Yes, as said many times here, there was severe debris damage to the structure and major fires on several floors. Quite definitive as to the general condition of the structure that day --- it was in bad shape.
And i have been showing that to be a vague, hollow statement.
There was NO damage to the area where the collapse began.
The fires were insufficient to heat core columns to 1,000 F over 4 floors.
A core column, weighing over 4 tons per floor, would have to be uniformly heated to about 1,000 F, and 3 or 4 floors would have to collapse all around that column, before it could break at 3 splice joints and buckle.
That would assume that such column was undergoing stresses that would be considered normal.
There was no significant abnormal stress to the wast end of WTC 7.
WTC 7 was built to carry many times it's live load in a hurricane.
The NIST report is a preliminary report that did not go into the extent of fire damage at all.
The NIST report has three pages detailing the progression of the fires. [photos in FEMA and NIST reports]
NIST has many other photos. If there were any other fires, NIST would have listed them.
C7 said:
There was no debris damage to or near the area of the initiating event.
As pointed out many times , this is not neccessary to cause a collapse initiating failure. Insisting that it is required is naive.
You have claimed this many times.
You fail to grasp the concept that all the framework in between the damage and the area where the collapse began, would take up the stresses.
Correction, was being debated there. It petered out largely because you felt more compelled to post in this thread.
I have responded to all reasonable posts including your last post.
[i am partial to this thread]
C7 said:
I can only show that the evidence does not support the NIST hypothesis.
there you go, attempting to prove that negative.
Not at all. One cannot prove a negative, one can only point out that the people at NIST included enough facts to show that the conditions needed for a core column to fail were not present.
The column is not very sensitive to the number of stories of unbraced. This column would be approaching its load carrying capacity for an unsupported length of four stories if it was also subject to a uniform temperature of 500 °C.
However a floor system failure would further stress other structural systems nearby. It may not be the 'final straw' but it would contribute to the added stress of other systems.
1) It would take the collapse of several floors and the uniform heating of 17 tons of steel column to 1,000 F before failure could occur.
2) There is no evidence of floor failure in the east end of WTC 7, just fires on floors 11 and 12 up until 3:00 p.m., then floor 13, and later floor 8.
"In the mid-1990s British Steel and the Building Research Establishment performed a series of six experiments at Cardington to investigate the behavior of steel frame buildings. These experiments were conducted in a simulated, eight-story building. Secondary steel beams were not protected. Despite the temperature of the steel beams reaching 800-900° C (1,500-1,700° F) in three of the tests (well above the traditionally assumed critical temperature of 600° C (1,100° F), no collapse was observed in any of the six experiments."
In a test structure that was in pristine condition before the test fire and in which only one fire was lit at a time. This was a test fire.
The area of the initiating event was in 'pristine' condition as there was no damage to this area.
Are you saying the test has no bearing and the British Research Establishment just wasted its time and money?
Actually, what the test showed is that steel frame buildings perform better than was previously thought.
Columns and certain other structural elements are normally exposed to fire from all sides. In this fire, the steel columns retained their structural integrity and held their loads.
Experience in this and similar high-rise fires suggest that columns are the least vulnerable structural members, due to their mass and relatively short height between restraints (floor to floor).
Major damage has occurred to horizontal members, without compromising the vertical supports.
In structures that are intact before the fire starts.
The area of the initiating event was intact.
A column which is not bearing its load directly vertically or that has an inordinate lateral stress will react differently.
There were no inordinate lateral stresses on the area of the initiating event.