This is hogwash and you know it. I did not criticize him for using data, it was because he cherry picked the only dirty chip in the paper to compare to some other clean millette chip and known paint. He says they are similar or the same but that is no longer true when the dirty chip has been washed.
Nope, no cherry picking occurred at all. The aim of the post you are referring to was to show how the paper and truthers are incorrect when they postulate that the MEK was contaminated. I've since posted and clarified exactly, the thought process and logic that leads me to that conclusion.
You are using a strawman. That is something that we often see from truthers when arguing a point.
Don´t pretend to know any better than i do. They show all 3 main regions in 16 to 18, including one for the matrix material so you have a poor excuse. Besides, you do not seem to agree with Sunstealer who said the signals are still there, so maybe you think he is lying or maybe you know better?
Yes you do pretend to know better because you are claiming that there is a problem with Figs 16, 17 and 18 whose spectra don't show certain elements observed in the pre MEK soaked spectra. Read the words written underneath those graphics which explain exactly what was analysed.
I note that you haven't addressed my statements in reply to you queries regarding this. (ignore if already done so) Oystein is correct, he has a high level of reading comprehension and has spent significant time learning about the scanning electron microscope and energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy in order to understand what he's looking at. I doubt Oystein has ever seen a SEM in the flesh let alone operated one, however, he has educated himself to a level that is sufficient to understand the capabilities and limitation of the equipment.
It's best if you familiarise yourself with the equipment and it's capabilities before you start commentating upon data from said equipment. There is no shame in this - SEM specialised equipment in the scheme of things.
I do not say, "the signals are there". Again you are misunderstanding what I wrote and then making a strawman out of it.
I clearly say that the labelling of the peak in fig 18 at 1 KeV is incorrect. I've explained to you that this peak should be labelled Zn due to the overlap in k-alpha and k-beta lines between these two elements.
You have ignored this response. Twice.
Similarly Fig 18 shows significant peaks for elements P (Phosphorous) and Cl (Chlorine) that are not present in fig 14 pre-MEK soaking. Why are you not focussing on that? Why are you focussing on one element even when that has been explained to you?
Again this is a classic example of what truthers do. They focus on one item that has been explained, refuse the explanation, but completely ignore anomalies that are equivalent using your logic. If you are going to pontificate on lack of element peaks in the EDX spectrum then at least be consistent.
They seem to have all used 10 keV. Only fig 18 used 15kev and fig 11 used 20kev, and considering figs 16 to 18 are about figuring out which elements are separate it is not hard to figure out why they did not use 20 keV, it makes them blend together:
I have no idea what you are talking about. Could you please explain in detail regarding your explanation for differing KeV energies and how this "blends them together". Thanks.
Maybe you are not the expert you think you are?
I see that you are using the standard truther tactic of totally ignoring what the poster wrote and instead attacking the posters credentials.
This automatically red-flags you as someone who is way, way, way out of their depth. Instead you should be trying to understand what Oystein wrote and why it is of significance.
Perhaps you may care to educate us all on how acceleration voltage influences the interaction volume and how that is dependent upon different elements.
What are you basing that on, did fig 14 need 20kev to find Zn?
Harrit et al is specific with regard to the parameters used in their analysis.
An FEI XL30-SFEG scanning electron microscope (SEM) was used to perform secondary-electron (SE) imaging and backscattered electron (BSE) imaging. The SE imaging was used to look at the surface topography and porosity of the red/gray chips, while the BSE imaging was used to distinguish variations in average atomic number, Z. The microscope was also equipped with an EDAX X-ray energy dispersive spectrometry (XEDS) system. The XEDS system uses a silicon detector (SiLi) with resolution better than 135eV. The spectrum resolution was set to 10 eV per channel. Operating conditions for the acquired XEDS spectra were 20 keV beam energy (unless otherwise specified) and 40-120 second acquisition time (livetime). XEDS maps were acquired using the same system at a beam energy of 10 keV.
Page 9, second paragraph under - 2. Chip Size, Isolation, and Examination.
So there you have it. Unless specified the beam energy was 20KeV. There is no specification for fig 14. If you focus the spot beam on a particular point, with a set eV, then the characteristics of the interaction volume will change. That's the point. I suggest you familiarise yourself with the SEM before commenting further.
What about Millette? Read the progress report -it tells you the information I think you want regarding eV. N.B. It's a progress report and not a paper btw.
What about jones and his tnemec sample?
Why don't you ask him? (Considering the statement on the operating parameters in Harrit et al there's the likelihood that 20KeV was used)
Who is panicking? Why dont you just answer the question? Why the drama?
No one is panicking at all. We have answered all of your questions, you just seem to ignore the answers.
We have encountered many people "just asking questions" and they nearly always turn out to be truthers, because they ask questions, but never acknowledge the answers, often mis-understand the answers and seek to engage people on minutiae.
That's why you are getting short-thrift.
If you are genuine then I'd advise you to ask questions in depth and acknowledge the answers given, indicating whether you understand them or not.