So Sunstealer, you say the Zn is still there mislabeled but Oystein says it is not there because Jones focused on a spot without Zn. Which one is it?
Given you are right and there is still some Zn there, why is there less of it after MEK wash? Why did fig14 not have the same amount of Zn as the known sample(from Jones) of Tnemec you yourself used for comparison?
And you said fig14 was a match for this Tnemec from Jones and also a match to some Millette chips, so why did Millette rule out Tnemec?
Your Tnemec hypothesis has some holes in it so big you could drive a truck through it.
Actually I was talking about the fact that all those elements disappeared after washing in figures 16 to 18. You say the Zn is still there but what happened to the other stuff? Do you agree with Oystein that you can cherry pick the Zn as part of the chip while dismissing the rest, or at least the Ca and S, as contamination?
I said before that you guys should show me some references to what truthers have to say about your technical points, but you don´t. I did a quick search for "Harrit paint" and found a paper he wrote about the chips vs Tnemec paint. This essay clearly says the Zn disappeared after washing chip from fig14, and it also points out lack of Magnesium.
Both Harrit and Millette rule out Tnemec.
You ignored this question Sunstealer, and given the information above it seems obvious why.
You simply do not understand.
I've told you to go away and research SEM EDX but you refuse to do it. You don't understand why fig 16 and 17 show no zinc even though it's been explained to you half a dozen times. Again if you focus the electron beam using a lower KeV then you are examining an ever smaller area/volume of the sample. We'll try another analogy to see whether you can get it through your skull.
Imagine a bowl of fruit containing apples, oranges pears and bananas. Now with your eyes you can see all the fruit. Now get a pair of binoculars and focus solely on an apple. Hey, where did the bananas go? The bananas have disappeared! See how silly you are being? You are claiming that the bananas have disappeared. They haven't it's still there. So is the Zinc, so is the Iron etc.
How are you determining quantity using EDX spectra? Do you know the difference between quantitative and qualitive?
I've already told you why Millette ruled out Tnemec for his chips that matched samples a-d, but you fail to understand even when a simple analogy is used.
Millette was tasked with looking at spectra that matched samples a-d. He didn't perform any additional experimentation on samples that didn;t match that criteria. Since Tnemec red EDX spectra is outside of this criteria then how on earth could he conclude that his additionally analysed chips could be Tnemec?
Again - if you are asked to pick only apples (EDX of samples a-d) from a fruit bowl then you can safely say they are not bananas (Tnemec Red paint). However, if Millette was to pick bananas out then he would find bananas wouldn't he? It's a simple analogy.
No Millette does not rule out Tnemec completely. Millette rukes out Tnemec ONLY for samples that match the EDX for samples in Harrit et al.
Are you doing this on purpose? Are you willfully getting this stuff wrong even when explained to you? Why are you coming here asking questions when you flatly refuse the answers given? You reek of truther. I'll not bother with you if you keep up these shenanigans.
I don't cherry pick anything - accuse me again and you'll go onto ignore - I've explained in detail why the MEK chip cannot have any significant contamiation and how that chip and some of Millette's chips that are not equivalent to chips a-d are excellent matches for Tnemec red primer paint.
Why would I point you in the direction of truther points? The Harrit et al paper is a crock of *****, totally worthless, not peer-reviewed and published in a pay to publish vanity journal who's editor resigned because of it. Truthers know nothing about the topic and that includes Harrit, Jones, Farrer, Basile etc. If they did know how to conduct a materials characterisation exercise then they wouldn't have produced such crap.
How do you publish a rebuttal to a paper that was never published in a peer-reviewed journal of decent reputation.
Why don't you publish why the earth goes round the sun or why the earth isn't flat in say Nature? I'm sure they would jump at such revelations. No one in the wider scientific community knows about the crappy Harrit et al "paper". It doesn't exist as far as academia is concerned.