10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
I wasn't aware the columns were visible from the outside.

Intuition



Thank you. This admission invalidates your point and proves mine. So, there was no debris damage or diesel fire at the initiating point; but the debris damage caused the fires.

Although it's implied, are you saying that these fires brought down the building ? If so, I believe this thread is over..
It was, long ago. Like a Zombie, chris just doesn'tknow it yet



I'd like to see this, too..

NewtonsBit did it, wheter any twoofer wants to admit it or not.



You're playing semantics again. You still haven't told me how you choose this definition of "around" as over the other 32..

through circular reasoning, as usual. If you can't chase your own tail, where is the fun


Isn't stress a weakening factor, one way or the other ?

Nope. Stress is a result of the load.
You don't put mechanical parts under stress--you put a strain on them by applying a load. Stress is the measure of that.
Just another area where Chris is talking out of his nether regions, without a clue.

A hint, Christopher7--If you can't even use the correct terminology, all we can do is laugh and point.
 
I wasn't aware the columns were visible from the outside.
They are obvious is the Spak photo with graphics and the version i posted.

Thank you. This admission invalidates your point and proves mine. So, there was no debris damage or diesel fire at the initiating point; but the debris damage caused the fires.
OMG i stuck my foot in it, didn't i ?
Allow me to rephrase that.
The debris caused the fires but there is no confirmation that the fires caused the collapse.

You're playing semantics again. You still haven't told me how you choose this definition of "around" as over the other 32.
Who's playing with semantics?
I interpret around to mean surrounding or next to because of the way they used it in the sentence.
What definition do you choose and why?

Isn't stress a weakening factor, one way or the other ?
The amount of stress to the area of the initiating event was negligible.
If it were significant, NIST would have said so.
 
<<snip>>
Who's playing with semantics?
I interpret around to mean surrounding or next to because of the way they used it in the sentence.
What definition do you choose and why?

In the strictest of terms, "Around" means some way other than "Through". You are way too specific.

<<The amount of stress to the area of the initiating event was negligible.
If it were significant, NIST would have said so.

Still don't understand anything at all about stress,strain, loads, and the relationships between them, do you ,Chris?
 
care to comment, Christopher7?
Around; core meaning:
surrounds a place or is situated on all sides of it

In the sentence;

"Analysis of the global structure indicates that the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged areas."

around means on all sides of it.

Loads would be transferred to the columns next to the severed or damaged columns.

NB's generalized model shows that loads will not transfer very far.
Column 4 had a significant negative load and column 5 had a small positive load. Beyond that, loads would be negligible.

The lateral stresses would be transferred to the entire building thru hundreds of moment frames.

You are trying to imply that the debris damage to the south west part of WTC 7, weakened and/or had a significant effect on the area of the initiating event. It did not.
If it were a factor, NIST would have said so. They did not.
 
NB's generalized model shows that loads will not transfer very far.
Column 4 had a significant negative load and column 5 had a small positive load. Beyond that, loads would be negligible.

The lateral stresses would be transferred to the entire building thru hundreds of moment frames.

1) You're not thinking 3D.

2) You use the word moment frame, but you have no idea what it means. I built a best case model, a VERY stiff moment frame. The moment frames in the WTC7 are not necessarily the same.

3) You keep using words like "stress" and have no idea what it means. Stress is not transfered to other parts of the building. FORCES are. They're two very different things. Stress is a function of a force based on the dimension of the member a force is acting on and the direction of the force based on it's position along that member.

4) There were not hundreds of moment frames, the long side of the building had 15 frames. Its construction was very different than WTC1&2 which had perimeter columns at 3'-4" o.c.
 
1) You're not thinking 3D.

2) You use the word moment frame, but you have no idea what it means. I built a best case model, a VERY stiff moment frame. The moment frames in the WTC7 are not necessarily the same.

3) You keep using words like "stress" and have no idea what it means. Stress is not transfered to other parts of the building. FORCES are. They're two very different things. Stress is a function of a force based on the dimension of the member a force is acting on and the direction of the force based on it's position along that member.

4) There were not hundreds of moment frames, the long side of the building had 15 frames. Its construction was very different than WTC1&2 which had perimeter columns at 3'-4" o.c.
You ignored the issue completely.

The damage to the south west face had no significant effect on the area of the initiating event.
 
You ignored the issue completely.

The damage to the south west face had no significant effect on the area of the initiating event.

You're ignoring the fact you don't know anything about what you're talking about. You use the word significant, but to be able to properly use that term you need to be at least passingly familiar with the subject. You've proven to everyone who's had the misfortune of following this thread that you do not have any grasp of structural engineering. This is not a slight on your character, knowledge of this requires years and years of study, which you have not had.

Without running a full-scale model, even I can't tell you if the damage had a significant effect. But that's exactly the point. I know enough to know that this is an exceptionally complicated problem, and that you can't whisk an educated guess out of the air without performing a good 100 hours worth of engineering analysis. And even then, it's still just a guess.
 
The damage to the south west face had no significant effect on the area of the initiating event.

Why do you always trot that same sentence out as if it is some sublime statement that answers any possible questions as to the validity of your theory?

I'm no structural engineer, but I've seen and heard enough of them tell you that you don't know what the hell you're talking about to believe them over you.
 
Chris

Tell me. How long does it take to qualify as a structural engineer and what is involved by way of study?
 
Without running a full-scale model, even I can't tell you if the damage had a significant effect. But that's exactly the point. I know enough to know that this is an exceptionally complicated problem, and that you can't whisk an educated guess out of the air without performing a good 100 hours worth of engineering analysis. And even then, it's still just a guess.
The problem is not that complicated.

Your model shows that loads become negligible beyond the second column from the damage.

We both know that lateral stress will be distributed to the entire building.

Please read post #2217

NIST made it clear, by omission, that the damage to the perimeter columns did not have a significant effect on the area of the initiating event.

There is no reason to believe otherwise.

Thank you for admitting that you don't know and that 100 hours of analysis would still result in a guess.
 
The problem is not that complicated.

Your model shows that loads become negligible beyond the second column from the damage.

We both know that lateral stress will be distributed to the entire building.

Please read post #2217

NIST made it clear, by omission, that the damage to the perimeter columns did not have a significant effect on the area of the initiating event.

There is no reason to believe otherwise.

Thank you for admitting that you don't know and that 100 hours of analysis would still result in a guess.
so, a 15% reduction in vertical load 1 column removed, and a 3% increase in vertical load plus a new horizontal load of 5% of the vertical load 2 columns removed is insignificant?
stick to your lumber, nails, and backyard sheds, boy.
You don't have a clue.
 
A hint, Christopher7--If you can't even use the correct terminology, all we can do is laugh and point.
snob:

1) somebody who looks down on others
somebody who admires and cultivates relationships with those considered socially superior, and disdains those considered inferior

2) somebody who feels superior
somebody who looks down on people considered to have inferior knowledge or tastes
 
so, a 15% reduction in vertical load 1 column removed, and a 3% increase in vertical load plus a new horizontal load of 5% of the vertical load 2 columns removed is insignificant?
The effect to columns beyond the first 2 columns is insignificant.
This includes the area of the initiating event.
 
Come on, lad.
You're the one calling yourself an architect, you tell me.

BTW, Mr. architect, do you think that the damage to the south west perimeter frame had a significant effect on the area of the initiating event?

If so, why do you suppose the experts at NIST didn't think of it?
 
4 years university, usually a further 2-3 practical work prior to sitting your exams for your MIStructE. Subjects will include, amongst others, plastic and elastic theory, structural analysis, and design work.

I'm just intrigued how, having conveniently bypassed all this, you purport to understand structures more accurately than NB. Perhaps you coudl fill us in?
 
4 years university, usually a further 2-3 practical work prior to sitting your exams for your MIStructE. Subjects will include, amongst others, plastic and elastic theory, structural analysis, and design work.

I'm just intrigued how, having conveniently bypassed all this, you purport to understand structures more accurately than NB. Perhaps you coudl fill us in?
I already have.
Perhaps you could post something relevant.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom