10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Probably because if you have a basic knowledge of engineering, it's IMPLIED. The degree into which it affects the other columns is a question, it may be tiny. It may be big. THATS ALL we've been saying. The engineers at NIST know this. They also know that the debris damage alone did not cause the collapse. That doesn't mean the damage wasn't significant. It also doesn't mean that it is significant. What it means is: wait for the actual report.
OK

Will everyone here stop saying or implying that the debris damage to WTC 7 had a significant effect on the collapse until the final report comes out?
 
There is NO evidence in any government report to support the claim that debris damage had a significant effect on the area of the initiating event, or the collapse of WTC 7.*
And yet, the hypothesis as it stands is entirely plausible. Funny that.

Wait for the actual report.

*...other than the leaning, bulging, and creaking.
 
then will you stop implying that they did not until the final report comes out? how about you stop guessing as to what happened until you get your engineering degree.
 
OK

Will everyone here stop saying or implying that the debris damage to WTC 7 had a significant effect on the collapse until the final report comes out?
Sure. So long as you stop saying or implying that the debris damage had no significant effect on the collapse and that there is any evidence of CD.

Deal?
 
Disbelief
Jim Ben Arm
NB
Belz
twinsted

This thread, is about debris damage and fires in WTC 7.

Please post your comments and questions about CD on the CD thread.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2498320#post2498320



You cannot deny that the following statement is true.


There is NO evidence in any government report to support the claim that debris damage had a significant effect on the area of the initiating event, or the collapse of WTC 7.
Excuse me, but until you are made a mod, don't tell me where or what I can post. I don't take any orders from you, dude!
 
Post #2247 summaries NIST Apx. L pg 36 - 42.

They make it clear that the damage to the perimeter columns did not cause the initiating event. [first part of the framework to fail]

They site core damage and fires as possible causes.

They did not say that the damage to the perimeter columns was a contributing factor.

Do they have to specifically say it wasn't a factor?



Do you believe them over the engineers at NIST ?
Against my better judgement I'm going to post in this thread again.
Actually here's what Sunder (NIST) said in a more recent interview for Popular Mechanics. (Or I should say more recent than the draft report)

"Sunder says it appears the fires worked in conjunction with the damage from debris to weaken the building's structure, but NIST has not determined whether one or the other was the primary instigator of the collapse."

Page 56 Debunking 9/11 Myths
 
Last edited:
then will you stop implying that they did not until the final report comes out?
I will not state it as a fact but i will continue to say i believe it to be true.

There is no evidence that debris damage contributed to the collapse.

There is no reason to believe the damage to the south west part of WTC 7 contributed to the collapse. IMO


I am trying to word the statement in a way that we can agree.

There is no evidence that debris damage had a significant effect on the collapse of WTC 7.

 
Excuse me, but until you are made a mod, don't tell me where or what I can post. I don't take any orders from you, dude!
Perhaps you're not familiar with the word "Please".

"Used to add politeness to requests"

Do you know the difference between an order and a request?
 
Against my better judgement I'm going to post in this thread again.
Actually here's what Sunder (NIST) said in a more recent interview for Popular Mechanics. (Or I should say more recent than the draft report)

"Sunder says it appears the fires worked in conjunction with the damage from debris to weaken the building's structure, but NIST has not determined whether one or the other was the primary instigator of the collapse."

Page 56 Debunking 9/11 Myths
When did he make that statement?

He also said that there was a gouge 30 to 40 feet deep, 60 to 80 feet wide from floor 10 to the ground.

This is not true.

Either he is wrong or the firefighters who reported "no heavy debris in the lobby" are wrong.


Has Mr. Sunder made that statement publicly [like in PM magazine] or just in a book costing $12.98 ?
 
That is a matter of opinion.
No. Plausibility, in evaluating a hypothesis, is entirely objective.

The drastically simplified version:
Does it fit the observed data? Yes or no.
Is it falsifiable? Yes or no.
If yes to both, it's plausible.

Plausibility (a matter of objective analysis) has nothing to do with probability (a matter of objective & subjective judgment) or believability (a matter of subjective opinion).

NIST's hypothesis is entirely plausible. Their subsequent work will falsify, correct, or affirm this hypothesis.
 
Last edited:
I am trying to word the statement in a way that we can agree.

There is no evidence that debris damage had a significant effect on the collapse of WTC 7.
Corrected:

The FEMA report and the preliminary NIST draft contain no direct evidence (other than leaning, bulging, and creaking) that debris damage had a significant effect on the collapse of WTC 7.
 
Corrected:

The FEMA report and the preliminary NIST draft contain no direct evidence (other than leaning, bulging, and creaking) that debris damage had a significant effect on the collapse of WTC 7.
There's nothing in the NIST report about WTC 7 leaning.

That is a 9/11 myth.

The bulging was in the SW corner.

The creaking no doubt accompanied the bulging.
 
When did he make that statement?

He also said that there was a gouge 30 to 40 feet deep, 60 to 80 feet wide from floor 10 to the ground.

This is not true.

Either he is wrong or the firefighters who reported "no heavy debris in the lobby" are wrong.


Has Mr. Sunder made that statement publicly [like in PM magazine] or just in a book costing $12.98 ?

He said "approximately 10 stories" Both may be wrong. We don't know currently the exact size right now. But no doubt the size has changed from the eariler report.
Its in the book. Sometime after the report and before June of last year. Again I quoted the page. Does the price for $12.98 some how lessen the statement?
 
Last edited:
There's nothing in the NIST report about WTC 7 leaning.

That is a 9/11 myth.

The bulging was in the SW corner.

The creaking no doubt accompanied the bulging.
No doubt. How does this square with your "no evidence"?

Evidence, remember. Not proof. Evidence supporting a hypothesis. A falsifiable hypothesis that has to be tested.

This is objective evidence supporting the hypothesis that the debris damage caused significant shifts in the loading of the building. The hypothesis may be wrong (wait for the actual report) but to say there is no evidence supporting it is flat wrong.
 
No doubt. How does this square with your "no evidence"?

Evidence, remember. Not proof. Evidence supporting a hypothesis. A falsifiable hypothesis that has to be tested.

This is objective evidence supporting the hypothesis that the debris damage caused significant shifts in the loading of the building.
NIST put forth no such hypothesis.

They sited possible debris damage to core columns and fire as the possible causes of the initiating event. [first part of framework to collapse]
 
Guys c'mon, you know you're out of your depth. Christopher7 build a house with wooden poles. He knows what he's talking about.

-Gumboot
 
A.There's nothing in the NIST report about WTC 7 leaning.

B. That is a 9/11 myth.


A. It is not out yet!
B. 911 "myths" may be the only thing, you are a leading"scholar" in! Tooo bad for you, this is not one of those things!

Lettering by moi!
 
He said "approximately 10 stories" Both may be wrong.
Can you post his entire statement please?

The firefighters that said there was "no heavy debris in the lobby" gave the most detailed account in the report.

They were not wrong.

We don't know currently the exact size right now. But no doubt the size has changed from the earlier report.
It has.

NIST Apx. L June 2004 pg 18 [22 on pg counter]
"Middle 1/4 to 1/3 width of south face gouged out from floor 10 to the ground."

In the Final report of April 5 2005 pg 15
"South Face Damage-
middle 1/4 - 1/3 width south face, 10th floor to ground"


The 30 to 40 foot deep gouge and the damage attributed to it did not exist.


Its in the book. Sometime after the report and before June of last year. Again I quoted the page. Does the price for $12.98 some how lessen the statement?
Not seeing the whole statement and knowing when it was made lessens its value.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom