Why is the Government Truth Movement© so angry, defensive, and abusive?

...True, but being on the side of power gives a bigger hormonal hit. It's an instinctual herd reaction.
...
Wrong. Perception governs the reaction, not reality. It's why conspiracy theorists often insist they're the only people capable of seeing The Truth, and everyone else is just incapable of really thinking about the matter. Same with any emotionally charged debate.

To quote Scott Adams, "nothing makes [people] argue harder than being proven wrong." Here's a Cracked article with more, which happens to prove you are wrong. I look forward to your response.

So, the next time you find yourself desperately Googling for some factual example that proves your argument is right, and failing to find even one, stop. See if you can put the brakes on and actually say, out loud, "Wait a second. If the things I'm saying in order to bolster my argument are consistently wrong, then maybe my argument is also wrong."
 
Last edited:
Abusers, of all stripes, don't abuse because of how other people behave. They abuse because they have a need to abuse.

The rationalizations and justifications come later.

More to the point: one side seems to cry foul entirely as an attention getting device. It is a forced victimhood which is meant to distract from the general paucity of their arguments. Threads such as this one are a perfect example of such tact. CT SpringHallConvert begins a thread by begging the question. Irrespective of the nature of the replies he/she receives (whether abusive or respectful), she/he responds with the responses like:
Like I said, angry, defensive, and abusive.

It is a transparent, though marginally effective debate tactic when the arguer runs out of evidence to bemoan a culture of abuse and hostility. We've often called it the Galileo argument on this forum. It is a way for the arguer to claim to be right, despite all evidence to the contrary. It is no surprise, therefore, that we hear 9/11 CT's using this defense so often. Of course, to be Galileo, you also have to be right, and this is not an issue with 9/11 Conspiracy Theorists.

My response to a baiting, poorly phrased question was a thoughtful analysis of where the vitriol comes from in the debate. My argument, which I will summarize, since CT's in general have poor reading comprehension skills, is that respectful debate and information sharing is useful only for educating the ignorant. The CT's that are left on this forum, however, represent ideologues, charlatans, anti-semites and racists. Their purpose goes beyond simple 9/11 conspiracy theories and broaches a deeper and more sinister societal danger. Their willingness to lie and distort in order to obtain followers is detestable.

One day, while at school, a fundamentalist southern Baptist preacher was preaching typical crap in the quad. When he started launching into a long anti-semitic rant, I went up to him and argued back. I shouted at him. I called him a Nazi. His argument was that the Jews were in league with Satan and tearing this country away from God (or something to that effect). My argument was that he was a nutcase.

I'm certain that, from a certain point of view, I was verbally abusive to him. I shouted until my voice was hoarse. However, it is my opinion that such ideologies must be met with force of word. Ideologies such as Nazism should make every free-thinking, free person on Earth furious. They must be shouted down at every single opportunity. The consenting silence of the crowd is what the likes of these want. The anger and hatred of an organized group of like minded citizens is what they fear. Your argument that abusers (in this case, me) have a need to abuse falls flat on its ass in this instance. I have no desire to be verbally abusive, and every obligation as a free-thinking human to forcefully oppose Nazi ideology.

Once again, I don't think all 9/11 CT's are Nazis. Some of them most certainly are, but the vast majority are just morons. That's fine with me. Idiots don't require abuse, nor do they warrant it. But there comes a time when said CT has restated her argument for the 100,000th time, and one must wonder why he seems so obstinate in the face of logic. To me, they appear to cross the line between casual morons and ideologues. Their obstinance reveals a deeper ideology that prevents them from accepting any rational worldview. These are dangerous.

I generally dislike the tendency of people on this forum to jump down the throats of new users who express CT tendencies. However, this tactic of crying abuse at every opportunity rather than addressing legitimate arguments is tiresome.
 
The worst case is when someone is stupid AND insane......then you get a conspiracy theorist that is truly something to behold....but I digress.

Actually, you get these guys...
jared%20laughner%20booking.JPG

Jared Laughner
18029019_240X180.jpg

Sean Fitzgerald

See also: Curtiss Maynard, James W. Vonn Brunn, Kurt Sonnenfeld

I'd rather they weren't something to behold...
 
All human behavior is regulated by hormones. This book, The Social Psychology of Power, is worth reading if you're interested in exploring this topic, for example, page 36,

"High-status baboons also benefit from lower levels of stress hormones overall than those at lower levels of the hierarchy. This is especially the case following conflict situations. High-status baboons enjoy a rewarding rush of testosterone, whereas the vanquished, low-status baboons suffer a flood of cortisol instead."

Possibly I completely misunderstood your original claim: "...being on the side of power gives a bigger hormonal hit. It's an instinctual herd reaction" -- although, at the moment, I don't think so.

I took that to mean that what SHC here dubbed the "Government Truth Movement" derives hormonal advantage from siding with the government.

Here you seem to argue that debunkers on JREF derive hormonal advantage from being high-status relative to Truth Movement adherents.

If you're making either of those arguments, I haven't seen you support either of them, so I'm not sure why you think that these remarks about high-status baboons are on point. Certainly they might be.

Who, then, is responsible for the debunkers' behavior?

Presumably people are responsible for their own behavior. What, then, is the point of your question?

It's interesting that you camp up your language here ("deign to venture"). The difference is the difference between an individual and a group. I haven't seen any twooferologists on this thread deny that they act abusively towards twoofers. Most merely seek to justify it.

You disregarded the first obvious question about your comments, and I find it strange.

"The difference is the difference between an individual and a group." ? Are you suggesting that pejorative tribal generalizations are somehow inherently less logically fallacious than pejorative statements about individuals? Why do you think the difference you cite is relevant?

Remind me: have you denied that you act abusively toward "twooferologists," or are you merely seeking to justify it? :rolleyes:

Really, what would be the point of arguing with SpringHallConvert about whether I act abusively?

That is precisely what the poster calling me delusional is doing in the posts he has addressed to me.

No, it isn't. The poster offered his or her own perspective on forum dynamics, which is sharply at variance with yours. He or she also called you "delusional" -- as a newbie, I don't know on what basis. Right or wrong, harsh or merely blunt, that comment has no real bearing on the rest of the post. newton's comments about forum dynamics stand and/or fall on their own merits, not on anything said about you.

Remind me: did you have any substantive criticism of those comments? When you wrote, "Not if one regards arguments about the towers' destruction etc as red herrings," was that intended to hint that you agree with many of "twooferologists'" criticisms of common Truth Movement arguments? That wouldn't necessarily discredit the hypothesis that "twooferologists" are motivated by the desire for hormonal rushes, but it would at least provide some useful context.
 
Possibly I completely misunderstood your original claim: "...being on the side of power gives a bigger hormonal hit. It's an instinctual herd reaction" -- although, at the moment, I don't think so.

I took that to mean that what SHC here dubbed the "Government Truth Movement" derives hormonal advantage from siding with the government.

Yes

Here you seem to argue that debunkers on JREF derive hormonal advantage from being high-status relative to Truth Movement adherents.

Yes.

If you're making either of those arguments, I haven't seen you support either of them, so I'm not sure why you think that these remarks about high-status baboons are on point. Certainly they might be.

The baboons show the hormonal consequences of power differential in conflict and the rewards available to the winners. I believe that twooferologists are attracted to twoofers because it is easy to win against them (and easy to get away with abusing them). The same applies to many other topics on the forum or, indeed, to the forum as a whole.


Presumably people are responsible for their own behavior. What, then, is the point of your question?

You appeared to be blaming debunkers' behavior on the environment created by the low quality of their opponents


You disregarded the first obvious question about your comments, and I find it strange.

"The difference is the difference between an individual and a group." ? Are you suggesting that pejorative tribal generalizations are somehow inherently less logically fallacious than pejorative statements about individuals? Why do you think the difference you cite is relevant?

Ad hominem means "to the man" or "to the person".

Remind me: have you denied that you act abusively toward "twooferologists," or are you merely seeking to justify it? :rolleyes:

I am not the subject of this thread, which is: "Why is the Government Truth Movement© so angry, defensive, and abusive?"

Really, what would be the point of arguing with SpringHallConvert about whether I act abusively?

It could lead to an expanded awareness of something!


No, it isn't. The poster offered his or her own perspective on forum dynamics, which is sharply at variance with yours. He or she also called you "delusional" -- as a newbie, I don't know on what basis. Right or wrong, harsh or merely blunt, that comment has no real bearing on the rest of the post. newton's comments about forum dynamics stand and/or fall on their own merits, not on anything said about you.

I was referring his name-calling and character assassination attempts (Some of this thread has been moved to here).

His personalizes his argument from the outset and continues in the same vein throughout:
Your impressions are, not surprisingly, completely wrong...

People who are delusional have a track record of often being wrong though....so I should expect this.


Remind me: did you have any substantive criticism of those comments? When you wrote, "Not if one regards arguments about the towers' destruction etc as red herrings," was that intended to hint that you agree with many of "twooferologists'" criticisms of common Truth Movement arguments?
That wouldn't necessarily discredit the hypothesis that "twooferologists" are motivated by the desire for hormonal rushes, but it would at least provide some useful context.

I do not intend to debate "common Truth Movement arguments" in this thread.

My comment was intended to point out that some people regard a focus on the destruction of the towers as a red herring. Applying science and engineering expertise to a red herring does not, therefore, necessarily impart the authority that the poster appeared to claim it gives him on the topic as a whole.

BTW, I like the term "twooferologist" because it expresses the codependent nature of the relationship, while acknowledging twooferologists' fondness of ad hominem baby language.
 
Last edited:
I can't use the quote function cuz I'm on my phone, but did you just say dialog with SHC could lead to ” expanded awareness”?


Methinks you need to pay closer attention to why he's Here...
 
I can't use the quote function cuz I'm on my phone, but did you just say dialog with SHC could lead to ” expanded awareness”?

Yes, though it was a light-hearted comment. Any form of communication has the potential to expand awareness.


Methinks you need to pay closer attention to why he's Here...

Why is he Here...?
 
I believe that twooferologists are attracted to twoofers because it is easy to win against them

There is probably something to that. Winning the typical argument with a Truth Movement adherent is about as hard as winning cheat solitaire. There's no big hormone rush, but sometimes the predictability is soothing.

However, I don't think it's the dominant motivation -- which, of course, varies from individual to individual. If you're interested in this subject, many debunkers have made interesting comments about it.

(and easy to get away with abusing them).

That makes more sense reframed as a generalization about people who like to argue on the internet. By the standards of internet debate, critics of the TM don't seem especially abusive in general.

You appeared to be blaming debunkers' behavior on the environment created by the low quality of their opponents

It isn't a matter of blame. I do believe that if truthers made better arguments, debunkers would treat them with more respect -- which seems very reasonable to me. But if the empirical puzzle you're trying to address is why debunkers don't ignore truthers altogether, well, debunkers wonder about that, too.

Ad hominem means "to the man" or "to the person".

Yes, I know. So? Are you arguing that group slurs can't be ad hominems because that would be ungrammatical?

I am not the subject of this thread, which is: "Why is the Government Truth Movement© so angry, defensive, and abusive?"[/div]

That question inevitably leads to others, such as "by what measures?" and "compared to what or whom?" Someone who asks the first question without being interested in the others probably isn't actually very interested in the first question. So far, almost all the actual interest in the question seems to have come from the debunker side -- which, in my experience, is not unusual.

It could lead to an expanded awareness of something!

I'm not sure what JREF rules allow me to say about that. SHC might expand my awareness that I'm not as patient a person as I used to think, but I figured that out at least five years ago.

...His personalizes his argument from the outset and continues in the same vein throughout:

Name-calling isn't identical with personalizing an argument. The distinction isn't even all that subtle, although people may disagree in particular instances.

I do not intend to debate "common Truth Movement arguments" in this thread.

That's reasonable, but I think that the intellectual quality of common TM arguments is germane to the subject. Don't you?

My comment was intended to point out that some people regard a focus on the destruction of the towers as a red herring. Applying science and engineering expertise to a red herring does not, therefore, necessarily impart the authority that the poster appeared to claim it gives him on the topic as a whole.

What "topic as a whole"?

To be honest, your comment appears to be intended to move the goalposts somewhere out in the fog.

BTW, I like the term "twooferologist" because it expresses the codependent nature of the relationship, while acknowledging twooferologists' fondness of ad hominem baby language.

Priceless.
 
Mark, I have to thank you for quoting JJ so extensively. Like any other member I have identified as an adherent of 1 9/11 Truth, I have JJ on IGNORE. Although to JJ's credit, there is some insight in this post.

I believe that twooferologists are attracted to twoofers because it is easy to win against them (and easy to get away with abusing them). ...I like the term "twooferologist" because it expresses the codependent nature of the relationship, while acknowledging twooferologists' fondness of ad hominem baby language
I have made the same point several times. I no longer respond to those who advocate a 9/11 Truth and have almost all on IGNORE. This would be the first in maybe a year I have responded directly to one.

As far as I'm concerned, there is nothing to be gained any more from watching these arguments. In the short time I've been here, I see the same arguments over and over and over and over again. Ryan Mckey has basically stopped responding and appears to have stopped debating Truth activists in public forums.

There's simply no need to be doing this anymore. What ever else this thing that is not the Truth Movement is, it is no longer radical. It's just a bunch of idiots mouthing the same things they saw on a Youtube video. It's not intellectual. It has no direction. It's now so dead in the USA that it's looking for converts in Canada. The only place you can find more than a handful of Truthers in one place is in a Ron Paul campaign rally.

So this raises the point, why would anyone want to argue about this anymore? I understand the point made earlier that you need to keep these guys quarantined somewhere because if you don't, they'll take over ever forum everywhere. But who would want to debate under these circumstances? They seem almost certain to create the conditions in which name calling will follow.
 
Last edited:
As far as I'm concerned, there is nothing to be gained any more from watching these arguments. In the short time I've been here, I see the same arguments over and over and over and over again. Ryan Mckey has basically stopped responding and appears to have stopped debating Truth activists in public forums.

Scott, in this particular case I have some genuine curiosity because I don't know much about JJ -- and I think the social psych etc. is not without interest. That's true in other isolated cases, as well. But mostly there is numbing repetition.

There's simply no need to be doing this anymore....

I agree. There may be some virtue in saying something for the benefit of lurkers (I've found JREF discussions actually informative), but most of the movement posts here simply don't warrant response, and are best disregarded. Given that you've been here longer than I have, it isn't surprising that we draw our lines in different places.
 
Mark, I have to thank you for quoting JJ so extensively. Like any other member I have identified as an adherent of 1 9/11 Truth, I have JJ on IGNORE... I no longer respond to those who advocate a 9/11 Truth and have almost all on IGNORE.

This is another fascinating aspect of the Government Truth Movement. If they fail to convert, badger, harass, or mock someone with an opposing viewpoint into submission, they will cover up for their inability to successfully persuade the opposition by ignoring them. It's essentially, "my way or the highway". There's no middle ground for these people. No compromise. No meeting of the minds. It has to be their way or no way at all.

Then, to top it all off, they announce, "I'm ignoring you", which is the internet equivalent of the playground lament, "I'm taking my ball and going home". These people are like children, but with an obvious fascist streak.
 
This is another fascinating aspect of the Government Truth Movement. If they fail to convert, badger, harass, or mock someone with an opposing viewpoint into submission, they will cover up for their inability to successfully persuade the opposition by ignoring them. It's essentially, "my way or the highway". There's no middle ground for these people. No compromise. No meeting of the minds. It has to be their way or no way at all.

Then, to top it all off, they announce, "I'm ignoring you", which is the internet equivalent of the playground lament, "I'm taking my ball and going home". These people are like children, but with an obvious fascist streak.

I wish I had the I <3 irony picture right now. It would fit perfectly considering that SHC does this all day, everyday with evidence. When perfectly good evidence is presented it's the internet version of SHC putting his fingers in his ears and says "la la la la, I can't hear you." To see him say that ignoring something is childish could not possibly be anymore ironic.

Furthermore, he gets his internet based "rocks off" on putting words in "debunkers" mouths. Such as:

If they fail to convert, badger, harass, or mock someone with an opposing viewpoint into submission, they will cover up for their inability to successfully persuade the opposition by ignoring them

Even though no one here is attempting to "convert" anyone. Individuals come here with questions, are provided with information and the choice is up to the person.

No compromise. No meeting of the minds. It has to be their way or no way at all.

There is no "meeting of the minds", we're referring to a tragedy. Not some video game where you have to create a strategy to "win." Sounds like someone has a horrible case of no self awareness.
 
This is another fascinating aspect of the Government Truth Movement. If they fail to convert, badger, harass, or mock someone with an opposing viewpoint into submission, they will cover up for their inability to successfully persuade the opposition by ignoring them. It's essentially, "my way or the highway". There's no middle ground for these people. No compromise. No meeting of the minds. It has to be their way or no way at all.

Then, to top it all off, they announce, "I'm ignoring you", which is the internet equivalent of the playground lament, "I'm taking my ball and going home". These people are like children, but with an obvious fascist streak.
That tends to happen with those who rely upon old well known rhetorical trickery.

Why does this surprise you?
 
These people are like children, but with an obvious fascist streak.


You want to see fascist tendencies, then look no further than your average Truth Movement moderated forums, where even a hint of departing from the Truther party line results in a torrent of verbal abuse and instant and permanent banning. I once got "banned" for simply asking a question on a Truther's YouTube page. He blocked me from replying and then started posting questions and comments ostensibly back to me. He crowed about my lack of response to his posts in the thread. Little did the other participants know that I wasn't responding because the owner of the page wasn't letting me respond. You can try to find similar behavior in "Debunker" moderated threads, but I doubt you'll have much luck. I'd like to quote for you the most thoughtful, reasonable and intelligible response I've ever gotten on a YouTube CT-centric debate (oh, God I wish I were exaggerating about this):

"Ha ha I hate u but u funny. Just kidding lol"

Or check out forums where Truthers gleefully discuss what they'll do to Debunkers after the Revolution. Entire threads have been devoted here to these two subjects if you are skeptical of my claim.

I have all sorts of problems with the government of the United States and other governments, but a Government run by Truthers would make Nazi Germany look like hell week at a fraternity house. They don't object to paranoid violent thugs running a country into the ground. They're just upset that they aren't allowed to be the paranoid violent thugs.

Having said that I have no one on "ignore". If nothing else I'd think it would make a thread hard to follow if large chunks of it were effectively hidden from my view. Also annoying is the tendency that some members here have of asking others not to quote people who appear on ignore lists. It seems to be an unreasonable and difficult to adhere to request.
 
You want to see fascist tendencies, then look no further than your average Truth Movement moderated forums, where even a hint of departing from the Truther party line results in a torrent of verbal abuse and instant and permanent banning.

In ten years of following this debate from both sides of the fence, I've never seen this kind of behavior from honest, genuine non-government truthers. Maybe from trolls, plants, and agent provocateurs, but not honest non-government truthers.

I once got "banned" for simply asking a question on a Truther's YouTube page. He blocked me from replying and then started posting questions and comments ostensibly back to me. He crowed about my lack of response to his posts in the thread. Little did the other participants know that I wasn't responding because the owner of the page wasn't letting me respond. You can try to find similar behavior in "Debunker" moderated threads, but I doubt you'll have much luck.

I've seen firsthand this tactic employed on government truther forums. I call it "pruning". The mods will selectively delete posts to steer the argument.

I'd like to quote for you the most thoughtful, reasonable and intelligible response I've ever gotten on a YouTube CT-centric debate (oh, God I wish I were exaggerating about this):

"Ha ha I hate u but u funny. Just kidding lol"

Somehow I doubt this.

Or check out forums where Truthers gleefully discuss what they'll do to Debunkers after the Revolution. Entire threads have been devoted here to these two subjects if you are skeptical of my claim.

While I had somebody here tell me that they wouldn't mind the government putting people like me into concentration camps. They called it "unfortunate" that this isn't the case.

I have all sorts of problems with the government of the United States and other governments, but a Government run by Truthers would make Nazi Germany look like hell week at a fraternity house. They don't object to paranoid violent thugs running a country into the ground. They're just upset that they aren't allowed to be the paranoid violent thugs.

This is your imagination running wild..

Having said that I have no one on "ignore". If nothing else I'd think it would make a thread hard to follow if large chunks of it were effectively hidden from my view. Also annoying is the tendency that some members here have of asking others not to quote people who appear on ignore lists. It seems to be an unreasonable and difficult to adhere to request.

You're a more reasonable government truther. You're a cut above some of the outright fascists here.
 
In ten years of following this debate from both sides of the fence, I've never seen this kind of behavior from honest, genuine non-government truthers. Maybe from trolls, plants, and agent provocateurs, but not honest non-government truthers.


No True Scotsman fallacy.

I've seen firsthand this tactic employed on government truther forums. I call it "pruning". The mods will selectively delete posts to steer the argument.


Yes, posts get "pruned" here all the time and sent to AAH. More than a few of mine have been sent there and to be honest they deserved to be. I'm not talking about that though. I'm talking about being permanently banned for asking an on topic question. Your personal incredulity that such things don't happen doesn't mean they don't happen.

Somehow I doubt this.


You are perfectly entitled to your skepticism of this. I don't see how I could prove this to you anyway since I'd have to locate every response I've ever gotten over the course of several years and even then you'd have no reason to believe those posts were genuine.

To be fair, I engaged in a month-long email conversation with the spokesman for We Are Change Atlanta a while back. He was reasonably polite and articulate but kept harping on his talking points rather than engaging in an actual debate. A bit like how a Customer Service Rep has to stick to the script when dealing with an irate customer. It results in a technically polite but often frustratingly unproductive conversation.

While I had somebody here tell me that they wouldn't mind the government putting people like me into concentration camps. They called it "unfortunate" that this isn't the case.


Link? FWIW, I object to such talk, even in jest. I don't wish ill of any Truther/CTist. Even if I did, having to live with such paranoia, fear and suspicion 24/7 is far worse than any other form of punishment. I myself went through something akin to a CT phase in my teens/early 20s. If I hadn't insisted on studying both sides of the debate by reading everything I could get my hands on, I might still hold some of those beliefs.

This is your imagination running wild..


Perhaps, but I can only go by what Truthers themselves are threatening.

You're a more reasonable government truther. You're a cut above some of the outright fascists here.


Um, thanks? Congratulations, by the way. That's now the the nicest thing a Truther has ever said to me. Sad, really but I guess it takes all types to make a world:)
 
SHC is "fascist" simply a scary word you use for people who disagree with you? What on earth leads you to believe that anybody on this forum is a "fascist"?
 
Balsamo must be an agent provacatuer

he banned me as I suggested he produce a techbical paper for such mags a special sbfoum fo ths bo sagees Aviation Week
then commented upon my failing to respond to his questions for me even though as mod he knew I had not even visited the site until after I was banned

in fact of course to even pst on pft one must run a gaunlet to find if you are allowed to post in any place other than a
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom