10 story hole in WTC 7

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nice try.
When we say the loads were "redistributed around the severed and damaged areas", we mean just that. The load paths were destroyed, and new ones formed. The damage was bypassed, and loads redistributed based on damage location, available load paths and loading conditions. It is not inconcievable that some potential load paths physically near the damage were then damaged by the load transfer, being unable to take the load themselves, yielding until the rest of the structure was able to support it.
You seem to think you know more about it than the engineers at NIST.

This load path stuff is a figment of your imagination.

NIST said The debris damage DID NOT cause the collapse and that the

loads were redistributed around the severed and damaged areas.

They did not say there were further collapses. You are making this s*it up as you go. Give it up.

The people at NIST are a lot smarter, more educated and more informed than you.

They made no mention of load paths, or any other of the gibberish terms and scenarios you guys have come up with.

You just can't admit that the debris damage did not contribute to the initiating event.

The damage was to the south west part of the building.

The collapse started in the east central part of the building.

Why do you claim there is a connection when NIST did not say there was ?

You do NOT know better than the experts at NIST!
 
The damage to the south west part of the building WOULD have played a role in the way the building ultimately collapsed even if not part of the initiating events.
 
You seem to think you know more about it than the engineers at NIST.

This load path stuff is a figment of your imagination.
No--just as much. It is what I do, and have done for a living for 35 years.
Go look up my qualifications
NIST said The debris damage DID NOT cause the collapse and that the

loads were redistributed around the severed and damaged areas.

They did not say there were further collapses. You are making this s*it up as you go. Give it up.

The people at NIST are a lot smarter, more educated and more informed than you.

They made no mention of load paths, or any other of the gibberish terms and scenarios you guys have come up with.

You just can't admit that the debris damage did not contribute to the initiating event.

The damage was to the south west part of the building.

The collapse started in the east central part of the building.

Why do you claim there is a connection when NIST did not say there was ?

You do NOT know better than the experts at NIST!

No, just as much.
Whereas you know absolutely nothing. About anything.
 
"the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged areas."

This is a clear and unambiguous statement.

Actually, it's very ambiguous. "Around" isn't a specific place.

Around means "something surrounds a place or object or is situated on all sides of it".

It does NOT mean "The other end of the building"

Again, you're trying to make them say something they didn't say. If I say I walked "around" my house, does that mean I was within arm's length of it at all times ?

Why can't you just accept that instead of clinging to
"they didn't specifically rule it out"

Because your either mistaken or dishonest in the way you quote the report.

and trying to infer the debris damage contributed to the initiating event. It did not.

You keep repeating that. I've shown that NIST doesn't say it didn't, unlike what you're claiming. They said there wasn't debris damage IN the area of the initiating event, not that the former didn't lead to the latter.
 
Actually, it's very ambiguous. "Around" isn't a specific place.



Again, you're trying to make them say something they didn't say. If I say I walked "around" my house, does that mean I was within arm's length of it at all times ?



Because your either mistaken or dishonest in the way you quote the report.



You keep repeating that. I've shown that NIST doesn't say it didn't, unlike what you're claiming. They said there wasn't debris damage IN the area of the initiating event, not that the former didn't lead to the latter.

What everybody, and Christopher7 is hung up on is the term "Initiating event".
The intiating event was 2 airplanes crashing into the 2 towers. NIST refers to the initiating event specifically as that event that immediately preceded the total collapse. Trnaslated into layman's terms, it was "The straw that broke the camel's back"
A series of events led up to the final collapse, not a single happening. Go get a dry stick, say, 3/8 to 1/2 inch around (or square) grab the ends, clamp one end to a sturdy bench, and add weight to the other end, gradually. There will be a series cof cracks, snaps, and assorted noises, and the stick will bend a lot. At some point, one of the weights you add will cause catastrophic failure in the stick. It will be sudden, and probably unexpected at the time. The last weight was NIST's "Initiating event". Does that mean the events before (adding other weights) had nothing to do with the failure? Only a fool would argue that this is true.
Steel acts the same way--yopu apply load, apply load, and keep applying load, untill suddenly the whole thing gives. The actual collapse was a long, slow process. It's progress was visible to everyone by the bulge described by NYFD---they even had a transit on it.
The building was collapsing the minute the chunks of the tall tower hit it.
 
Please remember your Membership agreement and remain civil and polite.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero


No, just as much.
Whereas you know absolutely nothing. About anything.
I know what is in the NIST report.
The statements are clear.
"A progression of column failure to adjacent columns would have been arrested by the vierendreel action of the perimeter moment frame"

They made it perfectly clear to anyone, not in denial, that the damage to the perimeter frame did not contribute to the initiating event.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Actually, it's very ambiguous. "Around" isn't a specific place.
Only to someone in denial

If you think "around" includes the other end of the building, you are:
A) lying to yourself
B) lying to me
C) in need of a remedial reading course


Because your either mistaken or dishonest in the way you quote the report.
No, read it, quote it, point out where i am mistaken or dishonest.
Talk's cheap.
Put up or shut up.

You keep repeating that. I've shown that NIST doesn't say it didn't, unlike what you're claiming. They said there wasn't debris damage IN the area of the initiating event, not that the former didn't lead to the latter.
For a person desperately looking for a reason to deny the obvious, anything other than a specific statement that the Debris damage did not contribute to the initiating event, is enough reason to say that did.
 
Talk is cheap, especially when not using your real name.
Give your real name and qualifications.
Put up or shut up.

I know what is in the NIST report.
The statements are clear.
"A progression of column failure to adjacent columns would have been arrested by the vierendreel action of the perimeter moment frame"

They made it perfectly clear to anyone, not in denial, that the damage to the perimeter frame did not contribute to the initiating event.

Yet nobody has come forward expressing doubt that that the official story expresses anything but reality. You can't be so dense as to believe that any disagreement with the NIST engineers is tacit agreement that the building could not have collapsed with anything else but CD.

You are hitching your wagon upon a star that disproves your entire premise.

Good luck with that.
 
Last edited:
Load paths is a CONCEPT, Christopher7. It's the same concept used to determine that the load travels AROUND damaged area. A Layman thinks that the load just travels through adjacent columns. Engineers know that it's a hellau more complex than that.
 
Load paths is a CONCEPT, Christopher7. It's the same concept used to determine that the load travels AROUND damaged area. A Layman thinks that the load just travels through adjacent columns. Engineers know that it's a hellau more complex than that.
The loads were transferred to the surrounding columns via the moment frame.

They did not "find a path" to the area of the initiating event.

You don't know squat. Stop blowin' smoke.
 
Load paths is a CONCEPT, Christopher7. It's the same concept used to determine that the load travels AROUND damaged area. A Layman thinks that the load just travels through adjacent columns. Engineers know that it's a hellau more complex than that.

I should know as little as you, NB..:D
 
And a hell of a lot more data and expertise than you as well.
That's why i quote them.

In fact, your attempt at interpreting what NIST says is pathetic.
"If the initiating event was due to damage to the perimeter moment frame, then it would have started along the south or southwest facade."

"Analysis of the global structure indicates that the structure redistributed loads around the severed and damaged areas."

You say pathetic, i say prophetic.

Let's call the whole thing off.
 
You're right, I don't know anything. I'm just someone who does that stuff for a living. There's absoluetly no way that the debris damage contributed to the collapse. And since the fire CAUSED by the debris obviously can't hurt steel, I can come to no other conclusion that the building must have been brought down with controlled demolition or thermite or magical energy beams of nuclear space dust.

Right.
 
You're right, I don't know anything.
Right

I'm just someone who does that stuff for a living.
Wrong

There's absoluetly no way that the debris damage contributed to the collapse.
Right

And since the fire CAUSED by the debris obviously can't hurt steel
Wrong

I can come to no other conclusion that the building must have been brought down with controlled demolition
Right

or thermite or magical energy beams of nuclear space dust.

Right.
Wrong
 
OK then Christopher, what does Newtons Bit do for a living?
Anyone can claim to be anything, using an assumed name.

NewtonsBit said:
The load will be transferred not only to the nearest column, but also to a lesser degree the ones further away.
Only if the nearest column bends.

NewtonsBit said:
If a cantilevered beam is developed, an upwards load will actually develop in the columns furthest from the damage.
Not so.

The load will be bourn by the column acting as the fulcrum.

Only if, and to the extent, the fulcrum column bends, will a negative load be transferred to the next column.

The weight pushing down on the beams [on the other side of the fulcrum point] is greater than the weight of the hanging floors in the damaged areas.

If you had 1 person sitting on one side of a see-saw and several people sitting on the other side, the person sitting on the far end would not be affected one way or the other by the 1 person.

This is not complicated as NB would have us believe.

His claim that the 'cantilever' effect would produce a negative load on the columns furthest away is incorrect.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom