10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tell me, chris, if five columns bear a load, like this:

-------------------
|___|___|___|___|

And you remove the second from the left, can you tell me how much of that load each of the remaining columns bears ? You seem to think that only the 1st and 3rd would get an increase. I'm wondering why you think that. Anyone who actually knows the answer can freely chime in and tell me the answer, given hypothetical loads.

wow, i learned what happened in situations like that back in 8th grade when we were building a stage for a play we were doing, and one of us forgot to nail in a post securely.
 
Against my better judgement, I'm going to spend another half hour here. Someone put the wrong date on a food order and I ended up getting free food. :)

Let's take the sample problem that Belz proposed of five columns and the second one from the left is removed. I've got a little model here showing exactly what happens. This is all dependant upon the stiffness of the individual elements. If the beams are relatively unstiff (A w8x10 for example), the force from the column will force that beam into catenary action (think a steel rope) and it will pull, not bear on its supports. The stiffer the beam is, the less tugging will occur. I'm using W30x99 and fixed supports everywhere. Fixed supports basically mean that at the connection, there is zero rotation regardless of the load at that connection. This is a gross over-exaggeration of what happens in reality. I'm also going to put a couple of stories above the frame to show what Vierendeel truss action is.

First, the problem:



The joint reactions: (x, y and z are in kips, mx, my and mz are moment, or torque, in kip*ft)
Code:
		X	Y	Z	MX	MY	MZ
1	N1	0	300	0	0	0	0
1	N2	0	300	0	0	0	0
1	N3	0	300	0	0	0	0
1	N4	0	300	0	0	0	0
1	N5	0	300	0	0	0	0
1	Totals:	0	1500	0			
1	COG (ft):	X: 40	Y: 24	Z: 0
Now let's remove that column. The deflection is shown at 5x magnification and it's minor (really stiff beams!)



According to Christopher7, the columns above N1 and N3 should equally share the load from above N2 and that should be that. The resultant according to him should be:

Code:
		X	Y	Z	MX	MY	MZ
1	N1	0	450	0	0	0	0
1	N2	0	0	0	0	0	0
1	N3	0	450	0	0	0	0
1	N4	0	300	0	0	0	0
1	N5	0	300	0	0	0	0
1	Totals:	0	1500	0			
1	COG (ft):	X: 40	Y: 24	Z: 0
Suprisingly enough, it's not! The real reactions are:

Code:
		X	Y	Z	MX	MY	MZ
1	N1	14.257	431.843	0	0	0	-50.096
1	N2	0	0	0	0	0	0
1	N3	-11.516	513.333	0	0	0	50.121
1	N4	-.739	246.38	0	0	0	8.199
1	N5	-2.002	308.444	0	0	0	13.148
1	Totals:	0	1500	0
Some might argue that it's close. And it kind of is, but it's very, very different. The last column of the table is bending moments that just caused those columns to fail. Before we removed the second column, the interaction equation for every column was 0.573 (1 or greater means that is has failed). After the column is removed, the two adjacent columns are now 1.37. This is due to the bending induced into the columns. 4 and 5 are close to failure, and if I had picked the sizes/loads differently, they would have failed as well. This is an example of 1) the resultant is NOT just gravity loads. And 2) the whole structure is affected.

The above is an example of Vierendeel action. It's rather neat. Without moment connections, the beams next to the columns that fail have a habit of accelerating.
 
I don't see why.
The moment frame connections at every floor kept the adjacent columns from bending.
The photographs of the area show that the adjoining columns did not bend.
The additional loads cannot 'skip' the adjacent columns.

NIST Apx. L pg 36

"If the initiating event was due to damage to the perimeter moment frame, then it would have started along the south or southwest facade."

"Analysis of the global structure indicates that the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged areas. Progression of column failure to adjacent columns would have been arrested by the vierendeel of the perimeter moment frame which could span across a sizeable opening due to the strength and stiffness of the frame,"

The report then talks about possible damage to core columns and fires in the area of the initiating event.

pg 37

" I2.1 South facade damaged
> I3.1 Perimeter moment frame redistributes loads around damage
> I4.1 Local failure only"

PG 41

"
If a group of perimeter columns failed, the perimeter framing above this area would have redistributed its loads, due to the redundancy of the moment frame."

pg 42

" Initiating event scenarios from I4.4 to I4.6
> V1.1 Any perimeter column fails
> V2.1 Collapse does not progress vertically"

The report makes no further mention of the damage to the south face.

They site core damage and fires as the possible causes of the initiating event.

They ruled out perimeter column damage as contributing to the initiating event.

Only devout deniers still insist that there is a connection.


See ? This is what I don't understand about your argument. Not knowing anything about loads, I'd say that the weigth of the horizontal member would be distributed among the remaining columns, which means that ALL FOUR of the remaining columns, not only 1 and 3, would bear added load; though I suspect it wouldn't be an equal share, now that there is a big hole where 2 used to be.
The horizontal members went from column to column. They were not continuous.
The columns were continuous
If column 3 did not compress or bend, how could the load be transferred to column 4 or 5 ?
 
They ruled out perimeter column damage as contributing to the initiating event.

Only devout deniers still insist that there is a connection.

1) No one here, or at NIST, said that the structural damage caused by debris CAUSED the collapse. It did however contribute, possibly insignificantly, but it did have an effect.

The horizontal members went from column to column. They were not continuous.
The columns were continuous
If column 3 did not compress or bend, how could the load be transferred to column 4 or 5 ?

2) In a moment frame system, the beams behave continuous through their connections. This is due to the fact that there is zero (or almost zero) change in rotation of the connection on both sides. The connection is designed to be stronger and stiffer than the actual beam itself. This is why moment frames are so good at resisting collapse: the beams act continuous. You've been proven wrong over and over again on your fake knowledge of structural engineering. Give it up.
 
1) No one here, or at NIST, said that the structural damage caused by debris CAUSED the collapse. It did however contribute, possibly insignificantly, but it did have an effect.
We have finally found some common ground.

The debris damage to the south west face of WTC 7 put some stress on the entire building but it did not have a significant effect in the area of the initiating event.
i.e. It did not weaken the columns, girders or beams in the area of the initiating event.

2) In a moment frame system, the beams behave continuous through their connections. This is due to the fact that there is zero (or almost zero) change in rotation of the connection on both sides. The connection is designed to be stronger and stiffer than the actual beam itself. This is why moment frames are so good at resisting collapse: the beams act continuous.
Again, we agree on these points.
Since the moment frame areas don't rotate, there is no significant cantilever effect.
Since columns don't stretch [or compress], there's no way a beam could put a negative [or positive] load on the column furthest away as you said in post #2103

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2557330#post2557330

Any load would be taken up by the column next to the severed column and what little got past the moment frame at every floor [almost zero rotation],
would have been taken up by the next column.

You've been proven wrong over and over again on your fake knowledge of structural engineering. Give it up.
Talk to yourself much?
 
The moment frame connections at every floor kept the adjacent columns from bending.
The photographs of the area show that the adjoining columns did not bend.
The additional loads cannot 'skip' the adjacent columns.

Then perhaps you can provide and annotate said photographs ?

"If the initiating event was due to damage to the perimeter moment frame, then it would have started along the south or southwest facade."

Again, I think you're confusing what they mean by "initiating event". Or are you saying that NIST claims that 1 WTC's collapse didn't cause 7 WTC's collapse ?

The report makes no further mention of the damage to the south face.

Let's not forget that it is a preliminary report, however. And if you're going to say that this won't change, then why are they still working on it ?

They site core damage and fires as the possible causes of the initiating event.

They ruled out perimeter column damage as contributing to the initiating event.

Only devout deniers still insist that there is a connection.

Of course there is a connection, since the same event that caused the perimeter damage caused the core damage.

If column 3 did not compress or bend, how could the load be transferred to column 4 or 5 ?

Beats me, that's why I asked the question. However, I suspect it's not as simple as that.
 
Chris

Is it not rather telling that you've proven unable to respond the NB's actual structural calcs? Why don't you analyse the figures to the same extend and then we'll interrogate them for you?

Or are you unable to to do so? What are your structural engineering qualifications?
 
Since the moment frame areas don't rotate, there is no significant cantilever effect.
Since columns don't stretch [or compress], there's no way a beam could put a negative [or positive] load on the column furthest away as you said in post #2103

The columns compress at a ratio of exactly 1% of their total length over 29000 ksi. Though this is only true to the first 0.2%, and then the column has basically failed. This is a very simple engineering concept that you'd get in your first year of an undergrad program.

The frame areas DO rotate. You don't get this concept either, albeit this one is more complicated. There is always a roughly 90 degree angle (in this case) between the column and the beam. This does not mean that there is not rotation from base at this point. The stiffness of moment frames are judged by a ratio of the stiffness of the beams and the stiffness of columns. I provided a very stiff moment frame. The rotation of the column and beam assembly would be much more pronounced if there were less stiff columns.


Any load would be taken up by the column next to the severed column and what little got past the moment frame at every floor [almost zero rotation],
would have been taken up by the next column.

Brilliant! Your powers of completly ignoring mathmatical proof is supernatural! Take a look at the actual structural analysis of the frame question that was posed to you. Before the collapse, each column had a reaction of 300k. After one column is removed, a non-adjacent columns had it's load REDUCED to 246. The net effect of the collapse of that column resulted in a negative load applied to a column not immediately adjacent to the collapsed column. You keep asserting that this cannot happen. I've proven otherwise with a mathmatical model.

Second, there are also LATERAL loads present. The removal of that one column causes a compression and/or tension load to form IN THE BEAMS. This also according to you is impossible.

Again, we agree on these points.
We may now, but we certainly didn't a few posts ago.
The horizontal members went from column to column. They were not continuous.
Flip-flop much when it suits your purpose? You're willing to change your mind on the continuouty of the beams through the columns but not on the other engineering concepts I've outlined for you? You trust me on one issue but not on another. That's very interesting.
 
Snip good stuff-go back and read it!>



Brilliant! Your powers of completly ignoring mathmatical proof is supernatural! Take a look at the actual structural analysis of the frame question that was posed to you. Before the collapse, each column had a reaction of 300k. After one column is removed, a non-adjacent columns had it's load REDUCED to 246. The net effect of the collapse of that column resulted in a negative load applied to a column not immediately adjacent to the collapsed column. You keep asserting that this cannot happen. I've proven otherwise with a mathmatical model.

Second, there are also LATERAL loads present. The removal of that one column causes a compression and/or tension load to form IN THE BEAMS. This also according to you is impossible.
you will never, ever, get a truffer to admit that gravitational forces can cause anything but vertical forces and/or deflections. Not even if you build an inverted "L" out of PVC, stick it in the ground, and hang a weight on the end of the "L". Has to be explosives or something making it move sideways.


We may now, but we certainly didn't a few posts ago.

Flip-flop much when it suits your purpose? You're willing to change your mind on the continuouty of the beams through the columns but not on the other engineering concepts I've outlined for you? You trust me on one issue but not on another. That's very interesting.
Remember--thos "load path thingies" are figments of the collective imagination of competent engineers. Youare just making stuff up as you go, aren't you!:D :D
 
Then perhaps you can provide and annotate said photographs ?
Here are the photographs of what actually happened to the columns to the east of the severed columns.

sfacegraphic3np6.jpg


wtc7roofdamagepn6.jpg


The columns did not fail or bend significantly.



Again, I think you're confusing what they mean by "initiating event". Or are you saying that NIST claims that 1 WTC's collapse didn't cause 7 WTC's collapse ?
NIST defines the initiating event as the beginning of the collapse on pg 36 of Apx. L

"Within each phase of the collapse shown in figure L-25, the initiating event, vertical progression, horizontal progression, and global collapse, ........"

Let's not forget that it is a preliminary report, however. And if you're going to say that this won't change, then why are they still working on it ?
The hypothesis may change but the facts will not.

Of course there is a connection, since the same event that caused the perimeter damage caused the core damage.
What core damage?

NIST Apx. L pg 50

"The extent of damage ........ of core framing is not known"

Beats me, that's why I asked the question. However, I suspect it's not as simple as that.
I will address that in my reply to NB this evening.

The debris no doubt caused the fires but the debris damage did not weaken the columns, girders and beams in the area of the initiating event.



NB: Do you think the debris damage to the south west face of WTC 7 had a significant effect on the area of the initiating event?

areaofinitiatingeventli5.png
 
Last edited:
you will never, ever, get a truffer to admit that gravitational forces can cause anything but vertical forces and/or deflections. Not even if you build an inverted "L" out of PVC, stick it in the ground, and hang a weight on the end of the "L". Has to be explosives or something making it move sideways.


And yet, WTC 1 and 2 were controlled demolitions because the top didn't fall sideways.

:mgbanghead
 
The columns compress at a ratio of exactly 1% of their total length over 29000 ksi. Though this is only true to the first 0.2%, and then the column has basically failed. This is a very simple engineering concept that you'd get in your first year of an undergrad program.
That's nice, so what?
The perimeter columns next to the severed columns did not fail.

The frame areas DO rotate. There is always a roughly 90 degree angle (in this case) between the column and the beam. This does not mean that there is not rotation from base at this point. The stiffness of moment frames are judged by a ratio of the stiffness of the beams and the stiffness of columns. I provided a very stiff moment frame. The rotation of the column and beam assembly would be much more pronounced if there were less stiff columns.
Sounds like you don't know the actual strength of the columns or moment frames in WTC 7.

Take a look at the actual structural analysis of the frame question that was posed to you. Before the collapse, each column had a reaction of 300k. After one column is removed, a non-adjacent columns had it's load REDUCED to 246. The net effect of the collapse of that column resulted in a negative load applied to a column not immediately adjacent to the collapsed column. You keep asserting that this cannot happen.
Wrong, please stop misquoting me.

In post #2103 you said:
"If a cantilevered beam is developed, an upward load will actually develop in the columns furthest away from the damage"

In post #2106 i replied:
"The upward load will be the greatest on the adjoining column, and to a lesser degree, on the columns further away. The load would be taken up by each column in turn."

Second, there are also LATERAL loads present. The removal of that one column causes a compression and/or tension load to form IN THE BEAMS. This also according to you is impossible.
Wrong again. Show me where i said that.


Flip-flop much when it suits your purpose? You're willing to change your mind on the continuouty of the beams through the columns but not on the other engineering concepts I've outlined for you? You trust me on one issue but not on another. That's very interesting.
What makes you think i trust you on anything?

In your tables, column 1 got 432 kips and column 3 got 513

column 4 got 246 [due to the cantilever effect i presume]

column 5 got 308 or just 2.7% more than its normal load.

Beyond column 5 the effects of the severed column would be negligible.
 
Here are the photographs of what actually happened to the columns to the east of the severed columns.

The columns did not fail or bend significantly.

Well, it's a good thing you can see them through all that smoke. But since I lack X-Ray vision, I'm not sure what I see except a big vertical hole.

NIST defines the initiating event as the beginning of the collapse on pg 36 of Apx. L

That I know. What they state, however, by your own admission, is that there was no debris damage or diesel fires in the area of that initiating event. We can agree on that. What seems like a non sequitur is you concluding that one didn't have anything to do with the other.

The hypothesis may change but the facts will not.

Excellent.

What core damage?

"The extent of damage ........ of core framing is not known"

YOU'RE the one who mentioned it. Keep up.

The debris no doubt caused the fires but the debris damage did not weaken the columns, girders and beams in the area of the initiating event.

That's because you think the load can't spread further than the immediate adjacent columns. It seems you are wrong on that.

NB: Do you think the debris damage to the south west face of WTC 7 had a significant effect on the area of the initiating event?

As a layman, I would assume that any damage to the structure weakens the whole.
 
Well, it's a good thing you can see them through all that smoke. But since I lack X-Ray vision, I'm not sure what I see except a big vertical hole.
Much of the area east of the damaged area is clearly visible thru the smoke. The columns held.

That I know. What they [NIST] state, however, by your own admission, is that

there was no debris damage or diesel fires in the area of that initiating event.
We can agree on that.
[brackets & bolding mine]

Thank you

What seems like a non sequitur is you concluding that one didn't have anything to do with the other.
You can say there was a connection because the debris started the fires but you cannot say that the debris damage to the south west face of WTC 7 had any significant effect on the area of the initiating event.

YOU'RE the one who mentioned it. Keep up.
Whatever ejected the elevator cars into the hallway may have damaged a core column on the 8th floor.
There were no reports of damage to the core column area by the firefighters who were searching the building for people that couldn't get out. They did report damage to the south facade on the 8th floor.

That's because you think the load can't spread further than the immediate adjacent columns. It seems you are wrong on that.
NB pointed out that there could have been a negative load to columns adjoining the columns next to the severed columns but no one has shown how a positive load could be transferred to columns beyond the columns next to the severed columns.

Perhaps Architect could provide some calculations to show how this would be possible.

NIST's assessment was that the loads were redistributed around [next to] the damaged areas. As a carpenter, i understand how this works. I have seen nothing to suggest that loads were transferred to the area of the in initiating event or that the debris damage somehow weakened the framework in the area of the initiating event.

As a layman, I would assume that any damage to the structure weakens the whole.
Damage to the south west face of WTC 7 put stress on the whole building but it did not weaken the framework in the area of the initiating event.
The stress was the greatest around the damaged areas and progressively less further away.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom