Why is the Government Truth Movement© so angry, defensive, and abusive?

I'm really sorry but, it is pretty annoying when Truthers are assumed to be left-wing. We already have to deal with having to be associated with white guys in dredlocks and others who believe in New Age crap.

Weird thing is that we often find ourselves debating with decidedly right wing 911 conspiracy adherents.
For instance I believe that we would find that those 911 conspiracy adherents who also are Holocaust deniers would fit into the right wing in political leanings. (marriage=man+woman,, anti-abortion,, small government,, few or no social programs,, strident anti-gun control,, white,, ostensibly Christian)

Would Clayton Moore regard hinself as conservative or liberal?
 
Last edited:
First of all this forum certainly does not have a greater amount of P & V{"piss and vinegar" from the OP} than do the forums that operate from the opposite side of the discussion. I am sure you will have noticed that.
This would of course be my humble opinion. However JJ it would seem, directly contradicts this and believes the complete opposite.

There are three choices of course
A )-debunker forums have greater numbers of angry postings
B )-911 conspiracy adherent forums have greater numbers of angry postings
C )-both have essentially the same number of angry postings

We could do a completely unscientific and essentially useless poll on this and other forums,
OR
anyone who truly wishes to know for sure (JJ and SHC seem to be obvious choices) could survey a sample of 100 15 threads on each of JREF, SLC, LC, and AE911T and get back to us.

Now given that JJ only just entered this debate I would like to point out that the OP was addressed by several posters which she may have missed.
One example would be my post:

The deaths of thousands of people in the space of a few hours is going to be an emotional subject, wouldn't you agree? Both sides of this discussion are convinced they know who is responsible for that. There are however purely technical issues involved such as how 4 structures suffered the damage they are seen to have suffered. In that it is obvious, scientifically and technically, that three were hit by aircraft while the other succumbed to its design plus widespread and unfought fires.
While that should lead to a discussion that would center only on who sent those planes, it has not. We still see persons coming here and making 'jet fuel cannot melt steel' posts. We still see people posting "there were missile pods on the planes". We still see many more examples of such misguided and misconstrued posts. THAT makes people who actually do understand scientific and technical issues a bit cranky since it shows that these posters are holding to their technically erroneous views solely because they fit their own politically motivated and somewhat paranoid world view. The larger number of members here get upset at people who's political sense drives their belief, and willful ignorance, of scientific issues.

Clear now?


Most recently there seems to be a shift , even among the pillars of 911 conspiracy issues, towards more of what is termed LIHOP rather than what is termed MIHOP.
These are more vaporous issues than the technical issues discussed in the past. Do I believe that OBL was the titular head of a loose organization of like minded groups which he termed Al-Qada. Do I believe that the people involved in that organization were angry at, and considered themselves at war with, the west and the USA in particular due to their religious beliefs? Do I believe that a member of this organization came up with the idea of combining suicide attacks with aircraft hijacking and requested funding for same from AQ and OBL, that it was approved and carried out on Sept 11/01?

Yes, yes, and yes. My reasons for believing so are as valid, and I believe, certainly much more valid than the politically motivated paranoid view that OBL was a CIA (NWO/Israeli,,,,,) pawn, and was put forth as the leader of a fictitious organization known as Al-Qada all because those who controlled OBL wanted to attack and kill American, British, Australian, and Spanish civilians and garner two wars in the middle east, and that this maneuvering began in the 1980s when the USSR was in Afghanistan?
No, to all!
 
Last edited:
Weird thing is that we often find ourselves debating with decidedly right wing 911 conspiracy adherents.
For instance I believe that we would find that those 911 conspiracy adherents who also are Holocaust deniers would fit into the right wing in political leanings. (marriage=man+woman,, anti-abortion,, small government,, few or no social programs,, strident anti-gun control,, white,, ostensibly Christian)

Man, the bolded part describes me to a tee :D
 
Man, the bolded part describes me to a tee :D
The first part doesn't though.

It would seem that you are apparently an anomoly in 911 conspiracy adherent circles.

I on the other hand must be an anomoly as a debunker since I don't give a rat's tuckus who marries who, cannot countenance the idea of a rape or incest victim being required to carry a child of that abomination, support gov't health care and some other social programs, believe gov't should be as large as required to fulfill its mandate to support the people of the nation, believe that no one should be able to obtain a firearm unless they can pass even basic safety test and criminal check (got a felony on your sheet=no gun for you, too bad so sad), and am non-religious. I am white as it gets OTOH.
BTW I voted for the Liberal Party of Canada in the last federal election.

So as I said above JJ's conjecture about debunkers would seem to leave me at the fringe.
 

yes that was a while ago wasn't it. I'd completely forgotten about it even though I had two posts there. I guess that illustrates how much I personally care about it.

Average Age = 40 years
% Male = 93.9%
% Female = 6.1%

Income:
<50K = 30.5%
50-100K = 45.8%
>100K = 23.7%

Political: Liberal/Dem = 38.5% Conservative/Rep = 15.4% Mix (of lib/con) = 18.5% Independent = 10.7% Other = 16.9%Education:

High School or Less = 9.2%
Some College up to Undergrad degree = 56.9%
Some Post Grad up to Completed Post Grad = 33.9%

However while that does address JJ's contentions it does not address the OP which concerns vitriol in postings.
 
Last edited:
It's a codependency thing and, therefore, about power. Twooferologists need twoofers. The relationship sanctions abuse. The dependency makes the twooferologists hate the twoofers.

Perceiving oneself to be right, on the side of power, creates a highly addictive hormone rush and the desire to feel it again. Power corrupts. The cycle of abuse continues.

I have noticed a correlation, on this forum, between dedicated twoofer-bashing and rigid, right-wing political ideology.

Interesting thoughts. Not so sure about the right-wing thing, though. These government truthers all strike me as hardcore left-wing, government fellating wackos.
 
Last edited:
I would agree with this to a point. In most cases, there are two sides to each issue and facts that must be carefully weighed and debated. Things like healthcare reform, immigration laws and tax policies have volumes of data supporting the many facets of each subject. Smart, honest people disagree on the ideal course of action. A perfectly valid method for solving those problems is to have a respectful, open debate followed by a period of negotiation and collaboration. That's fine with me.

In such cases as Moon Landing CT's, Holocaust denial and 9/11 CT's, we have a wholly different matter. It is not simply a matter of facts for both sides, equal in volume but opposing in direction. Rather it is a collection of relevant facts and information from professionals and experts versus a collection of lies and distortions supplied a collection of psychopaths, bigots and morons.

Gravy's Loose Change Guide is an excellent catalog of 9/11 CT distortions and lies in much the same way that Loose Change is an excellent example of how to deceive an audience. As an example, in one section of Loose Change, Avery edits the coroner's testimony to make it seem that the coroner found no bodies or body parts at the site of the flight 93 crash. Of course, the opposite is true, but the line was intentionally edited and inserted into the video to deceive the audience.

As a rational, thinking person, how am I to interpret such actions? What conclusions should I draw from a collection of people who believe that deception is a legitimate way to convert someone to your viewpoint? It seems to me that the purpose of such deception is invariably nefarious. First, there are the charlatans, who are interested in fundraising and jet setting about the country on a tour speaker schedule. These care neither for the truth nor for their professed goals (i.e. a new "investigation", etc). They are in it for the fame and nothing else. Charlatans and idiots make up the majority of the remains of the 9/11 conspiracy theory movement. The second group, however, truly distresses me. Their larger political motivations are deeply rooted in antisemitism or outright fascism. Avery had no problem quoting articles from American Free Press, a pro-nazi newspaper. Meanwhile, the likes of Phillip Jayhan are psychopaths. They genuinely believe what they preach, and Jayhan even financed Loose Change. The fact is, none of us would have bothered with this if Jayhan hadn't put up the money for Dylan to produce and edit the film. His intentions are clear: He wants converts and he will do anything to get them. And Dylan has no problem with that, as long as it services him and his goals.

This is not simply a matter of polite disagreement, it is a matter of racism and bigotry masking itself conspiracy theory. It is a matter of charlatans and Nazis using 9/11 conspiracy theories to recruit followers. It's Dylan Avery deciding to lie to make himself famous. This is the type of ideology that should make you angry. These are the ideologies that should be shouted down at every single opportunity. It is such actions by the likes of Dylan Avery that should be abhorred and detested by society. Appeasement, finding common ground, respectful disagreement are off the table when this is on it.

Are all 9/11 CT's nazis? Nope. Not even close. The vast majority have simply been fooled by the charlatans, and a brutal combination of ego and ignorance allow them to continue on this path. But when I look at the end game, I can see two futures. The charlatans will tire, get bored or move on. Their followers also fade into the dust. But the second group will continue to spout their nonsense, and every single opportunity they must be stopped.

This is a lengthy post, I know, but the point is this: Sometimes even I get a little short with the Truthers on the forum. It's because I'm trying to figure out which group they're part of. The ignorant, I try to educate. But when they repeatedly refuse to listen or consider the facts, I start thinking that they're more likely ideologues, looking for the newest followers. These, I'm not so polite to.

Now that's some good propaganda! Lots of good B.S. in this post.
 
Now that's some good propaganda! Lots of good B.S. in this post.

That was a great reply Springhall!

You really deal with each point in detail.....lol

Keep up the great work.....maybe someday your movement will reach the monumental number of 1%...

Keep us updated as to when that happens....at this rate you might make it in another 10 years or so ;)
 
Good thing you clarified that, because you quite often do exactly what you claim right wingers do.

For example?

(I notice that your comment attacks the arguer rather than the argument.)


So you have not simply made up this correllation? Or perhaps you have compiled some statistics that support the contention that those who oppose 911 conspiracies on internet forums are predominantly right wing or conservative...?

Have you compiled any statistics on abusive postings on JREF and SLC as opposed to LC and AE911T forums to determine that abusiveness is more prevalent on one side of the debate or the other?

I suspect not, which, if true, would make you rather hypocritical in claiming that making things up is a rightwinger/debunker attribute, do you not agree?


I was not comparing twoofer and twooferologist abuse. I said it was a codependent relationship.

As I wrote in my post, the right-wing correlation is something I have observed (i.e. subjective). I see posters spouting base abuse at their pets (twoofers) and then see the same posters acting abusively in the politics section, often operating as part of right-wing gang, gossiping about other posters (character assassination). On other forums and places I also observe right-wing posters being the extremley, personally abusive. Pretending to be able to read minds is another feature ("You think..."). It would probably be more accurate to correlate authoritarianism and its associated bullying with the twooferologist vitriol tendency, samples of which are being handily provided in this thread. I have also noticed that a militarist outlook also features strongly.


Your impressions are, not surprisingly, completely wrong...

People who are delusional have a track record of often being wrong though....so I should expect this.


Crude, abusive, character assassination. Surprise surprise! :)


What you don't realize....is that professionals....people who have spent the better part of their lives learning, mastering, and working in specific fields like engineering and science get annoyed when a bunch of amateurs think they can question a 10,000 page engineering report cause they watched a youtube video.

And when those people don't even have the basic fundamental skills to even have a low level discussion....the professionals end up becoming impatient and irritated.

Character assassination plus rationalizing lack of emotional control.

I regard 9/11 as a political/Intelligence puzzle rather than an engineeering puzzle.

You don't understand this because YOU ARE one of those amateurs.

Addressing arguer rather than argument...

I used to have a certain viewpoint about conspiracy theorists.....I used to believe that it was BECAUSE of their conspiracy leanings that they were unable to think critically and understand things like math or physics.

Now I think that it is because of their inability to think critically and understand topics like math or physics that makes them easy prey to conspiracy theories.....well that and being delusional and possibly mentally insane to a degree.

The worst case is when someone is stupid AND insane......then you get a conspiracy theorist that is truly something to behold....but I digress.

The bottom line is you don't understand why most professionals either ignore you or mock you. I'll give you a hint why.....it's the same reason why we would do that to people claiming the earth is flat or that the Easter bunny is real.....

(if you dont understand that.....I can explain further ;))

I notice that your comment avoids explaining why it is deemed necessary or productive to personally attack and abuse people who you think are wrong/ mentally ill.
 
Last edited:
ozeco41

WORD!

In my view, the so called 9-11 "Truthers" would NOT know what the truth, or a fact is were they a very sharp pointed cactus they sat on while naked.
 
Last edited:
Now that's some good propaganda! Lots of good B.S. in this post.

So, this is your response to a comprehensive, well thought out answer to your opening post in a thread you created?

Have you ever considered that responses such as this are the precise reason why debunkers so often respond with such vitriol? I could have very easily written, "Because 9/11 Conspiracy Theorists are morons and they deserve it." It was out of respect for you and your question that I actually sat down and thought about an answer.

So, I show you respect, and what you fling back is a set of sentence fragments which neither address nor refute the argument. It's hand-waiving away an answer to your question because it doesn't provide the answer you wanted. For FSM's sake, it's not even clear that you read any of the response! What shall I call such action other than idiocy?

Ok, then, I officially change my answer. Debunkers are short, mocking, sarcastic and occasionally verbally abusive to 9/11 CT's because 9/11 CT's are morons who invite such scorn upon themselves.
 
Chortle. If truthers don't want people to become annoyed with them, perhaps they shouldn't threaten and abuse folks for daring to disagree with them and saying why.

"Well in that case, Gravy is Gravy's handler. Gravy is everywhere. Gravy is the NWO. Gravy farts chemtrails. Gravy shoots holographic planes from his eyes. You cannot escape Gravy. Gravy can plant explosives simply by crossing his forearms and sharply nodding his head. He will get you. It is only a matter of time.":D:D:D
 
True, but being on the side of power gives a bigger hormonal hit. It's an instinctual herd reaction.

Evidence?

I have no idea how to measure hormone levels, but many of us viscerally root for the underdog. Personally, every single time I wander into one of these threads, I hope that anyone who identifies or sympathizes with the Truth Movement will have something interesting to say. Every single time. The psychic payoff to being disappointed again is distinctly inferior to the payoff of being pleasantly surprised.

My own experiences, first on the screwloosechange blog and then on this forum suggest otherwise, particularly on the former, where no censorship was applied. People dubious of the official narrative would frequently attempt to have a reasonable conversation only to be met with insane levels of abuse. This left me with the impression that the "debunkers" were using the subject matter to pursue unrelated personal, emotional agendas and gratification.

My dominant impression of JREF is the discouraging paucity of people who can reasonably be said to be "dubious of the official narrative," relative to the number of people who reject it but fail to marshal good arguments for their point of view. That pattern doesn't tend to encourage to select for good behavior among debunkers.

ETA:

JihadJane said:
Calling me delusional (and with no supporting evidence, incidentally) is an Ad Hominem attack, a logical fallacy.

If you were to deign to venture an argument about why it is a "logical fallacy" to characterize someone as "delusional" but not a logical fallacy to characterize people as "abusers," perhaps there would be some basis for rational discussion.

I don't see either one as inherently logically fallacious. This entire thread could be construed as "ad hominem," if one likes. The fallacy comes when one uses a characterization of a person or people as a justification for rejecting their arguments.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom