WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Sunstealer:

It isn't the same as the other chips period. There is no way it can be.

I've been right all along, why would I not be sure about Laclade?

You sound like a truther.

Focus on what Millette says when he concludes it's paint. Paint, paint, paint. He doesn't say anything else. If he concludes it's paint then why is there any weakness? It's paint, get over it.

If I sound like a truther you must sound like an arrogant preacher, and it is disappointing. I am trying to get you all to improve Millette paper, but it seems to be very difficult to even get any of you to admit to any problems, or even weak points. You say paint, period. By the way, there seem to be about three people here that actually know anything about Harrit paper and the debate.
 
Africanus: No, Harrit doesn't say that his chips remained hard.

what source tells you that the Zinc disappeared ofter soaking in MEK?

I already provided reference w page number for hard chips. Already referred graphs in Harrit paper for evident disappearance of Zn.
Save you comments for the WC, you don´t know what you are talking about.
 
Last edited:
It is not really helpful or true to call them uneducated and gullible. If you really think you have debunked the paper why don´t you publish your findings? I have read some of your posts but I don´t know if I read them all. I don´t think you have answered my questions, and you don´t seem to acknowledge any problems with Millette paper. I am sure you are ultimately right about Harrit chips but I would like to see it confirmed with published research and including all the tests. I would like more comments from you and Kminek on my posts.

You, jtl, are uneducated and gullible if you repeat the stupid truther question "why hasn't Millette done a DSC test", but refuse to accept the answer already given: "because he already had answered the question if the chips are thermitic already with a loud and clear NO. DSC test is incompetent and unnecessary to corroborate that result, and incapable of falsifying it. Therefore, it ought not be done."

Millette will eventually publish his findings. Please state NOW if you will accept that Harrit has been refuted once Millette has fully published a papet that unequivocally refutes Harrit!

Several of your questions are inane.

There are no real problems with Millette's preliminary report to be acknowledged. It is therefore a very good, thorough, systematic piece of scientific work that already answered our main question, and satisfied the reason why we commissioned his study in the first place: He confirmed that Harrit's chips a-d are paint, and not thermitic, and thus refuted the Harrit paper. If you don't understand that this is so, then you are insufficiently informed, or lack the ability to understand, or are in denial.

You ask questions of us, about Millette. Would you also want to ask Harrit and his co-authors some questions about their work? If yes, which?
 
I am trying to get you all to improve Millette paper, but it seems to be very difficult to even get any of you to admit to any problems, or even weak points.
To gain some focus: Can you please give us a list of no more than three main weaknesses that you perceive in the Millette paper, and why you think they are weaknesses? Please make sure you argue your opinion in the context of the objective of the Millette paper!

You say paint, period.
Yes, Harrit's chips a-d are paint, period.

By the way, there seem to be about three people here that actually know anything about Harrit paper and the debate.
Can you give us the about three names?
 
It would also be helpful if you all would give me links to truther arguments against your points, especially technical stuff.

Mmmm I thought you were the one with all the knowledge, or at least that's what you keep telling everyone.

:rolleyes:
 
Common, you can´t use washed Millette chips to compare to the Harrit dirty chip before MEK. You have to compare clean Harrit chip to clean Millette chip.

You are wrong again, Millette compared his chips to the fractured chips of the Harrit paper. It seems that you don't even know the basics.

But the real problem starts when the Zn starts to disappear after MEK. You may think you can see some Zn traces there but it is obvious that there is no longer as much Zn there.

1. What is the source for your disappearance claim?

2. Why is it obvious, that no more Zinc is in the chip after MEK soaking?

I already provided reference w page number for hard chips. Already referred graphs in Harrit paper for evident disappearance of Zn.
Save you comments for the WC, you don´t know what you are talking about.

I think that I know exactly what I am talking about. But it seems, that you are the one, who doesn't know what he is talking about. Your accusations of Millette and Sunstealer are hilarious. You make claims based on Harrit's paper, although Harrit's results are very shaky. You trust him although he never links his spectra to a given chip, you argue with the EDX map of the MEK chip although this map represents only a very small part of the chip and although it is not clear, if this part is representative of the chip. Millette's approach is in marked contrast of Harrits'. He always links the spectra to a particular chip, he always shows the area of the cross section, where the spectrum was recorded and he made EDX maps of a complete chip (and this chip has nearly the same size as Harrit's MEK chip).
 
You got to be kidding. I already said I dont believe the bomb conspiracy
I don't believe you.

but that is no reason not to criticize Millette, especially glaring DSC omissions
Not an omission. Millette not doing DSC is a clear sign he is a cometent researcher with lots of expertise in just the right disciplines.

DSC test is stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, stupid, jbl.

Need that any clearer?

It is moronic, idiotic, the mark of imbeciles.

and weak points like titanium chips.
Nothing weak about titanium chips.

Look, Harrit e.al. found Titanium in their chips:
http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums...ticMaterial/ActiveThermiticMaterial_Fig25.jpg

Look, Harrit e.al. found more Ti:
http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums...ede/ActiveThermiticMaterial_Fig07-labeled.jpg
There's an unlabeled bump in the spectrum of chip d right where the Ti-signal is expected. There is a bit of Titanium in their chips. It's a common and expected trace contamination in kaolin, due to it being a natural mineral and thus subject to natural impurities.

(We already know that Harrit e.al. did not reproduce all the element labels in their spectra that their device and software found. Compare this (top) to this - those are both the exact same spectrum from the same specimen: chip a. One only shows C, O, Al, Si and Fe, the other also shows S, Ca, Cr and Sr)

The paper as is will not refute Harrit. The DSC alone will refute Millette if he does not have tests that show known paint can do the same things as Harrit chips.
jbl, please answer the following two questions with YES or NO, so I can see how much or little you understand already:
1. Do you understand and acknowledge that Harrit e.al. probably looked at different kinds of red--gray chips?
2. Do you understand and acknowledge that Harrit e.al. did NOT provide any indication at all which kind or kinds of chips they tested in the DSC?

This sort of thing does not help you:
You quote-mined me.
Do you understand that I didn't say "You, jtl, are uneducated and gullible"? Can you please quote what I said instead? This is a test of your reading abillity and your honesty.
 
jtl: Hehe;) Since you've been already successful to offend almost all participants in this debate, I'm almost tempted to tell you: Just Enjoy the Truth;)

But, let me go back to two of your points.

1) You wrote: "The paper compares the DSC release to known superthermite paper and it seems like a fact that they are similar."

Do you think that all DSC peaks so broad (heat release in several minutes) can be regarded as proofs of thermitic reaction? No, since thermitic reaction, when triggered, must be extremely rapid. Therefore, no curve in Fig. 29, including this one for authentic nanothermite, can be regarded as some evidence of thermitic reaction. They are just general broad exotherms, which could indicate many various exothermic processes. Real, triggered thermitic reaction (DTA) curve should look like this (sharp peak):

picture.php


And again Fig. 29:

picture.php


And typical calorimetric (MCC) curve for epoxy resins:

picture.php


Please, look at these curves and compare them. Isn't the curve for authentic epoxy much more similar to curves for Bentham heated chips than the curve for authentic nanothermite? Bentham chips contained a lot of some organic/polymer, hence DSC had to record its burning as exotherm for sure. And, even when (hypothetically) there was some thermitic reaction, its exotherm must be "hidden" in the exotherm of polymer burning. You do not agree?

We can easily agree that real experiments would be better than indirect data from the literature, so let us wait for possible further experiments of Jim Millette...

----------------------------------------------------------------
2) You wrote: "Does it say anywhere that the chips remain brittle or hard like Harrit chips? This seems to give chance to open up the debate about the chips being the same or not. Why do Millette and Harrit get opposite results with MEK... One swells and remain hard, other softens."

I'm going to be rather repetitive, but once again for some basics on behavior of cross-linked polymers (e.g. epoxy resins /Laclede paint/, some polyesters, polyurethanes, alkyds /Tnemec paint/, melamine and phenolic resins etc.)


Typical cross-linked polymer, e.g. epoxy resin, consists of 3-dimensional network of mutually chemically bonded polymer chains. Network can be loose, but it is usually dense. Such dense network connected by chemical cross-links cannot be disrupted by any solvent (cannot be dissolved), and can only swell in it, which means that solvent goes inside the network and forces polymer chains between cross-links to elongate to maximal possible lengths.
Therefore, polymer increases its volume (the increase is dependent on the density of cross-links). In the swollen form, polymer is usually softened somehow (solvent acts as a kind of "plasticizer").

When such swollen polymer is removed from the solvent, this solvent (e.g. MEK) indeed slowly evaporates. During this evaporation, the polymer is being gradually de-swollen, it decreases its volume, but since polymer chains between cross-links cannot adopt the same shapes like before swelling, the de-swelling usually does not go to original sample volume.
Anyway, de-swollen samples with no solvent inside are usually again hard and usually more brittle than before. This can be connected also with some extraction of some linear/shorter polymer chains.

In summary, swollen cross-linked polymer is softened (more or less), de-swollen (dried) polymer is usually again hard/brittle. Although Millette did not write that, I suppose that also his dried chips were again hard/brittle (e.g. like MEK chip). But Millette can be asked in this respect. Note, that Harrit et al did not write if the MEK chip was softened when swollen, but it is something which can be supposed from the general and well-known rules of polymer chemistry/physics.
Is this issue more clear for you now?
Anyway, all MEK tests on red/gray chips (their results described, i.e. softening/swelling) are compatible with the behavior of some paints with cross-linked polymer binder. On the other hand, results are not compatible with known nanothermites (at least I do not know any example of nanothermite with prevailing crosslinked polymer, which can be used as pyrotechnics e.g. for cutting the steel, do you?)

Btw, more than year ago, I prepared some imitation of Laclede paint, which is described here (post 277) and has this composition, reasonably close to the authentic Laclede paint:

Used chemicals:
- Epoxy: Pattex Repair Universal Epoxy (Henkel, 5 min hardening time), 2.45 g
Fillers:
- Iron oxide, particle size between 1 and 3 μm; dark red-brownish powder (Lachema), 0.55 g
- Nanoclay, an aluminosilicate (hydrophilic bentonite) in the very fine platelet form (Sigma Aldrich), whitish powder, 0.41 g.
- Potassium chromate, yellow powder (Lachema), 0.04 g.


You have just inspired me to perform one extremely simple experiment. About 3 hours ago, I put several chips of this epoxy sample into MEK solvent and... let's wait ca 50 hours what will happen with it. Note: since I have no idea how dense is cross-linking in this particular epoxy, the real result (the extent of swelling) is impossible to predict; up to now, chips only slightly increased their volume and indeed, they are insoluble in MEK...)
 
Last edited:
You have just inspired me to perform one extremely simple experiment. About 3 hours ago, I put several chips of this epoxy sample into MEK solvent and... let's wait ca 50 hours what will happen with it

Hi Ivan, it may be worth removing some chips after 10 hours. This will simulate the test jtl is describing.

We wouldn't want jtl to be telling you that you don't know what you are talking about ;)
 
Hi Ivan, it may be worth removing some chips after 10 hours. This will simulate the test jtl is describing.

We wouldn't want jtl to be telling you that you don't know what you are talking about ;)

Thanks, but I'll have to be at home at the time t+10 h. I think that checking the chips next morning (after ca 19 hours of swelling) would suffice:cool:
 
Last edited:
You can´t call your peak "large" without having the same Y-axis, as it might as well be a tiny blimp that would hardly register on the Harrit graph. The point of the comparison seems quite clear also, to show that Harrit chips have similarly narrow peak as known superthermite and I think everyone agrees that no one has actually compared paint. Maybe this DSC method to compare is not very accurate so this seems like an easy chance for Millette to debunk Harrit.
First, just so you understand this graph, it is an overlay of figures 19 and 29 from the ATM paper, with the axes adjusted to match. The blue lines (corresponding to the MacKinlay 1 chip) overlap. The known thermite curve is one of the red curves, the one that is completely different to the rest:

DSC-overlaid2.png


Second, the DSC trace does yield a definitive conclusion: the energy density of the material is bigger than the maximum theoretical energy density of thermite, therefore what burned in DSC is not thermite. Quoting again from the superthermite paper (note that Fig. 3 is the Xerogel curve represented in the above graph):

Integration of the exothermic peak in Fig. 3 resulted in a heat of reaction value of 1.5 kJ/g. This is significantly lower than the theoretical value of 3.9 kJ/g. One potential explanation involves the aluminum fuel itself. We know from HRTEM analysis that the UFG Al used in this sample has an oxide coating of ~5 nm. With 30 nm diameter Al this oxide coating represents a large amount of the mass of the sample. In fact, a simple calculation, based on the volume of the oxide coating, indicates that the UFG aluminum used is actually 70% Al2 O3 weight.
​

However, the authors have to say this about the energy density of their chips:

The energy release for each exotherm can be estimated by integrating with respect to time under the narrow peak. Proceeding from the smallest to largest peaks, the yields are estimated to be approximately 1.5, 3, 6 and 7.5 kJ/g respectively. Variations in peak height as well as yield estimates are not surprising, since the mass used to determine the scale of the signal, shown in the DSC traces, included the mass of the gray layer. The gray layer was found to consist mostly of iron oxide so that it probably does not contribute to the exotherm, and yet this layer varies greatly in mass from chip to chip.​

That means that:

1. in two of the samples the energy release is shown to be greater than that of thermite, meaning it physically can not be thermite and therefore comparing the DSC trace of thermite with something that is not thermite does not make sense;

2. in the other two samples, the DSC curves are invalidated by the presence of an unquantified mass of gray layer that does not contribute to the exotherm, and therefore they can not be used to compare the curves to anything, even assuming (which is a too generous assumption) DSC to be a reliable method for material identification.

tl;dr version: It makes no sense to push any DSC trace similarities as proof that the chips can be thermite.

Third, you keep pushing for Millette to debunk the paper instead of pushing for the original authors to fix their blatant methodological mistakes and to publish the data they are holding. That is the wrong approach. The ATM paper is self-debunking. Millette merely used the correct analysis methods to prove beyond any doubt that chips a) to d) in the paper consist solely of kaolin, iron oxide and epoxy, IOW paint. The DSC test is a farce: misguided and inconclusive. Millette would have shown little scientific integrity if he did that test as an analysis method. Fortunately he didn't. Now go tell Farrer, Harrit, Jones, Ryan and the rest to release the FTIR and TEM data and to do an actual analysis that fixes all of their amateurish errors, instead of suggesting ways for Millette to debunk what is already debunked.


They do show molten iron and they do compare directly to known thermite residue. This kind of nit pick seems weak without Millette ignition results.
It's not nitpicking. Tillotson and Gash did their PXRD test for a reason: without showing that, other reactions could have happened among the constituents of the mix. The main suspect for what happened in the DSC is that the carbon-based epoxy burned in air. Figure 21 in the paper shows kaolin platelets and iron oxide crystals intact, as shown by Sunstealer. How can you say that looking for the known residues of a thermite reaction is nitpicking, when there are such strong indications that it did not happen at all?


Common, you can´t use washed Millette chips to compare to the Harrit dirty chip before MEK. You have to compare clean Harrit chip to clean Millette chip.
The spectrum shown in figure 14 matches that of red Tnemec plus maybe some gypsum. What are the chances of contamination having that spectrum?
 
Last edited:
You are wrong again, Millette compared his chips to the fractured chips of the Harrit paper. It seems that you don't even know the basics.
The MEK chip, which is under question here, was not fractured. See paragraph immediately above fig. 14.
 
Last edited:
If I sound like a truther you must sound like an arrogant preacher, and it is disappointing. I am trying to get you all to improve Millette paper, but it seems to be very difficult to even get any of you to admit to any problems, or even weak points. You say paint, period. By the way, there seem to be about three people here that actually know anything about Harrit paper and the debate.

Millette found no thermite. There is no evidence of thermite used on 911. There are zero piles of thermite product, big ugly piles of iron. There is no thermite iron fused to WTC steel, like in the idiotic videos produced by nuts like Cole. Where did the pounds, or in Harrit's case TONS of thermite product, called iron, go? The idiots in 911 truth, which you call
My truther nutcase of a cousin tells me
, and twoofies ignore the fact no thermite was used, and go with the fantasy of thermite. They can't produce evidence.

The Millette paper says no themite, hard to improve on reality.
The Harrit/Jones paper says no thermite, the DSC does not match, not even close. What we have here is 911 truth has no clue what DSC is used for, and a few nuts in 911 truth have fooled them. There is no way to make more studies that followers of 911 truth will suddenly become educated and believe. The problem is with what you call nutcase truthers.

It is crazy to chase down the idiotic claims of 911 truth. There are no rumors of bombs except in the minds of anti-intellectual, what did you call them? twoofies? Millette's study is supported with RJ Lees study, and USGS study of WTC dust. No thermite was found. No matter how much 911 truth lies, even if they plant thermite in the dust, there was no thermite used on 911.

What chemical engineering/chemist stuff does Millette's paper which found no thermite need? It would be interesting to hear from a chemist or chem engr what could be done to improve the paper. Are you a chem engr? Do you have some input from a chemist?
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Africanus
You are wrong again, Millette compared his chips to the fractured chips of the Harrit paper. It seems that you don't even know the basics.

pgimeno: The MEK chip, which is under question here, was not fractured. See paragraph immediately above fig. 14.

I don´t know why you guys make this look so complicated. Africanus was misunderstanding my reply to Sunstealer. I know millette has clean chips to compare to clean harrit chips, but it was sunstealer who picked the only harrit chip that was not clean and tried to compare it to some clean millette chip and this tnemec paint. This does not look good and it seems invalid since it is based on the assumption that the dirty chip is not dirty.

Originally Posted by jtl: Common, you can´t use washed Millette chips to compare to the Harrit dirty chip before MEK. You have to compare clean Harrit chip to clean Millette chip.

pgimeno: The spectrum shown in figure 14 matches that of red Tnemec plus maybe some gypsum. What are the chances of contamination having that spectrum?

You say it "matches" but as i pointed out to Sunstealer the match may not be that good considering small Zn peak. The real point is that most of this Zn disappears after MEK washing according to figures 16 to 18 in Harrit, so there is no longer a match after the dirty chip has been cleaned. The dirty chip is dirty for sure and does not seem to match Tnemec once clean.

Why is this such a big deal, can it not be laclede or some other paint? Are there any other options besides paint, such as insulation for fire proofing or maybe electrical cables, wiring?
 
pgimeno: 1. in two of the samples the energy release is shown to be greater than that of thermite, meaning it physically can not be thermite and therefore comparing the DSC trace of thermite with something that is not thermite does not make sense

This is an old argument that I used on some truthers long ago, but I no longer try it because it seems debunked. The 3.9 yield is for straight old school thermite but it does not apply to new mixtures with added materials that may increase the yield, and Harrit does mention the organic part. But maybe it is possible to show that 7.5 is too much?

in the other two samples, the DSC curves are invalidated by the presence of an unquantified mass of gray layer

it would invalidate it if the gray could be suspected of overpowering the red layer, but it is not so, instead it reduces the total output so it should make it more difficult for the red layer to appear like superthermite.

It makes no sense to push any DSC trace similarities as proof that the chips can be thermite.

You have to do it to show that Harrit is wrong about the traces supporting superthermite. He compares to known superthermite so obviously he is not the only one to do this test. The results are there so any challenger will have to repeat the tests.

It's not nitpicking. Tillotson and Gash did their PXRD test for a reason: without showing that, other reactions could have happened among the constituents of the mix. The main suspect for what happened in the DSC is that the carbon-based epoxy burned in air.

it is obvious nitpick when millette has no tests. Harrit shows match for thermite residues, with iron spheres and al. he did not specify al oxide? Where does the al in the spheres come from, laclede kaolin or tnemec al oxide? Both have very high melting temperatures like iron so I would like to see it confirmed with actual dsc tests that epoxy does this. These igniton results are the main thing is harrit paper so millette can not ignore them.

Third, you keep pushing for Millette to debunk the paper instead of pushing for the original authors to fix their blatant methodological mistakes and to publish the data they are holding. That is the wrong approach.

No it would be wrong to ignore millette mistakes and weak points, but that seems to be what you all are doing. If harrit made mistakes with the assumptions about his results then millette should show it by repeating the tests.
 
jtl - you simply haven't understood a word I've said. It is very, very, very simple.

Chips a-d from Harrit et al

These chips were broken in half and the red layer analysed with EDX.

Millette washed his chips and found EDX spectra that exactly matched the clean broken surface EDX for chips a-d.

Ergo Millette's wahsed chips contain no contamination. None.

MEK chip

Since Millette's chips contain no contamination and at least 6 of his chips match the MEK chip before soaking we can safely say that the MEK chip was not contaminated otherwise the spectra wouldn't match.

Therefore when truthers claim that the MEK chip was contaminated they are wrong. The paper is wrong to claim possible contamination.

If you can't understand that reasoning then I won't bother writing lengthy posts for you.



On the subject of the "missing Zn peak" - I've already told you that the Na peak is labelled incorrectly and should be Zn in fig 18. This was written in the spoiler section - click on it to read the explanation.


If you are worried about a missing Zn peak in the other figs post MEK then there is absolutely no help for you because you don't understand the writing below figs 16 & 17. Guess what they don't find any Fe in fig 16 and 17 so why aren't you bleating about that?

You are sounding more and more like a truther every day. i.e. someone who knows nothing about the subject but trying to argue with those that do. Remember you already told everyone you are not an expert.
 
This is an old argument that I used on some truthers long ago, but I no longer try it because it seems debunked. The 3.9 yield is for straight old school thermite but it does not apply to new mixtures with added materials that may increase the yield, and Harrit does mention the organic part. But maybe it is possible to show that 7.5 is too much?



it would invalidate it if the gray could be suspected of overpowering the red layer, but it is not so, instead it reduces the total output so it should make it more difficult for the red layer to appear like superthermite.



You have to do it to show that Harrit is wrong about the traces supporting superthermite. He compares to known superthermite so obviously he is not the only one to do this test. The results are there so any challenger will have to repeat the tests.



it is obvious nitpick when millette has no tests. Harrit shows match for thermite residues, with iron spheres and al. he did not specify al oxide? Where does the al in the spheres come from, laclede kaolin or tnemec al oxide? Both have very high melting temperatures like iron so I would like to see it confirmed with actual dsc tests that epoxy does this. These igniton results are the main thing is harrit paper so millette can not ignore them.



No it would be wrong to ignore millette mistakes and weak points, but that seems to be what you all are doing. If harrit made mistakes with the assumptions about his results then millette should show it by repeating the tests.
You haven't got the faintest clue what you are talking about.

Yep, definite truther. You routinely fail to comprehend. DSC is not required because Millette has already proven 100% what the material is.

The material is red paint composing kaolin and iron oxide pigment in an epoxy matrix adhered to oxidised steel.


Do you disagree with this conclusion?

Only idiot truthers think that this conclusion isn't supported because DSC wasn't done. FTIR trumps DSC. TEM-SAED trumps DSC. DSC does nothing to identify the material. Nothing.
 
This is an old argument that I used on some truthers long ago, but I no longer try it because it seems debunked. The 3.9 yield is for straight old school thermite but it does not apply to new mixtures with added materials that may increase the yield, and Harrit does mention the organic part. But maybe it is possible to show that 7.5 is too much?
...
How can thermite have more energy than thermite has. There is no new way to change the energy found in thermite. What are you talking about. No 911 truth member has debunked anything except themselves.
What new mixtures? You can't get more energy out of thermite. Are you saying chemistry is debunked?

They should have used office fires in their fantasy. Office fires had the heat energy of 2,500 tons of thermite.

Not sure which part of Millette found no thermite, RJ Lee, no thermite, and the USGS found no thermite. 911 truth has no clue what DSC is used for, and thus they can't comprehend the Jones paper shows no thermite.

JetFuelandWoodBeatThermite.jpg

The samples don't match thermite, and don't have much energy.
JonesHarritDelusion.jpg

The chips don't match thermite in energy. With the office fires equal in heat to over 2,500 TONS of thermite, ignoring the jet fuel had the heat over 260 TONS of thermite, we have an inefficient office fires heating the WTC to failure in an hour or so.

Are you saying you can get more energy out of Al/Fe2O3? You can't, and it means Harrit did not find thermite, he found dust with more or less energy than thermite.

Hard to improve Millette's paper finding no thermite. Why is DSC needed? What it the purpose of DSC? Why does the DSC in the failed Harrit paper published in a vanity journal show their samples are not thermite? How can they be that insane to include proof in their own paper it was not thermite?
 
You say it "matches" but as i pointed out to Sunstealer the match may not be that good considering small Zn peak. The real point is that most of this Zn disappears after MEK washing according to figures 16 to 18 in Harrit, so there is no longer a match after the dirty chip has been cleaned. The dirty chip is dirty for sure and does not seem to match Tnemec once clean.
They don't show the same thing. They focus the beam on different areas of the heterogeneous chip. Read carefully the captions of figures 16 to 18 and compare them to that of figure 14.

We have no overall scan of the whole red layer post-MEK. Your claim that the chip does not seem to match Tnemec after soaking is not supported by any data in the paper.


This is an old argument that I used on some truthers long ago, but I no longer try it because it seems debunked. The 3.9 yield is for straight old school thermite but it does not apply to new mixtures with added materials that may increase the yield, and Harrit does mention the organic part. But maybe it is possible to show that 7.5 is too much?
Same argument applies: they are comparing a known thermite that essentially has no added materials, with their red chips that yield more energy than thermite alone can yield, making it obvious that they are comparing different materials which are expected to have different thermal properties, therefore using the DSC curves to claim that the similarity means they are thermite is utterly stupid. You can return to using that comfortably; it is only "debunked" if you are gullible enough as to fall for such poor reasoning abilities. The argument is not substantially different to your claim that the comparison of the unwashed Tnemec chip with the chips washed by Millette is not valid (although we differ on the likeliness of that one). Follow the same reasoning here and you'll understand why the DSC traces are not comparable in order to claim that the material is thermite. Even if the chips were thermite + organic matrix, comparing the traces would still make no sense, because they show different materials in action with different thermal properties. Understood now?


it would invalidate it if the gray could be suspected of overpowering the red layer, but it is not so, instead it reduces the total output so it should make it more difficult for the red layer to appear like superthermite.
It invalidates all of the traces for the purposes of considering the total energy density of the red layer, which is the one considered to be thermitic. Even then, two of them still show an average energy density (including the gray layer) greater than that of thermite, proving it is not thermite alone. That the other two are within the theoretical range of thermite can't therefore be taken into account, given that without the gray layer their energy density would in all likeliness be shown to be much bigger.


You have to do it to show that Harrit is wrong about the traces supporting superthermite. He compares to known superthermite so obviously he is not the only one to do this test. The results are there so any challenger will have to repeat the tests.
I don't follow the logic that leads you to claim that any challenger will have to repeat the tests. Why repeat a flawed test? If someone claims that they used a thermometer and it shows that it is 7:30am, the way of disproving that it is 7:30am is not to use another thermometer. Millette used the right analysis methods. He used a clock.


it is obvious nitpick when millette has no tests. Harrit shows match for thermite residues, with iron spheres and al. he did not specify al oxide? Where does the al in the spheres come from, laclede kaolin or tnemec al oxide? Both have very high melting temperatures like iron so I would like to see it confirmed with actual dsc tests that epoxy does this. These igniton results are the main thing is harrit paper so millette can not ignore them.
It is still the original authors' task, not Millette's, to prove that what they claim that happened, actually happened. Ask them to repeat their work and show (1) that there is iron oxide and aluminium at start, and (2) that there is aluminium oxide and iron after they burn the chips in pure nitrogen, as the original thermite paper authors did. They have a result over an unidentified material; we don't know what they put in DSC to start with, except that it was red/gray and attracted by a magnet. The post-ignition residue can look similar to other stuff for a myriad of reasons. It proves nothing. Aluminium oxide is the result of a thermitic reaction. The authors are not showing that there is aluminium oxide, as the superthermite paper authors readily showed "[t]o verify that the reaction observed [...] was indeed the thermite reaction". That is a competent way of proving that the reaction was the purported one.


No it would be wrong to ignore millette mistakes and weak points, but that seems to be what you all are doing. If harrit made mistakes with the assumptions about his results then millette should show it by repeating the tests.
I can understand that you call "weak points" the fact that he didn't do an unnecessary DSC test, but what mistakes are you talking about?

I have already discussed why repeating flawed tests is flawed methodology. Look above.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom