Why is Rachel Maddow on The Onion?

Doesn't the Giant Head Of Brian Williams occasionally give Jon Stewart journalism advice? I believe Williams also appears on 30 Rock playing a parody of himself somewhat regularly.

When I see him on Letterman or other late night comedy shows, he is not in character. On a sitcom, well, everyone is in character.

I can't see Brian Williams doing the Maddow bit.

I would like to know from the source what Maddow was thinking. Her personal we site does not have a contact page, but I sent the quesiton to her partner who is linked on her site.

Maddow was just having fun. How much of her own presumed authentic commentary is just having fun? Some? Most? All? Oberman would go over the top sometimes and you would have to wonder if he was really serious about his rants. I have heard Maddow make loose associations at times and draw conclusions that were not supported by reality. One association was between Gabby GIfford's shooter and some racist cult in Spokane when they found a bomb there. Was she not completely serious then? Her logic seemed flawed. Could she say it was in part a parody or social commentary and we should not take her comments too seriously as real journalism?
 
The fact that she called another journalist a &$#@! means that she's in character, more like a charicature.
 
Maddow was just having fun. How much of her own presumed authentic commentary is just having fun? Some? Most? All? Oberman would go over the top sometimes and you would have to wonder if he was really serious about his rants. I have heard Maddow make loose associations at times and draw conclusions that were not supported by reality. One association was between Gabby GIfford's shooter and some racist cult in Spokane when they found a bomb there. Was she not completely serious then? Her logic seemed flawed. Could she say it was in part a parody or social commentary and we should not take her comments too seriously as real journalism?

If this isn't sarcasm...
 
The world keeps getting stranger and stranger. I wonder what this means. What is Rachel Maddow doing on The Onion? While I am left trying to formulate a theory, I wonder what people here think. Is she saying "gotcha ! I was never a serious journalist anyway !"?

Are you autistic?
 
I see news readers and commentators playing themselves in fictitious movies and TV shows, describing alien invasions and things.

Doctor Who comes to mind?
 
When I see him on Letterman or other late night comedy shows, he is not in character. On a sitcom, well, everyone is in character.

I can't see Brian Williams doing the Maddow bit.
I believe the phrase you're looking for is: "Yes, you are correct. I asked for other examples of serious journalists partaking in a comedy bit as themselves and you have presented one. It just goes to show that if you can learn something new everyday. Thanks again!"

You're welcome.
 
Are you autistic?
I never was diagnosed as such and I never thought I was.
Thanks for your concern.
And I know people diagnosed with Aspergers who are brilliant and the envy of their peers. It is an autistic disorder.
I believe the phrase you're looking for is: "Yes, you are correct. I asked for other examples of serious journalists partaking in a comedy bit as themselves and you have presented one. It just goes to show that if you can learn something new everyday. Thanks again!"

You're welcome.

That is not what I mean. There are tons of examples of what you are talking about. Dan Rather and Ted Kopple and Tom Brokaw all did comedy bits on David Lettermen but none of them acted like a clown whilst pretending to be themselves.

This is something different and new. Maddow is acting as herself. When The Daily Show first aired there was an anchor who completley made it a total goof. No social commentary. No in-depth reporting. The President or a Candidate for President would never consider sitting down with that guy because he was just a clown. But that guy left to persue a career in the movies.

THen came Jon Stewart. He was William and Mary educated, a fact that might have slipped past the people who choose him to fill the spot because Stewart had been in a previous show on Comedy Central where he and another woman just basically ripped and poked fun at current events. Stewart had a serious side and sometimes his bits had a point he was trying to make.

But Maddow is doing this in reverse. She seems to be looking for popularity above being regarded seriously. She is going from a serious journalist to a comedian. Not acting in a sketch. Not playing a character. SHe appears as herself.

People will wonder if she is really serious about what she reports now. And apparrently she does not mind as this latest photo seems to suggest.

http://www.maddowfans.com/media/pho....DownloadItem&g2_itemId=151&g2_serialNumber=2
main.php
 
Last edited:
I think that of all the talent that was left at the bitter end of AAR, I miss Rachel the most. She shows the greatest sarcastic sense of humor of any talk show personality I have heard. Maybe it goes over some peole's heads why this is a good thing in a commentator discussing issues of great pitch and moment, perhaps even the possible impending doom that might overtake all of life on earth.

Laughter is armor. We must all face things that we fear, or great sorrows and crushing defeats. How we deal with such adversity determines to a great ewxtent whether we may be considered successful, or brilliant or noble or blessed or heroic or vile in the eyes of others. It determines how we see ourselves and whether we even see a point in living any longer. Learning the right strategy to deal with adversity, with disappointment, with fear, with anger, with pain or with profound grief.

For some people, the best way to deal with the hobgoblin hiding under the bed is to kick the bed over and point to the hideous bearer of all angst and say, "My God! You one fugly git!" and then laugh.

Works for me.

Of course I am the eccentric old fart who looks back fondly on spending many a Sunday morning dragging a charged foam line into 5000 gallons of burning JP-4 just for drill and thinks, "My GAWD! That was a trip and a half!"

I think I answered most of my own questions about life and death and what it means to be fully alive the second time I walked into the fire. I think I also figured out what real courage is.

Courage is not an absence of fear. It is the ability to do what must be done in soite of the danger, in spite of the risk of harm, in spite of the enmity of the timid who would speak disparagingly of those who show courage and call it foolhardiness.

Nobody has more courage than those who laugh in the face of the Reaper and sodomize him with his own sycthe and laugh at his inefficacy. Those who challen ge the established order or a rising movement that threatens to overturn the existing and benevolent order to rerplace it with some dystopian nightmare put themselves at risk, whether such slight risk as a verbal rebuke or an assassin's bullet.

Laughing at a danger or disaster robs it of its ability to paralyze our thoughts, our actions or our conscience. It robs the horror of its ability to strip away our freedom and dignity.

Laughter is a signiture characteristic of the human spirit.

I know that the reason the right wing so hates lefties like Rachel is that they realize, sommewhere in the depths of their reptilian brain functions, that she is a more totally actualized human than any of her enemies.
 
So we agree O'Reilly is a bad example to draw a comparison to Maddow.

So, putting him aside, Is there any other example of someone who -- let's suppose -- wants to be respected as a journalist and decides to play a part in a news parody in character, appart from Maddow?
Also, what is the joke? What did her remark contribute? Was if funny, in your opinion, or just wierd? Someone suggested she did it because she has a sense of humor. I doubt that.


Over here "serious" reporters have been doing that for decades, here is one from 1957.

 
Over here "serious" reporters have been doing that for decades, here is one from 1957.

LMAO!

I love April Fools journalism.

You should see what the Ranger, a local military-oriented weekly runs for 1April.

If you have no sense of humor, you lack a critical human characteristic.

This is another thing we must contemplate when people state that John Stewart is funnier than the Rushblob.
 
That is not what I mean. There are tons of examples of what you are talking about. Dan Rather and Ted Kopple and Tom Brokaw all did comedy bits on David Lettermen but none of them acted like a clown whilst pretending to be themselves.
Okay, maybe I shuddered. Brian Williams on 30 Rock acts like a clown while pretending to be himself.
 
There are tons of examples of what you are talking about. Dan Rather and Ted Kopple and Tom Brokaw all did comedy bits on David Lettermen but none of them acted like a clown whilst pretending to be themselves.

Do you have a point?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom