10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Did you notice the shortened column on page 13 in the presentation from the Cardington tests that I linked in my earlier post Christopher. The page is labeled "Test 2 - Column shortening".
I did not see that. My bad, there was column shortening.

I have shown you pictures of the same type of damage from some of the WTC buildings in earlier posts. But as usual your WTC 7 columns are immune to fire.
WTC 7 columns 79, 80 and 81 were W14x730* cores and reinforcing plates [*730 lb per lineal foot].
The column in the Cardington test that buckled, was about W12x140 [140 lb per lineal foot].
The test building in the Cardington report is the same size as WTC 5 [8 stories].
Therefore, the columns are about the same size and weight.
The columns buckled in a similar manner.

Columns 79, 80 and 81 were 5 times as heavy as the one in the Cardington test [and WTC 5]

The heavier the column, the longer it takes to heat it up.
 
Chris, did columns 79,80 and 81 have fire insulation sprayed on them? If so, and if your contention that there was no way to have a fire large and hot enough to affect them is correct, why did the builders waste time and money putting fire protection on them?
Building codes.
[probably required fireproofing on all framing members]

The tests show that columns are affected by fire but that floors and beams suffer more than vertical members. To state that columns 'do not fail, even in severe fires' is a gross misrepresentation of the Cardington tests.
Actually, the column didn't fail, it was still there and supporting its load.

Besides which you once again assume a building in pristine condition and no matter what spin you try to put on it, WTC 7 was not, in any way, shape, or form, pristine.
You are using the words proximate and pristine so you can argue about their definitions.

My position is:
There was no debris damage to or near the area of the initiating event.
[core columns 79, 80 and/or 81]

With or without fireproofing, the fires in the east end of WTC 7 were not sufficient to heat a column weighing over 4 tons per floor to 1,000 F, on 4 contiguous floors.
 
My position is:
There was no debris damage to or near the area of the initiating event.
[core columns 79, 80 and/or 81]

With or without fireproofing, the fires in the east end of WTC 7 were not sufficient to heat a column weighing over 4 tons per floor to 1,000 F, on 4 contiguous floors.

Christopher, I need to point out that NIST in its interim report also find it possible that the initiating event could have started with components other than 79, 80 and/or 81. With this event possibly leading to the failure of columns 79, 80 and/or 81 and then the observed exterior signs of collapse.
NIST page L-51 said:
The initiating event may have included a number of structural components, though the
relative role of impact damage and fire need further investigation. Possible components that
may have led to the failure of columns 79, 80, and/or 81 include interior columns 69, 72, 75,
78, and 78A, the east transfer girder (which supports column 78A and frames into transfer
truss #2), and adjacent framing and floor systems.
My bolding.

This is discussed in greater detail on the preceding pages in the report, with failure mechanisms like this:
NIST page L-39 said:
I4.4 Lateral Displacements: Fire effects may have caused column instability
failure by lateral displacements from asymmetric thermal expansion of the floor
system. Such thermally-induced displacements must overcome the restraining effect
of the remaining floor system against further lateral deflection of the
column.
This is were the large floor spans of WTC 7 comes in to play.

And by the way Christopher, where are your temperature readings of the column temperatures inside WTC 7 during the fires that day. Or alternatively your calculations or computer simulations saying that any columns couldn't have reached critical temperatures during the fires. This is what you need to come up with to disprove NIST, if the final report from NIST have calculations and simulations indicating that critical column temperatures could indeed have been reached in the fires.
 
Last edited:
Building codes.
[probably required fireproofing on all framing members]

Oh, not so fast. Don't handwave that away like that. Whenever you say 'probably' that's a read flag. It means you really don't know, do you?

Why is fireproofing required on metal at all?
 
Building codes.
[probably required fireproofing on all framing members]

silly codes. Obviously that code was in place for no discernable reason.

"codes,,, codes,,, we don't need no stinkin' codes"

Actually, the column didn't fail, it was still there and supporting its load.

A load Chris. Quite obviously if it has shorthened and buckled it is not carrying the load the same way as before nor is it possible for iot to carry whatever max load it could before.

You are using the words proximate and pristine so you can argue about their definitions.

You have argued about minutia throughout this discussion Chris. I use the word 'proximate' , you use 'near'. I use 'pristine', well because it fits the condition you assume the building was in, at least near/proximate to the initiating event ( and for the sake of arguement we have concentrated on that being the failure of 79,80,81 although that is by no means clear)

My position is:
There was no debris damage to or near the area of the initiating event.
[core columns 79, 80 and/or 81]

There may or may not have been but one cannot rule out damages to the structure affecting the loads on the members 79,80,81 or those close to those columns.

With or without fireproofing, the fires in the east end of WTC 7 were not sufficient to heat a column weighing over 4 tons per floor to 1,000 F, on 4 contiguous floors.

A description which would indeed require that those columns be in pristine condition.
 
Christopher, I need to point out that NIST in its interim report also find it possible that the initiating event could have started with components other than 79, 80 and/or 81. With this event possibly leading to the failure of columns 79, 80 and/or 81 and then the observed exterior signs of collapse.
Where ever it may have started,
columns 79, 80 and 81 would have to be uniformly heated to 1,000 F over 4 stories before they would fail.

NIST L-39
I4.4 Lateral Displacements: Fire effects may have caused column instability failure by lateral displacements from asymmetric thermal expansion of the floor system. Such thermally-induced displacements must overcome the restraining effect of the remaining floor system against further lateral deflection of the column.

[The expanding floor system is holding on to the column thru the beam to girder to column connections, resisting further displacement]

NIST L-40
Welds reach yield strength at 600 deg C [1,100 F]


And by the way Christopher, where are your temperature readings of the column temperatures inside WTC 7 during the fires that day.
Or alternatively your calculations or computer simulations saying that any columns couldn't have reached critical temperatures during the fires.
There must be a fire to heat a column to critical temperature.

The only fires in the area of columns 79, 80 and 81, were on floors 8, 11, 12 and 13.

By 4:45 p.m., the fire on floor 12 had burned out.
 
Last edited:
Where ever it may have started,
columns 79, 80 and 81 would have to be uniformly heated to 1,000 F over 4 stories before they would fail.
What about the concept of those columns being overloaded because they have to take up the weight carried by one or more neighboring columns that fail Christopher.
 
Where ever it may have started,
columns 79, 80 and 81 would have to be uniformly heated to 1,000 F over 4 stories before they would fail.

Please show your engineering calculations on the bolded statement. If you can not provide such calculations we must disregard the statement as nothing more than an uneducated assumption.
 
Last edited:
What about the concept of those columns being overloaded because they have to take up the weight carried by one or more neighboring columns that fail Christopher.
Core columns were held in place by the remaining girders beams and floors around them, as well as their own strength.

NIST does not attempt to explain how the failure of column 79, 80 or 81 led to the collapse of the other two.
 
Please show your engineering calculations on the bolded statement. If you can not provide such calculations we must disregard the statement as nothing more than an uneducated assumption.

NIST L-38
I4.2 Unbraced Columns: .... At a floor where fires were noted, interior columns were comprised of W14x730 cores and reinforcing plates, and could support several stories unbraced without failure. .... This column .... would be approaching its load carrying capacity for an unsupported length of four stories if it was also subject to a uniform temperature of 500 °C.

NIST L-40I4.6 .... uniform steel temperatures of approximately 570 ºC [1058 ºF] would result in column failure.


[FONT=&quot]"In the mid-1990s British Steel and the Building Research Establishment performed a series of six experiments at Cardington to investigate the behavior of steel frame buildings. These experiments were conducted in a simulated, eight-story building. Secondary steel beams were not protected. [/FONT]
Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."

The traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600ºC applies to all steel framework members.
 
NIST L-38
I4.2 Unbraced Columns: .... At a floor where fires were noted, interior columns were comprised of W14x730 cores and reinforcing plates, and could support several stories unbraced without failure. .... This column .... would be approaching its load carrying capacity for an unsupported length of four stories if it was also subject to a uniform temperature of 500 °C.

NIST L-40I4.6 .... uniform steel temperatures of approximately 570 ºC [1058 ºF] would result in column failure.


Your statement of "columns 79, 80 and 81 would have to be uniformly heated to 1,000 F over 4 stories before they would fail." is not an accurate interpretation of the above. There are other ways for the column to fail. NIST is just saying that if the column was heated to that temp it would fail.

You seem to not be able to distinguish between theoretical (perfect world) and actual (real world).
 
Your statement of "columns 79, 80 and 81 would have to be uniformly heated to 1,000 F over 4 stories before they would fail." is not an accurate interpretation of the above. There are other ways for the column to fail. NIST is just saying that if the column was heated to that temp it would fail.

You seem to not be able to distinguish between theoretical (perfect world) and actual (real world).

The Cardington and other tests were used to develop the model which gives us that a uniform heating to 570o would result in column failure. In the real world some parts of that column could be heated to 700o while others parts were at 300o a condition that would stress the column more than a uniform heating to 570oeven though uniform heating to that temp would result in failure due to loss of strength due to plastic deformation.

Uniform heating would cause vertical creep. Non-uniform heating would cause twisting/bending. Non-uniform heating would be more common before the floors fail, while uniform heating would be more probable with the column being exposed due to floor failure. Floor failure would not occur right away obviously. Fire develops heating a column at one level and quite possibly one less than all 4 sides causing the hotter portions to expand and putting a bending strain on the coulmn. The flooring fails above and or below this area spreading the fire to the next level portion of the coulmn and possibly also to other faces of the column on the original and/or the new fire floors. Now you have a column that is bending, has less lateral support to constrain that bending and is also losing strength due to plastic deformation in some parts of the coulmn. Add to this a lateral pull due to damaged columns in other parts of the structure, and a situation in which there is less load-to-capacity headroom on this particular column than there is on adjacent columns and at some point it results in the failure of this column.

Complicated? Yes, its the real world and it will be more complicated than ideal conditions testing steel columns in test ovens and more complex than the Cardington tests as well. In the Cardington structure for instance each column in a fire area had the same load.

Am I saying that this IS what occured? No, but it does conform to what could happen in a real world fire
 
Your statement of "columns 79, 80 and 81 would have to be uniformly heated to 1,000 F over 4 stories before they would fail." is not an accurate interpretation of the above. There are other ways for the column to fail. NIST is just saying that if the column was heated to that temp it would fail.
I just read pg 38 - 40 again, and it refers to an unbraced column and uniform temperatures.

To fail, a column would have to bend in three places [splices were 20 or 30 feet apart]

You seem to not be able to distinguish between theoretical (perfect world) and actual (real world).
In the real world, columns do not fail.

http://www.interfire.org/res_file/pdf/Tr-049.pdf
pg 19 [24 on pg counter]
After the fire, there was evident significant structural damage to horizontal steel members and floor sections on most of the fire damaged floors. Beams and girders sagged and twisted -- some as much as three feet -- under severe fire exposures, and fissures developed in the reinforced concrete floor assemblies in many places. Despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.
 
The Cardington and other tests were used to develop the model which gives us that a uniform heating to 570o would result in column failure.
On the contrary,
the Cardington tests show the 570º C (1,058º F) is far to low.

Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."

In the real world some parts of that column could be heated to 700o while others parts were at 300o a condition that would stress the column more than a uniform heating to 570oeven though uniform heating to that temp would result in failure due to loss of strength due to plastic deformation.
Source?

Uniform heating would cause vertical creep. Non-uniform heating would cause twisting/bending.
Really? Source?

Fire develops heating a column at one level and quite possibly one less than all 4 sides causing the hotter portions to expand and putting a bending strain on the column.
Steel is known for it's ability to transfer heat rapidly.
Any bending strain would be minimal.

The flooring fails above and or below this area spreading the fire to the next level portion of the coulmn and possibly also to other faces of the column on the original and/or the new fire floors.
In the real world [WTC 7] there were fires on floors 8, 11, 12 and 13.
The fire on floor 12 burned out more than 1/2 hour before the building imploded.

Now you have a column that is bending,
No
has less lateral support
Yes
and is also losing strength due to plastic deformation in some parts of the coulmn.
No
Add to this a lateral pull due to damaged columns in other parts of the structure,
Framework between the damage to the south west part of WTC 7 and columns 79 - 81, would take up any lateral stress.

and a situation in which there is less load-to-capacity headroom on this particular column than there is on adjacent columns and at some point it results in the failure of this column.
NIST said that point is about 570º C.
Cardington tests put it much higher.

Complicated? Yes, its the real world and it will be more complicated than ideal conditions testing steel columns in test ovens and more complex than the Cardington tests as well.
Brilliant, my dear Watson.

In the Cardington structure for instance each column in a fire area had the same load.
Tests are very specific and detailed. Designed to test a particular piece of framework or section.
The results can then be used to set standards.
They can also be used to analyize events in the real world.

Am I saying that this IS what occured? No, but it does conform to what could happen in a real world fire
You throw around terms like plastic deformation, twisting/bending, bending strain, lateral pull and the cool sounding, but irrelevant 'load-to-capacity headroom'.

In the real world, none of these things you have mentioned has caused a column in a high rise building to fail!
 
Last edited:
In the real world, columns do not fail.

[/B]

:jaw-dropp
I simply cannot believe you wrote that. In your honor I am going to use your words for my new signature. In the real world, columns do not fail. Wow! Engineers around the world will be thrilled to learn the columns they design will never fail.
 
:jaw-dropp
I simply cannot believe you wrote that. In your honor I am going to use your words for my new signature. In the real world, columns do not fail. Wow! Engineers around the world will be thrilled to learn the columns they design will never fail.

You can't have the Stundie nomination, I beat you to it.

Dave
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom