William Rodriguez: "I am 9/11!"

Gravy,

Have you recived any reply from Willy regarding your "escape artist" paper?
Has he made any sort of rebuttal?
He said he wasn't looking for a debate and that he'd be discussing these issues in the national media (you know, the same national media that he accuses of suppressing his story and criminalizing Muslims).

I didn't offer him a debate. I offered to print his response to my paper. The offer remains open, but I doubt that he'll take it.
 
He said he wasn't looking for a debate and that he'd be discussing these issues in the national media (you know, the same national media that he accuses of suppressing his story and criminalizing Muslims).

If I were Willy I'd first patch up the holes in my story and then go to the national media.
 
"I'm Argentina, and always will be" -- Evita

"I am the law!" -- Judge Dredd, comic book version

"I am the lrgghglghnll" -- Judge Dredd, Stallone version

"I yam what I yam" -- Popeye

"I am that I am" -- Yaweh

"Oh, who is writing poetry sublime?
Iamb, Iamb, Iamb, Iamb, Iamb" -- Shakespeare (not really)

Respectfully,
Myriad


"I am not an American. I am the American." --Frank Fuller (Frequently misattributed to Mark Twain.)
 
"I am the Guardian of Forever. I am my own beginning, my own ending."

Giant Bagel of Time Displacement in: The City On The Edge Of Forever, Star Trek, 1st season.
 
Hehe...I love how LashL is perfectly polite and friendly, but the minute someone goes too far...LEGAL SMACKDOWN!

:D
 
LashL; said:
Your posts indicate otherwise.

Oh, please. Spare me your "internet lawyering" - I'm a real life, actual, practicing, trial lawyer. You claimed that the actions of people here "bordered on slander". You were wrong and I pointed that out to you. Now, you are pretending that you said something different, purporting to lecture me on the law of defamation, and moving the goalposts - probably after googling the difference between libel and slander and realizing that you were wrong in your prior post. Sorry, 3b, but words have meaning. You are entirely out of line and your attempt to reframe your prior post is entirely transparent.

WOW, you argue for a living, I find that hard to believe. Show me exactly how I was wrong or retract your accusation. You can't and I'll tell you why. Notice the qualifier "bordered", good luck arguing around that LashL. Or are you seriously holding onto the assumption that these statements aren't in any way slanderous? Check the law and get back to me. You'll find both are equally acceptable in this case. Arguing semantics seems beneath you, but if you think its pertinent let's rock.

LashL; said:
Wrong again, 3b. I have presumed nothing.

You admitted that William Rodriguez has been offered specifically to present his side of the story and has refused and dodged the offer. As such, he has not even presented his "facts and evidence" contrary to your "facts and evidence". And yet you seem fit to label him as being libelous. Now isn't that a little presumptuous?




LashL; said:
Either you have not read the threads as you claim or you do not understand them. Once you have read them, you can ask for clarification of the parts you don't understand and I'll be happy to assist you. The only one libelling anyone around here is William Rodriguez.

Ahh, an attack on my intelligence and an insinuation of my attempt to deceive. Is this how a lawyer makes her case? All I heard was "MEOW".

LashL; said:
Your weariness does not concern me. Your inability or unwillingness to research the issues upon which you purport to opine, however, does. Had you done a modicum of research into these particular issues, you would know why your allegations are entirely unfounded. I have no knowledge of what deliberations you engaged in before posting your erroneous assertions, and I take no issue with the fact that you felt that you were doing what "was right" even though your assertions were wrong.

"Taking a quote out of context and then running a smear campaign with it seems below this forum. While some may not agree with what Mr. Rodriguez has said or done this thread is hardly above that."

Point out the error in this statement or retract your accusation.

LashL; said:
The last paragraph of your post includes ridiculous and rhetorical questions which require no response. I could just as easily ask, "Why should I have to respond to such obvious erroneous posts and ridiculous questions, and why should anyone for that matter?" but doing so would be just as useless and silly as those portions of your post.

That's funny. You say you have no response to the rhetorical question, and then you proceed to respond to it. That kinda doesn't make it rhetorical now does it?

LashL; said:
And here is an unsolicited, but genuine, piece of advice for you: Don't quit your day job.

Aww, you got all flustered and missed the whole point LashL. I believe the same thing as you, I just don't believe that this is the right way to go about it.
And of course, here is an unsolicited, just as genuine piece of advice for you: Your obsession with Willie is showing
 
Gravy,

Have you recived any reply from Willy regarding your "escape artist" paper?
Has he made any sort of rebuttal?


WR at LCF:

William_Rodriguez said:
7. Why I do not answer Mark Roberts? because it is a compendium of personal speculations on his part and an effort destroy my efforts. I received more support after his piece, and engagements from all over. As a matter of fact, we are putting many of his things on a new video. In a way he made the work easier because we can adress them directly on my presentations. I just booked the WHOLE summer in EUROPE and I am leaving this Friday. If I spent my time answering every attacker, it will stop me from doing the amount of work I do out there and the outreach. You remember in this forum the efforts from a looser with a 2 cents TV show to engage me one way or the other. I do not need anybody making a name for themselves with me. I do that on my own.

http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/index.php?showtopic=10411&st=0
 
Billy the snakeoil salesman said...
I do not need anybody making a name for themselves with me. I do that on my own.

No truer words have been typed, or spoken!
 
"Taking a quote out of context and then running a smear campaign with it seems below this forum. While some may not agree with what Mr. Rodriguez has said or done this thread is hardly above that."

Point out the error in this statement or retract your accusation.

Easy. The quote wasn't taken out of context. On top of that, William has since come to this forum and repeated himself verbatum.

I am sure LashL will accept your admission of error when she returns to the forums next.
 
WOW, you argue for a living, I find that hard to believe. Show me exactly how I was wrong or retract your accusation. You can't and I'll tell you why. Notice the qualifier "bordered", good luck arguing around that LashL. Or are you seriously holding onto the assumption that these statements aren't in any way slanderous?

Well, for one thing, it's not slander. You mean libel, if anything. Slander is spoken.

For another, may I suggest you look up the term "libel-proof." Whether it applies in this case, I cannot say, although I have my opinion. But I think exploring that term, and the defenses for libel in general, might be found...interesting. :cool:
 
Easy. The quote wasn't taken out of context. On top of that, William has since come to this forum and repeated himself verbatum.

I am sure LashL will accept your admission of error when she returns to the forums next.




Exactly. My post from 16 hours ago:

Originally Posted by 3bodyproblem
Taking a quote out of context and then running a smear campaign with it seems below this forum. While some may not agree with what Mr. Rodriguez has said or done this thread is hardly above that.
Well, maybe you could put THIS in context, then?



Quote:
Originally Posted by William Rodriguez
Many accused me of exploting 9/11. I am 9/11!
No one mined this out of context. And just to make it clear, he came here and repeated it.

3B, your entire argument stems from that "out of context" idea, and no one took it out of context. I read through the entire thread at LCF and he repeatedly thumps his own chest in the same vein/spirit.

Further, while I don't speak for Lash (a mouthpiece for a mouthpiece, now that'd be interesting), I believe she was referring to William's statements on this thread (which have been removed to AAH) as being much closer to slander/libel than anything the JREFers have been posting.
 
WOW, you argue for a living, I find that hard to believe. Show me exactly how I was wrong or retract your accusation. You can't and I'll tell you why. Notice the qualifier "bordered", good luck arguing around that LashL. Or are you seriously holding onto the assumption that these statements aren't in any way slanderous? Check the law and get back to me.
I'm sure LashL will address this herself, but here's my layman's take: it ain't libel if it's true.

You admitted that William Rodriguez has been offered specifically to present his side of the story and has refused and dodged the offer. As such, he has not even presented his "facts and evidence" contrary to your "facts and evidence". And yet you seem fit to label him as being libelous. Now isn't that a little presumptuous?
His side of the story is extensively documented. You can read all about it here. I'm sure you'll be able to purchase his video version of the "truth" real soon.

Taking a quote out of context and then running a smear campaign with it seems below this forum.
It's not about one quote. It's about a body of work and the attitude of a man who values self-promotion and making political statements over truth. The quote exemplifies that attitude.
 
William is a buffer between us and the truthers, a shield that they hide behind as if to say "You call him a liar, he helped and aided people!".

It is somewhat defining of truthers, as they cherry pick evidence and in this case, a witness to one of the worst terrorist attacks in the history of man.

However, they tend to leave out the FDNY, hundreds of first responders, the 8000 man team at the pentagon, and the 1,100 man team at Flight 93's crash site. All who picked up human remains and form part of what you call the "governments official story". Guess what, it is not the "governments official story", it is the story of normal people who saw burnt bodies in their flight seats that could be your family members.

You have a man who speaks for you on your forums and your films, we on the other hand do not. Why? Because the vast majority do their jobs, and do not milk the cash cow for all it is worth. They do not want money or fame, they want to carry on with their lives, and it would help if you truthers stopped cowardly accusing them of covering up mass murder because they do not choose to have a public face.

Back in 1995 my father was stabbed when he put himself between the body of a boy on a North-London street being attacked by an iron bar. Unfortunatly he did not survive that attack, and I feel pride in his sacrafice every day.
But I feel pride because he acted like all of us should act, he acted like a man should act. If he survived, would it be right for him to tour the world saying what he did and how he did it? Would it be right for him to make money on what he did? It seems that simply because you were involved in an event that played before all our own eyes, you get more of a right to speak and make money over it? There are heroic acts performed by ordinary people every day, and you, on a humanitarian level, are no different. You are only different because you hold yourself to be, with the camera's and the spotlights thrust in your face.

You behaved like a true man on that day William, but you survived. 3000 did not. You are not 9/11. And saying you are, and getting money from all over the world, not on the issue of those people you helped, nor those we lost, but on a loud bang that has been debunked time and time again, destroys the humanitarinism you displayed on that day.

You are not 9/11. Nobody is 9/11. But here is one truth. 11th September 2001 was a day in which thousands of people joined together to save lives. And you are the only one attempting to give speeches and get paid for it.


Fourthed on the nomination.
 
O man, I know I'm a newb, I should read up on this, WR is really unfair, yada yada yada

Bottomline: 3bodyproblem is not WR, just an honest guy with an honest opinion.

So if we could keep our eye on the ball and not harass everyone that posts an opinion you don't like, the comments would start to make some more sense... even to the newbies

All these comments are highly emotional due to statements made in the distant (relevant) past... Not all of us have been in on those discussions... If that means it disqualifies anyone else from having an opinion or even forming one on their own in this forum, then that's sad.

As a skeptic, I think we should leave the biased opinions to the truthers and stick to the subject of the thread. Honestly and openly looking at what WR says, evaluate it, discuss it in this forum, without any prejudice and all of the negative emotions surrounding it. All good posts in here have... And some have been really worth reading. Especially Undesired Walrus...

Thanks

SYL :)
 
Last edited:
I no longer feel the need to put a "disclaimer" before everything I type about William Rodriguez. The usual "I'm not saying William Rodriguez wasn't a hero on 9/11" seems rather pointless, as his degree of lying in the aftermath of the attacks now far exceeds his actions on 9/11. The way I saw him in the past was to give him some slack because of his favorable actions at the World Trade Center on 9/11, before I addressed his post-9/11 garbage. It almost seemed as he was unwillingly misguided. Now, I'm just sick of his crap.

It is possible for the man to be a hero and a liar, it's a shame that he's exemplifying the latter to such an extent.

I'd say quit while you're ahead William, but it appears that you've already dug your own grave.
 
To further The Doc's point I'd like to add that I too am quite sick of the necessity of disclaimers anytime something related to William Rodriguez is discussed. The issue of him saving people on 9/11 and his supplication to Conspiracy Theorists thereafter are exclusive from one another. Calling him on the inconsistencies, illogic and impossibilities of his accounts is not saying he did not perform heroic actions. Likewise acknowledging said heroic acts does not and should not endorse his various conspiracy theory type claims. He was present at the worst terrorist attacks of modern times, this does not make him an automatic expert in modern terrorism. You need someone to talk about hauling injured co-workers up from a basement, then he's your man. If you need someone to talk about whether NORAD intercepted the flights, well then you should trust NEADS tape transcripts and ATC accounts.

Nobody here is trying to take anything away from what the man did on 9/11 but being a hero on one day does not give someone carte blanche to lie everyday thereafter. If he really felt the way he does and was really willing to stand behind it then why did he not take the opportunity to bring these issues up when he was actually talking with the actual NIST investigators?

Others here are right when they note that Truthers are using Mr Rodriguez as a shield to cover over their own innate inability to speak with authority on anything concerning events they claim to care so very much about. Hiding behind the actions of a "hero" to mask your own inadequacies is the absolute opposite of "heroic" as it is shameful and cowardly to the highest order. Likewise relegating oneself as a sycophant to a movement that does not think twice of claiming the FDNY, NYPD and NORAD were complicit in murder is also shameful and cowardly.
 
Where is William, by the way?

He mentioned that he's booked a whole summer in Europe, but there's no schedule posted anywhere and I can't find any blurbs mentioning him associated with any of the Euro-Troofer sites.

This is actually something that puzzles me about Wm. He is most definitely into self-promotion, but his blog and website are woefully late in getting up any updates. He has a link to a schedule of his February UK tour, but that looks like it was created by someone (probably in the UK) just to promote that tour. He lists no upcoming events on his site.

So what's he off to Europe to do? He mentioned the Europe trip on the LCF forum, when talking about how successful and swell he has become, and someone mentioned that they were traveling 300 miles to see him.... But where?
 
I no longer feel the need to put a "disclaimer" before everything I type about William Rodriguez. The usual "I'm not saying William Rodriguez wasn't a hero on 9/11" seems rather pointless, as his degree of lying in the aftermath of the attacks now far exceeds his actions on 9/11. The way I saw him in the past was to give him some slack because of his favorable actions at the World Trade Center on 9/11, before I addressed his post-9/11 garbage. It almost seemed as he was unwillingly misguided. Now, I'm just sick of his crap.

It is possible for the man to be a hero and a liar, it's a shame that he's exemplifying the latter to such an extent.

I'd say quit while you're ahead William, but it appears that you've already dug your own grave.

Well said. The whole "9/11 hero" spiel we usually get if we ask questions of WR is nothing but an appeal to emotion and has nothing to do with the conspiracy theories.

If only the truthers could understand this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom