Newtons Bit
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Apr 12, 2007
- Messages
- 10,049
That's nice, so what?
The perimeter columns next to the severed columns did not fail.
You can't actually tell. If they failed due to ineleastic buckling, the actual visible deflection would be minimal. The column would resist a certain force and then after that it would just continually deflect with the same load unless the force was relieved by other columns.
Wrong, please stop misquoting me.
#2086
#2099It's the 1 column pulling 5 columns sideways that i find bloody ridiculous, but that's above my pay grade. [as they say]
Some people here can't grasp the concept that gravity pulls things straight down, not sideways.
Is lateral force not sideways? The actual lateral force in my simple model was 15,000 pounds. This is not insignificant.
NB pointed out that there could have been a negative load to columns adjoining the columns next to the severed columns but no one has shown how a positive load could be transferred to columns beyond the columns next to the severed columns.
Lateral loads and moment transfer will effect that other side. The upwards load could be a big deal in a light breeze. The entire floor plate could act as a massive cantilever if enough columns in the right place fail.
Then you should have been able to point out everything that I proved in my models before it happened. Unfortunately you claimed many many things that were proven wrong. I guess we all know how a carpenter understands structures now.As a carpenter, i understand how this works.
Last edited: