Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Calebprime agrees wholeheartedly with Argumemnon and sunmaster14. How often does that happen?

Well, to be fair I don't agree with Sunmaster here, who will probably simply say that it's conservatives who are pragmatic. My point was rather that BOTH sides have liberal (pun intended) amounts of ideological blindness. And both sides have pragmatic considerations.

I'd still give the US conservatives the edge, but that's because the US has veered so much to the right that its "center" lies with the left. It's a very confusing sitution.
 
This is the most bizarro, perverse opinion I've seen in a long time. And I've spent a lot of time here at the ISF, so that's really saying something. It is 180 degrees opposite from my opinion, although I suspect most readers could have inferred that already.

I dunno.
I've seen opinions that say Clinton would have been worse than Trump.

That's pretty damn bizarro.
 
Are you serious here? Is that your personal opinion? I've seen scores of liberals who are consumed by ideology.

It’s a generalization of course, which means exceptions on both sides are inevitable. In many cases these exceptions will be Republicans or Democrats that are simply at odds with the mainstream of the party they vote for, but there are going to be some cases where they are baked into the parties themselves. This doesn’t make the general principle wrong though.
 
It’s a generalization of course, which means exceptions on both sides are inevitable. In many cases these exceptions will be Republicans or Democrats that are simply at odds with the mainstream of the party they vote for, but there are going to be some cases where they are baked into the parties themselves. This doesn’t make the general principle wrong though.

No but it means that I'm still waiting to know if this is just your opinion.
 
Well, to be fair I don't agree with Sunmaster here, who will probably simply say that it's conservatives who are pragmatic. My point was rather that BOTH sides have liberal (pun intended) amounts of ideological blindness. And both sides have pragmatic considerations.

I'd still give the US conservatives the edge, but that's because the US has veered so much to the right that its "center" lies with the left. It's a very confusing sitution.

Such as? How many Republican policy planks have fully realized pragmatic implementations attached to them? Now look at how many Democratic policy planks and see how many of those are aimed at actually implementing more general ideas. I’m not suggesting it’s all or nothing from either side, but it’s startling how few Mainstream Republican talking points are completely devoid of any pragmatic way to implement. In the flip side, while there are certainly some idealistic voters on the Democrat side, they are actually somewhat alienated from the direction of mainstream party.
 
No but it means that I'm still waiting to know if this is just your opinion.

It’s opinion obviously, as is pretty much anything related to politics. It’s formed by an outsider looking in on US politics and the policies supported by the mainstream “Liberal” and “Conservative” parties.
 
Such as? How many Republican policy planks have fully realized pragmatic implementations attached to them?

Did you do that on purpose or by accident, now? Substituting "Republican" for "conservative", I mean? You were talking about the latter and that's what I answered, and now you act as if we're discussing the former, instead.
 
Well, to be fair I don't agree with Sunmaster here, who will probably simply say that it's conservatives who are pragmatic. My point was rather that BOTH sides have liberal (pun intended) amounts of ideological blindness. And both sides have pragmatic considerations.

I'd still give the US conservatives the edge, but that's because the US has veered so much to the right that its "center" lies with the left. It's a very confusing sitution.

In what way has the US veered to the right? The federal government is bigger than ever, there are vastly more government agencies than there were before, and there are exponentially more regulations. What progressive political goals from, say, 50 years ago, remain to be achieved?
 
Liberals will never, repeat never, understand Conservatives. It's simple really. To change the United States away from the values and liberties it was founded on would in effect destroy it. You cannot or will not understand this principle, therefore you will never understand Conservatism.
 
Liberals will never, repeat never, understand Conservatives. It's simple really. To change the United States away from the values and liberties it was founded on would in effect destroy it. You cannot or will not understand this principle, therefore you will never understand Conservatism.

US liberals do understand that you want to destroy the values and liberties the US was founded on and that's enough. Nice of you to admit that's your aim, though.
 
US liberals do understand that you want to destroy the values and liberties the US was founded on and that's enough. Nice of you to admit that's your aim, though.

Speaking of aim, exactly how many Liberals are in favor of the 2nd Amendment?
Chris B.
 
Your disconnect with reality in the past two statements is a perfect example of the problems Liberals face. Chris B.

Your seeing things that aren't there is a perfect example of the problems "conservatives" face.
 
Liberals will never, repeat never, understand Conservatives. It's simple really. To change the United States away from the values and liberties it was founded on would in effect destroy it. You cannot or will not understand this principle, therefore you will never understand Conservatism.

Sure we do.

Conservatives are selfish, and only concentrate on topics that directly affect them, and them only.

This prevents them from ever seeing the big picture, or thinking long-term.
 
Speaking of aim, exactly how many Liberals are in favor of the 2nd Amendment?
Chris B.

Here's one right here. I just think the thing's terribly written.

Liberals will never, repeat never, understand Conservatives. It's simple really. To change the United States away from the values and liberties it was founded on would in effect destroy it. You cannot or will not understand this principle, therefore you will never understand Conservatism.

Funny thing is, the Founders were pretty liberal for the time. It's pretty silly to think they'd never imagine or things could change over centuries, or that they wouldn't want them to.
 
Sure we do.

Conservatives are selfish, and only concentrate on topics that directly affect them, and them only.

This prevents them from ever seeing the big picture, or thinking long-term.

There you are, what you think you know about Conservatives is wrong, yet you'll fight tooth and nails to keep that view/opinion........lost cause. Chris B.
 
Well, to be fair I don't agree with Sunmaster here, who will probably simply say that it's conservatives who are pragmatic. My point was rather that BOTH sides have liberal (pun intended) amounts of ideological blindness. And both sides have pragmatic considerations.

I'd still give the US conservatives the edge, but that's because the US has veered so much to the right that its "center" lies with the left. It's a very confusing sitution.

This contributes to confusion when people use terminology like "conservative" or "liberal" as proxies for "Republican" and "Democrat". There's too much overlap.

My observation is that Democrats are an alliance of Liberals and socially progressive fiscal Conservatives, while Republicans are a mix of social Conservatives and ultraconservative Reactionaries with a fiscally naiive Libertarian economic model.

I'm Canadian, but if I were to describe myself, I'd say I was a Conservative, and I would have voted Democrat, because I think they have the right balance of government and liberty and appropriate social objectives and economic and diplomatic long term plans that satisfy a Conservative's measured caution.



Back to Wowbagger's OP... one thing I have observed about skeptics is that we act like these cartoon Liberal Elites pretty consistently. We're the "They" in "They act like they know better than the average guy."

I withdrew from organized skepticism in part because I thought there was no coherent outreach strategy.

When I read The Righteous Mind, it did ping my alarm bells about the prospects for skepticism, because his professional research matched my amateur research. Skeptics are terrible at outreach because we have no empathy for those who are on the receiving end of our 'education' and use crappy technique.

I think this is an agnostic topic, not specific to skeptical subject matter, or even politics really.

Let's look at a specific example, and I know it is a sensitive topic, but let's consider Dawkins' approach. Number one: take for granted that the core morality is to reduce harm. Everything else (community cohesion, &c) needs to be subordinated to that ethic. OK, even if he's right, Conservatives disagree, so now what? Number two: there's no talking to these guys, so the right course of action is to mock their beliefs until they are sufficiently cowed. The Skeptical Champion is the same as the Liberal Elitist.



There's a root problem about a lack of empathy across the boundaries, because it has frustrated efforts to build a shared reality against which policy can be negotiated among people who have different values. Most Republicans don't really want sick people to die miserably. They just sincerely believe that deregulating medical care will provide cheaper healthcare for everybody. All the evidence to the contrary is Lies! Propaganda! Liberal Blinders! It's an information gap, and I'm not sure how to use Haidt's findings to mitigate that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom