WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

* pgimeno holds his breath...

;)

Owing to quite a large amount of info in all these paint (and microspheres) threads, I'm not really sure: have we discussed this old good NIST image of Tnemec primer heated to more than 650 degrees C?

picture.php


This burned paint layer with some rust scales is basically quite similar to "infamous" Bentham chips:

picture.php


This is no surprise, since any such red primer paint "after exposure greater than 650 degrees" should be basically similar to unheated paint (visually). But what is probably interesting that we do not see any microspheres created from the scales here. Scales still look like scales (although the image quality is probably not good enough).

From this point of view (which is not conclusive) , Bentham chips heated in DSC device should be different kind of paint chips, since microsphere formation (mostly from gray rust scales) was very apparent there, at similar temperatures:cool:
 
Last edited:
jtl: Why did it go from a tiny peak to almost disappearing after washing, just like a lot of other stuff from fig14?

Oystein:This has been explained to you several times, by at least 3 posters.
Because Jones specically and deliberately focused on small spots rich in other pigments.
Sunstealer: Oh, the Zn is there. Definitely there in Fig 18. You can't see it because you don't know what you are looking at.

So Sunstealer, you say the Zn is still there mislabeled but Oystein says it is not there because Jones focused on a spot without Zn. Which one is it?

Given you are right and there is still some Zn there, why is there less of it after MEK wash? Why did fig14 not have the same amount of Zn as the known sample(from Jones) of Tnemec you yourself used for comparison?
And you said fig14 was a match for this Tnemec from Jones and also a match to some Millette chips, so why did Millette rule out Tnemec?

Your Tnemec hypothesis has some holes in it so big you could drive a truck through it.

No, obviously not, you think that the mapping in Fig 15 shows that the Zn and the S, the Ca, Cr, S have all disappeared from the sample. lol.

Actually I was talking about the fact that all those elements disappeared after washing in figures 16 to 18. You say the Zn is still there but what happened to the other stuff? Do you agree with Oystein that you can cherry pick the Zn as part of the chip while dismissing the rest, or at least the Ca and S, as contamination?

Harrit essay on Tnemec: The resulting XEDS of this chip (Figure 6, below)
displays tiny blips indicating the presence of chromium and zinc. They disappeared after the chips had been soaked/rinsed with the organic solvent. Therefore, they are believed to derive from surface contamination, which very well could have been from the primer paint(!).Magnesium was never observed, which is another element characteristic of the primer paint

I said before that you guys should show me some references to what truthers have to say about your technical points, but you don´t. I did a quick search for "Harrit paint" and found a paper he wrote about the chips vs Tnemec paint. This essay clearly says the Zn disappeared after washing chip from fig14, and it also points out lack of Magnesium.

Both Harrit and Millette rule out Tnemec.

jtl: If you are such an expert and so sure of everything you say, why dont you put your money where your mouth is and publish your results? Why did you not do it years ago when you claimed to have debunked Harrit? i think it is obvious that a published paper would have done a lot more good to debunk harrit than than some cheap talk amongst people behind fake names. But you can´t can you?

You ignored this question Sunstealer, and given the information above it seems obvious why.
 
So Sunstealer, you say the Zn is still there mislabeled but Oystein says it is not there because Jones focused on a spot without Zn. Which one is it?

Given you are right and there is still some Zn there, why is there less of it after MEK wash? Why did fig14 not have the same amount of Zn as the known sample(from Jones) of Tnemec you yourself used for comparison?
And you said fig14 was a match for this Tnemec from Jones and also a match to some Millette chips, so why did Millette rule out Tnemec?

Your Tnemec hypothesis has some holes in it so big you could drive a truck through it.



Actually I was talking about the fact that all those elements disappeared after washing in figures 16 to 18. You say the Zn is still there but what happened to the other stuff? Do you agree with Oystein that you can cherry pick the Zn as part of the chip while dismissing the rest, or at least the Ca and S, as contamination?



I said before that you guys should show me some references to what truthers have to say about your technical points, but you don´t. I did a quick search for "Harrit paint" and found a paper he wrote about the chips vs Tnemec paint. This essay clearly says the Zn disappeared after washing chip from fig14, and it also points out lack of Magnesium.

Both Harrit and Millette rule out Tnemec.



You ignored this question Sunstealer, and given the information above it seems obvious why.

Nice post, what's it got to do with thermite ?
 
Spanx: Originally Posted by Spanx:
@jtl

Please could you clarify what you think Millette's role is.

Please explain what his objective was from the start.

Spanx: Thanks for ignoring this post jtl, I guess it is not technical enough for you

Judging by your comments like "we need to help Millette debunk harrit" I guess you don't understand that Millette has carried out an independent study to establish if the red/gray chips are thermite. He has not carried out a study to debunk Harrits paper.

You keep insisting that Jref posters should influence his work, which in turn would invalidate his work.

JREF posters are paying for his work so they have every right to make sure he does all the work, all the tests laid out by Harrit. Trying to influence Millette to exclude some tests you don´t like invalidates his paper. Millettes role is very clear since he is supposed to repeat the work by Harrit, and since you all seem to want the result to be paint his role is specified in plain old English by Harrit:

To merit consideration, any assertion that a prosaic sub-
stance such as paint could match the characteristics we have
described would have to be accompanied by empirical dem- onstration using a sample of the proposed material, including SEM/XEDS and DSC analyses.

People on this forum are pretending there are no weaknesses with Millette paper but he fails to repeat the work and it is not even 100% for sure that he has the same chips. You say its paint from the wtc but he has not identified any chips as such paint, and he does not offer any empirical demonstration that a sample of paint can produce the same results as Harrit chips in dsc. You can´t see the elephant in the room?

None of you see any room for improvements?

plague311: They didn't post their paper in a peer review journal so it has no scientific merit.

You do not make yourselves or Millette look any better by spreading this sort of garbage. Refusing to do the tests and spreading dirty garbage looks very bad.

Spanx: Nice post, what's it got to do with thermite ?

Since you don´t understand you have no reason for being here except trolling, so you know why I won´t bother with you no more. I should have known after your comments about thermite energy release, but now it is official.
 
Last edited:
So Sunstealer, you say the Zn is still there mislabeled but Oystein says it is not there because Jones focused on a spot without Zn. Which one is it?

Given you are right and there is still some Zn there, why is there less of it after MEK wash? Why did fig14 not have the same amount of Zn as the known sample(from Jones) of Tnemec you yourself used for comparison?
And you said fig14 was a match for this Tnemec from Jones and also a match to some Millette chips, so why did Millette rule out Tnemec?

Your Tnemec hypothesis has some holes in it so big you could drive a truck through it.



Actually I was talking about the fact that all those elements disappeared after washing in figures 16 to 18. You say the Zn is still there but what happened to the other stuff? Do you agree with Oystein that you can cherry pick the Zn as part of the chip while dismissing the rest, or at least the Ca and S, as contamination?



I said before that you guys should show me some references to what truthers have to say about your technical points, but you don´t. I did a quick search for "Harrit paint" and found a paper he wrote about the chips vs Tnemec paint. This essay clearly says the Zn disappeared after washing chip from fig14, and it also points out lack of Magnesium.

Both Harrit and Millette rule out Tnemec.



You ignored this question Sunstealer, and given the information above it seems obvious why.
You simply do not understand.

I've told you to go away and research SEM EDX but you refuse to do it. You don't understand why fig 16 and 17 show no zinc even though it's been explained to you half a dozen times. Again if you focus the electron beam using a lower KeV then you are examining an ever smaller area/volume of the sample. We'll try another analogy to see whether you can get it through your skull.

Imagine a bowl of fruit containing apples, oranges pears and bananas. Now with your eyes you can see all the fruit. Now get a pair of binoculars and focus solely on an apple. Hey, where did the bananas go? The bananas have disappeared! See how silly you are being? You are claiming that the bananas have disappeared. They haven't it's still there. So is the Zinc, so is the Iron etc.

How are you determining quantity using EDX spectra? Do you know the difference between quantitative and qualitive?

I've already told you why Millette ruled out Tnemec for his chips that matched samples a-d, but you fail to understand even when a simple analogy is used.

Millette was tasked with looking at spectra that matched samples a-d. He didn't perform any additional experimentation on samples that didn;t match that criteria. Since Tnemec red EDX spectra is outside of this criteria then how on earth could he conclude that his additionally analysed chips could be Tnemec?

Again - if you are asked to pick only apples (EDX of samples a-d) from a fruit bowl then you can safely say they are not bananas (Tnemec Red paint). However, if Millette was to pick bananas out then he would find bananas wouldn't he? It's a simple analogy.

No Millette does not rule out Tnemec completely. Millette rukes out Tnemec ONLY for samples that match the EDX for samples in Harrit et al.

Are you doing this on purpose? Are you willfully getting this stuff wrong even when explained to you? Why are you coming here asking questions when you flatly refuse the answers given? You reek of truther. I'll not bother with you if you keep up these shenanigans.

I don't cherry pick anything - accuse me again and you'll go onto ignore - I've explained in detail why the MEK chip cannot have any significant contamiation and how that chip and some of Millette's chips that are not equivalent to chips a-d are excellent matches for Tnemec red primer paint.

Why would I point you in the direction of truther points? The Harrit et al paper is a crock of *****, totally worthless, not peer-reviewed and published in a pay to publish vanity journal who's editor resigned because of it. Truthers know nothing about the topic and that includes Harrit, Jones, Farrer, Basile etc. If they did know how to conduct a materials characterisation exercise then they wouldn't have produced such crap.

How do you publish a rebuttal to a paper that was never published in a peer-reviewed journal of decent reputation.

Why don't you publish why the earth goes round the sun or why the earth isn't flat in say Nature? I'm sure they would jump at such revelations. No one in the wider scientific community knows about the crappy Harrit et al "paper". It doesn't exist as far as academia is concerned.
 
Since you don´t understand you have no reason for being here except trolling, so you know why I won´t bother with you no more. I should have known after your comments about thermite energy release, but now it is official.

That's where you are wrong, unlike you I don't make out that I know more than everybody else. I can understand that if you can't find the materials to make thermite there is no need to continue searching.

And just for the record I have just as much right to be on this forum as you, you are not special.
 
... People on this forum are pretending there are no weaknesses with Millette paper but he fails to repeat the work and it is not even 100% for sure that he has the same chips. You say its paint from the wtc but he has not identified any chips as such paint, and he does not offer any empirical demonstration that a sample of paint can produce the same results as Harrit chips in dsc. You can´t see the elephant in the room?

....
What is wrong with the study? Did the study ruin your fantasy of thermite? Have you been banned at other forums?

You are pretending to know something about chemistry and thermite. You should team up with a chemical engineer next time.

You don't know what DSC means, so you make up nonsense. Pure nonsense. There was no thermite used on 911. Proved on 911. Millette's paper found no thermite, the same as Harrit's paper.

USGS found not thermite. Lee study found no thermite right next to the WTC,unlike dust collected from where in the Jones farce. Millette found no thermite. The only people who found thermite are those you call crazy "truthers", or nut-case crazy... etc.

Try using the quote button, your replies might/could be faster

Fooled by the people you call crazy who believe 911 truth?
Do you understand thermite was NOT used on 911 to destroy the WTC? A very simple question with only two possible answers for you, on correct answer for the rational world. Yes or No. Circle one.
 
Sunstealer: Oh, the Zn is there. Definitely there in Fig 18. You can't see it because you don't know what you are looking at.

jtl: So Sunstealer, you say the Zn is still there mislabeled but Oystein says it is not there because Jones focused on a spot without Zn. Which one is it?

Sunstealer: You don't understand why fig 16 and 17 show no zinc even though it's been explained to you half a dozen times.

Oh wow Sunstealer, fig18 to 16 and 17, such a nice handwave! I am sure no one will notice.;)

jtl: Given you are right and there is still some Zn there, why is there less of it after MEK wash? Why did fig14 not have the same amount of Zn as the known sample(from Jones) of Tnemec you yourself used for comparison?

Sunstealer: No Millette does not rule out Tnemec completely. Millette rukes out Tnemec ONLY for samples that match the EDX for samples in Harrit et al.
Millette: small EDS peaks of zinc and chromium were detected in some samples but the amount detected was inconsistent with the 20% level of zinc chromate in the primer formula.

Strawman! Are you lying on purpose or you just a quack? Did you not understand my question? You gonna publish a paper soon?

jtl: If you are such an expert and so sure of everything you say, why dont you put your money where your mouth is and publish your results? Why did you not do it years ago when you claimed to have debunked Harrit? i think it is obvious that a published paper would have done a lot more good to debunk harrit than than some cheap talk amongst people behind fake names. But you can´t can you?

Sunstealer: Why would I point you in the direction of truther points? The Harrit et al paper is a crock of *****, totally worthless, not peer-reviewed and published in a pay to publish vanity journal who's editor resigned because of it. Truthers know nothing about the topic and that includes Harrit, Jones, Farrer, Basile etc. If they did know how to conduct a materials characterisation exercise then they wouldn't have produced such crap.

How do you publish a rebuttal to a paper that was never published in a peer-reviewed journal of decent reputation.

Oh you can officially stop your act. My post had some very specific questions but you either ignore them or answer with strawman tactics, and when all else fails you resort to spreading garbage about Harrit paper. Maybe you can still impress some of your buddies on this forum but outside of it you are just another troll with pants full of crap. So sad.
 
My post had some very specific questions .

Try using the quote button, your replies might/could be faster



Fooled by the people you call crazy who believe 911 truth?

You can ask, but you can't answer?
Do you understand thermite was NOT used on 911 to destroy the WTC? Yes or No. Circle one.
 
You ignored this question Sunstealer, and given the information above it seems obvious why.

Everyone noticed you ignored this. Is this really that tough a question?

OK lets try this.

Here is Fig 7 in the Harrit et al paper.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=181&pictureid=874[/qimg]

Do you agree that these EDX spectra; a, b, c and d, show that the red layer is the same material? i.e. a=b=c=d.

Answer Yes or No.

A simple yes or no will do. :rolleyes:
 
Kminek: This burned paint layer with some rust scales is basically quite similar to "infamous" Bentham chips:

This is no surprise, since any such red primer paint "after exposure greater than 650 degrees" should be basically similar to unheated paint (visually). But what is probably interesting that we do not see any microspheres created from the scales here. Scales still look like scales (although the image quality is probably not good enough).

From this point of view (which is not conclusive) , Bentham chips heated in DSC device should be different kind of paint chips, since microsphere formation (mostly from gray rust scales) was very apparent there, at similar temperatures

This is a point raised by Harrit in his essay about the chips vs Tnemec, and it seems to rule out Tnemec. The Tnemec before and after burning looks like the Harrit chips before they are ignited, but not after. It looks like chips of Tnemec on those gray flakes would not produce the spheres in dsc test, so the chips must be some other paint.

You see? Those curves (TGA and MCC) correlate quite nicely and they basically tell us:

Yes maybe some of those paint curves are similar, but they are a bit conflicting. Again I think we agree that a test is needed with same parameters as Harrit.

Question: The al in the residue spheres kind of has to be pure al? Al oxide and kaolin have very high melting temps while al melts below 700. How can we get al from kaolin of al oxide from laclede or tnemec in those dsc tests?
 
Oh wow Sunstealer, fig18 to 16 and 17, such a nice handwave! I am sure no one will notice.;)




Strawman! Are you lying on purpose or you just a quack? Did you not understand my question? You gonna publish a paper soon?





Oh you can officially stop your act. My post had some very specific questions but you either ignore them or answer with strawman tactics, and when all else fails you resort to spreading garbage about Harrit paper. Maybe you can still impress some of your buddies on this forum but outside of it you are just another troll with pants full of crap. So sad.
Yep, definitely outed as a truther. You came onto this site saying don't believe in bombs and stuff and now you are openly defending Harrit et al whose entire conclusion is thermite bombs.

You said you weren't an expert, although you now claim to know better than everyone else. You have ignored all of the technical answers, ignored all of the technical posts, purposely misread and twisted posts designed to help you understand, you have no understanding of SEM and I doubt you've ever seen one, but are telling people who do have extensive experience in that field that they are wrong, you finally let the mask slide by defending Harrit and attacking Millette even when it's all been explained to you. There is no point in talking with such a wilfully ignorant and dishonest person.

Onto ignore you go. Bye.
 
Last edited:
... Question: The al in the residue spheres kind of has to be pure al? Al oxide and kaolin have very high melting temps while al melts below 700. How can we get al from kaolin of al oxide from laclede or tnemec in those dsc tests?

What is the question? This is nonsense.


Question:
Do you understand thermite was NOT used on 911 to destroy the WTC? Yes or No. Circle one
 
There is no evidence of individual elemental aluminum particles of any size in the red/gray chips, therefore the red layer of the red/gray chips is not thermite or nano-thermite.

:rolleyes:
 
Sunstealer: There is no point in talking with such a wilfully ignorant and dishonest person.

Onto ignore you go. Bye.

Oh boo hoo Sunstealer, stop the act, you were caught cheating and lying, and you have crapped you pants. You the self proclaimed expert could not even refer to Millette paper without lying. This is desperation for all to see:

Sunstealer: No Millette does not rule out Tnemec completely. Millette rukes out Tnemec ONLY for samples that match the EDX for samples in Harrit et al.
Quote:
Millette: small EDS peaks of zinc and chromium were detected in some samples but the amount detected was inconsistent with the 20% level of zinc chromate in the primer formula.

Harrit and Millette both rule out Tnemec because of lack of Zn. Sunstealer thinks he knows better than both, but it seems his ego is a lot bigger than his honesty and ability. The rest of you should also notice that Sunstealer admits that some of Millette chips are no match for Harrit chips.
 
Oh boo hoo Sunstealer, stop the act, you were caught cheating and lying, and you have crapped you pants. You the self proclaimed expert could not even refer to Millette paper without lying. This is desperation for all to see:



Harrit and Millette both rule out Tnemec because of lack of Zn. Sunstealer thinks he knows better than both, but it seems his ego is a lot bigger than his honesty and ability. The rest of you should also notice that Sunstealer admits that some of Millette chips are no match for Harrit chips.

Who's the troll ? :D
 
Oh boo hoo Sunstealer, stop the act, you were caught cheating and lying, and you have crapped you pants. You the self proclaimed expert could not even refer to Millette paper without lying. This is desperation for all to see: ...
Do you know your posts have a lot of nonsense in them? Do you know where the quote button is?

Since you are completely off topic, try an easy question.


Question:
Do you understand thermite was NOT used on 911 to destroy the WTC? Yes or No. Circle one - good luck
 
Last edited:
DGM: Do you support the notion that Harrit and company should release all their data or do you agree they need to hold it back?

Yes, they should release all data, but this is hardly a big issue until the previous data have been dealt with. I don´t know how much data is left but maybe there is enough for another Harrit paper? This should dome out after Millette publishes his paper.

Someone said something about another researcher putting out a paper?

Spanx: Who's the troll ?

You Spanx and beachnut. You keep repeating the same non sense again and again even though you have been told I won´t bother, so maybe you will understand this time? I won´t bother again so Good Bye.:D
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom