Oystein said:
Dr. Millette describes red-gray chips with the morphological characteristics:
- Fe/O rich grains, 100-200 nm in size
- Al/Si-rich platelets, less than 1 micron thin
and that those match specimens described by Harrit et al.
But that is untrue.
Huh?
What is untrue, specifically?
That Millette describes red-gray chips with the morphological characteristic "Fe/O rich grains, 100-200 nm in size"? But
that is true, he does describe this, I quoted him!
That Millette describes red-gray chips with the morphological characteristic "Al/Si-rich platelets, less than 1 micron thin"? But
that is true, he does describe this, I quoted him!
That Harrit's red-gray chips a-d have the morphological characteristic "Fe/O rich grains, 100-200 nm in size"? But
that is true! See Fig. 8, 10 and 11b!
That Harrit's red-gray chips a-d have the morphological characteristic "Al/Si-rich platelets, less than 1 micron thin"? But
that is true! See Fig. 8, 10 and 11a!
MM, what in the stuff you quoted is untrue? Nothing!
I cut out all the other crap. It was full of lies and lying insinuations.
Your dodging appears extremely cowardly and dishonest.
Stop the dodging.
Stop the lies.
Act like a man or woman of courage and honor!
Please answer the following question:
Are chips a-d the same material?
Please answer this very simply with "yes", "no" or "I, MM, don't know".
Clearly, as these three options enumerate the possible answers, and are disjoint, you can decide on an answer. I understand that it causes you great pain and distress to spell out an honest answer by typing the three letters "y", "e" and "s", but try to be a man (or a woman - don't know which you are; not a spineless sponge at any rate), muster all your courage, stop running away, and just answer it. Thank you.
When (and if) you have given a simple answer of "yes" or "no", please follow up with an (honest and courageous, if have it in you) answer to:
Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?
Do not invoke Millette when answering this question. Do not invoke DSC or any other heating, as you damned well know that no such test is recorded for chips a-d - I don't want to read that lie once more.
We'll get to Millette after you have given your answers to both questions honestly and courageously.