10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Debris damage and fires in the building are well established as having occured.
So what?
There was no debris damage to or near the area of the initiating event.
The fires were insufficient to cause a column, weighing over 4 tons per floor, to fail.

There is no evidence at all to establish, to anywhere near the same degree, that explosives were used in this building.
Subject shift and the traditional "MY dog is bigger than your dog" statement.
 
Here is the evidence:

There were fires on several floors, at different times, in the area of the initiating event.
[the failure of core column 79, 80 and/or 81]

Fires in east half of WTC 7

NIST
11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.
Fire on floor 12, moved toward the east face
2:00 to 2:30 p.m.
Fires on east face Floors 11 and 12 at the southeast corner, progressing north

As of 3:00 p.m., there were fires on floors 11 and 12 in the area of the initiating event.
Some time later, fires on 8 and 13

Yes, as said many times here, there was severe debris damage to the structure and major fires on several floors. Quite definitive as to the general condition of the structure that day --- it was in bad shape.



[qupte]A core column, weighing over 4 tons per floor, would have to be uniformly heated to about 1,000 F, and 3 or 4 floors would have to collapse all around that column, before it could break at 3 splice joints and buckle.[/quote]

That would assume that such column was undergoing stresses that would be considered normal. That cannot be said to be the case and in fact should very much be expected to not be the case given the debris and fire damage occuring in the structure.

There is no evidence that the initiating event was caused by fire.*

The NIST report is a preliminary report that did not go into the extent of fire damage at all.

There was no debris damage to or near the area of the initiating event
.

As pointed out many times , this is not neccessary to cause a collapse initiating failure. Insisting that it is required is naive.



This thread is about the lack of evidence for the DD/F hypothesis.
Evidence for CD is a separate subject and is being debated here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=2301403#post2301403

Correction, was being debated there. It petered out largely because you felt more compelled to post in this thread.

You are asking me to prove a negative
.

Your whole approach to this thread is an attempt to prove that negative. The other point, that explosives were used, would be asking you to prove a positive point.

I can only show that the evidence does not support the NIST hypothesis.

there you go, attempting to prove that negative.

*Column failure
NIST Apx. L pg 38 [42 on pg counter]
I4.2 Unbraced Columns: If floor systems failed, one or more columns may have lost lateral bracing. At a floor where fires were noted, interior columns were comprised of W14x730 cores and reinforcing plates, and could support several stories unbraced without failure. The column is not very sensitive to the number of stories of unbraced. This column would be approaching its load carrying capacity for an unsupported length of four stories if it was also subject to a uniform temperature of 500 °C.

However a floor system failure would further stress other structural systems nearby. It may not be the 'final straw' but it would contribute to the added stress of other systems.

I4.6 Uniform High Temperatures: .......
uniform steel temperatures of approximately 570 ºC would result in column failure.

570
°C = 1058°F

Yep, and my woodstove chimney must be rated to withstand 2000oC and that is for nothing but wood and gases released by combustion of wood.
Oh, and it really doesn't matter what colour you make the letters most people here are quite comfortable converting F to C.

"In the mid-1990s British Steel and the Building Research Establishment performed a series of six experiments at Cardington to investigate the behavior of steel frame buildings. These experiments were conducted in a simulated, eight-story building. Secondary steel beams were not protected. Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."
http://www.interfire.org/res_file/pdf/Tr-049.pdf
pg 19 [24 on pg counter]
After the fire, there was evident significant structural damage to horizontal steel members and floor sections on most of the fire damaged floors.
Despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.

In a test structure that was in pristine condition before the test fire and in which only one fire was lit at a time. This was a test fire.




http://www.iklimnet.com/hotelfires/m...a_lessons.html
12. Columns and certain other structural elements are normally exposed to fire from all sides. In this fire, the steel columns retained their structural integrity and held their loads. Experience in this and similar high-rise fires suggest that columns are the least vulnerable structural members, due to their mass and relatively short height between restraints (floor to floor). Major damage has occurred to horizontal members, without compromising the vertical supports.

In structures that are intact before the fire starts.

A column which is not bearing its load directly vertically or that has an inordinate lateral stress will react differently.
 
So what?
There was no debris damage to or near the area of the initiating event.
The fires were insufficient to cause a column, weighing over 4 tons per floor, to fail.

Your opinion that debris damage contributing to the failure must be proximate to the collapse initiating failure.
Your personal incredulity that fire caused enough damage to cause the initial failure to take place is not evidence that it did not.

Subject shift and the traditional "MY dog is bigger than your dog" statement.

No, it is the whole point in determing what caused the collapse of this building. Yes, there simply and concisely is more evidence that the debris damage, combined with the accumulating fire damage caused the building to collapse.

Two dogs in the yard one big (German Shepard), one tiny (Pomeranian). A 2 foot wide and 1 foot deep hole has been dug in the yard in the past hour, obviously by one of the dogs. What's the best bet which one did the deed?

btw, my dog died several years ago. however my large cat is , at this time, my avatar:cool:
 
Last edited:
Chris, since you believe the building was taken down by a CD please provide evidence of said CD. Anything. Anything at all. Any shred of evidence would be met with open arms.
 
Here I outlined the NIST damage edge, de-skewed:
Yes it's rough. Floor 15 is iffy, but 14 and below seem clearly gone as if torn away.

http://i133.photobucket.com/albums/q62/chainsawmoth/NIST_edge.jpg

Here's an analysis of Zafar's image.
15 and 14 seem intact to the edge, probably 13, and 12 too for all we can tell. All that's visible seems intact. Hmm...

http://i133.photobucket.com/albums/q62/chainsawmoth/Zafar_Analysis.jpg
Put together with other images of lower damage, the contrast is interesting. Borrowing Arie's graphic from his corner controversy PDF, which excluded NIST's for being suspicious, I put it like this (even excluding floor 13's apparent intactness just for good measure):
http://i133.photobucket.com/albums/q62/chainsawmoth/Arie_Put_Together.jpg
His is to the left, what I think it should have looked like center, and what it'd look like with NIST's swapped in for Zafars at right. It seems obvious to me... what am I missing?
I agree with the center.
I see the problem as being:
Both NIST photos show a jagged edge and part of the corner windows gone on 14 and 15.
The Zafar photo shows they are still there.

http://img487.imageshack.us/img487/5107/postcollapsebarcklaysmxh9.png
This photo shared above shows what may be the only other logical answer:
Perhaps the outer wall was pushed in in such a way that it was invisible from the northeast and far above (NIST helicopter shot) AND below (Cirone and Miller shots) but when seen more level, from the southeat and far away (Zafar's), it looks perfclty intact even though it's two different planes that happen to line up perfectly from that angle.

This seems a stretch to me, as NIST's image shows a jagged edge, not a curve.
I agree.

BTW, nice work
 
Yes, as said many times here, there was severe debris damage to the structure and major fires on several floors. Quite definitive as to the general condition of the structure that day --- it was in bad shape.
And i have been showing that to be a vague, hollow statement.

There was NO damage to the area where the collapse began.

The fires were insufficient to heat core columns to 1,000 F over 4 floors.

A core column, weighing over 4 tons per floor, would have to be uniformly heated to about 1,000 F, and 3 or 4 floors would have to collapse all around that column, before it could break at 3 splice joints and buckle.
That would assume that such column was undergoing stresses that would be considered normal.
There was no significant abnormal stress to the wast end of WTC 7.

WTC 7 was built to carry many times it's live load in a hurricane.

The NIST report is a preliminary report that did not go into the extent of fire damage at all.
The NIST report has three pages detailing the progression of the fires. [photos in FEMA and NIST reports]
NIST has many other photos. If there were any other fires, NIST would have listed them.

C7 said:
There was no debris damage to or near the area of the initiating event.
As pointed out many times , this is not neccessary to cause a collapse initiating failure. Insisting that it is required is naive.
You have claimed this many times.
You fail to grasp the concept that all the framework in between the damage and the area where the collapse began, would take up the stresses.

Correction, was being debated there. It petered out largely because you felt more compelled to post in this thread.
I have responded to all reasonable posts including your last post.
[i am partial to this thread]

C7 said:
I can only show that the evidence does not support the NIST hypothesis.

there you go, attempting to prove that negative.
Not at all. One cannot prove a negative, one can only point out that the people at NIST included enough facts to show that the conditions needed for a core column to fail were not present.

The column is not very sensitive to the number of stories of unbraced. This column would be approaching its load carrying capacity for an unsupported length of four stories if it was also subject to a uniform temperature of 500 °C.
However a floor system failure would further stress other structural systems nearby. It may not be the 'final straw' but it would contribute to the added stress of other systems.
1) It would take the collapse of several floors and the uniform heating of 17 tons of steel column to 1,000 F before failure could occur.

2) There is no evidence of floor failure in the east end of WTC 7, just fires on floors 11 and 12 up until 3:00 p.m., then floor 13, and later floor 8.

"In the mid-1990s British Steel and the Building Research Establishment performed a series of six experiments at Cardington to investigate the behavior of steel frame buildings. These experiments were conducted in a simulated, eight-story building. Secondary steel beams were not protected. Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."

In a test structure that was in pristine condition before the test fire and in which only one fire was lit at a time. This was a test fire.
The area of the initiating event was in 'pristine' condition as there was no damage to this area.
Are you saying the test has no bearing and the British Research Establishment just wasted its time and money?
Actually, what the test showed is that steel frame buildings perform better than was previously thought.

Columns and certain other structural elements are normally exposed to fire from all sides. In this fire, the steel columns retained their structural integrity and held their loads. Experience in this and similar high-rise fires suggest that columns are the least vulnerable structural members, due to their mass and relatively short height between restraints (floor to floor). Major damage has occurred to horizontal members, without compromising the vertical supports.
In structures that are intact before the fire starts.
The area of the initiating event was intact.

A column which is not bearing its load directly vertically or that has an inordinate lateral stress will react differently.
There were no inordinate lateral stresses on the area of the initiating event.
 
Your opinion that debris damage contributing to the failure must be proximate to the collapse initiating failure.
Yes.

Your personal incredulity that fire caused enough damage to cause the initial failure to take place is not evidence that it did not.
Actually, it's the lack of fire on 4 contiguous floors in the area of the initiating event.

Seriously jdh, do you think office fires could heat a vertical column weighing over 4 tons per floor to 1,000 F ?
How long do you think that would take?

C7 said:
Subject shift and the traditional "MY dog is bigger than your dog" statement.
No, it is the whole point in determing what caused the collapse of this building. Yes, there simply and concisely is more evidence that the debris damage, combined with the accumulating fire damage caused the building to collapse.
The evidence clearly shows that the fires were insufficient to cause a core column to fail.

There is NO evidence that the debris damage had a significant structural effect on the initiating event.

Two dogs in the yard one big (German Shepard), one tiny (Pomeranian). A 2 foot wide and 1 foot deep hole has been dug in the yard in the past hour, obviously by one of the dogs. What's the best bet which one did the deed?
Teenage mutant Ninja gophers?
btw, my dog died several years ago. however my large cat is , at this time, my avatar:cool:
If you share a house with a cat, you can't be all bad.:cool:
 
Norseman: thanks for the thoughts. I'm not sure that explains it, as NIST's really seems to show no corner columns or anyything at that spot or below, roughly matching the lower photos (Miller, Cirone), which likewise show stuff entirely gone it seems, and I don't think the angle is sharp enough that minor damage like that would be maximized like that. But hey, I'm not an expert, I just can't see it with my dumb eyes for some reason. And being OT that's all for now except:

I agree with the center.
I see the problem as being:
Both NIST photos show a jagged edge and part of the corner windows gone on 14 and 15.
The Zafar photo shows they are still there.

I agree.

BTW, nice work

Thanks! But what I was trying to show with the center shot how little sense it makes, which would've been worse if I'd included floors 12 + 13 which also seem intact. My point was the right image makes mot sense. All of this has me very confused and I will now drop the issue. :) Sorry for the off-tracking all and for nothing else to add to a discussion that's over my head. Traipsing back south of the Hudson and Potomac...
 
Norseman: thanks for the thoughts. I'm not sure that explains it, as NIST's really seems to show no corner columns or anyything at that spot or below.........

If you are referring to floor 14 and 15 that is correct, as I said in my earlier post. The corner window frames are there, but everything from the right hand side in the corner window frames and out is gone. The other available photos of the SW corner confirm this fact. As you should see in the crop below from the NYPD photo, the corner windows below floor 14 are hidden by smoke. And as Arie concluded in his report, the corner on floor 12 in the Zafar photo is in fact hidden by a part of the World Financial Center 3 building in the foreground.

As you asked in your earlier post, any other differences in my view is just smoke illusions and some twisting of the remaining plates between the window frames in the corner area. The photos are consistent with each other.

(click for full size)
 
Thanks! But what I was trying to show with the center shot how little sense it makes .... . My point was the right image makes most sense. All of this has me very confused and I will now drop the issue. :) Sorry for the off-tracking all and for nothing else to add to a discussion that's over my head.
You added this:

NIST_edge.jpg

It points out the difference between the NIST photos,

and the Zafar photo and this screen capture:
[shows corner column on 17, 16 and possibly 15]

wtc7column00001iy5.jpg
 
and the Zafar photo and this screen capture:
[shows corner column on 17, 16 and possibly 15]

wtc7column00001iy5.jpg

C7, what you are looking at in that picture above is the broken off edge of the south side exterior wall. The corner column is gone. In the crop I have posted below, from figure 5-16 in the FEMA report, you can see what the corner column actually looks like. Compare it also with figure 5-11 in the report. And keep in mind that both photos posted here are tele lens photos with compressed distances. But it is quite obvious that the wall edge is receded compared with the visible parts of the intact part of the SW corner column some floors below.

(click to enlarge)
 
How the Cardington Fire Tests were Done

Here is a Power Point presentation on how the Cardington tests were done. One fire in a limited compartment on one floor for each test, in a test building with a traditional steel grid construction. Nothing like the large scale fires on multiple floors in WTC 7, which had a tube in tube construction, and some unique construction features on the lower floors.

The technically minded reader will find a lot more information here at the University of Manchester.
 
If you share a house with a cat, you can't be all bad.

Two cats actually. It was three until this summer when the 15 year old passed away.

Quote:
Your personal incredulity that fire caused enough damage to cause the initial failure to take place is not evidence that it did not.


Actually, it's the lack of fire on 4 contiguous floors in the area of the initiating event.

Seriously jdh, do you think office fires could heat a vertical column weighing over 4 tons per floor to 1,000 F ?
How long do you think that would take?


Originally Posted by C7
Subject shift and the traditional "MY dog is bigger than your dog" statement.

Quote:
No, it is the whole point in determing what caused the collapse of this building. Yes, there simply and concisely is more evidence that the debris damage, combined with the accumulating fire damage caused the building to collapse.


The evidence clearly shows that the fires were insufficient to cause a core column to fail.

There is NO evidence that the debris damage had a significant structural effect on the initiating event.

Now you are trying to say that the area proximate to the initiating event was in pristine condition!!

The entire building is proximate to and significant in the stresses experienced by, the columns near the initiating event.

You seem to be alluding to an idea that since the structural members near the heavy damage would bear the extra loads that there would be no effect at all on the western, "pristine" portion of the building. That is simply untrue.

The cardington tests show quite well what occurs during an office fire. ONE office fire at a time. They did not attempt to test the effect of multiple fires on the structure. They did not attempt to test the effect of other heavy structural damage to a building on fire. You seem to be unable to grasp the difference between a test and real world conditions and why tests are done when they obviously cannot mimic all real world conditions.
 
C7, what you are looking at in that picture above is the broken off edge of the south side exterior wall. The corner column is gone. In the crop I have posted below, from figure 5-16 in the FEMA report, you can see what the corner column actually looks like. Compare it also with figure 5-11 in the report. And keep in mind that both photos posted here are tele lens photos with compressed distances. But it is quite obvious that the wall edge is receded compared with the visible parts of the intact part of the SW corner column some floors below.

(click to enlarge)
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1814147060cb62152a.jpg
The corner column is clearly there on floors 17 and 16 in the screen cap i posted. The broken off edge of the wall, as you call it, is the corner column. If the corner column was gone, it would have taken part of the south wall with it and there would be a ragged edge, not the straight edge that we see.

The photo you posted is not as clear as the one i posted. That might be the corner column on [about] floor 12 but it's hard to say.
The NIST photos shows the corner and the first windows are gone on floors 11, 12 and 13.
 
Seriously to me, I just see smoke obstructing the view so would not hang my hat on it, far less accuse people of fakery

If all these pics had no smoke and were clear then I would see the point of this discussion but they are not

leave it and move on to the real meat like silent explosives
 
Here is a Power Point presentation on how the Cardington tests were done. One fire in a limited compartment on one floor for each test, in a test building with a traditional steel grid construction. Nothing like the large scale fires on multiple floors in WTC 7, which had a tube in tube construction, and some unique construction features on the lower floors.

The technically minded reader will find a lot more information here at the University of Manchester.
The Cardington tests don't mention columns, only beams.
The only relevance is, steel frame buildings fair better in fires than previously thought.

The reports on the Meridian Plaza [which had fires on many contiguous floors, and burned much longer than fires in the east half of WTC 7] specifically say that the columns held their loads without obvious damage.

The columns in WTC 7 [79, 80 and 81] were much heavier and therefore they would take much longer to heat up.

http://www.interfire.org/res_file/pdf/Tr-049.pdf
pg 19 [24 on pg counter]
After the fire, there was evident significant structural damage to horizontal steel members and floor sections on most of the fire damaged floors. Beams and girders sagged and twisted -- some as much as three feet -- under severe fire exposures, and fissures developed in the reinforced concrete floor assemblies in many places. Despite this extraordinary exposure, the columns continued to support their loads without obvious damage.

[FONT=&quot]http://www.iklimnet.com/hotelfires/m...a_lessons.html[/FONT]
Experience in this and similar high-rise fires suggest that columns are the least vulnerable structural members, due to their mass and relatively short height between restraints (floor to floor). Major damage has occurred to horizontal members, without compromising the vertical supports.


There is no evidence to support the failure of columns 79, 80 and/or 81.

On the contrary, the evidence clearly states that vertical members do not fail, even in severe fires.

 
The Cardington tests don't mention columns, only beams.

On the contrary, the evidence clearly states that vertical members do not fail, even in severe fires.
[/B]

Did you notice the shortened column on page 13 in the presentation from the Cardington tests that I linked in my earlier post Christopher. The page is labeled "Test 2 - Column shortening".

I have shown you pictures of the same type of damage from some of the WTC buildings in earlier posts. But as usual your WTC 7 columns are immune to fire. What happened in WTC 1 and WTC 2, and what did your favorite expert, Jowenko, say about those two buildings Christopher?
 
Last edited:
Chris one huge wrench I need to throw into your analysis is that you don't know if the building was properly assembled, or if quality steel was used, or quality concrete, or quality connectors. All the scenarios you present are perfect-world, and because perfect-world probably did not exist for WTC7 they must be discounted.

Now about those silent explosives that no one could have planted in a burning building.......
 
The reports on the Meridian Plaza [which had fires on many contiguous floors, and burned much longer than fires in the east half of WTC 7] specifically say that the columns held their loads without obvious damage.

bully for the Meridian Plaza. For some odd reason all real world situations do not have the same results. Go figure.

The columns in WTC 7 [79, 80 and 81] were much heavier and therefore they would take much longer to heat up.

..........<<snip>>.........

There is no evidence to support the failure of columns 79, 80 and/or 81.

On the contrary, the evidence clearly states that vertical members do not fail, even in severe fires.

[/B]

Chris, did columns 79,80 and 81 have fire insulation sprayed on them? If so, and if your contention that there was no way to have a fire large and hot enough to affect them is correct, why did the builders waste time and money putting fire protection on them?

If they were insulated then they are vulnerable which is why they were insulated. Insulation has a time rating because of the expectation that the fire will be fought.

The tests show that columns are affected by fire but that floors and beams suffer more than vertical members. To state that columns 'do not fail, even in severe fires' is a gross misrepresentation of the Cardington tests. Besides which you once again assume a building in pristine condition and no matter what spin you try to put on it, WTC 7 was not, in any way, shape, or form, pristine.
 
Chris one huge wrench I need to throw into your analysis is that you don't know if the building was properly assembled, or if quality steel was used, or quality concrete, or quality connectors. All the scenarios you present are perfect-world, and because perfect-world probably did not exist for WTC7 they must be discounted.

Now about those silent explosives that no one could have planted in a burning building.......

Chris does not want to talk about explosives here. He wants to talk about explosives in the other thread (linked to in this thread, a page or two back).

Chris knows that there are mack truck sized holes in the CD contention so he would rather try and poke pin holes in the debris damge/fire damage hypothesis.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom