So the government doesn't mention it in a rough draft and suddenly it can't ever happen.
Between FEMA and NIST, they spent between 2 and 3 years researching and studying WTC 7. Too bad there wasn't a blow job involved or they would have had sufficient funds to get the job done in that time.
It may be a preliminary report but it is definitely not a rough draft.
Let's explain some more. We've seen what happens to moment-frames with the loss of ONE column. WTC7 lost many. In that moment frame (especially the first one I posted), the whole frame moved. The gravity columns (core columns) that are attached to the moment frame go along for a ride.
Go along for the ride? Please, you said the beams had zero capacity to transfer moment to the column.
Once again, the columns were NOT attached to the floor beams.
The floor beams were attached to girders that spanned between the columns.
The girder and the connection at the column would be much stronger than the beam to girder connection.
NIST said the perimeter frame handled the damage.
You are the only one saying that damage to the perimeter frame had a significant effect on the area of the
initiating event.
They don't contribute to the lateral stiffness of the building.
The hell they don't. Moment frames, shear walls and diagonal bracing is necessary throughout the building but the massive core columns provide some lateral stiffness.
Don't tell me you know better.
Are you a member of any engineering society like SEAoNY ?
It's easy to overstate you qualifications when using an alias.
Comments like:
A cantilever effect would create an upward load in the columns furthest from the damage.
and
The core columns go along for the ride.
are ridiculous.
The perimeter moment frame affected only the perimeter columns.
Between the perimeter frame and the columns were two beam connections and a girder connection.
These were not moment frames.
This causes a displacement in the gravity columns which in turn generates bending moments. It means that the fires had to be a little less hot to cause that column to fail.
Very little.
Columns 79, 80 and 81 were the first to fail.
They were at the other end of the building.
The amount of vertical load transferred to them was zero.
The amount of lateral load was negligible.