Now that you have introduced a new "moral foundation" I don't think your argument still works. Liberals do accept "liberty" as a moral foundation (it's in their name), so now both groups have 3 moral foundations and you can't claim that one has fewer of them than the other.
Wowbagger was simplifying, unfortunately. If you have a look at the chart he posted, the reality is that there's always a blend of these values across the left-right spectrum. The mix changes as the segment moves across the X axis from Liberals emphasizing two as much more important than the others, to Conservatives who tend to juggle them all equally.
Of course these concepts are too little defined to be quantified.
The research defines them better than Wowbagger's summary for a SkeptiCamp, as you can expect.
How many more are needed to cover every other political philosophy?
The authors' model seems to be pretty complete at this point.
First you'll need to show that the theory is accurate.
Don't confuse this with a philosophical approach... they're trying to describe an observation. It's more of a biological model than a moral philosophy model. This is why there's an analogy with tastebuds. We only have certain types. The model is proposing that we only have a handful of moral modules as well. I find the model compelling.
For the theory to have any merit, it needs to address these "complication" directly rather than as an afterthought.
Probably. I read through the earlier posts, and am not sure what complications are being referred to here. However, it's worth pointing out that they adapt their model to data, which is appropriate for what they're trying to build (a descriptive model of individual moral preferences, possibly due to biology).
If I had time to challenge every silly moral philosophy in existence, i'd be immortal.
I guess I need to reiterate: this isn't a moral philosophy model. It's more of a behavioral genetics model. There is no attempt to 'prove' that any particular moral stance is superior to others; rather, it's an attempt to understand why we have different moral stances distributed in the population in the first place, and how to categorize them for analysis.
You kind of are making that argument, by claiming that things would be better if liberals had read the books you did.
I agree with his point in that it's a good idea to learn how our minds work if we want to learn about ourselves, and if we want to craft effective Skeptical Outreach.
Everything can be miraculous, as long as you're willing to wait long enough for "miracles" to occur.
I think Wowbagger's point was about choosing phrasing based on the audience so they don't get all prickly and reject what would have been a persuasive argument because of vocabulary choices.