Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Doesn't seem to. If you ask Canadians or Europeans or Kiwis or Australians or even Japanese, I think they'll all agree that the US is very much right-wing comparatively.



Of course you will. Otherwise you might have to concede the point I just made.

EXTREMELY right wing is more accurate i think
 
I find it fascinating how any discussion about politics on the International Skeptics Forum (or anywhere else, period) almost invariably turns into snarky and transparently biased back-and-forth masquerading as intellectual debate. And I'm certainly guilty of participating in this myself.

Really illustrates just how much us human beings are really poor at being rational but are really skilled at rationalizing our arguments values, which are far more likely to be - at a fundamental, base level - irrational, and greatly influenced by any number of biases/prejudices that are based on family upbringing, socialization, personal experience, and so forth. And the more intellectual and skeptical among us are often the worst offenders in that sense. Intellectual arrogance and hubris go hand in hand.

Anyway, carry on! :D
 
Last edited:
Many of my close friends are gun-toting, deer-slaying folks who absolutely support the 2nd Amendment but are mortified by the actions of the NRA and others to reject any attempts to better regulate access to guns. They're in their deer stands and duck blinds this fall, struggling to determine like the rest of us how so many Americans fell for Trump's schtick and elected that dangerous lunatic to the highest office in the land.

Yes Chris, this "liberals want to repeal the 2nd Amendment" idea is pure fantasy. Some liberals think that, sure, but no one I've ever met who's given it more than 5 minutes' thought seriously entertains the notion of a 2nd Amendment repeal. It's not a part of any Democratic Party platform I've ever read, and I can't even recall it being brought up by any of the dozens of hippies and peaceniks in my Facebook and Twitter feeds. It's not a thing.

Sorry, you're just going to have to acknowledge that you've been force-fed a steady diet of bovine excrement on this one and instead of questioning if you should eat it at all, you asked for seconds and more gravy.
 
Wowbagger said:
Care, Fairness (proportional fairness), Liberty (not on the chart because its newer), Loyalty, Sanctity, and Authority.

(snip)

In the same way, liberals tend to accept Care and Fairness as the ONLY TRUE moral foundations, and they dismiss the others. Conservatives, it is implied, have a much wider 'palate' of acceptable moral foundations.
Now that you have introduced a new "moral foundation" I don't think your argument still works. Liberals do accept "liberty" as a moral foundation (it's in their name), so now both groups have 3 moral foundations and you can't claim that one has fewer of them than the other.

Of course these concepts are too little defined to be quantified.

The very reason the foundations were increased from 5 to 6 was to cover libertarianism, in fact.
How many more are needed to cover every other political philosophy?

This, according to theory, is not accurate.
First you'll need to show that the theory is accurate.

And, it is possible his studies have already unraveled some of the complications you are throwing in. He seems to imply that in a few points in the book, mostly in the footnotes.
For the theory to have any merit, it needs to address these "complication" directly rather than as an afterthought.

If you are willing to write to him about these ideas, I would be curious to know how he responds.
If I had time to challenge every silly moral philosophy in existence, i'd be immortal.

That, I hope you understand, is NOT the argument I am making.
You kind of are making that argument, by claiming that things would be better if liberals had read the books you did.

You know, I could rephrase that as "Markets CAN BE Miraculous". Clearly they are not always as such.
Everything can be miraculous, as long as you're willing to wait long enough for "miracles" to occur.

Travis said:
If you have empathy you will desire single payer healthcare. It is just that simple. Since every other option leaves some people without healthcare, and since anyone not having access to healthcare is immoral, I just don't see a way around it.
You are confusing "single payer healthcare" with "universal healthcare". One can have universal healthcare without it being single payer. In fact most modern nations have universal healthcare but not single payer healthcare.

Single payer healthcare does seem to be the most cost effective form of universal healthcare... at least until some right wing government gets it in its head that it could "save costs" by introducing "market incentives".
 
You said most. He said all. Literally, those two things are very different. What is it, Argumemnon? Is it most or is it all?

Took long enough to get to the heard of the disagreement, here. Why didn't you say that in the first place rather than dance around the issue?

Yes, he said all. My bad. Although you'll note that "most" is included in "all", so again you seem to be objecting to what I said on the basis that you wanted to object at the time.
 
Many of my close friends are gun-toting, deer-slaying folks who absolutely support the 2nd Amendment but are mortified by the actions of the NRA and others to reject any attempts to better regulate access to guns. They're in their deer stands and duck blinds this fall, struggling to determine like the rest of us how so many Americans fell for Trump's schtick and elected that dangerous lunatic to the highest office in the land.

Yes Chris, this "liberals want to repeal the 2nd Amendment" idea is pure fantasy. Some liberals think that, sure, but no one I've ever met who's given it more than 5 minutes' thought seriously entertains the notion of a 2nd Amendment repeal. It's not a part of any Democratic Party platform I've ever read, and I can't even recall it being brought up by any of the dozens of hippies and peaceniks in my Facebook and Twitter feeds. It's not a thing.

Sorry, you're just going to have to acknowledge that you've been force-fed a steady diet of bovine excrement on this one and instead of questioning if you should eat it at all, you asked for seconds and more gravy.

Perhaps you should also listen to the Clinton recording I linked above. Chris B.
 
Took long enough to get to the heard of the disagreement, here. Why didn't you say that in the first place rather than dance around the issue?
I did.

Yes, he said all. My bad. Although you'll note that "most" is included in "all", so again you seem to be objecting to what I said on the basis that you wanted to object at the time.

By saying "most", you fundamentally changed his meaning and mischaracterized his point.
 
I don't think they are, but if you're right then the prospects of reconciliation and compromise seem very poor.

There is no hope of compromise or reconciliation. It’s not that understanding Conservatives is very hard, the problem is there is no substance to what they say or believe. Their beliefs have diverged so far from the real world that even if you understand it the only response you can have is to politely point out it’s fantasy based BS that doesn’t reflect the real world.

Eg in the real world the US has swung hard right and the role of government has declined for 40 years. In Bizzaro Conservative World the exact opposite has happened and there is no hope of reconciling these views. Neither is there any hope of compromise, just look at what happened with Obama Care, instead of going with Democrats preferred approach he tried to compromise and implement a plan proposed Conservative Republican think tanks. Conservatives promptly moved even farther right and this Conservative Republican plan was now to Liberal.


No matter how politely you point any of this out, you’ll be dismissed as “Liberal Elite”.
 
Not all of them of course, but it's clear you are.

Again, the world where liberals want to eliminate the 2nd Amendment is a fantasy world.

It doesn't exist, no matter how badly you want it to.

Yet another Clinton supporter that doesn't know her position on the second Amendment. Review the Clinton recording above for enlightenment.

You guys didn't know this? Really? Chris B.
 
Yet another Clinton supporter that doesn't know her position on the second Amendment. Review the Clinton recording above for enlightenment.

You guys didn't know this? Really? Chris B.

Now you're lying.

I told you I'm a Bernie guy. Why would you have to lie about something so trivial?

It couldn't possibly be just to get interwebz points, could it? :rolleyes:
 
Which part, specifically, do you think supports your claim? You've already quoted her once and failed.

Specifically where she says the second Amendment is wrong. About 58 second to the end. The entire clip is just over a minute long. Chris B.
 
Now that you have introduced a new "moral foundation" I don't think your argument still works. Liberals do accept "liberty" as a moral foundation (it's in their name), so now both groups have 3 moral foundations and you can't claim that one has fewer of them than the other.

Wowbagger was simplifying, unfortunately. If you have a look at the chart he posted, the reality is that there's always a blend of these values across the left-right spectrum. The mix changes as the segment moves across the X axis from Liberals emphasizing two as much more important than the others, to Conservatives who tend to juggle them all equally.

Of course these concepts are too little defined to be quantified.

The research defines them better than Wowbagger's summary for a SkeptiCamp, as you can expect.


How many more are needed to cover every other political philosophy?

The authors' model seems to be pretty complete at this point.


First you'll need to show that the theory is accurate.

Don't confuse this with a philosophical approach... they're trying to describe an observation. It's more of a biological model than a moral philosophy model. This is why there's an analogy with tastebuds. We only have certain types. The model is proposing that we only have a handful of moral modules as well. I find the model compelling.


For the theory to have any merit, it needs to address these "complication" directly rather than as an afterthought.

Probably. I read through the earlier posts, and am not sure what complications are being referred to here. However, it's worth pointing out that they adapt their model to data, which is appropriate for what they're trying to build (a descriptive model of individual moral preferences, possibly due to biology).



If I had time to challenge every silly moral philosophy in existence, i'd be immortal.

I guess I need to reiterate: this isn't a moral philosophy model. It's more of a behavioral genetics model. There is no attempt to 'prove' that any particular moral stance is superior to others; rather, it's an attempt to understand why we have different moral stances distributed in the population in the first place, and how to categorize them for analysis.


You kind of are making that argument, by claiming that things would be better if liberals had read the books you did.

I agree with his point in that it's a good idea to learn how our minds work if we want to learn about ourselves, and if we want to craft effective Skeptical Outreach.


Everything can be miraculous, as long as you're willing to wait long enough for "miracles" to occur.

I think Wowbagger's point was about choosing phrasing based on the audience so they don't get all prickly and reject what would have been a persuasive argument because of vocabulary choices.
 
Last edited:

No, you didn't. You implied that what he said was entirely different.

By saying "most", you fundamentally changed his meaning and mischaracterized his point.

No I didn't. At most you can say that I made his claim weaker, which is irrelevant to the post I was responding to anyway. You have a point, however, that I should have said 'all'.
 
Now you're lying.

I told you I'm a Bernie guy. Why would you have to lie about something so trivial?

It couldn't possibly be just to get interwebz points, could it? :rolleyes:

Excuse me for specifying you supported Hillary, I assumed since you supported Bernie, you would had voted for Clinton in the general election. I would have been more accurate to have specified your Liberal view of the 2nd. If you didn't vote for Hillary, congratulations there may be hope for you yet. Chris B.
 
Specifically where she says the second Amendment is wrong. About 58 second to the end. The entire clip is just over a minute long. Chris B.

"In this case"

I think you forgot the qualifier. Now why would you do that?

Dishonest people do stuff like that. You're not dishonest, are you?
 
There is no hope of compromise or reconciliation.

Then there's no point to having a politics section and we should close it.

It’s not that understanding Conservatives is very hard, the problem is there is no substance to what they say or believe.

Really? There is substance to their beliefs at all? What makes your beliefs more substantial? Are you refering to all of them or only the crazy ones?
 
Specifically where she says the second Amendment is wrong.

Quote please. I want a verbatim quotation of exactly what you're refering to. Asking me to check somewhere on the recording risks me picking the wrong sentence and you dodging around the point. Either make your case or retract it.

What I see is her saying that the SCOTUS' interpretation is wrong. That's not what you're claiming.
 
Last edited:
Then there's no point to having a politics section and we should close it.



Really? There is substance to their beliefs at all? What makes your beliefs more substantial? Are you refering to all of them or only the crazy ones?

Conservative beliefs in today's day and age don't seem to be grounded in reality.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom