Miragememories
Banned
"@ Miragememories:
Are chips a-d the same material?"
Unfortunately, the 2012 unpublished work by Dr. Millette represents a nominal investigation into the 9/11 WTC dust substance that was reported in the 2009 Bentham paper.
Dr. Millette attempts a dismissal of the findings of the 2009 Bentham paper solely by claiming his selected 9/11 WTC a-d chip selects match the selects highlighted by Dr. Harrit et al.
Because Dr. Millette's claims his findings do not describe, or show, an a-d chip chemistry that would behave in the repeatable manner observed by Dr. Harrit, Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer and chemical engineer Mark Basile, we have to conclude that without further corroboration, Dr. Millette has failed to make a case.
Dr. Millette unequivocally declared the substance could not be thermitic but he has never published his evidence, or confirmed his opinion with a simple heat test.
He ignored the chief findings of the 2009 Bentham paper.
He refused to use his own heat test in a separate test to observe a possible ignition and residue results.
The results would either provide Dr. Millette with additional confirmation for his a-d chip matching, or, results that disputed his claim that his chip selections matched those used in the 2009 Bentham paper.
After fully analyzing all the data from his chip selections heated to 400 C, he could have possibly validated this data by re-heating those 'no longer needed chips' just another 30 C.
But no.
Dr. Millette stops.
He has read the 2009 Bentham paper.
He knows his selected chips were only +30 C from behaving like those in the 2009 Bentham paper --- or not.
Why not toss those finished samples into the oven and see what happens at 430 C?
Because benign ash results mean his chips were not a match for those used in the 2009 Bentham paper.
And iron-rich micro-spheroids would represent an unprofitable controversy.
Dr. Harrit, Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer, chemical engineer Mark Basile et al have 'published dramatic proof' that the substance was thermitic.
Other than your own prejudice, on what basis should Dr. Millette's unpublished opinion outweigh that of senior scientists who have a solid consensus about their 'published' research findings?
MM