Zohran Mamdani

I dunno. DSA seems to want it, along with the nationalization of a whole bunch of other industries. And open borders, no minimum sentencing regardless of the crime, and an entire host of communist ideas. If I didn't know better, I'd say they all read Orwell and Rand and just really sympathized with the villains.
You might want to learn a little bit about Orwell.
 
I dunno. DSA seems to want it, along with the nationalization of a whole bunch of other industries. And open borders, no minimum sentencing regardless of the crime, and an entire host of communist ideas. If I didn't know better, I'd say they all read Orwell and Rand and just really sympathized with the villains.
That is sort of mindset of the socialist. They view themselves as the anointed and smarter than everyone else.
 
Last edited:
Wait, what kind of socialist is Mamdani supposed to be? A knee-jerk, can't trust private businesses, government control solves every systemic problem, if you like taxes you must be socialist, type socialist?

Or his he more of a principled, government should own the means of production, type socialist?
 
Kind of. Margins are low at the retail level, but behind the scenes you have a mess of anti-competitive practices. Famously, dominant buyers make demands on suppliers and wholesalers that smaller chains or independent stores can't. New York State is currently in the process of trying end this kind of price discrimination...I guess we'll see how that goes.

Just a note here.

But the Robinson-Patman Act bars this at the Federal level. Reagan stopped enforcing the act in the 1980s and administrations afterwords continued ignoring the law. I guess there are just too many laws on the books to keep up with these days.
 
I'm seeing every day positive actions by Mamdani, and the people of NYC are very happy with him.

His policies are firmly aimed at lifting the bottom, and appear to be working. A new opinion poll shows him at well in positive territory, in spite of NYPost trying to demonise him daily.
 
100%.

It's one of the great shames he can't aspire to another job. The man has it all and has taken pains to include everyone.

Other than the uber-rich.
 
Mamdani Surprises Fox News Host

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani sat down with Fox News host Shannon Bream on Sunday to discuss the midterm elections and "blue wave" that hit the U.S. last week, but when the topic turned to his own socialist views, Bream was taken aback.

Socialism and DSA candidates were used by Republicans as a wedge issue leading up to the election, warning voters of the dangers of electing individuals with such views to office. Clearly, the tactic didn't work, and when pressed on how he feels about some specific topics, Mamdani's answers surprised Bream.


The exchange went like this:

Bream: Get rid of borders?

Mamdani: No

Bream: Get rid of SCOTUS?

Mamdani: No

Bream: Get rid of jails?

Mamdani: No

Bream: Do you think DSA is gonna kick you out?

Mamdani: No

🤣

PS: I still need to figure out what the DSA has become. Hm.
 
🤣

PS: I still need to figure out what the DSA has become. Hm.

To be fair, DSA's positions don't explicitly say get rid of borders, they just want to make it easier for people to enter the country and become citizens with many fewer requirements or barriers, thus increasing the volume of immigration to much higher levels without technically removing the on-the-map borders of the country.
End ICE detention and deportations and punish federal agents' brutality. Legalize migration, grant amnesty for all immigrants regardless of status, provide a path to citizenship for all permanent residents, and end visa caps and quotas.

Mamdani says the DSA doesn't want to eliminate SCOTUS... which is an interesting approach. I mean, maybe there's some technicality wherein they think that completely replacing SCOTUS (as well as the president) with a judiciary and executive installed by and subordinate to congress isn't "eliminating" them?
For the working class to govern, we need a new political system. End political corruption and legalized bribery: get rid of lobbyists, dark money, and Citizens United, and publicly finance all elections. Abolish the Electoral College. Replace the President and Supreme Court with an executive and judiciary chosen by and subordinate to Congress.
Speaking of Congress, DSA also wants to get rid of the senate entirely.

Mamdani can say "no" with respect to getting rid of jails... but that's contradicted by the DSA program which says (emphasis mine):
Demilitarize police departments, disempower police unions, and redirect funding to public services as steps towards fully abolishing the police and prison system which protects the rich and jails the poor.

So yeah. Mamdani is just straight up lying, and is contradicted by the DSA's program.

 
So yeah. Mamdani is just straight up lying, and is contradicted by the DSA's program.
This is...stupid. It's a 'program', not even a platform, and DSA members are not duty-bound to agree with everything on the DSA web site. He's an individual. He can have his own opinions and priorities. In the real world, the DSA is a big tent in a small pond, an organization that includes a spectrum of left wing political ideologies ranging from orthodox Marxists to boring old social democrats.

Would you have this much difficulty if a Democrat stated his opposition to abortion rights? "But...the Democratic platform!"
 
Last edited:
To be fair, DSA's positions don't explicitly say get rid of borders, they just want to make it easier for people to enter the country and become citizens with many fewer requirements or barriers, thus increasing the volume of immigration to much higher levels without technically removing the on-the-map borders of the country.


Mamdani says the DSA doesn't want to eliminate SCOTUS... which is an interesting approach. I mean, maybe there's some technicality wherein they think that completely replacing SCOTUS (as well as the president) with a judiciary and executive installed by and subordinate to congress isn't "eliminating" them?

Speaking of Congress, DSA also wants to get rid of the senate entirely.

Mamdani can say "no" with respect to getting rid of jails... but that's contradicted by the DSA program which says (emphasis mine):


So yeah. Mamdani is just straight up lying, and is contradicted by the DSA's program.

My understanding is the want to make the SCOTUS subordinate to the Congress rather than eliminated, that isn't really eliminating them it just making the much more political in nature. To be fair to Mamdami, almost nobody agrees entirely with their political party's platform. Particularly when you are in a first past the post system.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom