WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

"Harrit et al found chips in which the MEK treatment leaves behind unbound aluminum in still hard chips, while Millette has chips that become soft with MEK and without any unbound aluminum. Why?
Millette has not replicated the ignition tests and scrutinized the composition of the spheres reported by Harrit et al, which means there is no challenge to their results."

How much clearer could questions of anomalies in the tests BE? Yet Chris Mohr answers "Hmmm... I hired Jim Millette to do a bunch of experiments, and along the way, several others have done smaller experiments to demonstrate a particular point."

So what. The point is, Millette is being called on not doing ignition test replication and that his chips didn't react the same way in MEK! Which serves notice on the entire Millette conclusion. Those are the specific questions you are being tasked to address.

Ok Remo

Can you explain to me why Harrit et al's chips have Al concealed within an organic matrix yet the Fe is not.

What is the reason for keeping the two separated. Is it to increase performance ? Or is it to hide nano thermite ?
 
"Harrit et al found chips in which the MEK treatment leaves behind unbound aluminum in still hard chips, while Millette has chips that become soft with MEK and without any unbound aluminum. Why?
This has been answered hundreds of times. It's just truther deliberate "na na I can't hear you" and unwillingness to accept the answer. Look at my signature.

The MEK chip in the ATM paper is different from chips a-d. It has a spectrum of a very different nature. Yet Millette tested chips matching the spectrum of chips a-d, not matching the spectrum of the MEK chip.

They tested different chips, they obtained different results. That's why.

Why should anyone be surprised?


So what. The point is, Millette is being called on not doing ignition test replication and that his chips didn't react the same way in MEK! Which serves notice on the entire Millette conclusion.
You're missing Millette's point. The ignition tests are nonsensical once you prove there is no thermite because there is no free aluminium (and even if you haven't). He proved there is no aluminium; therefore there's no thermite in those chips.

And it's quite cynical of Jones to claim that Millette had the wrong chips given that (1) he and the other authors claimed that the chips are ubiquitous in the dust, showing many samples from many sources; (2) he did not make any effort in separating different types of chips, and instead assumed they all were the same thing, yet he's now criticizing Millette for following that line of reasoning; (3) he has expressly refused to provide his chips that he believed to be thermitic to Millette for independent analysis.
 
Truthers still can't grasp that the chip soaked in MEK was of a different composition to chips a-d in Harrit et al.

Chips a-d contain no aluminates.
MEK chip does contain aluminates.

Separation of these aluminates using MEK occurs. The paper makes the mistake that this separation is the separation of elemental Al particles.

Millette used a criteria in order to isolate chips that were the same material as chips a-d for further study. Therefore he will not end up with material that matches the MEK soaked chip.

Chips a-d have an epoxy matrix (which is another indicator that the paint is Laclade primer paint), whilst the chip soaked in MEK is likely Tnemec primer paint which has a completely different binder/matrix namely an alkyd resin.

It's no surprise that two different binders are going to react differently to MEK.

This is not difficult to understand.

Oystein has done some further work to back up the MEK soaked chip being Tnemec red primer paint. I notice no truther is arguing against this work.
 
Truthers still can't grasp that the chip soaked in MEK was of a different composition to chips a-d in Harrit et al.

Chips a-d contain no aluminates.
MEK chip does contain aluminates.

Separation of these aluminates using MEK occurs. The paper makes the mistake that this separation is the separation of elemental Al particles.

Millette used a criteria in order to isolate chips that were the same material as chips a-d for further study. Therefore he will not end up with material that matches the MEK soaked chip.

Chips a-d have an epoxy matrix (which is another indicator that the paint is Laclade primer paint), whilst the chip soaked in MEK is likely Tnemec primer paint which has a completely different binder/matrix namely an alkyd resin.

It's no surprise that two different binders are going to react differently to MEK.

This is not difficult to understand.

Oystein has done some further work to back up the MEK soaked chip being Tnemec red primer paint. I notice no truther is arguing against this work.

It is pointless attempting a detailed discussion with Oystein as long as he persists in lying.

MM
 
It is pointless attempting a detailed discussion with Oystein as long as he persists in lying.

MM

It is pointless attempting a serious discussion with MM as long as he persists in run run ruuuuunnnnnniiiiing away from all the question that he knows and FEARS will shatter his dear faith! :D

Run, MM! 17 questions in the other thread, hundreds more that you ran away from in the past! MM - running away from tough questions since January 2007 :D :D :D
 
For what it's worth, as we speak I am trying to figure out a way to do some kind of test where the red-grey chips are heated. Here are the important questions I have:

1.) Dr. Jones, may we please have some samples of red-grey chips you believe are thermitic which we can cook up in a DSC analysis?

2.) Before we cook them, can we do a chemical analysis of them? If Dr. Jones says they are unignited thermitic materials, let's look for the chemical signature of thermite. Let's also compare them to the chips Millette used. If we don't find it, then as Jim Millette told me personally, they will have to come up with some other hypothesis as to what these chips are "because they are not thermite."

3.) If we cook them up and iron micropsheres are formed during and after ignition, at what temperature are these microspheres formed? If they are formed at less than the melting point of steel and/or iron, that would prove experimentally that the claims of microspheres being formed only above the melting point of steel would be proven false. If indeed the chips burn at 3000-4000 degrees F, we would have to also burn known samples of primer paints similar to the WTC paints to see if they burn at much lower temperatures. Ideally, we could burn Millette's chips and see if they burn cooler.

Oh yeah, we can't do ANY of this until we get a yes answer to question #1, for as long as Jones refuses to release chips he certifies are thermitic, he will always deny we have the right chips!
 
For what it's worth, as we speak I am trying to figure out a way to do some kind of test where the red-grey chips are heated.

why dont you just ask millette to heat his to 450C as per astm standards for the muffle furnace test. from there, we can see if millettes chips form iron and silicon microspheres and/or "iron films" like basille found. basille's chips ignited around 430C remember.
 
Chris , just remark:

Prof. Jones does not know (and cannot know) what was the temperature of his burning chips. He did not measure it. He only thinks that since microspheres were formed, temperature had to be very high.

DSC does not measure the increase of sample temperature caused by some exothermic reaction. Quite contrary: DCS tries to keep (by heating or cooling the sample) the same temperature of the sample as is the temperature of non-reacting reference sample (some "inert stuff" which does not react with some thermal effect at all).

In principle, for very rapid exothermic rection, it is possible that actual temperature of burning sample would strongly exceed the actual temperature of a heating pan, but DSC is not proper method for recording such very rapid processes.

What we see in Bentham paper are very broad exotherms lasting several minutes. Hypothetically, they could be even some very sharp "hidden" exotherms in reality (e.g. for nanothermite;), lasting let's say a second or even much less, but they cannot be easily recorded by DSC (and they were not for sure recorded in Bentham paper as well, since we simply do not see them).

Broad DSC curves shown in Bentham paper are fully compatible with a slow burning of e.g. paints or other materials with a lot of organics/polymers.

As I already pointed out, for the measurements of actual temperature of burning samples, other method must be used, namely e.g. Differential Thermal Analysis (DTA). Jones did not employ it.
 
Last edited:
It is pointless attempting a serious discussion with MM as long as he persists in run run ruuuuunnnnnniiiiing away from all the question that he knows and FEARS will shatter his dear faith! :D

Run, MM! 17 questions in the other thread, hundreds more that you ran away from in the past! MM - running away from tough questions since January 2007 :D :D :D

Why should I waste my time amusing you by answering 17 questions when you have no qualms about using lies to respond?

There are no shortage of examples;

"What Farrer, Harrit and the others found was that thei chips react exothermally mostly around a peak at 430°, plus minus 50°. This means their reaction already started under 400°C. This is consistent with Millette's ashing of the sample at 400°C."


Extract from the 2009 Bentham Paper:
"Red/gray chips were subjected to heating using a differential scanning calorimeter (DSC). The data shown in Fig. (19) demonstrate that the red/gray chips from different WTC samples all ignited in the range 415-435 ˚C."

MM
 
Last edited:
Extract from the 2009 Bentham Paper:
"Red/gray chips were subjected to heating using a differential scanning calorimeter (DSC). The data shown in Fig. (19) demonstrate that the red/gray chips from different WTC samples all ignited in the range 415-435 ˚C."

MM

Is that a signature of "thermite" or do other things do this also?

(cue MM claiming "iron spheres" that his heroes forgot to document which chips produced them).
 
MM: What we see in Fig. 19 is this:

picture.php


Apparently, exothemic reactions (burning) started at about 330-370 degrees C in the case of two "bigger" exotherms. You do not see that?

It is in very good agreement e.g. with this calorimetric curve for epoxy resins/composites:

picture.php


Because of this typical behavior of polymers (e.g. binder in paints), temperature for ashing set to about 400 degrees C is ideal, since all polymer is burned after some time (1 h in Millette's study), but the effect of heat on pigments and other uncombustible components is minimal.
 
Last edited:
why dont you just ask millette to heat his to 450C as per astm standards for the muffle furnace test. from there, we can see if millettes chips form iron and silicon microspheres and/or "iron films" like basille found. basille's chips ignited around 430C remember.

Hey senenmut,

Why don't you ask Jones for some red/gray chips, then perhaps Millette could do some tests before he burns the evidence.

At least that's how I interpret what Chris has just posted.
 
Mohr: It seems to me that many claims here at JREF are actually backed up in some way (not all, to be sure, but more than you seem to be willing to give them credit for). I think it's time you acknowledge that your global assertion, "none of you have ever made any experiments to back up your claims" is simply false. Please acknowledge this inaccuracy.

Stick to the subject at hand, the chips. If your buddies have made some experiments where they reproduce ignition results by Harrit et al, please show them. Remember those iron spheres?

Oh, and what happened to your admission to Ryan that he was right about Millette fraud charges?
 
Stick to the subject at hand, the chips. If your buddies have made some experiments where they reproduce ignition results by Harrit et al, please show them. Remember those iron spheres?

Oh, and what happened to your admission to Ryan that he was right about Millette fraud charges?
What "chips" produced these? Were they the ones with or without the elemental aluminum?
 
Source please?

The video shows a reaction time of 1/15 to 2/15 of a second.

MM

Source is the paper itself, have you read the paper? - page 10, first paragraph.

Some samples were also tested in a differential scanning calorimeter (Netzsch DSC 404C) to measure heat flow into
or out of the red/gray chips. The DSC tests were conducted with a linear heating rate of 10 °C per minute up to a temperature of 700 °C.
The x-axis on a DSC is also a time axis. For every increase in 10°C on the x-axis then 1 minute has occurred.

So if you heat from 20°C to 100°C then that takes 8 minutes.

100-20/10 = 8

The DSC curve in Harrit et al shows the main exotherm occurring between approximately 370°C and 470°C, so

470-370/10 = 10 minutes.

10 minutes is several minutes. This has been explained to you repeatedly, but you still refuse to understand such simple calculations.

If you think you can do better, then show on the DSC curve from Harrit et al at what temperature you think the exotherm starts and stops and then calculate the time taken. You won't because you know the answer is going to be different to what you think.
 
Last edited:
Chris , just remark:

Prof. Jones does not know (and cannot know) what was the temperature of his burning chips. He did not measure it. He only thinks that since microspheres were formed, temperature had to be very high.

DSC does not measure the increase of sample temperature caused by some exothermic reaction. Quite contrary: DCS tries to keep (by heating or cooling the sample) the same temperature of the sample as is the temperature of non-reacting reference sample (some "inert stuff" which does not react with some thermal effect at all).

In principle, for very rapid exothermic rection, it is possible that actual temperature of burning sample would strongly exceed the actual temperature of a heating pan, but DSC is not proper method for recording such very rapid processes.

What we see in Bentham paper are very broad exotherms lasting several minutes. Hypothetically, they could be even some very sharp "hidden" exotherms in reality (e.g. for nanothermite;), lasting let's say a second or even much less, but they cannot be easily recorded by DSC (and they were not for sure recorded in Bentham paper as well, since we simply do not see them).

Broad DSC curves shown in Bentham paper are fully compatible with a slow burning of e.g. paints or other materials with a lot of organics/polymers.

As I already pointed out, for the measurements of actual temperature of burning samples, other method must be used, namely e.g. Differential Thermal Analysis (DTA). Jones did not employ it.

Solid, Jackson!:cool:
 
"In principle, for very rapid exothermic rection, it is possible that actual temperature of burning sample would strongly exceed the actual temperature of a heating pan, but DSC is not proper method for recording such very rapid processes.

What we see in Bentham paper are very broad exotherms lasting several minutes. Hypothetically, they could be even some very sharp "hidden" exotherms in reality (e.g. for nanothermite;), lasting let's say a second or even much less, but they cannot be easily recorded by DSC (and they were not for sure recorded in Bentham paper as well,]since we simply do not see them.
"
"Source please?

The video shows a reaction time of 1/15 to 2/15 of a second."
"Source is the paper itself, have you read the paper? - page 10, first paragraph.

The x-axis on a DSC is also a time axis. For every increase in 10°C on the x-axis then 1 minute has occurred.

So if you heat from 20°C to 100°C then that takes 8 minutes.

100-20/10 = 8

The DSC curve in Harrit et al shows the main exotherm occurring between approximately 370°C and 470°C, so

470-370/10 = 10 minutes.

10 minutes is several minutes. This has been explained to you repeatedly, but you still refuse to understand such simple calculations.

If you think you can do better, then show on the DSC curve from Harrit et al at what temperature you think the exotherm starts and stops and then calculate the time taken. You won't because you know the answer is going to be different to what you think.
"

Muddy the waters much?

The temperature range for the exothermic reaction exhibited by the ignited thermitic material was clearly stated in the Bentham Paper;

2009 Bentham Paper said:
"Red/gray chips were subjected to heating using a differential scanning calorimeter (DSC). The data shown in Fig. (19) demonstrate that the red/gray chips from different WTC samples all ignited in the range 415-435 ˚C."

Dr. Harrit et al did the actually testing, whereas you and Ivan provided ---- smoke and mirrors and heavily biased analysis.

As I said, the video shows a reaction time of 1/15 to 2/15 of a second for the ignition.

The minutes of heat buildup before and after this reaction are irrelevant to this point.

MM
 
Muddy the waters much?

The temperature range for the exothermic reaction exhibited by the ignited thermitic material was clearly stated in the Bentham Paper;



Dr. Harrit et al did the actually testing, whereas you and Ivan provided ---- smoke and mirrors and heavily biased analysis.

As I said, the video shows a reaction time of 1/15 to 2/15 of a second for the ignition.

The minutes of heat buildup before and after this reaction are irrelevant to this point.

MM
You should stop asking technical sounding questions, :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom