WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

it is logical to assume that there is something different about these "dead" chips. as to what, I hope harret finds out.
That would be true. That is if there actually is "live" and "dead" chips.

Do you know where we can find the data that could help us figure this out? (It's not in their paper)
 
Last edited:
There's no such thing as "dead", "active" or "live" chips. The very idea is nonsense. How do you deactivate thermite? It's either Fe2O3 plus Al which is thermite or it isn't. Harrit does himself no favours when discussing "dead" chips. In fact it discredits him as being a loony.
 
There's no such thing as "dead", "active" or "live" chips. The very idea is nonsense. How do you deactivate thermite? It's either Fe2O3 plus Al which is thermite or it isn't. Harrit does himself no favours when discussing "dead" chips. In fact it discredits him as being a loony.

haha..I was thinking the same thing too, also about the epoxy chips millette has. how would they degrade into "dead" chips since you guys think they make the iron and silicon rich microspheres.
 
haha..I was thinking the same thing too, also about the epoxy chips millette has. how would they degrade into "dead" chips since you guys think they make the iron and silicon rich microspheres.
This makes no sense. :confused:

Are you saying Millette didn't find the gray layer?
 
Last edited:
of coarse he found gray layers with his red gray chips????

what do u not understand?

How can you claim that the chips are different when they have similar chemical compositions? If there is something that would cause one set of chips to be "dead" and one set of chips to be "live" then there would have to be something in the chemical composition that adds the "liveness". Am I wrong here?

You're busy looking at the results of the chips burning, instead of looking at the initial product.
 
This makes no sense. :confused:

Are you saying Millette didn't find the gray layer?
Nothing he says makes any sense. He can't even be bothered to capitalize the start of sentences let alone be capable of gaining any qualification in a scientific discipline. He's back on ignore for me.

I'd love to know how this thermite stuff can be turned on and off like a light-switch. It's amazing that several thousands of tonnes of this stuff was smuggled into the WTC and ignited yet there is evidence of unreacted thermite and also dead thermite in the dust that somehow has been made unreactive by magic. The whole thing is ludicrous.

Until Dr Millette and/or Chris Mohr release any further data or produce something else I'm going to ignore this thread. It's utterly pointless to indulge two truthers and their fantasies.

The whole 9/11 board is now reduced to 3 truthers: WTC Dust, Mirage Memories and Senenmut.

It's dead and not worth the time until something worthwhile crops up.
 
I think that by "dead" chips they may be referring to ignited thermite. This is why the emphasis on "iron-rich microspheres" (since iron is a byproduct of the thermite reaction). Truthers treat these microspheres like a smoking gun because they are confusing "iron-rich" with "pure iron". Am I also correct in assuming that there is a distinct lack of aluminum oxides in the dust?
 
we need him to elaborate on that point.
No. We need you to admit that the Bentham paper is insufficient for failing to note that they found dead chips - no matter what sample they found them in

does he tell us what sample he found the "dead" chips in?
Yes. From the context it is clear that it came from samples considered by them before the paper was published. That's enough to know.

did all the "dead" chips come in 1 sample?
It doesn't matter. They failed to mention them in the paper. That is a majot blunder in the paper, if not outright deception.

are the "active" chips in particular samples?
No, they are said to be in all samples.

do some samples contain all "active" and some all "dead".
This should be discernible from the paper. The paper is totally silent on dead chips.

It is thus a defective, insufficient paper. FAIL.

he does not tell us a whole lot.
That's excusable in an interview, inexcusable in a scientific publication.

are they the ones that are partially reacted? I hope they look into this deeper.
I am glad you start to realize how insuffiecient the paper is.

yep. but are they the same material?
Well, what do you think?
What criteria would you use to decide this question?
For that matter:
Can you please list ALL the objective, scientific and replicable criteria that Harrit employed to ascertain that chips a-d are the same material, please?



replication of experiments.
Since Harrit et al did NOT peform DSC or any other heating on chips a-d, this is not part of the necessary replication.

get those chips either to produce or not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres then we can talk.
Irrelevant. Harrit et al did NOT produce iron and silicon rich microspheres from chips a-d.

are millette's chips the "dead" ones?
Irrelevant, as the Bentham paper doesn't even mention the possibility that there are dead ones, let alone describe criteria.

no one does not have to agree that millettes chips "are" the same material until he heats them up and either makes or does not make iron and silicon rich microspheres.
FALSE, and blatant deception.

you have read the paper.
Yes, I have read the paper, and I know the answer. But I want YOU to answer the question - verbosely:

Can you please list ALL the objective, scientific and replicable criteria that Harrit employed to ascertain that chips a-d are the same material?

You know damned well that neither DSC not any other kind of heating are part of the accepted objective, scientific and replicable criteria, as Harrit did not do any of those on chips a-d.

Please answer the question!!!
 
I believe the data in the millette report, just don't think they are the same material being studied.

How did you decide that Millette's chip that resemble Harrit's chips a-d in every single available objective scientific criterion are not the same material?

How did you, for that matter, decide that chips a-d are all the same material?

Remember that they were not tested in the DSC, nor heated in any other way, as far as YOU know. So if you serve us the "heat them, look for microspheres" mantra, you are a liar, pure and simple, because you cannot use any such data as objective, scientific criteria - it does not exist.

Please list verbosely and specifically ALL the objective, scientific and replicable criteria that Harrit employed to ascertain that chips a-d are the same material! Only use criteria on which data actually is available for chips a-d!
 
haha..I was thinking the same thing too, also about the epoxy chips millette has. how would they degrade into "dead" chips since you guys think they make the iron and silicon rich microspheres.

No, we do not think this. Harrit's data is insufficient. We have no idea which of the several different kinds of red-gray chips formed microspheres of which kind.

We think that Millette's epoxy chips, with kaolin and hematite pigments, are the same material as chips a-d. They are all not thermite, as they contain no elemental Al (and also no oxidized Al).
 
"MM and Senenmut et al, what if regular primer paint on steel were burned in a regular fire and iron-rich microspheres were created?"

I certainly encourage further experimentation that seriously attempts to challenge the 2009 Bentham paper.

When heated to ~415-435 ̊C, if regular primer paint on steel produced a characteristic exothermic spike comparable to those in Fig. 19 of the 2009 Bentham paper and iron-rich micro-spheroids were created, it would be a result that contradicted what Dr. Harrit et al observed when they tested known WTC steel primer paint.

"This is the experiment I have been trying to get done by someone.

Would that have any effect on your belief that the iron microspheres can be produced only by melting steel or iron at 2700+ degrees Farenheit? Would it cause you to rethink that little bit of evidence?
"

Only if I felt I could trust whomever is performing the testing.

Dr. Millette appears unlikely to pay to have his 2012 report published, nor does it appear that you can persuade him from his busy-busy schedule to push his oven a few more degrees and then put the resulting chip residue under the microscope.

But if he did, would Dr. Millette see the exothermic flashes that showed as DSC spikes in Fig. 19, or would his selected chips just turn into benign ash as was observed when primer paint was heated and burned?

Ash results with no iron-rich spheroids, would add further confirmation that Dr. Millette was not using chips that contain the same volatile substance that was found in the 2009 Bentham paper 9/11 WTC dust red/chips.

It means that his analysis was fine for whatever those chips were that he was examining.

But it also means he cannot make a valid judgement about the 9/11 WTC dust chips used by Dr. Harrit et al.

But, since he never destroyed his original test chips, he could still put them back into an oven set to 450 ̊C for good measure.

Somehow I do not think he wants to report back about a resulting ash pile.

Somehow I do not think he wants to report back about an exothermic ignition and iron-rich micro-spheroids in the resulting residue either.

He won't publish, and he won't report on heat testing, because it would expose himself and the future profitability of his company to unwanted controversy.

But Chris, if you can get the ball properly rolling, I would certainly be interested in the results.

MM
 
Ash results with no iron-rich spheroids, would add further confirmation that Dr. Millette was not using chips that contain the same volatile substance that was found in the 2009 Bentham paper 9/11 WTC dust red/chips.
What do you mean by volatile substance? :confused: Do you mean epoxy?

Aluminium oxide is not volatile.
 
I think that by "dead" chips they may be referring to ignited thermite. This is why the emphasis on "iron-rich microspheres" (since iron is a byproduct of the thermite reaction). Truthers treat these microspheres like a smoking gun because they are confusing "iron-rich" with "pure iron". Am I also correct in assuming that there is a distinct lack of aluminum oxides in the dust?

I'd be astonished if there were NO aluminum oxide in the dust, since Al2O3 is such a common material. But if truthers are correct ;), there should be TONS of it in the dust from all that nanothermite. Off the top of my head, I'd take a sample of the dust and treat it with a solution of ~10% citric acid, which will dissolve aluminum oxide, iron oxides, and most other metallic oxides, but will not dissolve things like aluminum silicate, and is not strong enough an acid to attack metals by liberating H2. The metal citrates could then be separated by ion-exchange. Calcium sulfate is plentiful in the dust, but it's mildly soluble in H2O anyway.

Citric acid solution should also dissolve the iron oxides in the "gray layer" on the back of the paint chips, but won't touch the hematite in the organic matrix, as the matrix is hydrophobic.

Just the musings of a retired industrial chemists finishing my second Manhattan. :)

Oh, yes - this is semi-destructive of the dust samples, but Harrit, IIRC, claimed to have something like 20 liters of the stuff.
 
I certainly encourage further experimentation that seriously attempts to challenge the 2009 Bentham paper.

When heated to ~415-435 ̊C, if regular primer paint on steel produced a characteristic exothermic spike comparable to those in Fig. 19 of the 2009 Bentham paper and iron-rich micro-spheroids were created, it would be a result that contradicted what Dr. Harrit et al observed when they tested known WTC steel primer paint.

Originally Posted by chrismohr View Post
"This is the experiment I have been trying to get done by someone.

Would that have any effect on your belief that the iron microspheres can be produced only by melting steel or iron at 2700+ degrees Farenheit? Would it cause you to rethink that little bit of evidence?

Only if I felt I could trust whomever is performing the testing.

...

But Chris, if you can get the ball properly rolling, I would certainly be interested in the results.

MM

What if I had some interesting data, MM? Would you trust me?
'
Dave
 
There is a distinct lack of evidence for aluminum oxides in the dust.

Thank you for the correction. And Redwood raises a good point also, about Al2O3 being a relatively common thing to find, but not in the quantities that would be expected from a thermite reaction. On the whole, I find the whole "iron-rich microspheres" argument unconvincing, in that I would expect thermite to produce large volumes of elemental Fe and Al2O3. "Iron-rich" is not a qualifier I would expect to be used. Perhaps my expectations are unrealistic, though.
 
@ Miragememories:

YOu ran away from your denate with me. I had summarized your latest replies to me in post #3052:

I had asked you many many times:
Oystein said:
Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
You finally answered this:
"Steel primer paint dust chips adhering to any gray material ... could easily pass the initial isolation process [of magnetic attraction plus visual selection of red-gray chips]"
So your answer is: YES, there is a possibility that this method yields two or more different materials!


There is a corollary to your, MM's, answer:

We can't be certain, a-priori, that chips a-d are all the same material, when all we knew were that they were pulled from WTC dust with a magnet, and are red-gray. Because any two such chips could be different materials.

Agreed, MM? Of course you agree.

So we would have to analyse the chips a litte further to determine if they are the same material, right? So let's see, what analysis was done, what data do we have on chips a-d?
  • We have PLM micographs, showing color, luster, surface structure of all of chips a-d
  • We have SE-images, showing shape and microstructure of all of chips a-d
  • We have high-magnification BSE images to show the sub-micron structure of all of chips a-d
  • We have XEDS spectra of the gray sides of all of chips a-d
  • We have XEDS spectra of the red sides of all of chips a-d
  • We do NOT have DSC results for any of chips a-d
  • We do NOT have any sort of ignition residues for any of chips a-d
  • We do NOT have resistivity measurements for any of chips a-d

So having clued you in on all the data and analysis we do have, and some that we don't, here is my next question to you:

Are chips a-d the same material?
I must insist that you answer this briefly. There are exactly three possible answers to this, and your answer must be one of those three, it can't be anything else:
  • Yes.
  • No.
  • I, MM, don't know.

Notice the full stops at the end of each answer. No qualifications. In your opinion, chips a-d are the same material. Period. Or they are not the same material. Period. Or, if you can't decide on either yes or no, then evidently, you don't know if they are the same material or not. Period. There is no third possibility.


When you have decided on yes. or no., please follow up with this:

Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?

Note the word "objective". By this I mean criteria that stem from scientific analysis that was actually done on chips a as well as chip b as well as chip c as well as chip d. Don't you dare introducing any criteria that are not objective - that can be verified by the data already published!
Note the word "specific": Name the criterion, explain how it is evalued, cite the values!
Note that this question is about chips a-d. This means: Whatever you answer has to pertain to all four chips a-d. a and b and c and d. Don't mention any other chip, as this question is not about any other chip.
No more wiggle room for you, MM. Just tell us exactly how you know, from scientific analysis, that chips a-d are (or aren't) the same material.
 
Last edited:
...is off-topic here. Please do not derail. Also, you did not quote the questions I asked you. Therefore that's where I stopped reading your post.


I must insist: Please answer Post 3100, which is a slightly more concise version of Post 3052:


I had asked you many many times:
Oystein said:
Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
You finally answered this:
"Steel primer paint dust chips adhering to any gray material ... could easily pass the initial isolation process [of magnetic attraction plus visual selection of red-gray chips]"
So your answer is: YES, there is a possibility that this method yields two or more different materials!


There is a corollary to your, MM's, answer:

We can't be certain, a-priori, that chips a-d are all the same material, when all we knew were that they were pulled from WTC dust with a magnet, and are red-gray. Because any two such chips could be different materials.

Agreed, MM? Of course you agree.

So we would have to analyse the chips a litte further to determine if they are the same material, right? So let's see, what analysis was done, what data do we have on chips a-d?
  • We have PLM micographs, showing color, luster, surface structure of all of chips a-d
  • We have SE-images, showing shape and microstructure of all of chips a-d
  • We have high-magnification BSE images to show the sub-micron structure of all of chips a-d
  • We have XEDS spectra of the gray sides of all of chips a-d
  • We have XEDS spectra of the red sides of all of chips a-d
  • We do NOT have DSC results for any of chips a-d
  • We do NOT have any sort of ignition residues for any of chips a-d
  • We do NOT have resistivity measurements for any of chips a-d

So having clued you in on all the data and analysis we do have, and some that we don't, here is my next question to you:

Are chips a-d the same material?
I must insist that you answer this briefly. There are exactly three possible answers to this, and your answer must be one of those three, it can't be anything else:
  • Yes.
  • No.
  • I, MM, don't know.

Notice the full stops at the end of each answer. No qualifications. In your opinion, chips a-d are the same material. Period. Or they are not the same material. Period. Or, if you can't decide on either yes or no, then evidently, you don't know if they are the same material or not. Period. There is no third possibility.


When you have decided on yes. or no., please follow up with this:

Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?

Note the word "objective". By this I mean criteria that stem from scientific analysis that was actually done on chips a as well as chip b as well as chip c as well as chip d. Don't you dare introducing any criteria that are not objective - that can be verified by the data already published!
Note the word "specific": Name the criterion, explain how it is evalued, cite the values!
Note that this question is about chips a-d. This means: Whatever you answer has to pertain to all four chips a-d. a and b and c and d. Don't mention any other chip, as this question is not about any other chip.
No more wiggle room for you, MM. Just tell us exactly how you know, from scientific analysis, that chips a-d are (or aren't) the same material.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom