Why is Rachel Maddow on The Onion?

Okay, maybe I shuddered. Brian Williams on 30 Rock acts like a clown while pretending to be himself.

Dude, it is 30 Rock. Isn't that a comedy show about a comedy show? It is as if he is in an actual circus with clowns and the whole nine yards. Plus he is probably not even doing his own lines.

All that has nothing to do with my image of him. He can dress as Bozo The Clown and do children birthday parties in his spare time. He will still be thought of as a professional journalist and anchorman.

Actually, I think he and the other news people I mention get a pass because while they agree to participate they still do not say lines that they have written. Comedy is difficult and not everyone will think your performance is funny no matter what you do. So they all have an excuse and can avoid criticism by reminding people that they did not write the bit. They were just part of a show and if they did not do it, some other TV news personality would have replaced them.

But if Brian Williams had appeared on The Onion talking about a rivalry he had with a fake news person there -- all while sitting behind the desk where he reports his official news -- it would be pretty weird too. And I would have to wonder what he was thinking and what his point is.
 
Last edited:
Mark, you seem to be taking all this way too personally. Are you upset about my not posting something in the Humor section two years ago, or are you defending Maddow and her career move from journalism to parody. Stick to the subject. At least, give it a try. These personal attacks are boring. I don't think a single post you have made has been about Maddow.
 
This entire thing seems to be a study in the proper technique for reading too far into things and making mountains out of molehills.

ETA: to clarify, I would have literally no issue with any journalist playing the part of a journalist (or, hell, themselves) in an onion piece. Because I know the Onion is parody. Self-referential humor isn't a signal that you're changing your career path.
 
Somehow I can't imagine he really would.

From your posts in this thread, I take it that there are a lot of things people do quite regularly that you can't imagine... Seriously, are you being deliberatly obtuse and stubborn? You are tilting at a non-existent windmill with this entire thread.
 
Perhaps Bill doesn't realize The Onion is a parody and satire site? It's happened to others.

Why is this even an issue?
 
News at 11.

Snarky editorialist makes guest appearance on popular snarky humor vblog that parodies the news.

News at 11:05.

Woman crying at train platform.

:D:D:D
 
I take it you have never watched her on MSNBC or listened to her radio show.

Either that or you are, yourself, hideously humor-impaired.

Fasle Dichotomy

There are other options, such as, she isn't funny. But go ahead and post the funniest Maddow moment you can and if I chuckle I'll admit it.
 
Fasle Dichotomy

There are other options, such as, she isn't funny. But go ahead and post the funniest Maddow moment you can and if I chuckle I'll admit it.

I always enjoy when people post these kinds of "challenges." What is the point? Whatever is posted, you will just say, "that didn't make me laugh."

You can do it with anything:

"I think Monty Python is dumb. Post the funniest thing, if I even crack a smile I'll admit it."

Waste of time.
 
Humor is subjective. She has a sense of humor, it just likely does not match with yours. She tends towards snark and mockery in her humor, which is generally appealing to her audience. There is a lot of crossover between her audience and that of The Daily Show. That you do not find her humorous is one thing, but to not recognize that this Onion piece fits in with her general sense of humor demonstrates an unfamiliarity with her personal presentation. Pretty much everything Kent Jones does on her show is similar to the Onion. Maddow engages her audience on a personal level, not just as a political informant. A few of her regular segments and tendency to make cocktails when a guest on other shows is part of that personalizing presentation.

"Media personality makes a parody of her profession, news at 11." The more I consider people baffled by this action the funnier the very commentary of the piece is!
 
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed personal comments
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have a theory to throw out. I think some local Fox station once assumed a fake Onion report was real. Maybe Maddow hoped that her fake comment might actually get picked up by a Fox broadcast as authentic and she would have a deep, heart falt belly laugh with her giant horse-toothed grin because, you know, it is not about the truth; It is all about winning the game by making the meanies look stupid. Then we can all be happy and bask in the glow of the fantasy that is Liberalsim.
 
Mark, you seem to be taking all this way too personally.
That I find you amusing isn't taking it personally.


Are you upset about my not posting something in the Humor section two years ago
Hey man, it was the most spectacular fail I've ever seen. That you've been consistently failing since then isn't my problem, but it amuses me greatly.


or are you defending Maddow and her career move from journalism to parody.

Going to tell you a story now Bill, listen up you might learn something.

The BBC is a serious news organisation. No matter what anyone might claim about how good it is, it is undoubtedly a serious news station that employs real journalists and reports the news in a serious manner.

Every year, the BBC newsreaders dress up like idiots/showgirls/transvestites (all real examples) and perform songs live on television. They do this for charity, but they always seem to enjoy themselves.

Why am I bringing this up? Because it's entirely possible for a serious journalist to make a fool of themselves or engage in parody and still be a serious journalist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom