I would agree with this to a point. In most cases, there are two sides to each issue and facts that must be carefully weighed and debated. Things like healthcare reform, immigration laws and tax policies have volumes of data supporting the many facets of each subject. Smart, honest people disagree on the ideal course of action. A perfectly valid method for solving those problems is to have a respectful, open debate followed by a period of negotiation and collaboration. That's fine with me.
In such cases as Moon Landing CT's, Holocaust denial and 9/11 CT's, we have a wholly different matter. It is not simply a matter of facts for both sides, equal in volume but opposing in direction. Rather it is a collection of relevant facts and information from professionals and experts versus a collection of lies and distortions supplied a collection of psychopaths, bigots and morons.
Gravy's Loose Change Guide is an excellent catalog of 9/11 CT distortions and lies in much the same way that Loose Change is an excellent example of how to deceive an audience. As an example, in one section of Loose Change, Avery edits the coroner's testimony to make it seem that the coroner found no bodies or body parts at the site of the flight 93 crash. Of course, the
opposite is true, but the line was intentionally edited and inserted into the video to deceive the audience.
As a rational, thinking person, how am I to interpret such actions? What conclusions should I draw from a collection of people who believe that deception is a legitimate way to convert someone to your viewpoint? It seems to me that the purpose of such deception is invariably nefarious. First, there are the charlatans, who are interested in fundraising and jet setting about the country on a tour speaker schedule. These care neither for the truth nor for their professed goals (i.e. a new "investigation", etc). They are in it for the fame and nothing else. Charlatans and idiots make up the majority of the remains of the 9/11 conspiracy theory movement. The second group, however, truly distresses me. Their larger political motivations are deeply rooted in antisemitism or outright fascism. Avery had no problem quoting articles from American Free Press, a pro-nazi newspaper. Meanwhile, the likes of Phillip Jayhan are psychopaths. They genuinely believe what they preach, and Jayhan even financed Loose Change. The fact is, none of us would have bothered with this if Jayhan hadn't put up the money for Dylan to produce and edit the film. His intentions are clear: He wants converts and he will do anything to get them. And Dylan has no problem with that, as long as it services him and his goals.
This is not simply a matter of polite disagreement, it is a matter of racism and bigotry masking itself conspiracy theory. It is a matter of charlatans and Nazis using 9/11 conspiracy theories to recruit followers. It's Dylan Avery deciding to lie to make himself famous. This is the type of ideology that should make you angry. These are the ideologies that should be shouted down at every single opportunity. It is such actions by the likes of Dylan Avery that should be abhorred and detested by society. Appeasement, finding common ground, respectful disagreement are off the table when this is on it.
Are all 9/11 CT's nazis? Nope. Not even close. The vast majority have simply been fooled by the charlatans, and a brutal combination of ego and ignorance allow them to continue on this path. But when I look at the end game, I can see two futures. The charlatans will tire, get bored or move on. Their followers also fade into the dust. But the second group will continue to spout their nonsense, and every single opportunity they must be stopped.
This is a lengthy post, I know, but the point is this: Sometimes even I get a little short with the Truthers on the forum. It's because I'm trying to figure out which group they're part of. The ignorant, I try to educate. But when they repeatedly refuse to listen or consider the facts, I start thinking that they're more likely ideologues, looking for the newest followers. These, I'm not so polite to.