WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

"@ Miragememories:
Are chips a-d the same material?
"

Unfortunately, the 2012 unpublished work by Dr. Millette represents a nominal investigation into the 9/11 WTC dust substance that was reported in the 2009 Bentham paper.

Dr. Millette attempts a dismissal of the findings of the 2009 Bentham paper solely by claiming his selected 9/11 WTC a-d chip selects match the selects highlighted by Dr. Harrit et al.

Because Dr. Millette's claims his findings do not describe, or show, an a-d chip chemistry that would behave in the repeatable manner observed by Dr. Harrit, Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer and chemical engineer Mark Basile, we have to conclude that without further corroboration, Dr. Millette has failed to make a case.

Dr. Millette unequivocally declared the substance could not be thermitic but he has never published his evidence, or confirmed his opinion with a simple heat test.

He ignored the chief findings of the 2009 Bentham paper.

He refused to use his own heat test in a separate test to observe a possible ignition and residue results.

The results would either provide Dr. Millette with additional confirmation for his a-d chip matching, or, results that disputed his claim that his chip selections matched those used in the 2009 Bentham paper.

After fully analyzing all the data from his chip selections heated to 400 C, he could have possibly validated this data by re-heating those 'no longer needed chips' just another 30 C.

But no.

Dr. Millette stops.

He has read the 2009 Bentham paper.

He knows his selected chips were only +30 C from behaving like those in the 2009 Bentham paper --- or not.

Why not toss those finished samples into the oven and see what happens at 430 C?

Because benign ash results mean his chips were not a match for those used in the 2009 Bentham paper.

And iron-rich micro-spheroids would represent an unprofitable controversy.

Dr. Harrit, Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer, chemical engineer Mark Basile et al have 'published dramatic proof' that the substance was thermitic.

Other than your own prejudice, on what basis should Dr. Millette's unpublished opinion outweigh that of senior scientists who have a solid consensus about their 'published' research findings?

MM
 
Are iron rich microspheres only caused by a thermite reaction?

To answer your question directly, no, they're not only caused by an iron-oxide/aluminum redox. On the contrary, their very ubiquity is the entire problem.

At risk of derail: I had held the opinion that a considerable percentage of microspheres were not even generated on 9/11, but instead were created both during construction and afterwards deposited from such mundane sources as soot. The logical conclusion of my stance was that the spherules observed were merely liberated by the collapses. To this end, I cited the RJ Lee report's observation that pre-collapse surveys were markedly lesser in number compared to post collapse ones. However, I think I'm in the minority on this in here, as the prevailing opinion here is that the ones in question were in fact created by collapse processes. And in fact, that same RJ Lee series of reports provides a possible creation mechanism.

But that's a digression. The point is that there are so many alternate sources of microspheres.

However, the truther argument is not restricted to just the presence of them. It's that microspheres generated by the studied dust samples during experimentation demonstrates that they were generated by thermite. That's refutable, but I bring it up in order to point out that it's a multi-pronged argument that conspiracy advocates forward. It's not just that microspheres were present, therefore thermite.

Are they even a known byproduct of thermite?
Given the temperatures that thermite achieves, it's totally reasonable to presume that they are indeed produced by such a reaction. That's light years away from tying their presence in the dust samples to thermite in the towers, but as a stand-alone issue, it's an acceptable presumption.
 
Last edited:
.

Until Dr Millette and/or Chris Mohr release any further data or produce something else I'm going to ignore this thread. It's utterly pointless to indulge two truthers and their fantasies.

excellent idea about millette releasing further data!! i knew you had a scientific mind. one just cant say the chips are the same material until he follows the scientific method and replicates experiments and produces those pesky iron and silicon rich microspheres!!

i knew you had it in ya!
 
We think that Millette's epoxy chips, with kaolin and hematite pigments, are the same material as chips a-d. They are all not thermite, as they contain no elemental Al (and also no oxidized Al).

think?? your thinking too much and not doing enough. hell, quit thinking and get millette to use the scientific method and replicate those experiments. he will either get iron and silicon rich microspheres or not.
if he actually gets spheres then comes the fun part in trying to determine what in those epoxy/steel chips could possible cause a dsc spike around 430C and cause iron and silicon rich microspheres to form.

if no spheres, then not the same material.

ohhh, im sure you will bring up the dead chips. how would thermite be "dead"? harriet needs to elaborate more on those. but, epoxy/steel (millettes chips) should not be "dead" since you guys think the gray layer is the culprit behind the iron spheres.
 
@ Miragememories:

Are chips a-d the same material?
I must insist that you answer this briefly. There are exactly three possible answers to this, and your answer must be one of those three, it can't be anything else:
  • Yes.
  • No.
  • I, MM, don't know.
Unfortunately, the 2012 unpublished work by Dr. Millette ... [snipped a very unbrief reply that is not at all about chips a-d]

MM: You quoted a question about chips a-d.
How does invoking Millette, who never studied chips a-d, help you answering that question? It doesn't. It's adodge. Moving goal post. Running away from a simple question like a coward. Blatantly dishonest.
Please answer the question without recourse to Millette. We'll return to Millette after you have answered my two questions about chips a-d.

Also, I had asked you to answer the question briefly. By chips a-d I meant: You answer YES, or you answer NO, or you answer DON'T know. It's a simple yes/no question. So please answer my question about chips a-d briefly:

Are chips a-d the same material?
I must insist that you answer this briefly. There are exactly three possible answers to this, and your answer must be one of those three, it can't be anything else:
  • Yes.
  • No.
  • I, MM, don't know.


After you have given a brief (yes or no, nothing else) answer to the above, please answer my second question, and don't ignore it (everybody here can very clearly see through your shameful act, it doesn't become a man of courage, conviction and honesty):

Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?

Do not invoke Millette when answering this question. Do not invoke DSC or any other heating, as you damned well know that no such test is recorded for chips a-d.
We'll get to Millette after you have given your answers to both questions honestly and courageously.
 
think?? your thinking too much and not doing enough. hell, quit thinking ...

You're thinking to little and doing nothing.

I suggest that you start thinking, for example about chips a-d. You agreed they are all the same material - but: why?

How did you decide that Millette's chips that resemble Harrit's chips a-d in every single available objective scientific criterion are not the same material?

Remember that they were not tested in the DSC, nor heated in any other way, as far as YOU know. So if you serve us the "heat them, look for microspheres" mantra, you are a liar, pure and simple, because you cannot use any such data as objective, scientific criteria - it does not exist.

Please list verbosely and specifically ALL the objective, scientific and replicable criteria that Harrit employed to ascertain that chips a-d are the same material! Only use criteria on which data actually is available for chips a-d

In other words: Demonstrate how you think. If you think at all and aren't merely swallowing Saint Harrit's words hook, line, sinker, rod, fisherman and beach.
 
Dr. Harrit, Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer, chemical engineer Mark Basile et al have 'published dramatic proof' that the substance was thermitic.


MM

Yet Mark Basile wants an independent examination of the chips.

I don't see Harrit and Jones demanding one :rolleyes:

Perhaps Mark Basile feels he has had his pants pulled down to his ankles by Jones & Co ? Or maybe it's his way of covering his arse and making a half honest exit from the thermite scam? Either way there are only a handfull of truthers willing to donate which is a sure sign that the truth movement is dead.

It looks like its down to MM & Senemut to roll out the same old horse turd and claim they are following orders from their leader Steven Jones.
 
"MM: You quoted a question about chips a-d.
How does invoking Millette, who never studied chips a-d, help you answering that question?
"

I could have sworn that this thread was about Dr. Millette and his WTC dust study.

My posts are directed at the validity of Dr. Millette's study and how well it pertains to the 2009 Bentham paper which it was attempting to refute.

MM
 
I could have sworn that this thread was about Dr. Millette and his WTC dust study.

My posts are directed at the validity of Dr. Millette's study and how well it pertains to the 2009 Bentham paper which it was attempting to refute.

MM

Dodge. Answer the question.
 
I could have sworn that this thread was about Dr. Millette and his WTC dust study.

My posts are directed at the validity of Dr. Millette's study and how well it pertains to the 2009 Bentham paper which it was attempting to refute.

MM

Quite correct. Millette writes:
James Millette said:
In summary, red/gray chips with the same morphological characteristics, elemental spectra and magnetic attraction as those shown in Harrit et al.1 were found in WTC dust samples from four different locations than those examined by Harrit, et al.1. ... Based on the optical and electron microscopy data, the Fe/O particles are an iron oxide pigment consisting of crystalline grains in the 100-200 nm range and the Al/Si particles are kaolin clay plates that are less than a micrometer thick.
So he describes red-gray chips with the morphological characteristics:
  1. Fe/O rich grains, 100-200 nm in size
  2. Al/Si-rich platelets, less than 1 micron thin
and that those match specimens descibed by Harrit et al.

As Harrit et al demonstrate these morphological characteristics only for chips a-d, any comparison of Millette's findings with Harrit et al must focus on, or at least account of, chips a-d. Clearly, Millette is refering to chips a-d. So a brief preliminary discussion of chips a-d is on topic in this thread!

The question is of course: Are Millette's chips that conform to the above morphological desctiption the same material as chips a-d? Such a question would imply an assumption that chips a-d are the same material, so we must ask ourselved - or actually I am asking you, MM: Is that a valid assumption to have when discussing Millette?
Are chips a-d the same material?
Because if they are not, then it becomes quite unclear what to do with Millette's chips - but then it also becomes quite unclear what to do with chips a-d. Clearly, Harrit et al imply that chips a-d are the same material. And we (Sunstealer, Ivan, Gamolon, myself...) all agree: YES, chips a-d are the same material.

We just don't know what you say, MM:

Are chips a-d the same material?

Please answer this very simply with "yes", "no" or "I, MM, don't know".
Clearly, as these three options enumerate the possible answers, and are disjoint, you can decide on an answer. I understand that it causes you great pain and distress to spell out an honest answer by typing the three letters "y", "e" and "s", but try to be a man (or a woman - don't know which you are; not a spineless sponge at any rate), muster all your courage, stop running away, and just answer it. Thank you.


When (and if) you have given a simple answer of "yes" or "no", please follow up with an (honest and courageous, if have it in you) answer to:

Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?

Do not invoke Millette when answering this question. Do not invoke DSC or any other heating, as you damned well know that no such test is recorded for chips a-d - I don't want to read that lie once more.
We'll get to Millette after you have given your answers to both questions honestly and courageously.
 
Last edited:
Hey you guys, this might be a little off topic, but I wanted to know something for sure. Is it possible that Dr. Millette has no intention on publishing his paper? I mean, I know it's important to MM (I don't understand why he thinks the Bentham paper was properly peer reviewed, or even published in a real journal), but we say all the time how the truth movement is dead. Is it possible that it is such a no brainer to the scientific community at large, that he won't even bother with it?
 
plague,

according to Chris Mohr, Millette still intends to publish eventually, but it's low on his list of priorities. First and foremost, he's got a business to run. Some of the work is done by an employee - which means he needs some spare capacity not demanded by actual, money-paying project.

In contrast, Harrit and Jones are retired and could afford to decide to spend much time on this pet stuff. Farrer ... perhaps managing a microscopy lab leaves you with resources to play around and practice in the same lab. Does Kevin Ryan have a job these days? Farnsworth - when a Professor (Jones) asks you to help, you oblige.
 
plague,

according to Chris Mohr, Millette still intends to publish eventually, but it's low on his list of priorities. First and foremost, he's got a business to run. Some of the work is done by an employee - which means he needs some spare capacity not demanded by actual, money-paying project.

In contrast, Harrit and Jones are retired and could afford to decide to spend much time on this pet stuff. Farrer ... perhaps managing a microscopy lab leaves you with resources to play around and practice in the same lab. Does Kevin Ryan have a job these days? Farnsworth - when a Professor (Jones) asks you to help, you oblige.

Yeah, I assumed he was busy and that the publication was low on the totem pole. I just see MM spout on about Benthams peer review and publication, despite it's illegitimacy, and was curious if it was something that Millette intended on doing. From what I understand of the scientific process, peer review and publication is performed in order to further education in regards to that scientific experiment.

As we see here, the people who believe that there was thermite in the building will not have their views altered under any circumstance. On the flip, the people who know that there was no thermite in the building now have 2 separate sets of data (bentham and Dr. Millette) that confirm there was no thermite. So in essence, the opinions of the non-truthers won't change due to publication either.

I feel certain people use the publication of the Bentham paper as some pretend "line in the sand" that separates Millette and Bentham.
 
Hey you guys, this might be a little off topic, but I wanted to know something for sure. Is it possible that Dr. Millette has no intention on publishing his paper? I mean, I know it's important to MM (I don't understand why he thinks the Bentham paper was properly peer reviewed, or even published in a real journal), but we say all the time how the truth movement is dead. Is it possible that it is such a no brainer to the scientific community at large, that he won't even bother with it?

I vaguely remember what Chris Mohr wrote in some e-mail to me: Jim Millette's lectures about his WTC red/gray chips attracted a quite considerable attention in the conferences and they were well accepted and appreciated. But, Chris knows More;)
 
Last edited:
I just talked with Jim Millette today as it happens. Yes he still intends to publish his paper, but he is overwhelmed with work. Things have not let up for him but when they do he intends to get a paper out.
 
plague,

the point of publication is to make a work public.
So far, the work of Millette is only known to the handful of people that already knew the Harrit nonsense, and a few people that happened to attend the same couple of conferences and found their way into Millette's presentations. That isn't much publicity at all.

There are several venues to publish, and peer-reviewed journals are but one of them. Newspapers and magazines are another, as are online journals, blogs.

The point of publishing in scientific journals is to reach a relevant scientific community, and make a work known among peers in the same field. Harrit et al failed on that count by going to the Bentham "The Open Chemical Physics Journal", which has practically zero impact in the academic community.


Ohhh, look here:

http://www.bentham-open.org/

This domain may be for sale. Backorder this Domain

Hahaha this is sweet :D

ETA:
Looking up what's up with the domain:
http://whois.domaintools.com/bentham-open.org
Domain ID:D142378138-LROR
Domain Name:BENTHAM-OPEN.ORGCreated On:27-Mar-2007 19:32:21 UTC
Last Updated On:11-Apr-2013 09:12:59 UTCExpiration Date:27-Mar-2014 19:32:21 UTC
Sponsoring Registrar:eNom, Inc. (R39-LROR)
Status:CLIENT TRANSFER PROHIBITED
Registrant ID:8c6b7cee5d3ac550
Registrant Name:Reactivation PeriodRegistrant Street1:15801 NE 24th Street
Registrant Street2:
Registrant Street3:
Registrant City:Bellevue
Registrant State/Province:WA
Registrant Postal Code:98004
Registrant Country:US
Registrant Phone:+1.4252744500
Registrant Phone Ext.:
Registrant FAX:+1.4259744791
Registrant FAX Ext.:
Registrant Email:

And it's for sale:
http://www.namejet.com/Pages/Auctions/BackorderDetails.aspx?domainname=bentham-open.org
High Bid: No Bids
Type: Wish List
Your Last Bid: $0 USD
Bid History: 0 bids
 
Last edited:
February 2012 Millette 9/11 WTC Dust Red/Gray Chip Analysis

"I just talked with Jim Millette today as it happens.

Yes he still intends to publish his paper, but he is overwhelmed with work.

Things have not let up for him

but

when they do

he intends to get a paper out.
"

As expected.

Dr. Jim Millette will be "too busy" to publish as long as that argument suits him.

MM
 
"MM: You quoted a question about chips a-d.
How does invoking Millette, who never studied chips a-d, help you answering that question?
"
"I could have sworn that this thread was about Dr. Millette and his WTC dust study.

My posts are directed at the validity of Dr. Millette's study and how well it pertains to the 2009 Bentham paper which it was attempting to refute."
"Quite correct.

Dr. Millette describes red-gray chips with the morphological characteristics:
  1. Fe/O rich grains, 100-200 nm in size
  2. Al/Si-rich platelets, less than 1 micron thin
and that those match specimens described by Harrit et al.
"

But that is untrue.

Dr. Millete's chip selections came from a-d geographical locations in New York City that were close to the a-d locations referred to in the 2009 Bentham paper.

And I do believe that Dr. Millette must have some 'matching' chips in his 9/11 WTC dust samples. But based on his findings we have to conclude that he just hasn't selected any.

Dr. Millette describes a lot of similarities between his 9/11 WTC dust red/gray chips and those tested by Dr. Harrit et al.

But his insistence on confining his conclusions to data derived only from non-destructive testing means he can only say that his un-ignited chips "look" like what he thinks the pre-ignition 2009 Bentham paper chips "looked" like.

He cannot say his chips ignited at ~430 C like those in the 2009 Bentham paper.

He cannot say that his chips were not thermitic and left a post-ignition residue that was benign ash.

What Dr. Millette has concluded about his chips is that their chemistry would never behave in the manner observed by the scientists who published the 2009 Bentham paper.

Which, minus corroborative heat-testing, proves the chemistry of his chips does not match the chemistry of the chips highlighted in the 2009 Bentham paper.

And now we hear again, that as much as he really wants to do this, Dr. Millette will be "too busy" for an indefinite period of time to publish his report.

A report that he felt was 'polished' enough that he presented it to his peers over a year ago.

MM
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom