Why is Rachel Maddow on The Onion?

Re Thread Title: She was trying to find a network outlet that would increase her credibility as a journalist.
 
Last edited:
I have a theory to throw out. I think some local Fox station once assumed a fake Onion report was real. Maybe Maddow hoped that her fake comment might actually get picked up by a Fox broadcast as authentic and she would have a deep, heart falt belly laugh with her giant horse-toothed grin because, you know, it is not about the truth; It is all about winning the game by making the meanies look stupid. Then we can all be happy and bask in the glow of the fantasy that is Liberalsim.

My God. You're right. It all makes sense. Rachel Maddow planted thermite in the twin towers.
 
I have a theory to throw out. I think some local Fox station once assumed a fake Onion report was real. Maybe Maddow hoped that her fake comment might actually get picked up by a Fox broadcast as authentic and she would have a deep, heart falt belly laugh with her giant horse-toothed grin because, you know, it is not about the truth; It is all about winning the game by making the meanies look stupid. Then we can all be happy and bask in the glow of the fantasy that is Liberalsim.

There would be much better Onion pieces for this sort of plan. Remember, the news piece is about a woman crying and Maddow's part is a mildly vulgar passive aggressive "compliment" to five years of success on the part of that news show and the female anchor being bitchy. Not exactly much fodder for Fox or others to really comment on. Though she did have a good laugh about the guy who makes youtube videos calling her a lesbian vampire communist.

Besides, Fox has already carried an Onion story before. She doesn't need to invent a new situation to laugh at. It already exists. Though she has fallen victim to something similar too. :D
 
Re Thread Title: She was trying to find a network outlet that would increase her credibility as a journalist.

And to do that she went to a place that makes up stuff, features whacky loons as hosts, and posts completely unbelievable news stories?
Oh wait she went to The Onion, not Fox.
 
Why am I bringing this up? Because it's entirely possible for a serious journalist to make a fool of themselves or engage in parody and still be a serious journalist.

It takes some measure of brains to do comedy right.

That's why the only right winger I ever saw do it well is Michael Medved.

He actually gets a good joke in once in a while.

Nobody with the slightest compassion for their fellow critters finds the Rushblob funny.
 
Maybe The Onion wants to wrest the title of "Most Respected News Source" from... uh... John Stewart.

The Onion was "America's Finest News Source" before anyone knew who Jon Stewart was. :)

Let me guess, did Maddow talk about what's going on in Madison, WI? The Onion was started at UW-Madison and to this day we still get our own special edition. The 'AV Club' section in the middle has always been 'serious' (or at least as much as The Onion can be) and often has interviews with some very interesting people.
 
Why bring up MSNBC?

That would have been funny if it weren't the exact same joke the poster you quoted made. All it says here is that you can't come up with your own material and had to fall back on "I know you are, but what am I?"
 
Well, not exactly analogous, but one of our party leaders (of the Leftist party, if you're curious) here in Sweden appeared in a rather funny sketch where he bought stolen wheel rims and car radios in a back alley.

Richard Nixon appeared on Rowan and Martin's Laugh-In.
 
That would have been funny if it weren't the exact same joke the poster you quoted made. All it says here is that you can't come up with your own material and had to fall back on "I know you are, but what am I?"
Thanks for sharing. You also don't appear to have any content to provide.

MSNBC. MSNBC. Does the name send shivers down your leg?
 
So, putting him aside, Is there any other example of someone who -- let's suppose -- wants to be respected as a journalist and decides to play a part in a news parody in character, appart from Maddow?


I haven't read this thread carefully enough to know if what I'm about to post is what y'all are discussing (so I probably shouldn't be posting...)

But if the question is about serious journalists appearing in character on comedy shows, that occurred numerous times on the Murphy Brown television series.

Wikipedia confirms my memory of this:

Several noted TV journalists, including Connie Chung, Morley Safer, Paula Zahn, Faith Daniels, Katie Couric, Walter Cronkite, Larry King, Charles Kuralt, Ed Bradley, Lesley Stahl, Joan Lunden, John McLaughlin, Mike Wallace, Irving R. Levine, Linda Ellerbee, Tom Snyder, and Mary Alice Williams appeared on Murphy Brown during the course of the series. All of them played themselves and interacted with Murphy and the other FYI personnel as real peers and colleagues. Zahn, Daniels, Couric, Lunden and Williams appeared together as the guests invited to Murphy's baby shower in 1992.


What I also recall (although I don't have time at the moment to find a reference to confirm my memory) is that this was rather controversial at the time. There were a number of people -- on the left as well as on the right -- who felt it was inappropriate for journalists to blur the line between reality and fiction this way. In the end I think most of the people objecting to this gave up, and it became considered acceptable for journalists to portray themselves in tv shows and movies.

My recollection -- possibly wrong -- is that Murphy Brown was the first time this had occurred. Prior to the Murphy Brown series, if a tv show or movie called for a reporter role, they would invent a fictional character. But after the wall had been broken by Murphy Brown, a number of movies and tv shows featured real-life reporters playing themselves in small roles. For example, I'm pretty sure I recall the McLaughlin group appearing in some movie, arguing among themselves about political events occurring in the movie as if these events were real.
 
The world keeps getting stranger and stranger. I wonder what this means. What is Rachel Maddow doing on The Onion? While I am left trying to formulate a theory, I wonder what people here think. Is she saying "gotcha ! I was never a serious journalist anyway !"?

Nothing says "spoof" better than Rachel Maddow.
 
I think Eric Severeid was on an episode of Taxi.


I think (based on a quick Google) that you're right. Eric Sevareid appeared in the Taxi episode "Fantasy Borough, part 1", which aired in spring 1980 -- close to 10 years before journalists began playing themselves on Murphy Brown.

I wasn't watching much television in 1980 and don't think I ever watched Taxi. I don't recall any controversy over Sevareid's appearance in that episode, but if there were a controversy it easily could have escaped my notice.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom