10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's nice, so what?
The perimeter columns next to the severed columns did not fail.

You can't actually tell. If they failed due to ineleastic buckling, the actual visible deflection would be minimal. The column would resist a certain force and then after that it would just continually deflect with the same load unless the force was relieved by other columns.

Wrong, please stop misquoting me.

#2086
It's the 1 column pulling 5 columns sideways that i find bloody ridiculous, but that's above my pay grade. [as they say]
#2099
Some people here can't grasp the concept that gravity pulls things straight down, not sideways.

Is lateral force not sideways? The actual lateral force in my simple model was 15,000 pounds. This is not insignificant.

NB pointed out that there could have been a negative load to columns adjoining the columns next to the severed columns but no one has shown how a positive load could be transferred to columns beyond the columns next to the severed columns.

Lateral loads and moment transfer will effect that other side. The upwards load could be a big deal in a light breeze. The entire floor plate could act as a massive cantilever if enough columns in the right place fail.

As a carpenter, i understand how this works.
Then you should have been able to point out everything that I proved in my models before it happened. Unfortunately you claimed many many things that were proven wrong. I guess we all know how a carpenter understands structures now.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps Architect could provide some calculations to show how this would be possible.

I'll take that half-arsed attempt at a witty reply as confirmation that you cannot, in fact, post any structural calculations which come close to those put up by NB already.
 
I haven't put up calculations Architect, I put up the results of a model that did calculations for me :D

It would take about 5 hours to do that model by hand. And that's assuming that three hours in I don't realize I didn't carry a negative through and have to start all over again.
 
I haven't put up calculations Architect, I put up the results of a model that did calculations for me :D

It would take about 5 hours to do that model by hand. And that's assuming that three hours in I don't realize I didn't carry a negative through and have to start all over again.
or forgot and used the Left Hand rule...
What did you use? ANSYS? ALGOR? COSMOS? ProE? I don't recognize the format. It doesn't matter--they all do pretty much the same thing. Just curious...
 
It's RISA. Finite-Element, but quick. It's fairly limited in the dynamic and inelastic regions, but for just figuring which force goes where, it's good.
 
It's RISA. Finite-Element, but quick. It's fairly limited in the dynamic and inelastic regions, but for just figuring which force goes where, it's good.

I'll look into it. I've been looking for a decent cross between rigid-body statics and indeterminate elastic loads program. Does it do stress, or does it just give enough data for MC/I calc's?
 
This is why I need to find myself a book on mechanical engineering, I was never a great student but I am capable of doing the maths and understanding the concepts behind it.

That would be a laugh wouldn't it, putting myself through university to get a structural engineering qualification purely to debunk LC :)
 
You could self-teach. Assuming that you have a decent background in calculus and diferential equations, you'll need the following books:


Statics
Mechanics of Materials
Dynamics

Those three will get you the basic concepts. You'll then need a bit more:
Steel Design
Concrete Design

Along with those two, you'll want to get the new AISC Manual of Steel Construction (13th edition) as well as an ACI 318-05 and the PCA notes that go with it for concrete.

You'll also want a book on solving indeterminate frames and maybe a book on Finite Element just as a reference as to how it used to be done, though I don't have any of those to recommend. Finite Elements completly changed the whole engineering world and made computer models possible.

I hope you have about 2 years of paid time off stored up =]
 
You could self-teach. Assuming that you have a decent background in calculus and diferential equations, you'll need the following books:


Statics
Mechanics of Materials
Dynamics
You ought to be able to find copies of Beer and Johnston (Vector Mechanics for Engineers:Statics and Vector Mechanics for Engineers: Dynamics) from back in the 70's (Copyright is 1962 on mine). They give you basics, which, despite the contentions of some, have not changed significantly in decades...:D

For mechaince of materials, I have Beyers & Snyder Engineering Mechanics of Deformable Bodies.
I also recommend a decent Kinematics reference... Wish I had one. (decent one, that is)

Those three will get you the basic concepts. You'll then need a bit more:
Steel Design
Concrete Design

Along with those two, you'll want to get the new AISC Manual of Steel Construction (13th edition) as well as an ACI 318-05 and the PCA notes that go with it for concrete.

You'll also want a book on solving indeterminate frames and maybe a book on Finite Element just as a reference as to how it used to be done, though I don't have any of those to recommend. Finite Elements completly changed the whole engineering world and made computer models possible.

I hope you have about 2 years of paid time off stored up =]

I also recommend Jan Tuma's Engineering Mathematics Handbook as a reference. You can pick up a copy on Ebay for like $10 or less, if you don't insist on the latest edition. Mine is 3rd edition.
If you have some of the background, the PE Review manuals are very good for looking things up. Check with NSPE for your favorite specialty..
 
You could self-teach. Assuming that you have a decent background in calculus and diferential equations, you'll need the following books:

I hope you have about 2 years of paid time off stored up =]

Thanks for the book links, I'm actually from the UK but I will find them over here and add them to my wishlist. I have a reasonable background in calculus and I am planning on re-reading some textbooks to get me back up to scratch on differential equations (and bloody integration). Currently reading Horowitz and Hall, The Art of Electronics.

As for my paid time off, oh how I would love to have nothing to do all day but read textbooks. Still I'm young and there's plenty of time to go to university if my hopes of contracting come about :)

I appreciate the advice, both of you.
 
I'll look into it. I've been looking for a decent cross between rigid-body statics and indeterminate elastic loads program. Does it do stress, or does it just give enough data for MC/I calc's?

It's full blown stress analysis. There's different modules which will do just about anything, including floor plates, though the base model is mostly just line elements with all the usual degrees of freedom (the three moments, deflections, etc)

It doesn't do single angle (or other non-symmetric shapes) in bending which is annoying. My office has only one program that will do that and it's a mathcad spreadsheet.
 
As a carpenter, i understand how this works.
As a believer in nonsense, you decided that WTC 7 was brought down by controlled demolition before you knew it had huge fires, before you knew it had sustained massive damage, and before you knew NIST had issued an interim report on the building in 2004. Your decision was based solely on watching a video. Remember? You said that you had enough evidence to convict Cheney et al based on the 4 1/2-minute video you saw. You have shown yourself to be immune to reason. You are making the same damn mistakes over and over, and you are harping on the same damn assumptions over and over, despite knowing that an investigation into these issues has continued for the past 2 1/2 years. Why are you behaving this way?
 
C7 "The columns held."

You can't actually tell. If they failed due to ineleastic buckling, the actual visible deflection would be minimal. The column would resist a certain force and then after that it would just continually deflect with the same load unless the force was relieved by other columns.
NIST said:

"Progression of column failure to adjacent columns would have been arrested by the vierendeel action of the perimeter moment frame."

The photos show that the adjacent columns held.

The point here is:

The damage to the south west part of WTC 7 did not weaken or have a significant effect on the area of the initiating event.


Is lateral force not sideways? The actual lateral force in my simple model was 15,000 pounds. This is not insignificant.
In a 47 story building weighing over a million pounds it is insignificant.
There was a lot of building between that lateral force and the area of the initiating event.

Lateral loads and moment transfer will effect that other side. The upwards load could be a big deal in a light breeze. The entire floor plate could act as a massive cantilever if enough columns in the right place fail.
Please, the adjoining column had the weight of 30 or 40 stories above the area of the cantilever effect.


C7 "as a carpenter, i understand how this works."
Then you should have been able to point out everything that I proved in my models before it happened.
I agreed with you that a cantilever effect could occur but i disagreed on how far that effect could be transferred.

I said it would be the greatest on the adjoining column, and to a lesser degree, on the columns further away. [#2106]

You said it could cause a negative load in the column furthest away from the damage. [#2103]

Your model shows that the negative load was only to the adjoining column (4).

Column 5 had a small positive load.

We were both wrong, but you were wronger. :)

Any cantilever effect would not have affected the area of the initiating event.
 
I'll take that half-arsed attempt at a witty reply as confirmation that you cannot, in fact, post any structural calculations which come close to those put up by NB already.
I have stated several times that i am a carpenter, not an engineer.

NB provided the calculations that show:

No significant loads would be transferred beyond the second column from the severed column.
 
[insult deleted], you decided that WTC 7 was brought down by controlled demolition before you knew it had huge fires, before you knew it had sustained massive damage, and before you knew NIST had issued an interim report on the building in 2004. Your decision was based solely on watching a video. Remember?
Yes


you are harping on the same damn assumptions over and over, despite knowing that an investigation into these issues has continued for the past 2 1/2 years.
I am 'harping' about new things i have learned while debating this very important issue.

While answering some well thought out questions by jaydeehess, i found statements in the NIST reports that clearly state:

There is NO evidence of diesel fuel fires or debris damage in the area of the initiating event.

[see post #1884 pg 48]
Why are you behaving this way?
Recently, chipmunk stew and Belz agreed.

Some people here and in the gallery are willing to accept that the above statement is true because it says so in the NIST report, others, not so much.
 
The damage to the south west part of WTC 7 did not weaken or have a significant effect on the area of the initiating event.


NIST Apx. L pg 36

"If the initiating event was due to damage to the perimeter moment frame, then it would have started along the south or southwest facade."

"Analysis of the global structure indicates that the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged areas. Progression of column failure to adjacent columns would have been arrested by the vierendeel of the perimeter moment frame which could span across a sizeable opening due to the strength and stiffness of the frame,"

The report then talks about possible damage to core columns and fires in the area of the initiating event.

pg 37

" I2.1 South facade damaged
> I3.1 Perimeter moment frame redistributes loads around damage
> I4.1 Local failure only"

PG 41

"
If a group of perimeter columns failed, the perimeter framing above this area would have redistributed its loads, due to the redundancy of the moment frame."

pg 42

" Initiating event scenarios from I4.4 to I4.6
> V1.1 Any perimeter column fails
> V2.1 Collapse does not progress vertically"

The report makes no further mention of the damage to the south face.

They site core damage and fires as the possible causes of the initiating event.
 
Much of the area east of the damaged area is clearly visible thru the smoke. The columns held.

I wasn't aware the columns were visible from the outside.

Thank you

You're most welcome.

You can say there was a connection because the debris started the fires

Thank you. This admission invalidates your point and proves mine. So, there was no debris damage or diesel fire at the initiating point; but the debris damage caused the fires.

Although it's implied, are you saying that these fires brought down the building ? If so, I believe this thread is over.

Perhaps Architect could provide some calculations to show how this would be possible.

I'd like to see this, too.

NIST's assessment was that the loads were redistributed around [next to] the damaged areas.

You're playing semantics again. You still haven't told me how you choose this definition of "around" as over the other 32.

Damage to the south west face of WTC 7 put stress on the whole building but it did not weaken the framework in the area of the initiating event.

Isn't stress a weakening factor, one way or the other ?
 
Last edited:
Isn't stress a weakening factor, one way or the other ?

For a column not subject to buckling (which just about all are), stress is merely the force acting on that column divided by the cross-sectional area of that column. We like to measure that in ksi (kips per square inch). When a column reaches a stress equal to it's yield stress, it's usually considered "failed". Strength is a measurement of how much capacity to take stress is left in a member.

If there is adequate redundancy in the building, you probably couldn't even tell with the naked eye that a column had failed. It will take a load equal to approximately the yield stress times it's gross cross-sectional area and then stop taking additional load. The stiffness of the frame that it is in will redistribute the load into other columns (with more of the moment and lateral load problems as I addressed before). If the frame is very stiff, you won't notice a sizeable deflection in the column.

What Christopher7 doesn't understand about my model, is that it might be showing a progressive collapse. The columns that had an interaction equation greater than 1 failed, however the program I use doesn't take into account post-yield behavior.

Engineers don't really worry about what happens after a collapse is iniatited. We worry almost exclusively on preventing that collapse. Once the collapse starts, we might as well right the whole building off. The only thing we do with collapse on a normal basis, is to verify that the first thing to fail in the structure is ductile. I.e. making a connection stronger than the beam so that the connection doesn't suddenly shear off. This allows people to see the failing beam and get out of dodge.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom