal, and dust samples by Physics professor Steven Jones, PhD.

Yeah, he found sulfur. An element present in decent quantities, in drywall and ABS plumbing.
9. FEMA finds rapid oxidation and intergranular melting on structural steel samples

How is any evidence of incidiary action a hallmark of CD? I am unaware of any use of incidiaries in CD. (except in Los Vegas where they put in fireball creating gasoline bombs just for the show aspect.)
10. Expert corroboration from the top European Controlled Demolition professional
Top? You award him a title he either gave himself or was bestowed upon him by CT's
11.
Fore-knowledge of “collapse” by media, NYPD, FDNY

Yeah, right from the outset when they started looking over the damage to the building they were aware of the danger that the building might collapse. that's not 'foreknowledge' that's good deduction.
And exhibited none of the characteristics of destruction by fire, i.e.
1. Slow onset with large visible deformations

actually the building was deformed and material was falling off during the day.
2. Asymmetrical collapse which follows the path of least resistance (laws of conservation of momentum would cause a falling, to the side most damaged by the fires)

Collapse started in the interior and the last part to come down was the north wall, as far as we know. That would be the intact, north wall.
3. Evidence of fire temperatures capable of softening steel

Starting at 300oC IIRC and office fires can and do get much hotter than that.
4. High-rise buildings with much larger, hotter, and longer lasting fires have never “collapsed”.

None of which had been severly damaged in any way prior to the fires.

This is an absolutely crushing burden of evidence.

No, its all hand waving arguement based primarily upon a desire to pin this on a hated political entity.
I don't like Bush, Cheney or neo-con ideology either but I am unwilling to let that colour my perception.

An open mind is one thing, but do not allow it to open so much that your brains fall out.
 
Last edited:
No, its all hand waving arguement based primarily upon a desire to pin this on a hated political entity.
I don't like Bush, Cheney or neo-con ideology either but I am unwilling to let that colour my perception.

An open mind is one thing, but do not allow it to open so much that your brains fall out.

Love it! Well said.
 

Respublicus, this is not a characteristic of controlled demolition with explosives, it's a characteristic of volcanic eruptions. And using this argument is not a characteristic of people who boldly and independently think for themselves, it's a characteristic of obedient followers of the truth movement who've picked up some impressive sounding words on a website somewhere and don't realise that using them for the 9257th time in a place where their real meaning is well understood will make them look like an idiotic truther drone.

Dave
 
The building in Spain was torn down, it was destroyed by fire.

Indeed Beach. It must be noted that the steel in the Windsor did indeed fail and collapseon several upper stories. the only thing that kept it from becoming a global collapse was the concrete core coulmns which retained enough strength to remain standing. Concrete simply stands up better in fire than does steel.

When you watch the Windsor fire you notice that the steel sags and then sudenly lets go and the outer portion collapses quickly.
 
<snip to remove all of the cut and paste "Twoofer 101" entry level nonsense> None did. The first paragraph of the FEMA report cited above on the Meridian Plaza fire says that 20 months after the fire the building was still standing. What is your point here?

It looks like you deliberately missed my point. In fact, it looks like you just chose the nearest sentence to quote, without bothering to read the post, so that you could then jump in head first with the standard cut and paste twoofer CD nonsense that has been completely refuted here numerous times before.

All of the items on your list have been discussed here before. You could easily do a search for threads on those subjects, were you interested in learning rather than just cutting and pasting from the usual twoofer sites/suspects.

Should you conduct that search, in addition to learning about the very topics you raised in your post, you will likely also find some useful explanations of how to avoid the logical fallacies that you have employed, and you will, without a doubt, be exposed to the scientific method, critical thinking, and analytical thinking in action, all of which you could benefit from immensely, should you choose to try your hand at them.

Please do consider it, and good luck.
 
Last edited:
GT/CS: Galileo is a different person.
JREF decorum:
Attack the message, not the messenger.
Good then.
If a messenger does pull such offense tactics though I feel free to attack them.

I was quoting the NIST number which is far too low according to the Cardington tests.

Do you deny that even 570oC would severly compromise the strength of a column?
No, I thought not.



NIST did not mention plastic deformation.
They said the unbraced column would not be able to carry the load if uniformly heated to 570o C

Read the last few paragraphs of the interim report again Chris. The part about further calculations.

You're comparing a cookie sheet to a column weighing 730 pounds per lineal foot?

The temp gradient across a thin cookie sheet would be minimal, accross a thick column it would be much greater.



Any lateral stress to core columns in the west half of WTC 7 would be pulling primarily to the south.
South and west, the core failed and the progression was east to west.

The stress would be the greatest to adjacent columns and less to columns further away as the stiffness [shear strength] of the framework would 'take up' the lateral stress.

So, a giant spring extended to the south and west.


The columns with the greatest load would be the largest and therefore take longer to heat up.
I am stating that given two identical columns adjacent to each other that one is going to be carrying more load thatn the other and both would still be well within their design loads But given the same damage to each it would be the one with the greatest load that will fail first. The penthouse contained some very heavy equipment and although the mass was well within the design load of the columns beneath the penthouse there would be some that were carrying more than the others..

The failure of column 79, 80 or 81 would put additional vertical and lateral loads on adjacent columns.
This includes exterior columns and core columns 76, 77 and 78.
Though exposed to the same fires, these columns did not fail until about 7 seconds after the collapse sequence began.

Yeah, after they then suffered additional damage from the falling debris of the penthouse and all below it.

You keep implying that the debris damage to the west half of the south side had a significant effect on core columns in the east end of the building.
It did not.

Says you.

OTers keep using the praise 'unfought fires' as if it meant something.
The Meridian Plaza burned out of control for 19 hours. Firefighting was ineffective because of low water pressure. The fires burned on many contiguous floors and were therefore more intense than the limited fires in the east half of WTC 7.

each one of those 'limited fires' would have been considered a major fre by themselves.
Concerning Meridian, see above posts

http://www.interfire.org/res_file/pdf/Tr-049.pdf
pg 19 [24 on pg counter]
After the fire, there was evident significant structural damage to horizontal steel members and floor sections on most of the fire damaged floors. Beams and girders sagged and twisted -- some as much as three feet -- under severe fire exposures, and fissures developed in the reinforced concrete floor assemblies in many places. Despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.


Now that was a limited fire and it occured in a pure post and beam structure that was completely intact at the outset of the fire.
 
Free Thinking + Free Fall Speed = CD

The video evidence, by itself, is not enough to convict

If we had a society free of indoctrination and intimidation, the speed of fall alone would be enough to convince everyone it was a CD, and to indict a lot of suspects, too.

We obviously do not have such a free-thinking forum.

It is very simple and clear cut. There is no need to obfuscate hundreds of pages and six years. Can you walk through a closed door as fast as an open one?

That speed of fall was only possible if the doors were opened, if the support columns were instantaneously severed.

No 911 Big Liar yet has come up with an alternative explanation - for the simple reason there isn't one. It's the only way to do it.

Come on 911 liars. We truthers are open minded. Please tell us, while keeping your dogma of the 911 big lie intact, how the buildings could come down at the speed of a fall through air?

Never mind all this other verbiage. It doesn't cut one piece of steel. Just answer this one killer question. While keeping the rules of physics intact too, of course.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom