10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Architect

I have stated several times that i am a carpenter, not an engineer.

NB provided the calculations that show:

No significant loads would be transferred beyond the second column from the severed column.

You have yet to offer anything to the debate.

Do you think the damage to the SW part of WTC 7 had a significant effect on the area of the
initiating event?
 
Last edited:
Chris, I'm waiting for the full report. What amazes me is that arrogance of a chippy, who clearly has little or no grasp of structural issues and considers that the complex structure of WTC7 is in some way comparable to a couple of 4x2s, trying (and failing) to take someone who is clearly an engineer to task.
 
Chris, I'm waiting for the full report. What amazes me is that arrogance of a chippy, who clearly has little or no grasp of structural issues and considers that the complex structure of WTC7 is in some way comparable to a couple of 4x2s, trying (and failing) to take someone who is clearly an engineer to task.
AHA! Lebe3nty-one 111!!)))!!!!)
Obviously you ain't no archetect! 4x2. Ha! Everbidy no's that they is 2 by 4's!:D:D
 
What I have provided, Christopher7, is a simple model showing the effects of a basic moment frame designed to resist a progressive collapse. What you only look to see, is the gravity load transfered. I showed the moment transfer as well and it was significant even to that last column. The actual effect was to increase the interaction equation (where 1.0 = failure) of the columns by more than 0.1. This is not insignificant. I cannot translate what this means to WTC7 beyond the fact that I know the damage did have AN effect on the whole building. What level, I cannot tell, but it's not zero.

Again, this is a model of a MOMENT-FRAME. This type of system is what the perimeter of WTC7 was. The interior was gravity framed. This means that the connection from the beams is not considered continuous through the column. These connections have basically zeor capacity to transfer moment to the column. What a gravity column fails, something very different happens. The column, and everything above it, drops until something arrests its movement. This is typically the ground. However, if a sufficiently strong connection is at the column, the beams that attach to it can go into what is known as catenary action. Unable to support the column through bending stiffness(like a moment frame) they instead become tension only members. Essentially ropes. Much more lateral load is induced into the system. These lateral loads will act out of plane to the moment frames and can cause the whole building to be pulled inwards (if the building is capable of supporting).

I cannot provide a model of this as the software I have is not capable of analyzing this by default. I could probably jury-rig something, but I wouldn't be able to verify the results without doing many hours of hand-calcs, which I'm not going to do.

The model does not reflect WTC7. You said so yourself a few pages ago when you were trying to discount the CONCEPT I was offering. The concept holds true, but the actual behavior does not. The actual transfer of loads may be vastly larger to columns further away, or it may even be vastly smaller. It all depends on exactly what beams and what columns (even the floor deck to a degree) are. And I cannot model this without somewhere around 100 hours of time.
 
Chris, I'm waiting for the full report. What amazes me is that arrogance of a chippy, who clearly has little or no grasp of structural issues and considers that the complex structure of WTC7 is in some way comparable to a couple of 4x2s, trying (and failing) to take someone who is clearly an engineer to task.
Really? You [all] seem to be a bit skeptical about my credentials.
No worries.

Do you think this statement is true?

"If a cantilevered beam is developed, an upward load will actually develop in the columns furthest from the damage."

I don't


Stop insulting the arguer and address the argument.

Please read the following post and state weather or not YOU agree.
 
The damage to the south west part of WTC 7 did not weaken or have a significant effect on the area of the initiating event.


NIST Apx. L pg 36

"If the initiating event was due to damage to the perimeter moment frame, then it would have started along the south or southwest facade."

"Analysis of the global structure indicates that the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged areas. Progression of column failure to adjacent columns would have been arrested by the vierendeel of the perimeter moment frame which could span across a sizeable opening due to the strength and stiffness of the frame,"

The report then talks about possible damage to core columns and fires in the area of the initiating event.

pg 37

" I2.1 South facade damaged
> I3.1 Perimeter moment frame redistributes loads around damage
> I4.1 Local failure only"

PG 41

"
If a group of perimeter columns failed, the perimeter framing above this area would have redistributed its loads, due to the redundancy of the moment frame."

pg 42

" Initiating event scenarios from I4.4 to I4.6
> V1.1 Any perimeter column fails
> V2.1 Collapse does not progress vertically"

The report makes no further mention of the damage to the south face.

They site core damage and fires as the possible causes of the initiating event.
 
What I have provided, Christopher7, is a simple model showing the effects of a basic moment frame designed to resist a progressive collapse. What you only look to see, is the gravity load transfered. I showed the moment transfer as well and it was significant even to that last column. The actual effect was to increase the interaction equation (where 1.0 = failure) of the columns by more than 0.1. This is not insignificant. I cannot translate what this means to WTC7 beyond the fact that I know the damage did have AN effect on the whole building. What level, I cannot tell, but it's not zero.
I agree. The effect was to the whole building which means it was shared by all the components of the framework.
The loads would be the greatest next to the severed columns and less to columns further away because each column in turn would resist or take up some of the lateral load.

Again, this is a model of a MOMENT-FRAME. This type of system is what the perimeter of WTC7 was. The interior was gravity framed. This means that the connection from the beams is not considered continuous through the column. These connections have basically zero capacity to transfer moment to the column.
The floor beams were attached to the girders which spaned between the columns.
As you say, the floor beams had zero capacity ability to twist the girders and hence, the columns.

We are talking about hanging, broken floors, minus their live load.

The core columns are capable of carying several times their live load.

The hanging floors will create some lateral force.

What a gravity column fails, something very different happens.
The first columns to fail were columns 79, 80 and 81.
[the eastern most core columns]

The model does not reflect WTC7. You said so yourself a few pages ago when you were trying to discount the CONCEPT I was offering. The concept holds true, but the actual behavior does not. The actual transfer of loads may be vastly larger to columns further away,
I disagree.
Run your model again using more columns and see what happens, before making that claim.

or it may even be vastly smaller. It all depends on exactly what beams and what columns (even the floor deck to a degree) are. And I cannot model this without somewhere around 100 hours of time.
There is no way to accurately assess the actual damage so a 100 hr. model would not be all that useful anyway.
 
Why do you always trot that same sentence out as if it is some sublime statement that answers any possible questions as to the validity of your theory?
Post #2247 summaries NIST Apx. L pg 36 - 42.

They make it clear that the damage to the perimeter columns did not cause the initiating event. [first part of the framework to fail]

They site core damage and fires as possible causes.

They did not say that the damage to the perimeter columns was a contributing factor.

Do they have to specifically say it wasn't a factor?



I'm no structural engineer, but I've seen and heard enough of them tell you that you don't know what the hell you're talking about to believe them over you.
Do you believe them over the engineers at NIST ?
 
I love how this has turned into yet another "christophera" type of thing

where one who is arguing about a preliminary paper states, that is being handled by EXPERTS in engineering, thinks that whatever is said in that "preliminary" report is what is definitely final.

forget that they are still investigating; forget that he of course is not an expert

architect,newtons.. there is no use. you are arguing with a brick wall.
 
The debris caused the fires but there is no confirmation that the fires caused the collapse.

Very well, then. I suppose we can work on that.

What do you expect as "confirmation" that the fires caused the collapse ? Since you know there were fires; since you know that the fires were caused by the debris and that you know the origin of the debris can be accounted for, since you know that fires cause many buildings to collapse at least partially, and since you probably know that you can't possibly rig demolition charges in a burning, 47-floor building in so short a time; How do you explain the building's collapse if not by the fires ?

Who's playing with semantics?
I interpret around to mean surrounding or next to because of the way they used it in the sentence.
What definition do you choose and why?

I would opt for around meaning "in close proximity", which doesn't necessarily limit the load transfert to the immediate adjacent columns. Since NIST does not seem to specify that in your oft-quoted paragraph, how can you assume what they meant, exactly ? You wouldn't by any chance be using your own personal conclusion as a compass, here ?

The amount of stress to the area of the initiating event was negligible.
If it were significant, NIST would have said so.

Perhaps, but if one thing caused another that caused the collapse, I'd say the first thing has something to do with the last.
 
I agree. The effect was to the whole building which means it was shared by all the components of the framework.
The loads would be the greatest next to the severed columns and less to columns further away because each column in turn would resist or take up some of the lateral load.

Bolding mine.

So now you're saying that the loads would be greatest next to the severed columns, which in turn implies that the rest would be distributed among columns that were not "around" the severed ones. Which is it, Chris ? Was it ONLY on the adjacent columns or not ?
 
The floor beams were attached to the girders which spaned between the columns.
As you say, the floor beams had zero capacity ability to twist the girders and hence, the columns.

The hanging floors will create some lateral force.
Actually, they already put in a bending moment into the columns due to the eccentricity of the column, but the reaction of the beam at the column has no bending moment inherient in it. I'm not talking twisting (technically: torque), I'm talking moment (bending). They're two completly different things.

Run your model again using more columns and see what happens, before making that claim.
It's not the NUMBER of columns, it's their stiffness. How many times do I have to say this?

The core columns are capable of carying several times their live load.
No, they weren't. Under Dead + Live conditions, the columns would be at 60% capacity if designed correctly. This live load on the columns is also 50psf, not the 100psf that the floors were designed for. If you had an actual engineering background you'd already know this.
 
What do you expect as "confirmation" that the fires caused the collapse ?
With out the physical evidence, i don't think it can be confirmed.

I read somewhere that a few pieces of WTC 7 steel were salvaged but that's a subject for the C7 --- C4 thread.

Since you know there were fires; since you know that the fires were caused by the debris and that you know the origin of the debris can be accounted for, since you know that fires cause many buildings to collapse at least partially,
No modern high rise steel frame building has collapsed due to fire.

The Madrid Tower was primarily a reinforced concrete building with light weight perimeter columns on the upper floors that collapsed over a period of time.

and since you probably know that you can't possibly rig demolition charges in a burning, 47-floor building in so short a time;
And therein lies the rub.

It had to have been rigged in advance.

How do you explain the building's collapse if not by the fires ?
This seems to be the reasoning here:

I don't see how they could rig WTC 7 in advance or how the charges survived the fire, therefore it was not a CD.

I believe it was a CD. The CD thread is here:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2498320#post2498320

I would opt for around meaning "in close proximity", which doesn't necessarily limit the load transfert to the immediate adjacent columns. Since NIST does not seem to specify that in your oft-quoted paragraph, how can you assume what they meant, exactly ? You wouldn't by any chance be using your own personal conclusion as a compass, here ?
Close proximity works for me.

The loads would be transferred to the next undamaged column.
That column would bear the load or collapse.
There was no progressive collapse.
There is no reason to think that significant loads were transferred to the area of the initiating event at the other end of the building.

NB pointed out that negative loads could be transferred to the second undamaged column.
In the third column [5 in his model] there was a negligible positive load.

Perhaps, but if one thing caused another that caused the collapse, I'd say the first thing has something to do with the last.
Had something to do with yes, but the damage itself did not weaken the area of, or contribute to the initiating event.

Bottom line, people here keep saying or inferring that the debris damage contributed to the collapse.

There is NO evidence in any government report to support that claim.
 
Last edited:
Bolding mine.

So now you're saying that the loads would be greatest next to the severed columns, which in turn implies that the rest would be distributed among columns that were not "around" the severed ones. Which is it, Chris ? Was it ONLY on the adjacent columns or not ?
We were discussing lateral loads, not vertical loads.

Vertical loads would be transferred to the column next to the severed or damaged column.

Lateral loads would be bourn by the whole building with the greatest stress to the columns next to the severed or damaged columns, and less to columns further away.
 
And therein lies the rub.

It had to have been rigged in advance.

...and yet another unnecessary entity is born!

This seems to be the reasoning here:

I don't see how they could rig WTC 7 in advance or how the charges survived the fire, therefore it was not a CD.

More than that. There is no EVIDENCE that this was done. In fact, given that NO ONE who worked in this office building noticed all the wiring and charges and other preparations that would be necessary for this to happen, there is substantial evidence against it.

Bottom line, people here keep saying or inferring that the debris damage contributed to the collapse.

There is NO evidence in any government report to support that claim.

Where is evidence of a CD?
 
Bottom line, people here keep saying or inferring that the debris damage contributed to the collapse.

There is NO evidence in any government report to support that claim.


So the government doesn't mention it in a rough draft and suddenly it can't ever happen. Let's explain some more. We've seen what happens to moment-frames with the loss of ONE column. WTC7 lost many. In that moment frame (especially the first one I posted), the whole frame moved. The gravity columns (core columns) that are attached to the moment frame go along for a ride. They don't contribute to the lateral stiffness of the building. This causes a displacement in the gravity columns which in turn generates bending moments. It means that the fires had to be a little less hot to cause that column to fail.
 
With out the physical evidence, i don't think it can be confirmed.

Then it seems your position is nicely unfalsifiable.

No modern high rise steel frame building has collapsed due to fire.

None have been subjected to such conditions. "No Belz... has ever died" is another nice claim that is so precise as to be meaningless. Do you admit that every event has to happen a first time ?

The Madrid Tower was primarily a reinforced concrete building with light weight perimeter columns on the upper floors that collapsed over a period of time.

But it did collapse. It's a good thing it wasn't made only of steel, eh ?

And therein lies the rub.

It had to have been rigged in advance.

Only in the hypothesis that charges WERE used.

Let's just play a hypothetical scenario. Let's say the badguys rig 7 WTC for demolition. They know, somehow, that 1 WTC will collapse, and for some reason they figure a shredder wouldn't adequately get rid of those annoying documents. Nor will a campfire, apparently. But wait! What if 1 WTC debris DON'T fall on 7 WTC and DON'T start fires ? They would've had to cancel their plans for demolitions, right ? And if the fires were too light and they demolished it anyway and NIST began to suspect foul play ?

Your hypothesis not only makes no sense when put into perspective, but also ignores the fact that explosive charges may have been irrevocably damaged by the debris and fires.

What say you ?

The loads would be transferred to the next undamaged column.
That column would bear the load or collapse.
There was no progressive collapse.
There is no reason to think that significant loads were transferred to the area of the initiating event at the other end of the building.

But that doesn't follow from "close proximity". Close proximity entails SOME added loads to columns further away, does it not ? Otherwise we're back at "next to".

Had something to do with yes, but the damage itself did not weaken the area of, or contribute to the initiating event.

That's a contradiction.
 
More than that. There is no EVIDENCE that this was done. In fact, given that NO ONE who worked in this office building noticed all the wiring and charges and other preparations that would be necessary for this to happen, there is substantial evidence against it.

teleblasteriivc4.jpg


The Hi Ex Teleblaster II eliminates the need for wires.

The charges could have been placed in the elevator shafts and on the 5th and 6th floor without people noticing.
The conspirators would have to control security and maintenance.

You are not a CD expert so don't say "It couldn't be done."

Where is evidence of a CD?
See the C7 - C4 thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom