Because when someone is trying to have a nice discussion with you and you dismiss all of his arguments with "Shills! Plants! Agents! Prove me wrong!" it is kind of rude and insulting. You are basically not really having a "discussion" at all, you are just listening to yourself talk and the other person is merely background noise. In polite conversation people like to know that the other party is listening to the things that they say and giving thoughtful feedback.
I used to be a regular here, but now I just pop in every now and then with the occasional snide remark. Why? Many reasons, but partly because I felt like I wasn't being listened to. I was being asked to prove that the sky is blue, so I showed some photographs of the blue sky. And the Truther would respond "See, I knew it, you don't have any proof at all". It got frustrating. You would get frustrated too.