ponderingturtle
Orthogonal Vector
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2006
- Messages
- 54,796
What of these explains how unpopular Obamacare is, but all of its actual provisions are very popular?
Another point : for the values liberal values, he made them in quasi general applicable everywhere care and fairness. But for those of conservative he sliced them in small parcel, and then he is surprised conservative have more. e.g. Right of Choice is a high values to "liberals" , but is probably hidden in fairness, whereas sanctity cover far far less situation then fairness, but in reality is on the other side of right-of-choice/fairness.
Had he had values "versus" other values situation by situation it would become even more apparent, whereas just having them in a list hide that.
I am not saying it was intentional, but it is clearly a flaw.
Without reading further I am betting if I google it I will find out that Haidt is a conservative : he pretty much has a good grasp of the fine granularity of the values of conservative as a whole, but seem to have a blind spot on the fine granularity of values of liberals...
ETA: I was right he switched to "self declared atheist and liberal" to "center"
Wouldn't a clown be better than a corrupt person?
.
Yes, but liberals have it worse in that department.
Wouldn't a clown be better than a corrupt person?
Why settle for the glass half empty?
We can have both! Make America Great Again!
Regarding the book that inspired the thread topic, having read some more excerpts from the book, I think it makes some good points. I'm unimpressed with the idea that conservatives are somehow "broader" because the author came up with a certain number of descriptors that fit, but fewer descriptors for liberals. If we throw in "diversity" and "sensitivity" and "multiculturalism" or "environmentally friendly" or.....you get the idea. On the other hand, I thought the point about how they see conservatives was pretty good. Leftists value "compassion", and insist that anyone who doesn't accept their policy initiatives obviously must lack compassion. That's wrong, but it's a mistake repeated over and over.
And that's exactly the problem the left has had for years. The instant an average lefty finds out you're slightly less lefty than (s)he is, anything resembling a real conversation is over, replaced by a rabid reality-free Travisoid stream of "racist sexist homophobe Nazi fascist misogynist anti-Semite male inbred megacorporate racist sexist homophobe Nazi fascist misogynist anti-Semite inbred white megacorporate racist sexist homophobe Nazi fascist misogynist anti-Semite inbred megacorporate racist American sexist homophobe Nazi fascist misogynist..."I've found that the most productive political conversations/arguments I've had with people are the ones where there is no vilification and the parties involved see each other as fellow citizens and human beings who basically want the same things in the end. If I make an argument against Single-Payer healthcare, it doesn't mean I don't have empathy or I want people to die. Telling me I lack empathy or want people to die is going to make me start to disregard your argument.
And that's exactly the problem the left has had for years. The instant an average lefty finds out you're slightly less lefty than (s)he is, anything resembling a real conversation is over, replaced by a rabid reality-free Travisoid stream of "racist sexist homophobe Nazi fascist misogynist anti-Semite male inbred megacorporate racist sexist homophobe Nazi fascist misogynist anti-Semite inbred white megacorporate racist sexist homophobe Nazi fascist misogynist anti-Semite inbred megacorporate racist American sexist homophobe Nazi fascist misogynist..."
Such a break from reality is practically never productive, and it's how they've managed to pull off failures like the recent election, but it's also the only reaction they can come up with when it fails them, so the only result is more of the same, like a computer whose programmers didn't give it a no-division-by-zero rule dutifully trying to divide by zero forever.
Really? Where have you encountered this?
Could you give an example, please. Or really, multiple examples, as you assert this is happening "(t)he instant an average lefty finds out you're slightly less lefty than (s)he is", i.e, with all leftists all the time.
So, go ahead. Evidence.
A British example: anyone in the uk labour party to the right of momentum/corbyn (i.e. blairites) tends to get "red tory", "tory lite " screamed at them.
Yes, Europeans drop by the US politics forum weekly to point this out. It's neither a novel observation, nor a relevant one, but they do it anyway.it's interesting to hear Americans discuss liberals.
I often wonder if they simply don't realise that their idea of liberal is fairly right wing for the rest of the world?
Loyalty, Sanctity, and Authority.
I would rather lose every election that follows than ever admit there is any value in those awful notions as applied to morality.
I mean...sanctity? What kind of sick, twisted person sees any value in sanctity?
Really? Where have you encountered this?
Could you give an example, please. Or really, multiple examples, as you assert this is happening "(t)he instant an average lefty finds out you're slightly less lefty than (s)he is", i.e, with all leftists all the time.
So, go ahead. Evidence.
When it comes to loyalty, I think it is often widely regarded as a good thing to have some loyalty to certain groups such as family. I think Haidt makes the argument that conservatives and those from certain other cultures are more likely to put a larger emphasis on loyalty and extend it to certain kin affiliations that liberals may not.
In terms of authority, I think it is also common among certain theories of the social contract that there is a legitimate authority such as the police, the government etc... in fact, I think you also have very authoritarian instincts that you can rationalize.
Sanctity sounds a bit god squady but it could include things that people see as having non material value such as Indian burial grounds or whatever.
The point of the OP is that a lot of failures of communication happen when people say, "I can't imagine why these pricks think what they do unless it is because they are pathologically bad people!" Ironically a lot of that seems to be happening in this thread with some people reacting without thinking thus supporting Haidt's contention.
Why It Matters
Well, with Donald Trump as our President-elect I suppose it's pretty obvious why this matters, now! But, importantly: Some of us saw this coming!
The single most important thing to realize is that Liberals are pragmatists while Conservatives are idealists.
The single most important thing to realize is that Liberals are pragmatists while Conservatives are idealists. A lot of people miss this because up until ~1990 it was the opposite.
As a result conservatives are more likely to buy into simple sound-bite solutions to complex problems. Give the evolution of modern conservatives these simple solutions are often contradictory and/or doomed to fail if executed in their simple form. Furthermore these have reached the level of dogma with Conservatives so that they view the simple form not just as a basis for policy but a form of morality in its own right so that even attempting a pragmatic implementation is heresy and therefore something to be opposed.
For example when Liberals try to implement policy to create a functioning free market Conservatives oppose it under the guise of supporting free markets. When Liberals try to make pragmatic policy balance the budget, conservatives oppose it because “taxes” and/or “we need more military spending” even though they have no concept of how low taxes need to be or how much needs to be spent on the military. The only answer their dogma allows for tax rate is ”lower” regardless of how low they are. The only answer their dogma allows on military spending is “more” regardless of how much is currently being spent. Because these are both essentially “moral” stances they never need to connect the dots that these are mutually exclusive.
To me the big takeaway is that the oft presumed tendency of young people to vote Democrat is wrong. Younger voters tend towards idealism and going forward are more prone to voting Republican even though they differ on the issues. Eg young people are concerned about climate change, but the simple idealistic solution of “the free market will fix it” is going to resonate with them while the more pragmatic view is that climate change is a consequence of market failures that need to be regulated will not
Are you serious here? Is that your personal opinion? I've seen scores of liberals who are consumed by ideology.
This is the most bizarro, perverse opinion I've seen in a long time. And I've spent a lot of time here at the ISF, so that's really saying something. It is 180 degrees opposite from my opinion, although I suspect most readers could have inferred that already.
Michael Moore also "saw this coming" with a radically different (and considerable more convincing) explanation: Demagoguery works when frustration reaches a sufficiently high level.