WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

"A member of our team has undertaken FTIR studies which I hope will provide the answers we seek."

-- Dr. Steven Jones, 2009-02-02

MM- Do you feel the same about the author of the Bentham papers who have withheld not only their FTIR results but also the TEM data? Millette has a full time job that doesnt involve 9/11; the authors of the Bentham paper job is anything to do with 9/11. Why do you not hold them to the same standards? I know if Millette did a DSC and withheld his data from the public's view, you would be the first one to cry cover up and demand the release of that data.

They can use that same ole "well if nobody has refuted the paper then no need to release all the data" argument that suits them.

You have to give it to MM guys he isnt that big of a fool. He is smart enough not to answer any questions as it would put him in quite a predicament and open his opinions to scrutiny. At least he dropped the argument of resistivity being part of the isolation process even though it took Mark Basile's own work to do it.
 
Oystein said:
Dr. Millette describes red-gray chips with the morphological characteristics:
  1. Fe/O rich grains, 100-200 nm in size
  2. Al/Si-rich platelets, less than 1 micron thin
and that those match specimens described by Harrit et al.
But that is untrue.
Huh?
What is untrue, specifically?
That Millette describes red-gray chips with the morphological characteristic "Fe/O rich grains, 100-200 nm in size"? But that is true, he does describe this, I quoted him!
That Millette describes red-gray chips with the morphological characteristic "Al/Si-rich platelets, less than 1 micron thin"? But that is true, he does describe this, I quoted him!
That Harrit's red-gray chips a-d have the morphological characteristic "Fe/O rich grains, 100-200 nm in size"? But that is true! See Fig. 8, 10 and 11b!
That Harrit's red-gray chips a-d have the morphological characteristic "Al/Si-rich platelets, less than 1 micron thin"? But that is true! See Fig. 8, 10 and 11a!

MM, what in the stuff you quoted is untrue? Nothing!


I cut out all the other crap. It was full of lies and lying insinuations.
Your dodging appears extremely cowardly and dishonest.
Stop the dodging.
Stop the lies.
Act like a man or woman of courage and honor!


Please answer the following question:

Are chips a-d the same material?

Please answer this very simply with "yes", "no" or "I, MM, don't know".
Clearly, as these three options enumerate the possible answers, and are disjoint, you can decide on an answer. I understand that it causes you great pain and distress to spell out an honest answer by typing the three letters "y", "e" and "s", but try to be a man (or a woman - don't know which you are; not a spineless sponge at any rate), muster all your courage, stop running away, and just answer it. Thank you.


When (and if) you have given a simple answer of "yes" or "no", please follow up with an (honest and courageous, if have it in you) answer to:

Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?

Do not invoke Millette when answering this question. Do not invoke DSC or any other heating, as you damned well know that no such test is recorded for chips a-d - I don't want to read that lie once more.
We'll get to Millette after you have given your answers to both questions honestly and courageously.
 
Last edited:
"Quite correct.

Dr. Millette describes red-gray chips with morphological characteristics that match those specimens described by Harrit et al.
"
[edited to make the intended point clear and specific]

And I replied that it is untrue.

Plain and simple.

Resemblance to a loaded gun means nothing until you squeeze the trigger.

Because Dr. Millette's findings show 9/11 WTC dust chip selections that would not share the same chemical behavioural signatures as the hundreds of 9/11 WTC dust chips that have been found to be thermitic, "MATCH" cannot apply.

Logically there must be morphological differences in order to account for the hundreds of chips ignited by senior chemical engineer Mark Basile.

9/11 WTC dust chips which ignited at ~430 C and produced iron-rich micro-spheroids in their residue.

So, it does not matter if Dr. Millette observed "Fe/O rich grains, 100-200 nm in size" or "Al/Si-rich platelets, less than 1 micron thin."

To prove a match, Dr. Millette has to take his preserved sheet of 9/11 WTC red/gray dust chips and heat it a little higher then he did the first time.

So simple.

But you have to "pull the trigger."

MM
 
Last edited:
Because Dr. Millette's findings show 9/11 WTC dust chip selections that would not share the same chemical behavioural signatures as the hundreds of 9/11 WTC dust chips that have been found to be thermitic, "MATCH" cannot apply.

And with that statement above, have just proved Harrit's paper wrong.

Harrit and his cohorts believe that every single red/gray chip extracted from the dust samples with a magnet are thermitic. You have been shown quote after quote in the paper that reinforces this, including the conclusion.

The fact that Milltte uses the same exact extraction criteria listed in the paper and found "different chips" proves Harrit's paper is a farce.
 
To prove a match, Dr. Millette has to take his preserved sheet of 9/11 WTC red/gray dust chips and heat it a little higher then he did the first time.

So simple.

So simple?

Answer this MM. How can Harrit and his cohorts claim that Delassio/Breidenbach sample contained thermtitic chips? According to their paper, they didn't test it. They didn't publish DSC results for it.

How do you know the chips from that sample were a match?
 
MM,

The problem is that Harrit and his group believe that every single red/gray chip extracted from samples with a magnet are thermitic.

That is why the tests were done on RANDOM chips. Chips did not get ALL the same tests performed on them.

They took all the results from random tests done on random chips and stereotyped them ALL as being thermtic.

Then Jones (and a couple of others) opened their mouths and said that there was different kinds of red/gray chips that they found, including paint. Which is further backed up by Millette's tests.

OOPS!

So now the paper is proven to be wrong and Harrit or Jones won't answer any inquiries about it because they KNOW it's wrong.
 
[edited to make the intended point clear and specific]

And I replied that it is untrue.

Plain and simple.

Resemblance to a loaded gun means nothing until you squeeze the trigger.

Because Dr. Millette's findings show 9/11 WTC dust chip selections that would not share the same chemical behavioural signatures as the hundreds of 9/11 WTC dust chips that have been found to be thermitic, "MATCH" cannot apply.

Logically there must be morphological differences in order to account for the hundreds of chips ignited by senior chemical engineer Mark Basile.

9/11 WTC dust chips which ignited at ~430 C and produced iron-rich micro-spheroids in their residue.

So, it does not matter if Dr. Millette observed "Fe/O rich grains, 100-200 nm in size" or "Al/Si-rich platelets, less than 1 micron thin."

To prove a match, Dr. Millette has to take his preserved sheet of 9/11 WTC red/gray dust chips and heat it a little higher then he did the first time.

So simple.

But you have to "pull the trigger."

MM

So your claim must be the Harrit et al paper is not repeatable?

Harrit agrees that chips (a-d) are the same.

Why do you disagree? :confused:

ETA: Why do you keep bringing up Millette? He has nothing to do with the question.
 
Last edited:
MM,

Why can you not answer Oystein's question below? Why do you keep avoiding it? As has been pointed out to you many times, it has nothing to do with Millette or his paper. It's about the four chips (a-d) in Harrit's paper.

Please answer the following question:

Are chips a-d the same material?

Please answer this very simply with "yes", "no" or "I, MM, don't know".
Clearly, as these three options enumerate the possible answers, and are disjoint, you can decide on an answer. I understand that it causes you great pain and distress to spell out an honest answer by typing the three letters "y", "e" and "s", but try to be a man (or a woman - don't know which you are; not a spineless sponge at any rate), muster all your courage, stop running away, and just answer it. Thank you.


When (and if) you have given a simple answer of "yes" or "no", please follow up with an (honest and courageous, if have it in you) answer to:

Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?

Do not invoke Millette when answering this question. Do not invoke DSC or any other heating, as you damned well know that no such test is recorded for chips a-d - I don't want to read that lie once more.
We'll get to Millette after you have given your answers to both questions honestly and courageously.
 
MM,

Why can you not answer Oystein's question below? Why do you keep avoiding it? As has been pointed out to you many times, it has nothing to do with Millette or his paper. It's about the four chips (a-d) in Harrit's paper.
The answer is simple. It would force him to address/compare the papers on a strictly scientific level. Something no "truther" wants to do.

Belief is funny that way. ;)
 
"Resemblance to a loaded gun means nothing until you squeeze the trigger.

Because Dr. Millette's findings show 9/11 WTC dust chip selections that would not share the same chemical behavioural signatures as the hundreds of 9/11 WTC dust chips that have been found to be thermitic, "MATCH" cannot apply.

Logically there must be morphological differences in order to account for the hundreds of chips ignited by senior chemical engineer Mark Basile.

9/11 WTC dust chips which ignited at ~430 C and produced iron-rich micro-spheroids in their residue.

So, it does not matter if Dr. Millette observed "Fe/O rich grains, 100-200 nm in size" or "Al/Si-rich platelets, less than 1 micron thin."

To prove a match, Dr. Millette has to take his preserved sheet of 9/11 WTC red/gray dust chips and heat it a little higher then he did the first time.

So simple.

But you have to "pull the trigger."
"ETA: Why do you keep bringing up Millette? He has nothing to do with the question."

He has everything to do with the topic of this thread.

MM
 
"A member of our team has undertaken FTIR studies which I hope will provide the answers we seek."

-- Dr. Steven Jones, 2009-02-02


MM- Do you feel the same about the author of the Bentham papers who have withheld not only their FTIR results but also the TEM data? Millette has a full time job that doesnt involve 9/11; the authors of the Bentham paper job is anything to do with 9/11. Why do you not hold them to the same standards? I know if Millette did a DSC and withheld his data from the public's view, you would be the first one to cry cover up and demand the release of that data.

They can use that same ole "well if nobody has refuted the paper then no need to release all the data" argument that suits them.

You have to give it to MM guys he isnt that big of a fool. He is smart enough not to answer any questions as it would put him in quite a predicament and open his opinions to scrutiny. At least he dropped the argument of resistivity being part of the isolation process even though it took Mark Basile's own work to do it.

Funny, isn't it? It's four years later, and Jones, Harrit, et al have absolutely nothing to lose, except whatever is left of their reputations, by releasing their data. Maybe, they're being kind to all the truthers who believed that paint was really magic nanothermite, akin to the hayseeds who believe the carnie barker when he tells them that the cow fetus in the jar is really a sea monster.
 
MM, Millette followed the Bentham protocol for isolating the chips as does Basile's new proposed study. So are you now saying this is the wrong method for identifying the chips of interest that you want to examine? If so, then how can you truly replicate a study where the information for isolating the chips is insufficient?

Better call Basile up and let him know he needs to correct his methods for isolating the chips of interest before he does the study. No need in wasting money on a study that you think is already flawed.
 
Too funny that they have this information that would blow this case wide open and they refuse to release it.

They dont care about their audience, in my opinion, but only are focused on lining their pockets. They are trying to milk this cow for as long as they can.


Notice how Jones announced he would be moving on to a new study around the time of the Millette report; he knows he cant use "the study hasnt been refuted" argument.
 
And I replied that it is untrue.

Plain and simple.

Resemblance to a loaded gun means nothing until you squeeze the trigger.

Apparently, then, you don't actually mean that the morphological characteristics don't match. You mean that you don't care whether they match -- and that makes Oystein's statement "untrue." Interesting.

Logically there must be morphological differences in order to account for the hundreds of chips ignited by senior chemical engineer Mark Basile.

If "morphological" is construed to mean whatsoever you want it to mean, I suppose that statement makes perfect sense. Otherwise, it's a puzzlement.

Come to think of it, since Millette was describing a comparison to the specimens examined by Harrit et al. -- not chips ignited by senior chemical engineer Mark Basile, nor any other Mark Basile -- the statement is, at best, equivocal regardless of the definition of "morphological."
 
Last edited:
2009 Bentham paper said:
"When ignited in a DSC device the chips exhibit large but narrow exotherms occurring at approximately 430 °C, far below the normal ignition temperature for conventional thermite."

Dr. James Millette said:
"My assessment of the situation is that researchers performed DSC on some WTC chips and found what they thought was an exothermic reaction."

2009 Bentham paper said:
"Numerous iron-rich spheres are clearly observed in the residue following the ignition of these peculiar red/gray chips."

Dr. James Millette said:
"Their microscopical analysis showed some results that they concluded were consistent with thermite or nano-thermite. I was asked to analyze the materials to see if I could confirm or not confirm their conclusion."

Dr. Millette confirms that he was asked to analyze materials that matched those tested by the scientists who published the 2009 Bentham paper.

The determining results on which the 2009 Bentham paper bases its conclusive finding of "thermite or nanothermite" were obtained from ignition and subsequent microscopical analysis of the post-ignition residue.

Having read the 2009 Bentham paper, Dr. Millette knew how to get conclusive results.

Dr. Millette knew the easy route to refuting the 2009 Bentham paper.

He had the lab, the dust, and the time to ignite the chips and examine the residue.

But as we all know.

Dr. Millette decided, that a non-destructive analysis which avoided igniting any of his 9/11 WTC dust chip selections was sufficient to prove a shared chemical identity with other chips found to ignite and produce iron-rich micro-spheroids in their post-ignition residue.

He felt no need to actually ignite one as an experimental proof.

Even after finishing the analysis of his chosen chips which I guess now sit in an envelope in a filing cabinet.

And so the inconclusive findings of his unpublished report have little traction when attempting to infer that hundreds of chips observed to ignite and produce iron-rich micro-spheroids were an impossibility.

Photographed ignitions - impossible?

Iron-rich micro-spheroids - impossible?

Observations by:

Dr. Harrit - impossible?
Dr. Jones - Impossible?
Dr. Farrer - Impossible?
Mark Basile - Impossible?
and others - Impossible?

What is impossible is that Dr. Millette can be certain that the chips he evaluated were a match for those highlighted in the 2009 Bentham paper conclusions.

MM
 
The determining results on which the 2009 Bentham paper bases its conclusive finding of "thermite or nanothermite" were obtained from ignition and subsequent microscopical analysis of the post-ignition residue.

Yet Harrit didn't do a DSC test on the Delassio/Breidenbach and concludes that all the red/gray chips extracted by a magent are thermitic.

This, among other issues, renders Harrit's paper inconclusive by your own words.
 
Still too afraid to actually answer the question.

Funny thing. Harrit did (along with everyone else involved with the paper). :rolleyes:

Anyone still have any doubts about why MM won't do it?

Nope.

;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom