Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Pedantic nitpick Roger: You're, not your. You repeated it too many times to excuse it as a typo.

Otherwise I mostly agree with you. :)
 
The problem we are dealing with is not 'conservatives', the current crowd who have taken over the Republican party are not conservative in any meaningful sense of the word, they want to burn the system down in the name of a vision of 'freedom' and a fantasy of a past that never existed.

Aside from liberals thinking conservatives are evil. Past policy's helped make this a very prosperous country. Liberals think "progress" is moving into big government socialism which has always failed. Big government socialism is not our future, less government and more freedom is what works and always has.
 
A Liberal will try all the sweets in the one restaurant, then try all the salts in the other and think others should have the right to do so.

A Conservative will try one salt, declare all the others sinful, pass laws to ban the use of any of the others and then occasionally beat to death someone who is open about wanting to try the others because Jesus.

The current government for the past eight years is in a fevered pitch to pass as many regulations as they can, just like the last eight years. The liberals of today are not supporters of freedom.
 
Another distinction is that a Liberal will forgo some medical treatment of themselves to help a needy family get some that otherwise would have received none.

A conservative will refuse medical treatment of themselves if it prevents a needy family from getting any treatment because they just can't stand the idea of others not being miserable and in pain.
Lol
An interesting reality, but total crap. How does a liberal forgoing medical treatment give it to another?

Why and how does a conservative refuse medical treatment, thereby, preventing another from getting it?
 
Another distinction is that a Liberal will forgo some medical treatment of themselves to help a needy family get some that otherwise would have received none.

A conservative will refuse medical treatment of themselves if it prevents a needy family from getting any treatment because they just can't stand the idea of others not being miserable and in pain.

You are making it difficult to see progressives as not totally absorbed by their wacky delusions
 
Your wrong. Trump is not the threat, the people who support him are. When 50% of the people who vote want a clown for president, you know the country is doomed - whoever wins.

Wouldn't a clown be better than a corrupt person?
Again your wrong. Even if the Democrats had garnered enough votes to 'win' we still would have lost.
Because you don't get to win with a few states. ;)
Evil is as Evil does. I used to think that most conservatives aren't evil - but a rational person can only deny the facts for so long...

I used to think liberals could have some morals, but one only has to open their eyes to see truth.
 
*Shrugs* It's how discussions are these days.

- My side is right, the other side is evil.
- Therefore there are all sorts of rules the other side has to follow when dealing with me, no rules in my side dealing with them since the ends of defeating them justifies any means.
- My side's extremist are all either Strawmen, Poes, or No True Scotsmans the other side's extremists are obviously representative of the entire group.
- Compromise means "The other side needs to just go ahead and realize I'm right."
 
*Shrugs* It's how discussions are these days.

- My side is right, the other side is evil.
- Therefore there are all sorts of rules the other side has to follow when dealing with me, no rules in my side dealing with them since the ends of defeating them justifies any means.
- My side's extremist are all either Strawmen, Poes, or No True Scotsmans the other side's extremists are obviously representative of the entire group.
- Compromise means "The other side needs to just go ahead and realize I'm right."
Well you could acknowledge the posts that don't say this instead of fulfilling your own prophecy here. I for one said no such thing.
 
As I see it, the problem is that conservative morality is more consistent with our baseline impulses. People are naturally tribal the same way they're naturally superstitious. Why wasn't religion vanquished long ago in this country? Is it because religion has compelling, rational arguments??

Here's one of Haidt's more notorious scenarios, one that only highly educated, hard-core liberals found permissible:

"Julie and Mark are brother and sister. They are traveling together in France on summer vacation from college. One night they are staying alone in a cabin near the beach. They decide that it would be interesting and fun if they tried making love. At the very least, it would be a new experience for each of them. Julie was already taking birth control pills, but Mark uses a condom too, just to be safe. They both enjoy making love, but they decide never to do it again. They keep that night as a special secret, which makes them feel even closer to each other. What do you think about that? Was it ok for them to make love?"

The following link deals addresses the ad hoc reasoning people use to defend their objections: https://www.psychologytoday.com/blo...what-s-the-matter-little-brothersister-action

The good news is that the "expanding circle"/the "escalator of reason"/whatever can help us see past the illusion. In the case of incest, our revulsion instinct makes sense: it's Mother Nature's cock-block to prevent genetic deformities. Modern prophylactics allow us to do an end-run around a perfectly good instinct. With learning and education, we can see that sexual orientation and race are morally arbitrary characteristics, but even militant liberals have their limits. One liberal on this very forum -- probably in a fit of frustration -- labeled an articulate advocate of veganism a "species traitor."

Effortlessly cosmopolitan elites find it relatively easier to be concerned about the plight of Syrian refugees, the suffering of humans abroad in general. What is a typical American going to say? A typical Democrat? "We should take care of people in our own country first." While Angelina Jolie might be celebrated in the popular media, it's incredibly unusual in human history for someone to use their own resources to raise non-biological children born thousands of miles away. For such radical altruism to make any sense to a "normal" person it must be filtered through a religious lens.
 
I doubt that. The cognitive elements that emerge as conservatism go too deep. In a future post I hope to emphasize this points by talking about how Moral Foundations Theory ties into other studies: Cognitive dissonance, evolutionary development, etc.

Actually, the conservative of today are not the one of 60 years or 120 years ago. Just like everybody, with generations moving on , they die out and are replaced by other type of conservative.
 
Semantic point. But, whatever.

It is more than a semantic point. Moral is a loaded word with connotation when you "lack them". By painting it as moral blind spot, the author already pre-taint the debate.

It is one thing to have different value, but a moral blind spot, or having less moral , etc... You are automatically painting liberals as immoral, with the baggage the "moral" word hold.

Researcher tend to use neutral wording to avoid the bias I am talking about....

Looking at his wiki, as a sociologist he should know better than that. And reading the criticism snippet I see about his work (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Haidt#Criticism) particularly the second one, I would like to see more than the snippet because I think I am starting to see an inherent bias against "non conservatism" in how this is handled.
 
This is an absolutely perfect example of the bubble that many (most actually) liberals have created for themselves. There are perfectly good reasons for opposing the mainstream liberal position on each and every one of these issues, and yet many liberals won't even allow for that possibility - instead resorting to the effortless and comfortable conclusion that their political opponents are simply motivated by greed or hate. If they're being particularly generous, they might concede that their political opponents are just irredeemably stupid.

Most conservatives I know think of such liberals as being misguided and close-minded. Not evil, or even stupid.

Perfectly good reasons like, my Bible tells me so. And reactions of disgust that they have been indoctrinated in to.
 
Another point : for the values liberal values, he made them in quasi general applicable everywhere care and fairness. But for those of conservative he sliced them in small parcel, and then he is surprised conservative have more. e.g. Right of Choice is a high values to "liberals" , but is probably hidden in fairness, whereas sanctity cover far far less situation then fairness, but in reality is on the other side of right-of-choice/fairness.

Had he had values "versus" other values situation by situation it would become even more apparent, whereas just having them in a list hide that.

I am not saying it was intentional, but it is clearly a flaw.

Without reading further I am betting if I google it I will find out that Haidt is a conservative : he pretty much has a good grasp of the fine granularity of the values of conservative as a whole, but seem to have a blind spot on the fine granularity of values of liberals...

ETA: I was right he switched to "self declared atheist and liberal" to "center"
 
Last edited:
it's interesting to hear Americans discuss liberals.
I often wonder if they simply don't realise that their idea of liberal is fairly right wing for the rest of the world?
 
it's interesting to hear Americans discuss liberals.
I often wonder if they simply don't realise that their idea of liberal is fairly right wing for the rest of the world?

Not only don't we know, we don't care.
 
I've found that the most productive political conversations/arguments I've had with people are the ones where there is no vilification and the parties involved see each other as fellow citizens and human beings who basically want the same things in the end. If I make an argument against Single-Payer healthcare, it doesn't mean I don't have empathy or I want people to die. Telling me I lack empathy or want people to die is going to make me start to disregard your argument.

If you have empathy you will desire single payer healthcare. It is just that simple. Since every other option leaves some people without healthcare, and since anyone not having access to healthcare is immoral, I just don't see a way around it.

How can you defend any plan that will leave some without healthcare as being empathetic? That just doesn't make sense to me.

Lol
An interesting reality, but total crap. How does a liberal forgoing medical treatment give it to another?

Why and how does a conservative refuse medical treatment, thereby, preventing another from getting it?

The specifics don't matter. What matters is that a conservative is only happy when everyone else is less well off than them. They do not get joy when others achieve things or have great events in their life. They only get joy when others falter and fail. When others get sick and suffer. When others despair and die.

How else can you explain why they are against social safety nets? How else can you explain that they oppose people getting healthcare? How else can you explain that they insist babies be born into poverty made worse by their refusal to have social safety nets? How else can you explain their desire to see the world be polluted and ruined? How else can you explain how they want this ruined hellscape of exacerbated poverty and pollution to be rife with guns?

You are making it difficult to see progressives as not totally absorbed by their wacky delusions

And the wackiness is what? I see what I said as the logical extension of the conservative opposition to progressive desires to make the world a better place.
 
The specifics don't matter. What matters is that a conservative is only happy when everyone else is less well off than them.


It goes hand in hand with this thread you are speaking of US conservative, but I disagree here. It is not conservative only which are tainted by that feeling, but in the US it is a more general phenomenon IMO : the puritan thinking that you need to work your blood off for everything and anything.
 
It could also be that liberal views are colored by a basic misunderstanding of their opponents.

I.e. conservatives tend to think that liberals are well intentioned but naive. Liberals tend to think that conservatives are evil.

It's hard to engage honestly when your default view of your opponent is "evil"

Not supported by evidence though. Look at the incoming administration they are all people who view liberals as evil. They forced they gay on them and they will pay for that.
 
I, also, would like a better explanation of the OP. I don't get the sugar/salt analogy, and I'm kind of puzzled by the idea of conservatism as having a broader moral "palate".

It seems to me that conservatives value things that are traditional. That's pretty much it, although one might throw in "small government", if that is construed as applying only to economic interference. Conservatives in the USA tend to want less taxes, less regulation, and less government interference with business, but they also tend to be perfectly happy with interfering in people's personal lives.

Well not their personal lives just people who they don't care about.
 
If you have empathy you will desire single payer healthcare. It is just that simple. Since every other option leaves some people without healthcare, and since anyone not having access to healthcare is immoral, I just don't see a way around it.

How can you defend any plan that will leave some without healthcare as being empathetic? That just doesn't make sense to me.

The specifics don't matter. What matters is that a conservative is only happy when everyone else is less well off than them. They do not get joy when others achieve things or have great events in their life. They only get joy when others falter and fail. When others get sick and suffer. When others despair and die. How else can you explain why they are against social safety nets? How else can you explain that they oppose people getting healthcare? How else can you explain that they insist babies be born into poverty made worse by their refusal to have social safety nets? How else can you explain their desire to see the world be polluted and ruined? How else can you explain how they want this ruined hellscape of exacerbated poverty and pollution to be rife with guns?

And the wackiness is what? I see what I said as the logical extension of the conservative opposition to progressive desires to make the world a better place.

The policy issues have answers and justifications. There really is another side. But the highlighted portion, the conclusion reached, is a conversation stopper. How would you even start a dialogue if the premise is going to be, "You only think that way because you are an evil person."

Political affiliation, the new racism.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom