jtl: Hehe

Since you've been already successful to offend almost all participants in this debate, I'm almost tempted to tell you: Just Enjoy the Truth
But, let me go back to two of your points.
1) You wrote:
"The paper compares the DSC release to known superthermite paper and it seems like a fact that they are similar."
Do you think that all DSC peaks so broad (heat release in several minutes) can be regarded as proofs of thermitic reaction? No, since thermitic reaction, when triggered, must be extremely rapid. Therefore, no curve in Fig. 29, including this one for authentic nanothermite, can be regarded as some evidence of thermitic reaction. They are just general broad exotherms, which could indicate many various exothermic processes. Real, triggered thermitic reaction (DTA) curve should look like this (sharp peak):
And again Fig. 29:
And typical calorimetric (MCC) curve for epoxy resins:
Please, look at these curves and compare them. Isn't the curve for authentic epoxy much more similar to curves for Bentham heated chips than the curve for authentic nanothermite? Bentham chips contained a lot of some organic/polymer, hence
DSC had to record its burning as exotherm for sure. And, even when (hypothetically) there was some thermitic reaction, its exotherm must be "hidden" in the exotherm of polymer burning. You do not agree?
We can easily agree that real experiments would be better than indirect data from the literature, so let us wait for possible further experiments of Jim Millette...
----------------------------------------------------------------
2) You wrote:
"Does it say anywhere that the chips remain brittle or hard like Harrit chips? This seems to give chance to open up the debate about the chips being the same or not. Why do Millette and Harrit get opposite results with MEK... One swells and remain hard, other softens."
I'm going to be rather repetitive, but once again for some basics on behavior of cross-linked polymers
(e.g. epoxy resins /Laclede paint/, some polyesters, polyurethanes, alkyds /Tnemec paint/, melamine and phenolic resins etc.)
Typical cross-linked polymer, e.g. epoxy resin, consists of 3-dimensional network of mutually chemically bonded polymer chains. Network can be loose, but it is usually dense. Such dense network connected by chemical cross-links cannot be disrupted by any solvent (cannot be dissolved), and can only
swell in it, which means that solvent goes inside the network and forces polymer chains between cross-links to elongate to maximal possible lengths.
Therefore, polymer increases its volume (the increase is dependent on the density of cross-links). In the
swollen form, polymer is usually softened somehow (solvent acts as a kind of "plasticizer").
When such swollen polymer is removed from the solvent, this solvent (e.g. MEK) indeed slowly evaporates. During this evaporation, the polymer is being gradually de-swollen, it decreases its volume, but since polymer chains between cross-links cannot adopt the same shapes like before swelling, the de-swelling usually does not go to original sample volume.
Anyway, de-swollen samples with no solvent inside are usually again
hard and usually more
brittle than before. This can be connected also with some extraction of some linear/shorter polymer chains.
In summary, swollen cross-linked polymer is softened (more or less), de-swollen (dried) polymer is usually again hard/brittle. Although Millette did not write that, I suppose that also his dried chips were again hard/brittle (e.g. like MEK chip). But Millette can be asked in this respect. Note, that Harrit et al did not write if the MEK chip was softened when swollen, but it is something which can be supposed from the general and well-known rules of polymer chemistry/physics.
Is this issue more clear for you now?
Anyway, all MEK tests on red/gray chips (their results described, i.e. softening/swelling) are compatible with the behavior of some paints with cross-linked polymer binder.
On the other hand, results are not compatible with known nanothermites (at least I do not know any example of nanothermite with prevailing crosslinked polymer, which can be used as pyrotechnics e.g. for cutting the steel, do you?)
Btw, more than year ago, I prepared some imitation of Laclede paint, which is described
here (post 277) and has this composition, reasonably close to the authentic Laclede paint:
Used chemicals:
- Epoxy: Pattex Repair Universal Epoxy (Henkel, 5 min hardening time), 2.45 g
Fillers:
- Iron oxide, particle size between 1 and 3 μm; dark red-brownish powder (Lachema), 0.55 g
- Nanoclay, an aluminosilicate (hydrophilic bentonite) in the very fine platelet form (Sigma Aldrich), whitish powder, 0.41 g.
- Potassium chromate, yellow powder (Lachema), 0.04 g.
You have just inspired me to perform one extremely simple experiment. About 3 hours ago, I put several chips of this epoxy sample into MEK solvent and... let's wait ca 50 hours what will happen with it. Note: since I have no idea how dense is cross-linking in this particular epoxy, the real result (the extent of swelling) is impossible to predict; up to now, chips only slightly increased their volume and indeed, they are insoluble in MEK...)