10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here's an idea Christopher, go out into your wood shop, grab a 2x4 and nail one end to the top of your sawhorse and let another end hang a couple feet off the other end. Put all your weight on the free end and see what happens. You may want to weight the sawhorse.

Unless you weigh 50 lbs, that nail probably just popped out. You just created an upwards force by using a fulcrum. Now tell me, does your 2x4 have to BEND to pull that nail out?

Edit: As far as your see-saw analogy goes, by adding that one person way out on the end of the beam, you did increase the load on the fulcrum. However the weight that the large group of people on the ground just decreased by adding that person. Suppose that person waaay out at the end of the beam, hanging all alone, is a column. It's UP in the air. Thank you for proving my analogy.
 
Last edited:
Seems to me I have been trying to tell C7 that the missing columns would be creating a cantilever system out of the flooring that would be pulling the central columns towards the missing perimeter columns for some time now.

Taking NB's illustration above one needs only to note that the sawhorse may well tip over before the nail pops unless, as he says, you weigh the sawhorse down or nail it to the floor.
 
Here's an idea Christopher, go out into your wood shop, grab a 2x4 and nail one end to the top of your sawhorse .....................

Thank you for proving my analogy.
You left out some factors in your proposed experiment and analysis.

Let's look at the actual situation.

NIST said the loads were redistributed around the severed and damaged areas.

Around means, next to, not far away from.

Any cantilever effect would have to transfer loads thru several moment frame areas.

The weight pushing down on the next column would more than offset any cantilever effect from hanging floor sections.

The experts at NIST made no mention of the cantilever effect, load paths or lateral forces.

It's all just speculation by people here who claim to know engineering.


Your claim that the cantilever effect could put an upwards load on the columns furthest from the damage is wrong.

There's too much framework in between.


If NIST thought the debris damage to the SW perimeter frame had an effect on the area of the initiating event, they would have said so.
 
Seems to me I have been trying to tell C7 that the missing columns would be creating a cantilever system out of the flooring that would be pulling the central columns towards the missing perimeter columns for some time now.
I have been reminding you that the loads would be bourn by the entire building thru the moment frame where every column connects to floors throughout the building.

The pull would be the greatest on the surrounding columns and less to columns further away.

The effect to columns in the east part of WTC 7 would be negligible.
 
Last edited:
Only to someone in denial

If you think "around" includes the other end of the building, you are:
A) lying to yourself
B) lying to me
C) in need of a remedial reading course

Since A and B are impossible, here's what I say to C :

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/around

There are 33 definitions of this word. Please tell me which one you think the NIST used, and why you think it's not one of the 32 others.

No, read it, quote it, point out where i am mistaken or dishonest.
Talk's cheap.
Put up or shut up.

I've done that already. You're trying to add meaning to words and sentences to fit your preconceived theory. Tell you what ? Why don't we stop beating around the bush with this silly semantics thread and get right to the point: start a thread about controlled demolitions at 7 WTC and we'll debate YOUR theory, not some incomplete report.

For a person desperately looking for a reason to deny the obvious, anything other than a specific statement that the Debris damage did not contribute to the initiating event, is enough reason to say that did.

Personal attack aside, do you deny that saying that there was no debris or diesel fire damage AT that area says nothing about the former causing the latter ?
 
911 Commission Try Again!

Here are 40 distinguished leaders and experts sounding-off in short quotes about their misgivings with the 9/11 commission and the questions that are still smoldering [NB: Don’t miss the concluding quote]...

Summarized from www.patriotsquestion911.com


Senator Max Cleland - Former member of the 9/11 Commission, resigned in December 2003:
"I, as a member of the [9/11] Commission, cannot look any American in the eye... It is a national scandal... this White House wants to cover [9/11] up."

Senator Mark Dayton - Member, Senate Committee on Armed Services and Homeland Security:
"[NORAD] lied to the American people, they lied to Congress and they lied to your 9/11 Commission...the most gross incompetence and dereliction of responsibility and negligence"

Congressman Ron Paul - Vice Chairman of the Oversight and Investigations subcommittee:
“The [9/11] investigations that have been done so far as more or less cover-up and no real explanation"

Congressman Curt Weldon:
"[9/11 Commission] there's something very sinister going on here... something desperately wrong... This involved what is right now the covering up of information that led to the deaths of 3,000 people"

Congresswoman Cynthia McKinney - Member of the House Armed Services Committee:
“The [9/11] Commission ran up against obstruction by the administration and non-cooperation from government agencies... the errors and omissions immediately jumped out at us"

Director of the FBI, Louis Freeh:
"[9/11 Commission findings] raise serious challenges to the commission's credibility and, if the facts prove out, might just render the commission historically insignificant itself"

Assistant Secretary of the U.S. Treasury, Paul Craig Roberts, PhD:
"Distinguished national and international scientists and scholars present massive evidence that the 9/11 Commission Report is a hoax and that the 9/11 "terrorist attack" has been manipulated to serve a hegemonic agenda in the Middle East... We know that it is strictly impossible for any building, much less steel columned buildings, to "pancake" at free fall speed. Therefore, it is a non-controversial fact that the official explanation of the collapse of the WTC buildings is false"

Assistant Secretary of Housing, Catherine Austin Fitts:
"The official story could not possibly have happened... It’s not possible. It’s not operationally feasible... The Commission was a whitewash. "

U.S. Army Intelligence officer, Federal Prosecutor, Office of Special Investigations, U.S. Department of Justice, John Loftus:
"The information provided by European intelligence services prior to 9/11 was so extensive that it is no longer possible for either the CIA or FBI to assert a defence of incompetence"

Foreign Service Officer, George Kenney:
"I cannot believe, much as I might like to, the standard account of 9/11"

Foreign Service Officer, J. Michael Springman:
"Fifteen of the nineteen people who allegedly flew airplanes into buildings in the United States got their visas from the same CIA Consulate at Jeddah"

Deputy Attorney General, State of Pennsylvania, Philip J. Berg, Esquire:
"The official story of what actually took place on 0/11 is a lie. "

Major General U.S. Army, Commanding General of U.S. Army Intelligence and Security Command, Albert Stubblebine [his specialty – analyzing satellite photos]:
"I look at the hole in the Pentagon and I look at the size of an airplane that was supposed to have hit the Pentagon. And I said, ‘The plane does not fit in that hole. So what did hit the Pentagon?’”

Col. Ronald D. Ray, U.S. Marine Corps, Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense, Deputy Director of Field Operations for the U.S. Marine Corps Historical Center:
"I'm astounded that the conspiracy theory advanced by the administration could in fact be true and the evidence does not seem to suggest that's accurate."

Col. Robert Bowman, U.S. Air Force, Director of Advanced Space Programs, PhD Aeronautics and Nuclear Engineering:
"The official 9/11 story is impossible .. There is a cover up... high levels of our government don't want us to know what happened... highly placed individuals in the administration...Dick Cheney...the very kindest thing we can say about George W Bush...is high treason and conspiracy to commit murder."

Col. George Nelson, U.S. Air Force, aircraft accident investigator:
"I never witnessed nor even heard of an aircraft loss, where the wreckage was accessible, that prevented investigators from finding enough hard evidence to positively identify the make, model, and specific registration number of the aircraft -- and in most cases the precise cause of the accident... The government alleges that four wide-body airliners crashed on the morning of September 11 2001, resulting in the deaths of more than 3,000 human beings, yet not one piece of hard aircraft evidence has been produced in an attempt to positively identify any of the four aircraft. On the contrary, it seems only that all potential evidence was deliberately kept hidden from view .. with all the evidence readilty available at the pentagon crash site, any unbiased rational investigator could only conclude that a Boeing 757 did not fly into the Pentagon as alleged. Similarly, with all the evidence available at the Pennsylvania crash site, it was most doubtful that a passenger airliner caused the obvious hole in the ground and certainly not the Boeing 757 as alleged .. the most heinous conspiracy in outr country's history."

Major Douglas Rokke, PhD, U.S. Army:
[Regarding the impact at the Pentagon on 9/11/2001] "When you look at the damage, it was obviously a missile."

Capt. Russ Wittenberg, U.S. Air Force, fighter pilot, commercial pilot flying 707, 720, 727, 737, 747, 757, 767, and 777s. Had previously flown Flight 93, which impacted in Pennsylvania, and Flight 175, the second plane to hit the WTC:
"The government story they handed us about 9/11 is total B.S. plain and simple...[Regarding Flight 77]"The airplane could not have flown at those speeds which they said it did without going into what they call a high speed stall. The airplane won’t go that fast if you start pulling those high G maneuvers at those bank angles... The vehicle that hit the Pentagon was not Flight 77"

Lt. Col. Karen U. Kwiatkowski, PhD, U.S. Air Force, Office of the Secretary of Defense, staff of the Director of the National Security Agency:
"It is as a scientist that I have the most trouble with the official government conspiracy theory, mainly because it does not satisfy the rules of probability or physics. The collapses of the World Trade Center buildings clearly violate the laws of probability and physics...There was a dearth of visible debris on the relatively unmarked Pentagon, where I stood only minutes after the impact. Beyond this strange absence of airliner debris, there was no sign of the kind of damage one would expect from the impact of a large airliner... this visible evidence or lack thereof may also have been apparent to the Sec of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, who in an unfortunate slip of the tongue referred to the aircraft that slammed into the Pentagon as a ' missile ' ... I saw nothing of significance at the point of contact ~ no airplane metal or cargo debris was blowing on the lawn in front of the damaged building as smoke billowed from within the Pentagon .. all of us staring at the Pentagon that morning were indeed looking for such debris, but what we expected was not evident .. the same is true with regard to the damage we expected .. but I did not see this kind of damage. Rather, the facade had a rather small hole, no larger than 20 feet in diameter. Although this facade later collapsed, it remained standing for 30 0r 40 minutes, with the roof remaining relatively straight .. The scene, in short, was not what I would have expected from a strike by a large jetliner. It was, however, exactly what one would have expected if a missile had struck the Pentagon "

Senior Military Affairs Journalist at the Naval Postgraduate School, Barbara Honegger, MS:
"The US military, not al Qaeda, had the sustained access weeks before 9/11 to also plant controlled demolition charges throughout the superstructures of WTC 1 and WTC 2, and in WTC 7, which brought down all three buildings on 9/11...A US military plane, not one piloted by al Qaeda, performed the highly skilled, high−speed 270−degree dive towards the Pentagon that Air Traffic Controllers on 9/11 were sure was a military plane as they watched it on their screens. Only a military aircraft, not a civilian plane flown by al Qaeda, would have given off the "Friendly" signal needed to disable the Pentagon’s anti−aircraft missile batteries as it approached the building...Only the US military, not al Qaeda, had the ability to break all of its Standard Operating Procedures to paralyze its own emergency response system"

Capt. Gregory M. Zeigler, PhD, U.S. Army, U.S. Army Intelligence Officer:
"I knew from September 18, 2001, that the official story about 9/11 was false. ... [A]nomalies poured in rapidly: the hijackers' names appearing in none of the published flight passenger lists, BBC reports of stolen identities of the alleged hijackers or the alleged hijackers being found alive, the obvious demolitions of WTC 1 and 2...and WTC7...not hit by an airplane...the lack of identifiable Boeing 757 wreckage at the Pentagon"

Capt. Eric H. May, U.S. Army, Intelligence officer:
"I view the 911 event ...as a matter that implies either...A) passive participation by the Bush White House through a deliberate stand-down or active execution of a plot by rogue elements of government, starting with the White House itself, in creating a spectacle of destruction that would lead the United States into an invasion of the Middle East"

Former Chairman, National Intelligence Estimates, CIA, responsible for preparing the President’s Daily Brief, U.S. Army Intelligence Officer, Raymond L. McGovern:
"I think at simplest terms, there’s a cover-up. The 9/11 report is a joke...just as Hitler in 1933 cynically exploited the burning of the parliament building, the Reichstag, this is exactly what our President did in exploiting 9/11...making a war of aggression on a country that he knew had nothing to do with 9/11...that’s certainly an impeachable offense...But compelling evidence for an even more disturbing conclusion: that the 9/11 attacks were themselves orchestrated by this administration precisely so they could be thus exploited."

National Intelligence Officer and Director of the CIA's Office of Regional and Political Analysis, William Christison:
"there is persuasive evidence that the events of September did not unfold as the Bush administration and the 9/11 Commission would have us believe. An airliner almost certainly did not hit The Pentagon. The North and South Towers of the World Trade Center almost certainly did not collapse and fall to earth because hijacked aircraft hit them...this all was totally an inside job. I have since decided that... at least some elements in this US government had contributed in some way or other to causing 9/11 to happen or at least allowing it to happen... The reason that the two towers in New York actually collapsed and fell all the way to the ground was controlled explosions rather than just being hit by two airplanes. All of the characteristics of these demolitions show that they almost had to have been controlled explosions... I think you almost have to look at the 9/11 Commission Report as a joke and not a serious piece of analysis at all... It's a monstrous crime."

U.S. Marine Corps intelligence officer, case officer CIA. Robert David Steele:
"I am forced to conclude that there is sufficient evidence to indict (not necessarily convict) Dick Cheney, Karl Rove and others...This is, without question, the most important modern reference on state-sponsored terrorism, and also the reference that most pointedly suggests that select rogue elements within the US Government, most likely led by Dick Cheney with the assistance of George Tenet, Buzzy Kronguard, and others close to the Wall Street gangs, are the most guilty of state-sponsored terrorism...I'm absolutely certain that WTC 7 was brought down by controlled demolition and that as far as I'm concerned means that this case has not been properly investigated. There's no way that building could have come down without controlled demolition."

CIA Case Officer, Specialist in the Middle East, Directorate of Operations, Awarded Career Intelligence Medal, Robert Baer:
[Regarding the opinion there was an aspect of 'inside job' to 9/11 within the U.S. Government], "There is that possibility, the evidence points at it."

Counter-terrorism expert in the Security Division of the federal Aviation Administration. Team leader of the FAA's Red (Terrorism) Team in the Federal Air Marshall program, Coast Guard officer, Bogdan Dzakovic:
"At worst, I think the 9/11 Commission Report is treasonous."

Minister of Justice, West Germany, Horst Ehmke, PhD:
"Terrorists could not have carried out such an operation with four hijacked planes without the support of a secret service."

State Secretary, Federal Ministry of Defense, West Germany, Andreas von Buelow, PhD:
"The official story is so inadequate and far-fetched that there must be another one...This is unthinkable, without years-long support from secret apparatuses of the state and industry."

President of Italy, Francesco Cossiga:
"[9/11] could not be accomplished without infiltrations in the radar and flight security personnel."

General Leonid Ivashov, Chief of Staff, Russian armed forces, Ministry of Defense:
"Only secret services and their current chiefs – or those retired but still having influence inside the state organizations – have the ability to plan, organize and conduct an operation [9/11] of such magnitude...Osama bin Laden and "Al Qaeda" cannot be the organizers nor the performers of the September 11 attacks. They do not have the necessary organization, resources or leaders."

Foreign Minister of Egypt, Mohamed Hassanein Heikal:
"Bin Laden does not have the capabilities for an operation [9/11] of this magnitude. When I hear Bush talking about al-Qaida as if it was Nazi Germany or the communist party of the Soviet Union, I laugh because I know what is there. Bin Laden has been under surveillance for years: every telephone call was monitored and al-Qaida has been penetrated by American intelligence, Pakistani intelligence, Saudi intelligence, Egyptian intelligence. They could not have kept secret an operation that required such a degree of organisation and sophistication."

Chief of Staff, Pakistani Army, General Mirza Aslam Beg:
"The information which is now coming up, goes to prove that involvement by the ‘rogue elements’ of the U.S. military and intelligence organization is getting more obvious. Osama bin Laden and al-Qaeda definitely do not have the knowhow and the capability to launch such operations involving such high precision coordination, based on information and expertise."

European Parliament, Committee on Security and Defense, Giulietto Chiesa:
"Billions of people were given only one explanation....which is entirely false....everyone who dares to question it is treated as if he was a fool."

French Army Intelligence and artillery officer, Col. Pierre-Henri Bunel, Expert in the effects of artillery weapons and explosives:
"Image of the impact on the Pentagon is very instructive as to the nature of the explosion. ... It corresponds to a detonation of an explosive with high energetic power. The explosion does not correspond to a deflagration of kerosene...suggests a single engine flying vehicle much smaller in size than an airliner...resembles the effects of anti-concrete hollow charges that I have been able to observe on a number of battlefields...lead me therefore to think that the detonation that struck the building was that of a high-powered hollow charge used to destroy hardened buildings and carried by an aerial vehicle, a missile."

Safety Engineer and accident Analyst, National Safety Technology Authority, Finland, Heikki Kurttila, PhD: "Conclusion: The observed collapse time of WTC 7 was 6.5 seconds. That is only half a second longer than it would have taken for the top of the building to fall to the ground in a vacuum, and half a second shorter than the falling time of an apple when air resistance is taken into account. ... The great speed of the collapse and the low value of the resistance factor strongly suggest controlled demolition."

Counter-Terrorism Officer, MI5 (Britain), David Shayler:
"The available evidence indicates that people in key positions in the FBI, the State Department, the CIA and so on were not loyal to the Constitution; that they saw an opportunity in plans laid down by genuine Islamic terrorists to carry out an operation that would shock the world and would therefore justify U.S. adventurism in the middle East, particularly in Afghanistan and Iraq."

Chairman, 9/11 Commission, Thomas H. Kean, Former Governor of New Jersey:
"FAA and NORAD officials advanced an account of 9/11 that was untrue...We, to this day, don't know why NORAD told us what they told us...It was just so far from the truth."

Vice Chairman, 9/11 Commission, Lee Hamilton, Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, Homeland Security Advisory Council:
"we got started late; we had a very short time frame...we did not have enough money...We had a lot of people strongly opposed to what we did. We had a lot of trouble getting access to documents and to people. ... So there were all kinds of reasons we thought we were set up to fail."

9/11 Commissioner, Timothy J. Roemer, PhD, Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence:
"That panel members so distrusted testimony from Pentagon officials that they referred their concerns to the Pentagon's inspector general...We were extremely frustrated with the false statements we were getting."

Senior Counsel, 9/11 Commission, John J. Farmer, Jr., Former Attorney General, NJ, Former Commissioner of the State Commission of Investigations:
[Some staff members and commissioners of the Sept. 11 panel concluded that the Pentagon's initial story of how it reacted to the 2001 terrorist attacks may have been part of a deliberate effort to mislead the commission and the public] - "I was shocked at how different the truth was from the way it was described...The tapes told a radically different story from what had been told to us and the public for two years."

MM posted for Christopher7
 
Here are 40 distinguished leaders and experts sounding-off in short quotes about their misgivings with the 9/11 commission and the questions that are still smoldering [NB: Don’t miss the concluding quote]...

Of your 40 quotes, 21 are general 9/11 denier statements based on well-debunked assumptions that don't even mention the 9/11 Commission, 2 look more or less irrelevant and 4 are either ambiguous or so far removed from their context that it's impossible to tell their meaning. Of the remaining thirteen, six tell of the difficulties that the 9/11 Commission had in uncovering the full story, suggesting that they were seriously trying to get at the truth, and the other seven suggest that the 9/11 Commission was set up as a deliberate whitewash that never even tried to uncover the truth. Which one of these two mutually exclusive scenarios are your quotes supposed to support?

Dave
 
Those people should band together a make a new report, if they know so much.

Well, those people have their concerns, don't they? When you separate the wheat from the chaff and eliminate those who have trouble with the commission's findings but don't suspect foul play, and eliminate pure opinion, conjecture, and political bias the list really isn't as impressive as MM would like it to be, however, but yea, I agree; I would like to see an official competing report from these people outlining in detail their issues if they feel so strongly about it.
 
Indeed, most of the content of MM's post are either conjecture, arguments from incredulity or comments about things that don't support the MIHOP argument. At best, it's a LIHOP-supporting post.
 
This is a frame:



This is a building frame's deflection (at 5x magnification)


This is what happens when a column is removed.


Are there any questions?
 
Newton, you are obviously a shill. It's obvious to anyone with half a brain that only the area "around" the beam you remove will be affected. That far beam should be straight !!!!111eleventyone
 
Your stick drawings do not represent the framework of WTC 7.

There were 28 columns on the south side, not 3.

In the real world, the columns around the severed and damaged areas did not bend.

sfacegraphic3np6.jpg


wtc7roofdamagepn6.jpg
 
Since A and B are impossible, here's what I say to C :

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/around

There are 33 definitions of this word. Please tell me which one you think the NIST used, and why you think it's not one of the 32 others.
NIST meant next to because the loads would be transferred to the columns next to the severed or damaged columns. These columns would either support the additional loads or fail and pass the load to the next column.
Loads cannot be transferred to columns far away unless all the intervening columns fail.

I've done that already. You're trying to add meaning to words and sentences to fit your preconceived theory.
No, you are trying to say around means something other than next to in the statement:

"...the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged areas."

Tell you what ? Why don't we stop beating around the bush with this silly semantics thread and get right to the point: start a thread about controlled demolitions at 7 WTC and we'll debate YOUR theory, not some incomplete report.
There is a thread for the CD debate.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2498320#post2498320

Personal attack aside, do you deny that saying that there was no debris or diesel fire damage AT that area says nothing about the former causing the latter ?
No.
The debris may have caused diesel fuel fires in the west part of WTC 7.
 
"...the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged areas."

C7, is it your belief that NIST means loads were redistributed to columns 'next to' the damaged areas when they say 'around'?

In the real world, their use of the word 'around' means 'bypassing'.

Rewritten for your understanding: The loads were redistributed, BYPASSING the severed and damaged areas.

That doesn't mean it had to be columns RIGHT BESIDE the damaged areas. Load redistribution isn't necessarily uniform. It depends on the extent of the damage and the design of the building. NO ONE knows the exact damage, and thus, NO ONE knows exactly which columns carried greater loads after damaged columns failed.
 
NIST meant next to because the loads would be transferred to the columns next to the severed or damaged columns. These columns would either support the additional loads or fail and pass the load to the next column.

Circular reasoning. Your contention that the additional load would only bear on the adjacent columns to those damaged is in question, here. How can you claim that NIST couldn't possibly mean anything else ?

You do NOT know better than the experts at NIST!

Loads cannot be transferred to columns far away unless all the intervening columns fail.

Well, I'm no structural engineer, but that sounds like nonsense, to me. Could you explain, in layman's terms, why, if the columns far away bear some of the building's load, they will not be affected if other columns, which are presumably sharing that load, fail ?

No.
The debris may have caused diesel fuel fires in the west part of WTC 7.

Do fires spread, Chris ?
 
C7, is it your belief that NIST means loads were redistributed to columns 'next to' the damaged areas when they say 'around'?
Yes

In the real world, their use of the word 'around' means 'bypassing'.
Rewritten for your understanding: The loads were redistributed, BYPASSING the severed and damaged areas.
Yes

That doesn't mean it had to be columns RIGHT BESIDE the damaged areas.
Yes it does. The loads cannot bypass an undamaged column.

Load redistribution isn't necessarily uniform. It depends on the extent of the damage and the design of the building. NO ONE knows the exact damage, and thus, NO ONE knows exactly which columns carried greater loads after damaged columns failed.
We don't know exactly which columns were involved but common sense tells anyone not in denial that the loads once held up by the severed columns would be held up by the columns next to it.
 
Chris said:
Yes it does. The loads cannot bypass an undamaged column.

Tell me, chris, if five columns bear a load, like this:

-------------------
|___|___|___|___|

And you remove the second from the left, can you tell me how much of that load each of the remaining columns bears ? You seem to think that only the 1st and 3rd would get an increase. I'm wondering why you think that. Anyone who actually knows the answer can freely chime in and tell me the answer, given hypothetical loads.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom