WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

I don´t know why you guys make this look so complicated. Africanus was misunderstanding my reply to Sunstealer. I know millette has clean chips to compare to clean harrit chips, but it was sunstealer who picked the only harrit chip that was not clean and tried to compare it to some clean millette chip and this tnemec paint. This does not look good and it seems invalid since it is based on the assumption that the dirty chip is not dirty.
Why do you criticize Sunstealer for using data from Harrit e.al.? Why don't you criticize Harrit e.al. and demand that the MEK-chip not be considered at all, as it has not been shown to be of the same material as any other chips used in the paper to reach their conclusions?
We don't know if there are any "nano-sized" grains in there
We don't know if any chip similar to the MEK-chip was at all tested in the DSC
Etc.
Amateurish, bad, useless work.

You say it "matches" but as i pointed out to Sunstealer the match may not be that good considering small Zn peak. The real point is that most of this Zn disappears after MEK washing according to figures 16 to 18 in Harrit, so there is no longer a match after the dirty chip has been cleaned. The dirty chip is dirty for sure and does not seem to match Tnemec once clean.
You obviously don't understand the XEDS technique.

For Fig 14, Jones scanned a large portion of the surface, thus capturing a more representative distribution of its constituents. For Fig. 16-18, the beam was deliberately focussed on small spots rich in certain elements that Jones was interested in. These spectra do not prove at all that there are no zinc chromate pigments in that paint, he may simply have chosen to focus away from these pigments. He should have done another broad-area scan after the soak. Also, Fig. 17 was done with a 10 keV beam energy instead of 20 keV - no explanation is given. It might mask the heavier elements, such as zinc or chrome.

Why is this such a big deal, can it not be laclede or some other paint? Are there any other options besides paint, such as insulation for fire proofing or maybe electrical cables, wiring?
Why do you have this almost panicky need to deny Tnemec??
 
Kminek: And, even when (hypothetically) there was some thermitic reaction, its exotherm must be "hidden" in the exotherm of polymer burning. You do not agree?

We can easily agree that real experiments would be better than indirect data from the literature, so let us wait for possible further experiments of Jim Millette...

You are the only one here that seems interested in real discussion. I don´t know why the thermite exotherm would be hidden if it is possible to mix organic stuff with thermite. You show some peaks that look similar to harrit data but my point is we need this data for paint similar to the wtc stuff, on a graph with the same X and Y. So I think we agree that a real experiment would be the way to debunk harrit data. I don´t know why everyone else here is so touchy about this.

Millette did not write that, I suppose that also his dried chips were again hard/brittle (e.g. like MEK chip). But Millette can be asked in this respect. Note, that Harrit et al did not write if the MEK chip was softened when swollen, but it is something which can be supposed from

Supposing won´t do for scientific papers. The way Harrit paper is set up it looks like his chips remain hard soaked while paint softens. The way Millette paper is set up it looks like his chips soften. This sort of stuff along with titanium in millette chips leave the paper wide open for the truther defense of different chips. Millette should prevent this.

You have just inspired me to perform one extremely simple experiment. About 3 hours ago, I put several chips of this epoxy sample into MEK solvent and... let's wait ca 50 hours what will happen with it.

Thank you, i hope this inspiration will make it all the way to millette. If you can do more tests you should, including getting the spectra and dsc tests. You seem to know your way with paints so maybe you could make some replication paint for millette, maybe even imitate the redgray chips by painting a batch of ground down metal flakes. Send some to millette and some to harrit. More tests is the way to go, I don´t know why your buddies here are so touchy about it.

Since you've been already successful to offend almost all participants in this debate

Yes they seem offended but i cant see why. They call me stupid or a truther for asking questions, but this is silly. Criticizing millette is not the same as being against him, it helps to make his paper better. The really silly part is that no one seems to be offended by obvious trolling by some members here, and some really stupid and offensive remarks.
 
Millette found no thermite. There is no evidence of thermite used on 911. There are zero piles of thermite product, big ugly piles of iron. There is no thermite iron fused to WTC steel, like in the idiotic videos produced by nuts like Cole. Where did the pounds, or in Harrit's case TONS of thermite product, called iron, go? The idiots in 911 truth, which you call
My truther nutcase of a cousin tells me
, and twoofies ignore the fact no thermite was used, and go with the fantasy of thermite. They can't produce evidence.

You'd think that with "hundreds of tons" of thermite being ignited high in a skyscraper, it would have produced at least 50 tons of molten iron, resulting in globules resembling iron-nickel meteorites (photo) being everywhere, not to mention huge piles of debris welded together, which would have to be secretly cut up and smuggled off-site under cover of darkness and armed guards threatening anyone trying to take a look. Really hard to do when the site was visible from surviving hi-rises like One Liberty Plaza and the Millenium Hilton.
 

Attachments

  • Iron-Nickel Meteorites.jpg
    Iron-Nickel Meteorites.jpg
    60.4 KB · Views: 0
@jtl

Please could you clarify what you think Millette's role is.

Please explain what his objective was from the start.

Thanks
 
This is an old argument that I used on some truthers long ago, but I no longer try it because it seems debunked. The 3.9 yield is for straight old school thermite but it does not apply to new mixtures with added materials that may increase the yield, and Harrit does mention the organic part. But maybe it is possible to show that 7.5 is too much?

No, laddie, the yield for ferric oxide thermite is fixed by the immutable Laws of Thermodynamics, and there is nothing that anyone can do to raise it. There are other thermites, such as molybdenum trioxide thermite, with higher yields, but then we should have been hearing about "molybdenum-rich spheres" being found, along with its co-product, aluminum oxide (alumina), which we haven't heard reported from any truther dust study. Alumina, being only about half the density of iron, will be produced in about twice the amount, by volume, than iron.
 
Oystein: Why do you criticize Sunstealer for using data from Harrit e.al.

This is hogwash and you know it. I did not criticize him for using data, it was because he cherry picked the only dirty chip in the paper to compare to some other clean millette chip and known paint. He says they are similar or the same but that is no longer true when the dirty chip has been washed.

You obviously don't understand the XEDS technique.

For Fig 14, Jones scanned a large portion of the surface, thus capturing a more representative distribution of its constituents. For Fig. 16-18, the beam was deliberately focussed on small spots rich in certain elements that Jones was interested in. These spectra do not prove at all that there are no zinc chromate pigments in that paint, he may simply have chosen to focus away from these pigments.

Don´t pretend to know any better than i do. They show all 3 main regions in 16 to 18, including one for the matrix material so you have a poor excuse. Besides, you do not seem to agree with Sunstealer who said the signals are still there, so maybe you think he is lying or maybe you know better?

Also, Fig. 17 was done with a 10 keV beam energy instead of 20 keV - no explanation is given.

They seem to have all used 10 keV. Only fig 18 used 15kev and fig 11 used 20kev, and considering figs 16 to 18 are about figuring out which elements are separate it is not hard to figure out why they did not use 20 keV, it makes them blend together:

The beam energy (20 keV) is such
that the volume of material from which the X-ray signal is
generated is larger than the particles. Hence, some Al and Si
are seen in Fig. (11b) which may not be inherent in the fac-
eted grains, and some Fe is seen in Fig. (11a), which may
not be inherent in the plate-like particles.

Maybe you are not the expert you think you are?

It might mask the heavier elements, such as zinc or chrome.

What are you basing that on, did fig 14 need 20kev to find Zn? How about millette? What about jones and his tnemec sample?

Originally Posted by jtl: Why is this such a big deal, can it not be laclede or some other paint? Are there any other options besides paint, such as insulation for fire proofing or maybe electrical cables, wiring?
Oystein: Why do you have this almost panicky need to deny Tnemec??

Who is panicking? Why dont you just answer the question? Why the drama?
 
Redwood: No, laddie, the yield for ferric oxide thermite is fixed by the immutable Laws of Thermodynamics, and there is nothing that anyone can do to raise it.

You mean nothing besides adding extra chemicals to it like the organic matrix. This can also make nonexplosive thermite explosive.

pgimeno: two of them still show an average energy density (including the gray layer) greater than that of thermite, proving it is not thermite alone.

Good. No one is saying it is thermite alone. Harrit claims it a mixture of nanothermite in a organic matrix.

pgimeno: Even if the chips were thermite + organic matrix, comparing the traces would still make no sense, because they show different materials in action with different thermal properties. Understood now?

You contradict yourself. You began your arguments about the dsc curves by saying that harrit curves could not be superthermite because it has different properties. But now you seem to have realized that different compositions are expected to have different properties, so congrats. Comparing paint to the different superthermite traces is necessary to show that it can be as narrow. Understood now?

I can understand that you call "weak points" the fact that he didn't do an unnecessary DSC test, but what mistakes are you talking about?

Have gone over this several times. it can be disputed that millette has the same chips because they appear different in some respects and he is vague on some details and lacks some tests. it can be said that paint chips wont match harrit ignition tests until millette proves otherwise. i am not going over this for you again
 
Last edited:
This is hogwash and you know it. I did not criticize him for using data, it was because he cherry picked the only dirty chip in the paper to compare to some other clean millette chip and known paint. He says they are similar or the same but that is no longer true when the dirty chip has been washed.
It is not Sunstealer who does the cherry-picking at all!! It is Harrit and Jones who cherry-pick data!
How on earth do YOU know that the data from the unwashed chip can't be used?
Sunstealer is exactly right: The XEDS spectrum for the MEK-soaked chip is so damned similar to Tnemec, and also to some of Millette's chips, that the bare-assed assertion made by Jones, that Zn in that chip must be contamination, is just that: A bare-assed asertion, a hand-wave.

I think it is possible that the strong Ca-signal comes, in part, from gypsum, as does the S signal. All the rest of the signal is exactly what you'd expect for Tnemec.


Don´t pretend to know any better than i do.
I don't pretend - I do in fact know better than you. Your ignorance about every aspect of the Harrit and Millette papers, and the methods used thereim, screams out of every paragraph you write. You are really very very far from even a basic understanding.

They show all 3 main regions in 16 to 18, including one for the matrix material so you have a poor excuse. Besides, you do not seem to agree with Sunstealer who said the signals are still there, so maybe you think he is lying or maybe you know better?
This doesn't even make sense - your wording betrays your lack of understanding.
What "3 main regions" are you talking about??

They seem to have all used 10 keV. Only fig 18 used 15kev and fig 11 used 20kev,
This is plain wrong.

and considering figs 16 to 18 are about figuring out which elements are separate it is not hard to figure out why they did not use 20 keV, it makes them blend together:
This is plain wrong.

Maybe you are not the expert you think you are?
I am 100 times the expert you are. You just proved it with the total analytical desaster that your previous short paragraph was.

What are you basing that on, did fig 14 need 20kev to find Zn? How about millette? What about jones and his tnemec sample?
You obviously don't understand XEDS.

Who is panicking? Why dont you just answer the question? Why the drama?
Sunstealer says that the MEK-chip is Tnemec because its XEDS spectrum matches that of Tnemec in so much detail, and the macro-description (layer thickness, color) such a good match, it would be utter folly to deny it it, in fact, most likely Tnemec.

The same way, the XEDS spectra and visual appearance of chips a-d are such a perfect match for LaClede, it would be utter folly to deny they are most likely LaClede paint.

And the XEDS spectra for chips a-d are so very different from Tnemec, and the XEDS spectrum for the MEK chip so very different from LaClede, that they just can't be that.

Oh, and all these spectra show so little Aluminium, and so much hydrocarbon matrix, that this alone rules out thermite.

The DSC-results rule out thermite, too, by the way.
 
This is hogwash and you know it. I did not criticize him for using data, it was because he cherry picked the only dirty chip in the paper to compare to some other clean millette chip and known paint. He says they are similar or the same but that is no longer true when the dirty chip has been washed.
Nope, no cherry picking occurred at all. The aim of the post you are referring to was to show how the paper and truthers are incorrect when they postulate that the MEK was contaminated. I've since posted and clarified exactly, the thought process and logic that leads me to that conclusion.

You are using a strawman. That is something that we often see from truthers when arguing a point.


Don´t pretend to know any better than i do. They show all 3 main regions in 16 to 18, including one for the matrix material so you have a poor excuse. Besides, you do not seem to agree with Sunstealer who said the signals are still there, so maybe you think he is lying or maybe you know better?
Yes you do pretend to know better because you are claiming that there is a problem with Figs 16, 17 and 18 whose spectra don't show certain elements observed in the pre MEK soaked spectra. Read the words written underneath those graphics which explain exactly what was analysed.

I note that you haven't addressed my statements in reply to you queries regarding this. (ignore if already done so) Oystein is correct, he has a high level of reading comprehension and has spent significant time learning about the scanning electron microscope and energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy in order to understand what he's looking at. I doubt Oystein has ever seen a SEM in the flesh let alone operated one, however, he has educated himself to a level that is sufficient to understand the capabilities and limitation of the equipment.

It's best if you familiarise yourself with the equipment and it's capabilities before you start commentating upon data from said equipment. There is no shame in this - SEM specialised equipment in the scheme of things.

I do not say, "the signals are there". Again you are misunderstanding what I wrote and then making a strawman out of it.

I clearly say that the labelling of the peak in fig 18 at 1 KeV is incorrect. I've explained to you that this peak should be labelled Zn due to the overlap in k-alpha and k-beta lines between these two elements.

You have ignored this response. Twice.

Similarly Fig 18 shows significant peaks for elements P (Phosphorous) and Cl (Chlorine) that are not present in fig 14 pre-MEK soaking. Why are you not focussing on that? Why are you focussing on one element even when that has been explained to you?

Again this is a classic example of what truthers do. They focus on one item that has been explained, refuse the explanation, but completely ignore anomalies that are equivalent using your logic. If you are going to pontificate on lack of element peaks in the EDX spectrum then at least be consistent.


They seem to have all used 10 keV. Only fig 18 used 15kev and fig 11 used 20kev, and considering figs 16 to 18 are about figuring out which elements are separate it is not hard to figure out why they did not use 20 keV, it makes them blend together:
:confused:

I have no idea what you are talking about. Could you please explain in detail regarding your explanation for differing KeV energies and how this "blends them together". Thanks.



Maybe you are not the expert you think you are?
I see that you are using the standard truther tactic of totally ignoring what the poster wrote and instead attacking the posters credentials.

This automatically red-flags you as someone who is way, way, way out of their depth. Instead you should be trying to understand what Oystein wrote and why it is of significance.

Perhaps you may care to educate us all on how acceleration voltage influences the interaction volume and how that is dependent upon different elements.


What are you basing that on, did fig 14 need 20kev to find Zn?
Harrit et al is specific with regard to the parameters used in their analysis.

An FEI XL30-SFEG scanning electron microscope (SEM) was used to perform secondary-electron (SE) imaging and backscattered electron (BSE) imaging. The SE imaging was used to look at the surface topography and porosity of the red/gray chips, while the BSE imaging was used to distinguish variations in average atomic number, Z. The microscope was also equipped with an EDAX X-ray energy dispersive spectrometry (XEDS) system. The XEDS system uses a silicon detector (SiLi) with resolution better than 135eV. The spectrum resolution was set to 10 eV per channel. Operating conditions for the acquired XEDS spectra were 20 keV beam energy (unless otherwise specified) and 40-120 second acquisition time (livetime). XEDS maps were acquired using the same system at a beam energy of 10 keV.
Page 9, second paragraph under - 2. Chip Size, Isolation, and Examination.

So there you have it. Unless specified the beam energy was 20KeV. There is no specification for fig 14. If you focus the spot beam on a particular point, with a set eV, then the characteristics of the interaction volume will change. That's the point. I suggest you familiarise yourself with the SEM before commenting further.


How about millette?
What about Millette? Read the progress report -it tells you the information I think you want regarding eV. N.B. It's a progress report and not a paper btw.

What about jones and his tnemec sample?
Why don't you ask him? (Considering the statement on the operating parameters in Harrit et al there's the likelihood that 20KeV was used)

Who is panicking? Why dont you just answer the question? Why the drama?
No one is panicking at all. We have answered all of your questions, you just seem to ignore the answers.

We have encountered many people "just asking questions" and they nearly always turn out to be truthers, because they ask questions, but never acknowledge the answers, often mis-understand the answers and seek to engage people on minutiae.

That's why you are getting short-thrift.

If you are genuine then I'd advise you to ask questions in depth and acknowledge the answers given, indicating whether you understand them or not.
 
You mean nothing besides adding extra chemicals to it like the organic matrix. This can also make nonexplosive thermite explosive.
...
You don't understand the argument. You don't understand DSC. You don't understand enthalpy of reaction.

Harrit e.al.'s data, taken all together, proves that at least almost all of the energy came from burning the organic matrix. >95% actually, with 100% being a distinct and highly likely value.
The data contains no proof whatsoever that any thermite reaction at all tool place.



This argument "you can make thermite more energetic by mixing it with organics" is much like saying "beer can be healthier and have more vitamin C if you mix it with orange juice" - it's never the beer that's vC-rich, it's always the orange juice! And this case, you'd be mixing 95% orange juice with 5% beer - and calling it "beer". That borders on fraudulent.
 
Have gone over this several times. it can be disputed that millette has the same chips because they appear different in some respects and he is vague on some details and lacks some tests. it can be said that paint chips wont match harrit ignition tests until millette proves otherwise. i am not going over this for you gain
OK lets try this.

Here is Fig 7 in the Harrit et al paper.

picture.php


Do you agree that these EDX spectra; a, b, c and d, show that the red layer is the same material? i.e. a=b=c=d.

Answer Yes or No.
 
Sunstealer: Since Millette's chips contain no contamination and at least 6 of his chips match the MEK chip before soaking we can safely say that the MEK chip was not contaminated otherwise the spectra wouldn't match.

You are deluding yourself if you actually believe this. It is almost 100% for sure that all chips were contaminated before cleaning after storage in bags full of fine dust, and the MEK chip was no different. It is simply irrational to think that because some clean millette chips are a match for a dirty chip, that means the dirty chip is not dirty.

On the subject of the "missing Zn peak" - I've already told you that the Na peak is labelled incorrectly and should be Zn in fig 18. This was written in the spoiler section - click on it to read the explanation.


If you are worried about a missing Zn peak in the other figs post MEK then there is absolutely no help for you because you don't understand the writing below figs 16 & 17. Guess what they don't find any Fe in fig 16 and 17 so why aren't you bleating about that?

I already read your explanation and answered Oystein about the writing below the figures. But you ignore the answers. There is a trace of fe in both 16 and 17. there is some overlap in all 3 figures. Fig 15 shows it is really difficult to pick some one area free of specific chemicals. And what happened to all the other stuff from fig 14, the Zn, the S, the Ca, Cr, S?
All hiding in some magical unspecified area? How convenient.
Why did fig 14 never have a Zn peak that matches the known Tnemec sample? Why did it go from a tiny peak to almost disappearing after washing, just like a lot of other stuff from fig14?

You are sounding more and more like a truther every day. i.e. someone who knows nothing about the subject but trying to argue with those that do. Remember you already told everyone you are not an expert.

You are sounding more and more like a preacher, and someone without the credentials you claim for your authoritarian style. If you are such an expert and so sure of everything you say, why dont you put your money where your mouth is and publish your results? Why did you not do it years ago when you claimed to have debunked Harrit? i think it is obvious that a published paper would have done a lot more good to debunk harrit than than some cheap talk amongst people behind fake names. But you can´t can you?
 
Originally Posted by jtl
You mean nothing besides adding extra chemicals to it like the organic matrix. This can also make nonexplosive thermite explosive.
Oystein: You don't understand the argument. You don't understand DSC. You don't understand enthalpy of reaction.

No you dont understand. Lets get this straight. The above has nothing to do with the argument about harrit chips and if they are superthermite.

It is about the fact that superthermite exists and it can be a mixture of nanothermite and other stuff like the organic matrix and that this fact means a superthermite can have different output and properties than normal thermite. This means superthermite can exceed 3.9, and most likely very easily with organic component in air, and this also means superthermite can be explosive.

All those who understand this say so. If no one does then you can all go back to reading Ron Mossad and I will stop wasting my time.
 
You are deluding yourself if you actually believe this. It is almost 100% for sure that all chips were contaminated before cleaning after storage in bags full of fine dust, and the MEK chip was no different. It is simply irrational to think that because some clean millette chips are a match for a dirty chip, that means the dirty chip is not dirty.
If a dirty child looks just like your son, would you reject that child as your son just because he's dirty?

If the chip was so dirty that it couldn't be identified, then we couldn't identify it.

But we CAN identify it. Which means: The dirt is insignificant.

You are handwaving.

I already read your explanation and answered Oystein about the writing below the figures. But you ignore the answers.
Your answers were plain wrong.

There is a trace of fe in both 16 and 17. there is some overlap in all 3 figures.
Meaningless utterings. You obviously don't understand XEDS.

Fig 15 shows it is really difficult to pick some one area free of specific chemicals. And what happened to all the other stuff from fig 14, the Zn, the S, the Ca, Cr, S?
All hiding in some magical unspecified area? How convenient.
Why did fig 14 never have a Zn peak that matches the known Tnemec sample?
What??? Are you saying that Zn is missing in Fig 15?? And you think this means there is not Zn???

Why did fig 14 never have a Zn peak that matches the known Tnemec sample?
It DOES have a Zn peak that matchhes that of Tnemec. That is one of the main reasons we are confident it's Tnemec.

Why did it go from a tiny peak to almost disappearing after washing, just like a lot of other stuff from fig14?
This has been explained to you several times, by at least 3 posters.
Because Jones specically and deliberately focused on small spots rich in other pigments.

You could just as well ask: "Why did Al go from a tiny peak in Fig 14 to almost disappearing after washing in Fig 16?"

And the answer would be the same: Because that beam was focused on a particular other pigment, in that case silica (which is a filler, not pigment)

You are sounding more and more like a preacher, and someone without the credentials you claim for your authoritarian style. If you are such an expert and so sure of everything you say, why dont you put your money where your mouth is and publish your results? Why did you not do it years ago when you claimed to have debunked Harrit? i think it is obvious that a published paper would have done a lot more good to debunk harrit than than some cheap talk amongst people behind fake names. But you can´t can you?
Typical truther tactic. You don't understand the content, the argument, so you attack the form. Piss poor pathetic.
 
No you dont understand. Lets get this straight. The above has nothing to do with the argument about harrit chips and if they are superthermite.


It is about the fact that superthermite exists and it can be a mixture of nanothermite and other stuff like the organic matrix and that this fact means a superthermite can have different output and properties than normal thermite.
But the first question is: Is this thermite at all?
Amswer: There is zero evidence it is.

Consider this:

"Raspberry jelly is red and has a higher energy output and properties than normal thermite. Raspberry jelly exists. Therefore these chips could be Raspberry jelly."

Sounds spectacularly stupid? Well, that is exactly like your argument sounds.

This means superthermite can exceed 3.9, and most likely very easily with organic component in air, and this also means superthermite can be explosive.
"Organic component in air" most assuredly means that it cannot be explosive. But you wouldn't know, as you don't understand a single thing here.

All those who understand this say so.
Nonsense. You have been fooled by con men because you are ignorant and gullible.
 
You are sounding more and more like a preacher, and someone without the credentials you claim for your authoritarian style. If you are such an expert and so sure of everything you say, why dont you put your money where your mouth is and publish your results? Why did you not do it years ago when you claimed to have debunked Harrit? i think it is obvious that a published paper would have done a lot more good to debunk harrit than than some cheap talk amongst people behind fake names. But you can´t can you?

The harrit et al paper is self debunking, that appears to be what you're missing here. The paper proves that the chips they have are paint.

They didn't post their paper in a peer review journal so it has no scientific merit. What would the point in writing a peer reviewed paper just to debunk a self-debunking paper be? It's a waste of time.
 
Oystein: It is not Sunstealer who does the cherry-picking at all!! It is Harrit and Jones who cherry-pick data!
How on earth do YOU know that the data from the unwashed chip can't be used?
Sunstealer is exactly right: The XEDS spectrum for the MEK-soaked chip is so damned similar to Tnemec, and also to some of Millette's chips, that the bare-assed assertion made by Jones, that Zn in that chip must be contamination, is just that: A bare-assed asertion, a hand-wave.

I think it is possible that the strong Ca-signal comes, in part, from gypsum, as does the S signal. All the rest of the signal is exactly what you'd expect for Tnemec.

Jesus, you actually dont understand this? You are so deluded that you say that there is no cherry picking but at the same time you cherry pick Cs and S signals as contamination while you claim the Zn is not contamination. This is cherry picking 101 buddy.

If a dirty child looks just like your son, would you reject that child as your son just because he's dirty?

If the chip was so dirty that it couldn't be identified, then we couldn't identify it.

But we CAN identify it. Which means: The dirt is insignificant.

Your answers and beginning to look not only deluded but downright nuts.
But at least you acknowledge there is contamination, unlike sunstealer.

It DOES have a Zn peak that matchhes that of Tnemec. That is one of the main reasons we are confident it's Tnemec.

Even if we allow for your cherry picking of Zn as not contamination, you still have to have a certain amount of Zn to match Tnemec. I noted that even before washing, the Zn peak is no match for the peak in the example given by jones.

Originally Posted by jtl View Post
It is about the fact that superthermite exists and it can be a mixture of nanothermite and other stuff like the organic matrix and that this fact means a superthermite can have different output and properties than normal thermite.
This means superthermite can exceed 3.9, and most likely very easily with organic component in air, and this also means superthermite can be explosive.
Oystein: But the first question is: Is this thermite at all?
Amswer: There is zero evidence it is.

Listen Oystein, acknowledge the above or stick to Ron Mossad. None of you should engage in any debate about superthermite if you cant tell the difference between std thermite and superthermite.

Nonsense. You have been fooled by con men because you are ignorant and gullible.

This attitude looks even worse on you than Sunstealer. You both sound like fanatical "no planes" truthers ranting about holograms. Snap out of it.
 
Last edited:
... Your answers and beginning to look not only deluded but downright nuts.
But at least you acknowledge there is contamination, unlike sunstealer.
...
Listen Oystein, acknowledge the above or stick to Ron Mossad.
You don't understand DSC, or thermite.
Do you understand no thermite was used on 911 to destroy the WTC complex? This is a simple yes or no. You don't seem to know much about chemistry and offer no insights. Do you understand no thermite was used on 911? Yes or No. easy question, easy answer.
I have given you the answers, pick one; please.
 
No you dont understand. Lets get this straight. The above has nothing to do with the argument about harrit chips and if they are superthermite.

It is about the fact that superthermite exists and it can be a mixture of nanothermite and other stuff like the organic matrix and that this fact means a superthermite can have different output and properties than normal thermite. This means superthermite can exceed 3.9, and most likely very easily with organic component in air, and this also means superthermite can be explosive.

All those who understand this say so. If no one does then you can all go back to reading Ron Mossad and I will stop wasting my time.

If you are trying to prove that any kind of thermite was used, whether super-duper or not, then you are wasting your time.
 
Jesus, you actually dont understand this? You are so deluded that you say that there is no cherry picking but at the same time you cherry pick Cs and S signals as contamination while you claim the Zn is not contamination. This is cherry picking 101 buddy.
It's your son's face behind a thin coating of gypsum.
You'd deny your own son.

No, laddy. Not cherry picking.

Your answers and beginning to look not only deluded but downright nuts.
But at least you acknowledge there is contamination, unlike sunstealer.
I am more likely to be wrong about gypsum than about Tnemec.

Even if we allow for your cherry picking of Zn as not contamination, you still have to have a certain amount of Zn to match Tnemec. I noted that even before washing, the Zn peak is no match for the peak in the example given by jones.
Can you give reasons for that assessment?

Listen Oystein, acknowledge the above or stick to Ron Mossad. None of you should engage in any debate about superthermite if you cant tell the difference between std thermite and superthermite.
Strawman.
You still don't understand the argument.
Raspberry jelly. Think about it!

There is no evidence for the presence of thermite at all.
There is no evidence the thermite reaction occurred at all.
From this follows that there is no evidence for superthermite, or as much as there is evidence for raspberry jelly.

However, there is clear evidence that the organic matrix burned. Very. Slowly.

This attitude looks even worse on you than Sunstealer. You both sound like fanatical "no planes" truthers ranting about holograms. Snap out of it.
You deserve it.
You must know that you are miles out of your depth here.
Only the really stupid wouldn't even know when they are this far out of their depth.


But let's see if you understand a little bit about XEDS:

Here is Fig 7 in the Harrit et al paper.

picture.php


Do you agree that these EDX spectra; a, b, c and d, show that the red layer is the same material? i.e. a=b=c=d.

Answer Yes or No.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom