10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Can you post his entire statement please?

The firefighters that said there was "no heavy debris in the lobby" gave the most detailed account in the report.

They were not wrong.

It has.

NIST Apx. L June 2004 pg 18 [22 on pg counter]
"Middle 1/4 to 1/3 width of south face gouged out from floor 10 to the ground."

In the Final report of April 5 2005 pg 15
"South Face Damage-
middle 1/4 - 1/3 width south face, 10th floor to ground"


The 30 to 40 foot deep gouge and the damage attributed to it did not exist.


Not seeing the whole statement and knowing when it was made lessens its value.

The most important thing we found was that there was, in fact physical damage to the south face of WTC7. "On about a third of the face to the center and to the bottom approx. 10 stories about 25 percent of the depth of the building was scooped out.
I gave the other. We don't know exactly the damage. So I can't say out deep it was or for how long. The account says "no heavy debris observed in lobby area, white dust coating, black wires hanging from ceiling areas"

However we do have this
After the initial blast, Housing Authority worker Barry Jennings, 46, reported to a command center on the 23rd floor of 7 World Trade Center. He was with Michael Hess, the city's corporation counsel, when they felt and heard another explosion. First calling for help, they scrambled downstairs to the lobby, or what was left of it. "I looked around, the lobby was gone. It looked like hell," Jennings said.
http://www.record-eagle.com/2001/sep/11scene.htm
Part's of Barry's account is also in the NIST report. pg 110
In the NIST report a Port Authority Police Office stated in his fall 03 interview that "A large amount of debris crashed through the front center appox. 10th floor down to the ground level. (page109)NIST1-8
Another states 1/4 width south face, above 5th floor, atrium glass intact.
The NIST report clearly states there are some conflicting descriptions.
 
Last edited:
Guys c'mon, you know you're out of your depth. Christopher7 build a house with wooden poles. He knows what he's talking about.

-Gumboot


I've met many chippies who believe they know how to design and build buildings better than the trained professionals. But strangely, I have only ever met one chippie who managed to get qualified (as a building surveyor). Peculiar that, eh? ;)
 
The most important thing we found was that there was, in fact physical damage to the south face of WTC7. "On about a third of the face to the center and to the bottom approx. 10 stories about 25 percent of the depth of the building was scooped out.
I gave the other. We don't know exactly the damage. So I can't say out deep it was or for how long. The account says "no heavy debris observed in lobby area, white dust coating, black wires hanging from ceiling areas"

However we do have this
After the initial blast, Housing Authority worker Barry Jennings, 46, reported to a command center on the 23rd floor of 7 World Trade Center. He was with Michael Hess, the city's corporation counsel, when they felt and heard another explosion. First calling for help, they scrambled downstairs to the lobby, or what was left of it. "I looked around, the lobby was gone. It looked like hell," Jennings said.
http://www.record-eagle.com/2001/sep/11scene.htm
Part's of Barry's account is also in the NIST report. pg 110
In the NIST report a Port Authority Police Office stated in his fall 03 interview that "A large amount of debris crashed through the front center appox. 10th floor down to the ground level. (page109)NIST1-8
Another states 1/4 width south face, above 5th floor, atrium glass intact.
The NIST report clearly states there are some conflicting descriptions.
Shyam Sunders statement is incorrect.
He said "On about one third of the face to the center and to the bottom aprox. 10 stories and about 25% depth of the building was scooped out."
That would leave a great deal of heavy debris in the lobby.

I have always heard "in the center"

To the center would put the damage west of center.

Barry Jennings cannot be taken literally.
His statement would then be in direct conflict with the professional firefighters who said there was:
"no heavy debris in the lobby area as the building was exited, primarily white dust coating and black wires hanging from ceiling areas."

NIST Apx L pg 50

"...damage......of core framing is not known"


page 109 NIST 1-8 ?
URL please.


ETA Please read post #1884 for more on the 10 story gouge.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2506088#post2506088
 
Last edited:
I've met many chippies who believe they know how to design and build buildings better than the trained professionals. But strangely, I have only ever met one chippie who managed to get qualified (as a building surveyor). Peculiar that, eh? ;)
It really doesn't matter what this chippie hippie thinks.:cool:
The fact is:

There is NO evidence that the debris damage had a significant effect on the collapse of WTC 7.


BTW A person of your stature should be able to come up with something other than irrelevant questions and childish insults.
 
Sorry, but there is no point in engaging you in professional, technical debate. You cling to blatant misunderstandings, whilst disparaging the informed views put to you by people such as Newton who clearly do understand the issues at hand.

It's like dealing with TS1234 or ChristopherA, my friend. Analagous to heads and brick walls, I should imagine.
 
This thread, is about debris damage and fires in WTC 7.

Please post your comments and questions about CD on the CD thread.

Sorry, but your CD hypothesis is very important to this thread, because it seems that this conclusion of yours is preventing you from accepting any evidence or reasoning that contradicts it. I suggest you abandon your CD theory and start from scratch.

You cannot deny that the following statement is true.

There is NO evidence in any government report to support the claim that debris damage had a significant effect on the area of the initiating event, or the collapse of WTC 7.

By your own admittance, it did. The only obstacle left is for you to admit that fire destroys buildings; but that shouldn't be too difficult, should it ?
 
NIST put forth no such hypothesis.

They sited possible debris damage to core columns and fire as the possible causes of the initiating event. [first part of framework to collapse]
Your statement does not say the NIST put forth no such hypothesis. Your statement says there is no evidence for such a hypothesis. This is flat wrong.
 
[qimg]http://img235.imageshack.us/img235/6039/teleblasteriivc4.jpg[/qimg]

The Hi Ex Teleblaster II eliminates the need for wires.

The charges could have been placed in the elevator shafts and on the 5th and 6th floor without people noticing.
The conspirators would have to control security and maintenance.

You are not a CD expert so don't say "It couldn't be done."

See the C7 - C4 thread.

Look at it this way.

A building collapses. To determine the cause, we look at two possible triggers:

1. A 110-story building fell on it. We know this happened.
2. Someone secretly planted explosives in the elevator shafts. We don't know this happened. In fact, we have no evidence whatsoever that this happened.

Which is a more likely cause of the collapse?

Use your head. It's not that complicated.
 
Shyam Sunders statement is incorrect.
He said "On about one third of the face to the center and to the bottom aprox. 10 stories and about 25% depth of the building was scooped out."
That would leave a great deal of heavy debris in the lobby.

I have always heard "in the center"

To the center would put the damage west of center.

Barry Jennings cannot be taken literally.
His statement would then be in direct conflict with the professional firefighters who said there was:
"no heavy debris in the lobby area as the building was exited, primarily white dust coating and black wires hanging from ceiling areas."

NIST Apx L pg 50

"...damage......of core framing is not known"


page 109 NIST 1-8 ?
URL please.


ETA Please read post #1884 for more on the 10 story gouge.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2506088#post2506088

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-8.pdf

The lobby dispute is difficult to resolve. If we could ask the firefighers and Barry, it would better clear up account. But at least we DO know there was damage in the lobby.

Obviously there are various conflicts of damage as the NIST report clearly states. Interestingly the no heavy debris account is clearly from the same rescued Barry Jennings story.
 
Last edited:
Thank you

The lobby dispute is difficult to resolve. If we could ask the firefighers and Barry, it would better clear up account. But at least we DO know there was damage in the lobby.
NIST did ask the firefighters. They gave a professional account of what the saw when leading people out of the building.
Barry is Housing Authority worker trying to escape a build where explosions were going off. He said "the lobby was gone". He was clearly using an expression. He was not trying to accurately describe the damage.

Obviously there are various conflicts of damage as the NIST report clearly states. Interestingly the no heavy debris account is clearly from the same rescued Barry Jennings story.
No
Jennings and Hess scrambled down to the lobby.
The People who heard an explosion on the 8th floor were trapped for an hour and a half until they were rescued by firefighters who led them out of the building.


Did you read post #1883 ? I posted the link.
The 10 story gouge is in conflict with 4 other statements.
In the Final report on April 5 2005, they drop the word 'gouge' and just say damage floor 10 to ground.
 
http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-8.pdf
Interestingly the no heavy debris account is clearly from the same rescued Barry Jennings story.
I just read NIST NCSTAR1-8 pg 109 and viewed the New Footage video.
You are right, Michael Hess was rescued by the firefighters who reported "no heavy debris in the lobby"
So we have an accurate, detailed assessment of the damage to the lobby by professional firefighters and a characterization by a layperson.
 
Thank you


NIST did ask the firefighters. They gave a professional account of what the saw when leading people out of the building.
Barry is Housing Authority worker trying to escape a build where explosions were going off. He said "the lobby was gone". He was clearly using an expression. He was not trying to accurately describe the damage.

No
Jennings and Hess scrambled down to the lobby.
The People who heard an explosion on the 8th floor were trapped for an hour and a half until they were rescued by firefighters who led them out of the building.


Did you read post #1883 ? I posted the link.
The 10 story gouge is in conflict with 4 other statements.
In the Final report on April 5 2005, they drop the word 'gouge' and just say damage floor 10 to ground.

No Barry was clearly one of the people on the 8th floor with Hess. He was one of the three trapped people. Later he went down to the lobby
http://www.cooperativeresearch.org/entity.jsp?entity=barry_jennings_1

Again there are various conflicts. We don't have the full transcript of the interviews which is what I would like to see. from the NIST report
 
Last edited:
Sorry, but there is no point in engaging you in professional, technical debate. You cling to blatant misunderstandings, whilst disparaging the informed views put to you by people such as Newton who clearly do understand the issues at hand.
NB is a self proclaimed expert using an assumed name yet you believe him without question.
His assertion that cantilever effect would create a negative load in the columns furthest away from the damage shows that he is talking thru his hat.
His model shows that a cantilever effect would result in a substantial negative load to column 4 and a small positive load to column 5.
The negative load to column 6 would be negligible and the effect to columns furthest away would be zero.
The effect of severed columns would be the greatest to columns around the severed columns and less to columns further away.
You don't have to be an expert to figure that one out.
 
I just read NIST NCSTAR1-8 pg 109 and viewed the New Footage video.
You are right, Michael Hess was rescued by the firefighters who reported "no heavy debris in the lobby"
So we have an accurate, detailed assessment of the damage to the lobby by professional firefighters and a characterization by a layperson.

Ok, good so at least now you agree on that point.
 
We seem to be 'passing in the night'

Do we agree that the professional firefighters description of the damage is accurate?

Honestly I could go either way. We have a few different accounts. Its clear there was some damage to the lobby. But we don't know how much. When I e-mailed Steve Spak he also mentioned some lower damage to the building. But he was not detailed. There was also a lot of damage and debris in front of the south side as shown from the photos. But I can't say for sure Chris. NIST having access to more detailed information of these accounts stated that there was damage to the middle. However they could very well be mistaken. A lot more information has come in since the report. We know there are new photos, and a damage update from 10/6. Some photos we haven't seen yet will be coming.
Likely we will see more photos soon. But I can't say strongly one way or the other right now.

"First calling for help, they scrambled downstairs to the lobby..." was simply a cut and paste from the AP article.
http://www.record-eagle.com/2001/sep/11scene.htm
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom