10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
You should probably say whether or not those are simple shear connections or moment connections, Belz.

I've disproved him on just about every aspect of his "column behavior" B.S. I think we just need to concede the fact that he's a troll now.

Those pictures I posted by the way, are from RISA-3D. Not just hand sketches I invented.
 
You should probably say whether or not those are simple shear connections or moment connections, Belz.

I've disproved him on just about every aspect of his "column behavior" B.S.
On the contrary, my good sir, your claim that the cantilever effect could put an upwards load on the columns furthest from the damage is Bloody Silly.

NIST said "loads were redistributed around the severed and damaged areas."

You're trying to say that the loads were somehow transferred to the area of the initiating event.

This viewpoint ignores all the columns and framing members in between. These would have taken up any loads that somehow got past the columns next to the severed columns.

Those pictures I posted by the way, are from RISA-3D. Not just hand sketches I invented.
So what? They're still stick drawings that don't represent WTC 7.

stickdrawing1xc6.jpg


stickdrawing2gj0.jpg



This is what actually happened.
The columns around the severed columns DID NOT BEND as indicated in the stick drawing.

wtc7roofdamagepn6.jpg


sfacegraphic3np6.jpg
 
://www.prisionplanet.com/Pages/230904_whistleblowers.html

Yet nobody has come forward expressing doubt that that the official story expresses anything but reality.
Many qualified people have come forward.

They have been ignored or slandered by MSM and people here.

Post #2148 lists 40 of them.

Here are some more:

http://www.pogo.org/m/hsp/hsp-911commission-040913.pdf


Please stop making such patently false statements.
 
The fact is, your argument is nothing more than an argument from personal incredulity, which is not enough to dismiss the hypothesis developed by NIST.
Correct
Thank you for acknowledging that. As far as I'm concerned, then, there's nothing more to discuss with you until the report is finalized.

55 pages, based (by admission) on nothing more than an argument from personal incredulity?!?

Chris...what are you doing? Go enjoy the Spring weather. Wait until the final report is released.
 
55 pages, based (by admission) on nothing more than an argument from personal incredulity?!?
That statement was in reference to my personal disbelief that fire brought down WTC 7.

Chris...what are you doing?
Pointing out that:

There was no 60 to 80 foot wide, by 30 to 40 foot deep gouge,
floor 10 to the ground, in the middle of WTC 7.

There is no evidence of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

There is no evidence of debris damage in the area of the initiating event.

The debris damage to the south west face of WTC 7 did not weaken columns in the area of the initiating event.


These things are not going to change in the final report.

Live in the here and now, not in what you hope tomorrow will bring in the final report.
 
That statement was in reference to my personal disbelief that fire brought down WTC 7.

Pointing out that:

There was no 60 to 80 foot wide, by 30 to 40 foot deep gouge,
floor 10 to the ground, in the middle of WTC 7.

There is no evidence of diesel fuel fires in the area of the initiating event.

There is no evidence of debris damage in the area of the initiating event.

The debris damage to the south west face of WTC 7 did not weaken columns in the area of the initiating event.


These things are not going to change in the final report.

Live in the here and now, not in what you hope tomorrow will bring in the final report.
{ray stevens mode]
There is none so blind
as he who will not see
You must open up your eyes...[/ray stevens mode]
 
Circular reasoning. Your contention that the additional load would only bear on the adjacent columns to those damaged is in question, here. How can you claim that NIST couldn't possibly mean anything else ?
In order for weight to be transferred to columns beyond the columns next to the severed columns, the columns next to the severed columns must bend or fail.
To put it another way, the columns next to the severed columns will bear the weight or fail and pass it on.

You do NOT know better than the experts at NIST!
I don't claim to know better than NIST but you seem to think you do.

You insist that around the severed and damaged columns means the other end of the building.

Well, I'm no structural engineer, but that sounds like nonsense, to me. Could you explain, in layman's terms, why, if the columns far away bear some of the building's load, they will not be affected if other columns, which are presumably sharing that load, fail ?
The columns in the area of the initiating event were NOT sharing loads with the columns on the SW face of WTC 7.
Each column is holding up the weight in its own area.

Do fires spread, Chris ?
Either you did not read or you did not understand the "Fire on floor 12" section of post #1884 on pg 48.

"About 3:00 p.m., it reached the north side, east of center, and spread in both directions."
 
{ray stevens mode]
There is none so blind
as he who will not see
You must open up your eyes...[/ray stevens mode]
You should follow your own advice and read posts #1883, 1884 and 1885.

The quotes from the FEMA and NIST reports that confirm those 4 statements are there for you to see.
 
I agree Christopher.

I would like to hear Belz actually provide a thoughtful response to your remarks.

This would be new ground ie. unfamiliar territory, but I'm sure we would all benefit from his profound analysis.

MM
 
Tell me, chris, if five columns bear a load, like this:

-------------------
|___|___|___|___|

And you remove the second from the left, can you tell me how much of that load each of the remaining columns bears ? You seem to think that only the 1st and 3rd would get an increase. I'm wondering why you think that.
That's correct.
The load from the 2nd column will be bourn by the 1st and 3rd columns.
The 3rd column will bear the load or fail and pass it on to the 4th column,
 
That's correct.
The load from the 2nd column will be bourn by the 1st and 3rd columns.
The 3rd column will bear the load or fail and pass it on to the 4th column,

Gravity is a difficult concept for some people.

Another difficulty is accepting that people you trust are not always going to act in your best interests.

People in power always place THEIR interests first. If they align with yours..great..if they don't, well too ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ bad!

WTC7 was a controlled demolition!

It's obvious to all, accept those who are naive enough to believe that people with power won't allow themselves to be corrupted by that power.

Ever hear of a fool's paradise Belz?

Time to jump from the gravy train.

MM
 
Gravity is a difficult concept for some people.

Another difficulty is accepting that people you trust are not always going to act in your best interests.

People in power always place THEIR interests first. If they align with yours..great..if they don't, well too ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ bad!

WTC7 was a controlled demolition!

It's obvious to all, accept those who are naive enough to believe that people with power won't allow themselves to be corrupted by that power.

Ever hear of a fool's paradise Belz?

Time to jump from the gravy train.

MM

BS. You are NOT qualified to judge that the WT7 was a controlled demolition, no more so than a plumber who declares that the pain I have in my chest is a heart problem.

You can declare over and over and over again, but you will be wrong over and over and over again. The evidence does NOT support your conclusion. Experts do NOT support your conclusion. You are ideologically biased so nobody with half a brain would support your conclusion without independent verification.

To make a long story short, you don't know what the heck you are talking about, and no rational person should be under any obligation to believe a word you say.

You have a problem with that? Then PROVE YOUR POSITION. So far, you have nothing.
 
It's pointless twinstead, they're trolls. Just let the thread die.

That's correct.
The load from the 2nd column will be bourn by the 1st and 3rd columns.
The 3rd column will bear the load or fail and pass it on to the 4th column,

I proved this wrong by posting a finite-element model showing exactly what happens when one column fails. He says that model doesn't represent the WTC. Which is true. And I'm certainly not going to model the whole building. I did that model in 15 minutes during my lunch break. The proof that a non-adjacent column during a column failure event is effected is staring him right in the face in pictorial form. And he still doesn't get it.

stickdrawing2gj0.jpg


I wonder if he thinks I drew that in photoshop?

Just let the thread die.
 
I proved this wrong by posting a finite-element model showing exactly what happens when one column fails. He says that model doesn't represent the WTC. Which is true. And I'm certainly not going to model the whole building. I did that model in 15 minutes during my lunch break. The proof that a non-adjacent column during a column failure event is effected is staring him right in the face in pictorial form. And he still doesn't get it.

http://img489.imageshack.us/img489/486/stickdrawing2gj0.jpg

I wonder if he thinks I drew that in photoshop?
It's still a bloody stick drawing with 3 columns.

Try something more realistic like 14 south facade columns and 18 core columns.

wtc7fl8edit2ak2.png


Did you look at the photos of what actually happened ?

The perimeter columns next to the severed columns did not bend because they are attached to all the other columns thru the moment frame connections at every floor.
The core columns are attached to other core columns in the same manner.
 
Last edited:
I would like to hear Belz actually provide a thoughtful response to your remarks.

Exactly what about my contentions was thoughtless ?

This would be new ground ie. unfamiliar territory, but I'm sure we would all benefit from his profound analysis.

Someone else is already doing a "profound" analysis, but you have already decided that their conclusions will be wrong.

Gravity is a difficult concept for some people.

More so for some than others.

Another difficulty is accepting that people you trust are not always going to act in your best interests.

Which, in an of itself, is NO PROOF OF ANYTHING.

People in power always place THEIR interests first. If they align with yours..great..if they don't, well too ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ bad!

Yes, that has a tendency to happen. Now that we agree on that, do you have actual evidence that it happened the way you claim it happened ?

WTC7 was a controlled demolition!

It's obvious to all, accept those who are naive enough to believe that people with power won't allow themselves to be corrupted by that power.

To "all" except the majority ? Were you just now trying to make an argument from popularity and failing monstrously at even a fallacy ? Boy, you're bad at this.

Ever hear of a fool's paradise Belz?

Your basement ?

Time to jump from the gravy train.

Who's "gravy" ?
 
In order for weight to be transferred to columns beyond the columns next to the severed columns, the columns next to the severed columns must bend or fail.

I don't see why.

I don't claim to know better than NIST but you seem to think you do.

Then we are both mistaken.

You insist that around the severed and damaged columns means the other end of the building.

Strawman. I never said that. And you look silly for battling that dummy.

What I said, is that "around" is an imprecise term unless you can show which of the 33 definitions of the word was used. No assumptions, please.

That's correct.
The load from the 2nd column will be bourn by the 1st and 3rd columns.
The 3rd column will bear the load or fail and pass it on to the 4th column,

See ? This is what I don't understand about your argument. Not knowing anything about loads, I'd say that the weigth of the horizontal member would be distributed among the remaining columns, which means that ALL FOUR of the remaining columns, not only 1 and 3, would bear added load; though I suspect it wouldn't be an equal share, now that there is a big hole where 2 used to be.

I'd like to hear your thoughts about that, and rguinn's or Architect's thoughts as well. Someone who knows this stuff, anyway.
 
I don't see why.



Then we are both mistaken.



Strawman. I never said that. And you look silly for battling that dummy.

What I said, is that "around" is an imprecise term unless you can show which of the 33 definitions of the word was used. No assumptions, please.



See ? This is what I don't understand about your argument. Not knowing anything about loads, I'd say that the weigth of the horizontal member would be distributed among the remaining columns, which means that ALL FOUR of the remaining columns, not only 1 and 3, would bear added load; though I suspect it wouldn't be an equal share, now that there is a big hole where 2 used to be.

I'd like to hear your thoughts about that, and rguinn's or Architect's thoughts as well. Someone who knows this stuff, anyway.
Newton's bit is doing good. With complex, moment-carrying load paths, hand analysis and "common sense" will not give a correct answer. NB showed a couple of FEM's that give the correct situation, but Christopher7 has not a clue, and thus rejects it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom