Jtl:
You probably overlooked that I
(well, my colleague in the institute) already investigated the thermal behavior of my Laclede imitation chips using TGA (thermogravimetric analysis) more than year ago.
Here is a corresponding TGA curve under nitrogen:
And here is a TGA curve under air:
Although I already commented these experiments in the past, I have perhaps something new to add now, because of my recent findings as for microscale combustion calorimetry (MCC) results available for epoxy and other polymers in the literature.
Bear in mind that these TGA are very typical for epoxy resin thermal behavior
(I know it very well from the comparison with many available papers). And the explanation below is not mine, it is an excerpt from the literature.
Under nitrogen: Apparently, epoxy is massively degraded/pyrolyzed/vaporized around 400 degrees
even under inert. Above ca 600 degrees C, basically only incombustible pigments remain. Remember that there is ca 30 wt% of pigments in the imitation.
Under air: The behavior of epoxy is more complex here and has basically two stages. In the first stage, epoxy is again massively degraded/pyrolyzed, but we can see that some of the organic stuff remains at ca 460 to 600 degrees. This stuff has been analyzed many times and it usually described to have polyaromatic/graphitic nature
(well, it's just simply black soot). At temperatures above ca 500-550 degrees C, this black/dark stuff is further oxidized and basically disappears above ca 600 degrees C. Only inorganic pigments
(nanoclay and iron oxide in my case) remain in the sample.
I did not arrange any DSC measurements of this imitation that time, since although we have several those machines in the institute, none of them is suitable for the measurements up to such high temperatures (700 degrees) under air. We are anyway polymer institute, not inorganic one.
Bear in mind, that DSC is seldom used for examination of polymer thermal or thermal/oxidative degradation for reasons I have repeated here several times.
But, I can at least compare/correlate my TGA curves with MCC curves for epoxy resins from the literature. These are again pretty typical MCC curves:
You see? Those curves (TGA and MCC) correlate quite nicely and they basically tell us:
- In MCC apparatus, the epoxy resin is first pyrolyzed/degraded under inert, so it has to be degraded/vaporized similarly to my TGA curve under inert. But vaporized combustible stuffs are then quickly transported into oven with air and they are completely burned/combusted, resulting in MCC curve.
A comparison of the results I've just presented with DSC curves in Bentham paper says:
All these curves are fully compatible with the combustion of epoxy resin (or some other polymer binders) in some paint
There is a zero evidence coming from Bentham DSC curves that they have anything common with the thermitic reaction.