WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

This has been explained to you several times, by at least 3 posters.
Because Jones specically and deliberately focused on small spots rich in other pigments.
I was wondering, isn't an alternative explanation for the smaller peak that the energy of the specific spectrum in fig. 18 is 15 KeV instead of 20?
 
Good. No one is saying it is thermite alone. Harrit claims it a mixture of nanothermite in a organic matrix.
Harrit can claim whatever he wants. There is no proof of that whatsoever in the paper.

I said it is not "thermite alone" because it follows logically from the comparison with "thermite alone". I didn't mean to imply it was "thermite" but not "alone".


You contradict yourself. You began your arguments about the dsc curves by saying that harrit curves could not be superthermite because it has different properties. But now you seem to have realized that different compositions are expected to have different properties, so congrats.
I do not contradict myself. Once established that the energy density proves the compared materials are different, it makes no sense to compare the shapes or the heights or the widths of the peaks and claim that because they are similar, that is indicative of anything, which is what you attempted. If you've moved your goalposts since then, please let me know.

DSC was a stupid test to perform to start with. The results are just as inconclusive as expected. They merely do show one thing the chips are NOT. And that is thermite alone.


Comparing paint to the different superthermite traces is necessary to show that it can be as narrow. Understood now?
No. I don't understand where you get that from, unless you mean that Jones et al. should do it, as it's their burden of proof. They haven't established that the chips are not paint, let alone that it is thermite. Ask them to perform proper experiments that do prove their conclusions, not silly, amateurish and misguided experiments that prove nothing. And to publish the data they are hiding.


Have gone over this several times. it can be disputed that millette has the same chips because they appear different in some respects and he is vague on some details and lacks some tests. it can be said that paint chips wont match harrit ignition tests until millette proves otherwise. i am not going over this for you again
So there's no actual mistake in Millette's work. Just what I thought.




Fig 15 shows it is really difficult to pick some one area free of specific chemicals
Wrong.

MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Al+Si+O+Fe+C.jpg




This attitude looks even worse on you than Sunstealer. You both sound like fanatical "no planes" truthers ranting about holograms. Snap out of it.
Something tells me that ending up saying this was the objective of all this posing.
 
Last edited:
No you dont understand. Lets get this straight. The above has nothing to do with the argument about harrit chips and if they are superthermite.

It is about the fact that superthermite exists and it can be a mixture of nanothermite and other stuff like the organic matrix and that this fact means a superthermite can have different output and properties than normal thermite. This means superthermite can exceed 3.9, and most likely very easily with organic component in air, and this also means superthermite can be explosive.
All those who understand this say so. If no one does then you can all go back to reading Ron Mossad and I will stop wasting my time.


Really? Does it do windows too?
 
...I will stop wasting my time.
You are already wasting your time whatever your reason for posting.

The main technical reason being that there was no CD at WTC on 9/11.

This whole thermXte debate is a truth movement (i.e. S E Jones) constructed derail to attract attention away from the real issue. There was no CD. (And he was losing out to Gage in the race for attention.)

So pursue the thermXte chemical researches as much as you want

OR making insulting posts

OR whatever else takes your fancy.

Bottom line "No CD at WTC on 9/11"
 
Originally Posted by jtl
Jesus, you actually dont understand this? You are so deluded that you say that there is no cherry picking but at the same time you cherry pick Cs and S signals as contamination while you claim the Zn is not contamination. This is cherry picking 101 buddy.

Oystein: It's your son's face behind a thin coating of gypsum.
You'd deny your own son.

No, laddy. Not cherry picking.

You no longer even try to use reason, you are resorting to gibberish, it is not possible to reason with you.

nothing to do with the argument about harrit chips and if they are superthermite.

It is about the fact that superthermite exists and it can be a mixture of nanothermite and other stuff like the organic matrix and that this fact means a superthermite can have different output and properties than normal thermite. This means superthermite can exceed 3.9, and most likely very easily with organic component in air, and this also means superthermite can be explosive.

Originally Posted by jtl
Listen Oystein, acknowledge the above or stick to Ron Mossad. None of you should engage in any debate about superthermite if you cant tell the difference between std thermite and superthermite.

Oystein: Strawman. You still don't understand the argument. Raspberry jelly. Think about it!

My son´s face and rasberry jelly. You really look like you are having some sort of a meltdown so I won´t bother with you no more. I know we all have our good times and our bad times, and maybe you should take a break from JREF forum for a while. Really.
 
You no longer even try to use reason, you are resorting to gibberish, it is not possible to reason with you. ...

This should help Millette improve his paper, an order of magnitude, or what.

... My son´s face and rasberry jelly. You really look like you are having some sort of a meltdown so I won´t bother with you no more. I know we all have our good times and our bad times, and maybe you should take a break from JREF forum for a while. Really.

Will this help Millette's work too? Projection.

Do you understand thermite was NOT used on 911 to destroy the WTC? A very simple question with only two possible answers for you, on correct answer for the rational world. Yes or No. Circle one.
 
Last edited:
pgimeno: I said it is not "thermite alone" because it follows logically from the comparison with "thermite alone". I didn't mean to imply it was "thermite" but not "alone".

I do not contradict myself. Once established that the energy density proves the compared materials are different...

DSC was a stupid test to perform to start with. The results are just as inconclusive as expected. They merely do show one thing the chips are NOT. And that is thermite alone.

You are babbling. There is no "thermite alone", there is harrit comparing his suspected solgel superthermite to a known solgel superthermite in a paper by Tillotson et al, who are as far as I know not conspiracy theorists. Harrit used DSC because Tillotson used DSC so it is not stupid at all, but it is easy for self proclaimed experts behind false names to say all sorts of things.

I think maybe you should talk to Oystein about some jelly and stuff:rolleyes:
 
You are babbling. There is no "thermite alone", there is harrit comparing his suspected solgel superthermite to a known solgel superthermite in a paper by Tillotson et al, who are as far as I know not conspiracy theorists. Harrit used DSC because Tillotson used DSC so it is not stupid at all, but it is easy for self proclaimed experts behind false names to say all sorts of things.

I think maybe you should talk to Oystein about some jelly and stuff:rolleyes:

And they did not match. And you still can't tell anyone what DSC is used for. Better google that one.

Do you understand thermite was NOT used on 911 to destroy the WTC? A very simple question with only two possible answers for you, on correct answer for the rational world. Yes or No. Circle one.

The thermite claims of Jones and Harrit, destroyed by a real study by Millette, RJ Lee, and USGS. Plus reality based evidence, no blast effects or thermite effects on any steel from the WTC.

Try using the quote button, your replies might/could be faster.
 
Last edited:
@jtl

Please could you clarify what you think Millette's role is.

Please explain what his objective was from the start.

Thanks

Thanks for ignoring this post jtl, I guess it is not technical enough for you :D

Judging by your comments like "we need to help Millette debunk harrit" I guess you don't understand that Millette has carried out an independent study to establish if the red/gray chips are thermite. He has not carried out a study to debunk Harrits paper.

You keep insisting that Jref posters should influence his work, which in turn would invalidate his work.

Congrats on being the first debunker who believes Harrit found thermite ;)
 
Supposing won´t do for scientific papers. The way Harrit paper is set up it looks like his chips remain hard soaked while paint softens. The way Millette paper is set up it looks like his chips soften. This sort of stuff along with titanium in millette chips leave the paper wide open for the truther defense of different chips. Millette should prevent this.

Thank you, i hope this inspiration will make it all the way to millette. If you can do more tests you should, including getting the spectra and dsc tests. You seem to know your way with paints so maybe you could make some replication paint for millette, maybe even imitate the redgray chips by painting a batch of ground down metal flakes. Send some to millette and some to harrit. More tests is the way to go, I don´t know why your buddies here are so touchy about it.

Jtl: Hehe:cool: Your self-esteem seems to be pretty... spectacular:cool:

I just removed some of my "red chips" of Laclede paint imitation from MEK solvent, in which it laid about 20 hours. Linear ("flat") dimensions are about 30 % higher, so the overall increase of volume is about 2x. Those epoxy resin chips are swollen and significantly softened, so they can be easily now broken into pieces. I also subjected one chip to quick (1 hour) high-vacuum drying (normal procedure for polymer drying), and this chip is again hard like before soaking.
So my expectations were confirmed and I can conclude that WTC epoxy paint chips would behave in similar manner. But, my epoxy is probably more densely cross-linked than cross-linked binder in "MEK chip". I can conclude this for sure after another ca 30 hours of swelling...

You wrote: "The way Harrit paper is set up it looks like his chips remain hard soaked while paint softens."
Hehe:D A little repetition for you: A comparison of the solubility of WTC red/gray chips with some unspecified paint(s) is just a blatant, inexcusable, "crystalline" pure idiocy! Are you capable of understanding this plain fact? I would immediately fire up any student who would try to employ such cretinous comparison in his work;)

Your advices how to improve Millette's research/results are basically welcome. As well some of your advices how I can "improve" my own "research" on Laclede paint imitation.
But any closer research on such imitation does not really make sense, since:
- Real red Laclede primer paint was applied by electrophoresis and they are no sufficient details on this procedure in the paint specification in NIST report available. Also, composition of Laclede paint is not described in sufficient detail. And all such details can be crucially important for the behavior of paint (e.g. for the density of cross-links)
- For a really good comparison, the paint imitation should be applied on the provably same scales of gray rust as in WTC red/gray chips. Remember that shiny microsphere were created form the gray layers, their composition/structure are/can be important here.
- Truthers (probably including you;)) would hand-wave any results on such paint imitation anyway;)

You wrote: "Send some to millette and some to harrit." Are you serious? Do you believe that Harrit would cooperate with us (or with me)? Chris Mohr tried to cooperate with K. Ryan and you probably know the result, or not? The result actually was that Ryan wrote the dirty, silly and disgusting squib "When Mohr is Less", accusing Millette of frauds.

In the next post, I will write you something more about my Laclede imitation and perhaps also more about other stuff....
 
Last edited:
Jtl:
You probably overlooked that I (well, my colleague in the institute) already investigated the thermal behavior of my Laclede imitation chips using TGA (thermogravimetric analysis) more than year ago.

Here is a corresponding TGA curve under nitrogen:

picture.php


And here is a TGA curve under air:

picture.php


Although I already commented these experiments in the past, I have perhaps something new to add now, because of my recent findings as for microscale combustion calorimetry (MCC) results available for epoxy and other polymers in the literature.
Bear in mind that these TGA are very typical for epoxy resin thermal behavior (I know it very well from the comparison with many available papers). And the explanation below is not mine, it is an excerpt from the literature.

Under nitrogen: Apparently, epoxy is massively degraded/pyrolyzed/vaporized around 400 degrees even under inert. Above ca 600 degrees C, basically only incombustible pigments remain. Remember that there is ca 30 wt% of pigments in the imitation.

Under air: The behavior of epoxy is more complex here and has basically two stages. In the first stage, epoxy is again massively degraded/pyrolyzed, but we can see that some of the organic stuff remains at ca 460 to 600 degrees. This stuff has been analyzed many times and it usually described to have polyaromatic/graphitic nature (well, it's just simply black soot). At temperatures above ca 500-550 degrees C, this black/dark stuff is further oxidized and basically disappears above ca 600 degrees C. Only inorganic pigments (nanoclay and iron oxide in my case) remain in the sample.

I did not arrange any DSC measurements of this imitation that time, since although we have several those machines in the institute, none of them is suitable for the measurements up to such high temperatures (700 degrees) under air. We are anyway polymer institute, not inorganic one. Bear in mind, that DSC is seldom used for examination of polymer thermal or thermal/oxidative degradation for reasons I have repeated here several times.

But, I can at least compare/correlate my TGA curves with MCC curves for epoxy resins from the literature. These are again pretty typical MCC curves:

picture.php


You see? Those curves (TGA and MCC) correlate quite nicely and they basically tell us:
- In MCC apparatus, the epoxy resin is first pyrolyzed/degraded under inert, so it has to be degraded/vaporized similarly to my TGA curve under inert. But vaporized combustible stuffs are then quickly transported into oven with air and they are completely burned/combusted, resulting in MCC curve.

A comparison of the results I've just presented with DSC curves in Bentham paper says: All these curves are fully compatible with the combustion of epoxy resin (or some other polymer binders) in some paint;) There is a zero evidence coming from Bentham DSC curves that they have anything common with the thermitic reaction.
 
Last edited:
Jtl:
...and finally some short remarks as for MEK chip (without reading all debate above in detail):

1) Please, look at "height" of the aluminium peak in the Fig of unsoaked MEK chip. This peak is almost negligible;)

picture.php


It does not really matter if this chip was Tnemec, Laclede or whatever paint or other mundane material. This chip shouldn't be any aluminothermics, I would say;)

2) The plain common sense tells me:
- It is very probable that unwashed chips were contaminated mostly with calcium sulfate from pulverized drywalls (and Si, Al and other stuffs from the concrete). It is highly questionable, however, that all unwashed chips had to be contaminated to the same extent with these contaminants. Well... it is basically impossible, I would say.
- It is also highly questionable that unwashed chips can be (just accidentally;)) contaminated with Zn and Cr stuffs.

Therefore, Sunstealer, Oystein and others are indeed right: bearing in mind that XEDS peaks cannot be taken as strictly quantitative measures of elements content for numerous reasons, all we know about XEDS of MEK unsoaked chip is basically compatible with Tnemec red primer.

We cannot say this with certainty. But Tnemec seems to be pretty good candidate (in a very clear and distinct contradiction to any thermite).;)

(You wrote t
 
Last edited:
Ivan/Sunstealer/Oystein, do you have your work displayed/summarised anywhere so that people like myself can view your findings/workings without having to dig through pages and pages of forum posts?
 
Ivan/Sunstealer/Oystein, do you have your work displayed/summarised anywhere so that people like myself can view your findings/workings without having to dig through pages and pages of forum posts?

Yes, some aspects are summarized in great technical detail in my blog:
Oystein's 9/11 debates

Some articles for types like jtl to read (though I don't expect them to understand):

Steven Jones proves primer paint, not thermite:
This summarizes Sunstealer's findings with regard to the MEK-chip. I show imn detail the similarities between that chip and Jones's own data on Tnemec.

Why red-gray chips aren't all the same:
Proves in particular that the XEDS differences between chips a-d and the MEK-chip are so great they can't be explained by surface contamination. So these are different materials. It follows that all the data on the MEK-chip cannot be applied to any other chips, as there is no proof that any other chips like the MEK-chip were tested with any other method.

Another primer at the WTC: LaClede Standard Primer
Explains what we know about LaClede primer, and shows that Harrit's XEDS data on chips a-d matched the LaClede composition almost perfectly. Also argues that Harrit e.al. make an invalid argument when they compare chips a-d with Tnemec.

Steven Jones and Jeff Farrer confirm four of my claims concerning red-gray chips:
Documents that Jones and Farrer now admit four things: 1. Corroborate strontium chromate, the LaClede key pigment, for some chips 2. Corroborate kaolin by saying that some chips may have equal amounts of Al and Si 3. Doing DSC under air may have been the wrong way 4. Red-gray chips are from different materials, which immediately created the need to identify which material any specimen - a basic feat Harrit e.al. have not done in their paper

How Mark Basile confirms that red-gray chips are not thermitic:
The main argument is that Basile's "favorite" chips, according to his own data, cannot contain more than 4.75% thermite, even if you assumed that all the Al was elemental and would react with iron oxide, but it contains more than 80% organics. Since the energy density of almost all organics (burning under air, as happened in Basile's experiment) is at least 4 times that of thermite, it follows that no more 1.3%, but possibly 0%, of the energy release he observed could have come from thermite, but 98.7% to 100% from organic combustion. Therefore that chip, and its reaction, cannot be said to be thermitic (it would be like mixing 5 cl wine with 80 cl rum, selling the mix as a "winic beverage", and claiming it makes you drunk because it contains a very potent wine, when in fact the stuff looks lile rum, tastes like rum and it's the rum that makes you drunk).

Too little thermite to blow up Mark Basile's chip:
Continues the argument about Basile's chip and shows that this little thermite wouldn't even release enough heat to warm the organic matrix to the brink of decomposition or ignition, let alone turn it into gas.
The same argument applies to chips a-d and the MEK-soaked chip: Those, too, have too little Al and too much organic matrix to allow for these chips to be "superthermite" - even if all the Al could react as thermite, it couldn't blow up the matrix by turning it into gas.
 
Fig 15 shows it is really difficult to pick some one area free of specific chemicals. And what happened to all the other stuff from fig 14, the Zn, the S, the Ca, Cr, S?
All hiding in some magical unspecified area? How convenient.
You do realise that area mapping in Fig 15 using EDX is only looking for one specific element at a time don't you? So if you set the machine to scan an area for Al then it will give you a map that only shows Al. If you set the machine to only scan for Fe then you will only get a map for Fe.

No, obviously not, you think that the mapping in Fig 15 shows that the Zn and the S, the Ca, Cr, S have all disappeared from the sample. lol.

They haven't disappeared, the machine was simply told not to look for them.

Mate, you are hilarious. You obviously don't have the faintest clue what you are talking about yet you are trying to lecture those that do in full on truther mode. Your mask has slipped.

How can any of us take you seriously when you get such basics wrong, but won't listen of acknowledge any answers? Remember you are not an expert, you said so yourself. Take a step back and go and read all the relevant threads, then learn what a scanning electron microscope is and the role EDX plays before commenting on topics you know nothing about. Some of us have used/are using SEM in our jobs we know what we are talking about.
 
Harrit used DSC because Tillotson used DSC so it is not stupid at all, but it is easy for self proclaimed experts behind false names to say all sorts of things.
Which was a silly thing to do.

Tillitson had a known sample. Therefore using DSC to measure energy output was a reasonable thing to do. Even now Tillitson says that maybe DSC wasn't the best tool to use.

On the other hand Harrit had an unknown sample that primarily consisted of two widely different materials. This alone would mean that any DSC result would be meaningless because there is no way to ascertain exactly what material is producing the exotherm. They even say so themselves in the paper. If you understood DSC and weight then you would know why it's a significant problem and therefore why the DSC traces cannot give you any significant information.

If you look at post DSC photos of the material it is abundantly clear that the material is still red. Redness comes from the iron oxide particles. If this material was thermite it would be a very inefficient one because there would still be most of the fuel left over.

Secondly the gray layer is missing post DSC. Where did that go? Why has a layer with a defined structure vanished? The answer is it produces the microspheres.

Ivan has already shown you DSC traces of epoxy resin which have very similar curve profiles at the all magic 430°C temperature yet you completely ignore his posts. Why are you ignoring good hard data that explains the exotherm in Harrit et al?

Only truthers ignore hard data.
 
Ivan/Sunstealer/Oystein, do you have your work displayed/summarised anywhere so that people like myself can view your findings/workings without having to dig through pages and pages of forum posts?
Best go to Oystein's blog. All my writings are scattered across JREF.
 
You are babbling. There is no "thermite alone", there is harrit comparing his suspected solgel superthermite to a known solgel superthermite in a paper by Tillotson et al, who are as far as I know not conspiracy theorists. Harrit used DSC because Tillotson used DSC so it is not stupid at all, but it is easy for self proclaimed experts behind false names to say all sorts of things.
It is stupid because once established that it is a different material, any further comparison is nonsensical. Tillotson and Gash used DSC over a known material, not in order to characterize it. They knew the kind of UFG aluminium they had used, and the kind of iron oxide. They drew conclusions based on that. They did not use DSC as an identification tool.

DSC is not a proven method for material identification. Performing a DSC test over an unknown material is stupid. All they proved was it was not the same thing Tillotson and Gash tested. Big deal. And you infer from that that it must be another kind of thermite mixed with organics? Why? There is no data supporting that; that's pure belief.

Harrit et al. did however make FTIR and TEM tests to the chips, which are competent methods for positive material identification, as opposed to DSC, which is useless in that field except to discard what it is not, which is what the authors did. However they are holding the FTIR and TEM data. Why don't you ask them to publish that data and to use more competent methods to actually prove their conclusions based on pure beliefs (if not deception, which is a possible reason for holding the data), instead of insisting in reversing the burden of proof?

I know. You must actually have used the old trick of referring to your own cousin to talk about yourself. You show blind faith in the incompetent Gods of Thermite. You fail where truthers fail: epistemology. The data presented in the Harrit et al. paper is not only short of proving their conclusions, but also enough to debunk them. Yet you keep failing on the most basic standards for proof, believing that the paper proves something it actually doesn't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom