10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
[qimg]http://img235.imageshack.us/img235/6039/teleblasteriivc4.jpg[/qimg]

The Hi Ex Teleblaster II eliminates the need for wires.

The charges could have been placed in the elevator shafts and on the 5th and 6th floor without people noticing.
The conspirators would have to control security and maintenance.

You are not a CD expert so don't say "It couldn't be done."

See the C7 - C4 thread.


You don't have to be a CD expert to know that they HAVE to sever specific columns with specific amounts of explosives when doing a CD, not just put the charges in elevator shafts and on certain floors.
 
http://img235.imageshack.us/img235/6039/teleblasteriivc4.jpg

The Hi Ex Teleblaster II eliminates the need for wires.

The charges could have been placed in the elevator shafts and on the 5th and 6th floor without people noticing.
The conspirators would have to control security and maintenance.

You are not a CD expert so don't say "It couldn't be done."

See the C7 - C4 thread.
And you are a CD expert? Have you run this little fantasy of yours by one? Or does your experience as a carpenter give you super-powers the rest of us are unaware of?
 
With enough boom boom, you really just need to get close to the columns. The fireworks from that is pretty obvious though.
 
The Hi Ex Teleblaster II eliminates the need for wires.

Perhaps, but it would still take months to set up the explosives; assuming the building was stripped bare.

The charges could have been placed in the elevator shafts and on the 5th and 6th floor without people noticing.

Really ? And could the charges explode without people noticing ?

The conspirators would have to control security and maintenance.

Which miraculously makes them invisible...
 
Notice how Chris's answer to the fact there was no evidence of CD is to say it COULD have been, and since we aren't CD experts we can't say it couldn't have been done.

Actually, the correct response Chris would have been to present your CD evidence because of course you would never be like many other CTs and just poke holes in the official story so you can simply insert some pet alternative theory with no evidence to support it, would you? You must have TONS of evidence to support your theory, right?
 
So the government doesn't mention it in a rough draft and suddenly it can't ever happen.
Between FEMA and NIST, they spent between 2 and 3 years researching and studying WTC 7. Too bad there wasn't a blow job involved or they would have had sufficient funds to get the job done in that time.
It may be a preliminary report but it is definitely not a rough draft.

Let's explain some more. We've seen what happens to moment-frames with the loss of ONE column. WTC7 lost many. In that moment frame (especially the first one I posted), the whole frame moved. The gravity columns (core columns) that are attached to the moment frame go along for a ride.
Go along for the ride? Please, you said the beams had zero capacity to transfer moment to the column.

Once again, the columns were NOT attached to the floor beams.
The floor beams were attached to girders that spanned between the columns.
The girder and the connection at the column would be much stronger than the beam to girder connection.

NIST said the perimeter frame handled the damage.

You are the only one saying that damage to the perimeter frame had a significant effect on the area of the initiating event.

They don't contribute to the lateral stiffness of the building.
The hell they don't. Moment frames, shear walls and diagonal bracing is necessary throughout the building but the massive core columns provide some lateral stiffness.

Don't tell me you know better.
Are you a member of any engineering society like SEAoNY ?
It's easy to overstate you qualifications when using an alias.
Comments like:
A cantilever effect would create an upward load in the columns furthest from the damage.
and
The core columns go along for the ride.
are ridiculous.

The perimeter moment frame affected only the perimeter columns.
Between the perimeter frame and the columns were two beam connections and a girder connection.
These were not moment frames.

This causes a displacement in the gravity columns which in turn generates bending moments. It means that the fires had to be a little less hot to cause that column to fail.
Very little.
Columns 79, 80 and 81 were the first to fail.
They were at the other end of the building.
The amount of vertical load transferred to them was zero.
The amount of lateral load was negligible.
 
With enough boom boom, you really just need to get close to the columns. The fireworks from that is pretty obvious though.

But, the hypothesis is that it looks like a CD, therefore it is. They would not just put a bunch of explosives around and blow out columns. To look like a CD, the columns would have to be taken out at certain angles to ensure the collapse happened as planned. Just putting explosives around a bunch of columns would ensure a collapse, but it definitely would not be controlled.
 
:dl:
Between FEMA and NIST, they spent between 2 and 3 years researching and studying WTC 7. Too bad there wasn't a blow job involved or they would have had sufficient funds to get the job done in that time.
It may be a preliminary report but it is definitely not a rough draft.

Go along for the ride? Please, you said the beams had zero capacity to transfer moment to the column.

Once again, the columns were NOT attached to the floor beams.
The floor beams were attached to girders that spanned between the columns.
The girder and the connection at the column would be much stronger than the beam to girder connection.

NIST said the perimeter frame handled the damage.

You are the only one saying that damage to the perimeter frame had a significant effect on the area of the initiating event.

The hell they don't. Moment frames, shear walls and diagonal bracing is necessary throughout the building but the massive core columns provide some lateral stiffness.

Don't tell me you know better.
Are you a member of any engineering society like SEAoNY ?
It's easy to overstate you qualifications when using an alias.
Comments like:
A cantilever effect would create an upward load in the columns furthest from the damage.
and
The core columns go along for the ride.
are ridiculous.

The perimeter moment frame affected only the perimeter columns.
Between the perimeter frame and the columns were two beam connections and a girder connection.
These were not moment frames.

Very little.
Columns 79, 80 and 81 were the first to fail.
They were at the other end of the building.
The amount of vertical load transferred to them was zero.
The amount of lateral load was negligible.
:dl:

what else can I say/
 
And Christopher7 is now greatly overreaching his carpenter training.



You are the only one saying that damage to the perimeter frame had a significant effect on the area of the initiating event.
No, I said it MIGHT. It COULD. It would take a serious analysis to determine if it DID. I know enough to know that I can't just say one way or another without getting down into some pretty deep maths.

The hell they don't. Moment frames, shear walls and diagonal bracing is necessary throughout the building but the massive core columns provide some lateral stiffness.
By "some" do you mean, "a teeny tiny insignificant little fraction that engineers don't bother with because it's irrelevant"? Mathematically, they have ZERO stiffness. Prove me wrong by determining what the stiffness of a shear plate is. Oh wait, that's right, you can't do that math, can you?

Are you a member of any engineering society like SEAoNY ?
I am a member of SEA. We do not like to call ourselves a society. We are an association. Societies get together and plan balls and how to improve their communitiy. SEA gets together and talks about how much cash one can save by doing a shear wave velocity test or how to get owners onboard with specal inspection.

The core columns go along for the ride.

Since the regular gravity columns have no lateral stiffness, any deflection that the moment frames experience will be transfered to the gravity columns. The FLOOR PLATE, aka the diaphgram, is what binds all of the columns together. When one moves, they all move. This deflection causes bending moments to be generated in the gravity columns. You know this as Torque (in this case moment) = Force * Distance.

The reason why rwguinn is laughing, is that you were just wrong on every single thing in that post. It's amazing what a few classes in engineering will teach you.
 
It looks like this thread is starting its long, lonely descent into Christopheraville.

Very tragic.
 
No, I said it MIGHT. It COULD. It would take a serious analysis to determine if it DID. I know enough to know that I can't just say one way or another without getting down into some pretty deep maths.
Present evidence or be silent.

By "some" do you mean, "a teeny tiny insignificant little fraction that engineers don't bother with because it's irrelevant"? Mathematically, they have ZERO stiffness.
The massive columns in WTC 7 had ZERO stiffness.
Hogwash

I am a member of SEA.
Post your real name so we can verify this.

Since the regular gravity columns have no lateral stiffness, any deflection that the moment frames experience will be transferfred to the gravity columns. The FLOOR PLATE, aka the diaphgram, is what binds all of the columns together. When one moves, they all move.
Exactly
To move one core column, the lateral force would have to move them all.
 
Present evidence or be silent.
Then whay are you still talking.
Are you attempting suicide by mod? You have been presented calculations and evidence by the textbook load.
The massive columns in WTC 7 had ZERO stiffness.
Hey--you got one right!
then rescended it immediately. Go look up Column lateral stability in a real textbook somewhere
Post your real name so we can verify this.
As long as there are people like you on the 'net, it ain'tt going to happen. I take that (you said it to me, too) as a not-very-veiled threat
Exactly
To move one core column, the lateral force would have to move them all.
nope. Bending in the transverse beams will impart a really good-sized lateral force. The ratio of vertical force to lateral force is a function of sin(th)/Cos(th), where tan(th)=Displacement(vertical)/L(beam)
 
Bending in the transverse beams will impart a really good-sized lateral force. The ratio of vertical force to lateral force is a function of sin(th)/Cos(th), where tan(th)=Displacement(vertical)/L(beam)
And all that bombastic beetle sweat proves that significant loads were transferred to columns 79, 80 and 81, at the other end of the building.

How do you suppose the engineers at NIST missed such an important contribution to the global collapse of WTC 7 ?
 
Probably because if you have a basic knowledge of engineering, it's IMPLIED. The degree into which it affects the other columns is a question, it may be tiny. It may be big. THATS ALL we've been saying. The engineers at NIST know this. They also know that the debris damage alone did not cause the collapse. That doesn't mean the damage wasn't significant. It also doesn't mean that it is significant. What it means is: wait for the actual report.
 
The engineers at NIST also knew they had a lot more information to collect on the nature and extent of the damage. To have drawn any further conclusions based on a damage estimate that they knew to be incomplete and inaccurate would have been irresponsible.

Again: wait for the actual report.
 
But, the hypothesis is that it looks like a CD, therefore it is. They would not just put a bunch of explosives around and blow out columns. To look like a CD, the columns would have to be taken out at certain angles to ensure the collapse happened as planned. Just putting explosives around a bunch of columns would ensure a collapse, but it definitely would not be controlled.
Disbelief
Jim Ben Arm
NB
Belz
twinsted

This thread, is about debris damage and fires in WTC 7.

Please post your comments and questions about CD on the CD thread.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2498320#post2498320



You cannot deny that the following statement is true.


There is NO evidence in any government report to support the claim that debris damage had a significant effect on the area of the initiating event, or the collapse of WTC 7.


 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom