Why is the Government Truth Movement© so angry, defensive, and abusive?

Yes, I know. So? Are you arguing that group slurs can't be ad hominems because that would be ungrammatical?

No, it would be an inaccurate application of the fallacy.

I am not the subject of this thread, which is: "Why is the Government Truth Movement© so angry, defensive, and abusive?"[/div]

That question inevitably leads to others, such as "by what measures?" and "compared to what or whom?" Someone who asks the first question without being interested in the others probably isn't actually very interested in the first question. So far, almost all the actual interest in the question seems to have come from the debunker side -- which, in my experience, is not unusual.

Sticking to the thread topic isn't much to ask.

Are you familair with the Tu quoque fallacy?

Name-calling isn't identical with personalizing an argument. The distinction isn't even all that subtle, although people may disagree in particular instances.

The post in question does both. In the light of the OP, why do you think the poster feels the need to do either?

That's reasonable, but I think that the intellectual quality of common TM arguments is germane to the subject. Don't you?

No. Abusers abuse because they have a need to a abuse. This need is not put there by the victims of their abuse.

What "topic as a whole"?

"9/11"

Priceless.

Irony has a value but I wouldn't call it priceless!
 
Last edited:
I guess so, but to continue to ask him questions regarding clarification, or citation, is just mindless. I don't get it. He has no actual position on anything, so to ask him to discuss it is akin to asking a brick wall what its favorite movie is.
Yes he does, though he tries to conceal it. He's a Truther. He has no problem accepting the govt. evidence when he wants to.

9/11 and Al Qaeda: Says no one can prove anything, and all govt. sources or non-govt sources, yea, even unto those from the 80s, are unreliable.
Operation Northwoods: After repeated questioning, claims the govt. could release the information because everyone involved in Northwoods is dead or retired, never backs it up. Never answers my question about whether the "9/11 conspiracy" will ever be declassified.
Pearl Harbor: Insists the Truth may have been covered up by the govt, despite, logically, even more of those people being dead or retired.

I don't think I've ever seen someone use a triple standard before.

So? I think he demonstrating this perfectly to those that are. We couldn't do better. Rational people read his post and say WTF. Notice no one is jumping in to help his "cause".
Yeah, even other Truthers are letting him dangle. When Clayton Moore and Ergo don't want to back you up...

No, it would be an inaccurate application of the fallacy.

Sticking to the thread topic isn't much to ask.

Are you familair with the Tu quoque fallacy?

The post in question does both. In the light of the OP, why do you think the poster feels the need to do either?

No. Abusers abuse because they have a need to a abuse. This need is not put there by the victims of their abuse.

"9/11"

Irony has a value but I wouldn't call it priceless!

JJ, this thread was started as a thinly-veiled ad hom. You don't have to defend it. Just let it go.
 
Prove where Al-Qaeda's real funding originated.

Good luck with that.

Why bother? Whatever evidence I present will be dismissed as "this source is within 7 degrees of separation from George Bush so we can't trust it" or "two of the pixels in that photo look out of place, it was obviously tampered with" or "the author of this article sounds like a Jewish name; can't be trusted".

If you were willing to look at evidence that contradicted your beliefs you wouldn't be a Truther.

It would be a waste of my time. I have a life, and besides I'm not the one trying to change the status quo. I could do absolutely nothing and the so-called "official story" would still be the generally accepted version of events the world over. YOU'RE the one who needs to do work.
 
Last edited:
Why bother? Whatever evidence I present will be dismissed as "this source is within 7 degrees of separation from George Bush so we can't trust it" or "two of the pixels in that photo look out of place, it was obviously tampered with" or "the author of this article sounds like a Jewish name; can't be trusted".

If you were willing to look at evidence that contradicted your beliefs you wouldn't be a Truther.

It would be a waste of my time. I have a life, and besides I'm not the one trying to change the status quo. I could do absolutely nothing and the so-called "official story" would still be the generally accepted version of events the world over. YOU'RE the one who needs to do work.

The real (official) story is the one that will be in the history books. Truthers have nothing.
 
Nobody is jumping in to help because they realize it's a one-sided curb-stomping. They realize I don't need help, which is why they are just sitting back and watching.

I'm sure you're right...reality is just a passing fad. Soon, it'll go the way of bell-bottoms and tie-dyed shirts, and we'll all get caught up in the next "big thing".

It's like a turkey shoot in here.

Ooh, I've had that before. Luckily, there's medication for it. See your doctor.
 
I'm amused at SHC accusing people of being angry, defensive, and abusive by being angry, defensive, and abusive. It just lacks the ooomph it could have.
 
I'm amused at SHC accusing people of being angry, defensive, and abusive by being angry, defensive, and abusive. It just lacks the ooomph it could have.
The "defensive" part really shows when we ask him what evidence he will except. So far, only dodges to these requests (unless "show me and I'll decide" constitutes an answer).
 
No, it would be an inaccurate application of the fallacy.

You're entitled to your bald assertion, but I have no basis for accepting it.

Sticking to the thread topic isn't much to ask.

I think I explained why the comments were on topic. Not that you have to respond to the content of my posts.

Are you familair with the Tu quoque fallacy?

Yes. The questions I posed have nothing to do with tu quoque.

The post in question does both.

Another bald assertion.

In the light of the OP, why do you think the poster feels the need to do either?

Why do I feel the need to beat my wife? Oh, wait.

No. Abusers abuse because they have a need to a abuse. This need is not put there by the victims of their abuse.

You haven't demonstrated either abuse or a "need" to abuse.


OK, then this is yet another bald assertion. How do you infer that someone attempted to argue that his(?) science and engineering expertise gave him authority on every aspect of 9/11?

Oh, wait, "appeared to claim." Maybe this particular assertion wasn't bald so much as indecipherable.

It seems to me that the original post has little if any merit. I am giving you every opportunity to argue otherwise, but I don't think that flinging around the names of fallacies constitutes much of an argument.
 
attachment.php




! Ha, Ha, Ha, Ha, Ha ! ......


Stay Down !
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kA3WxjplKzo
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom